Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

We are not set up for electric vehicles in this country

391 replies

Pollyannaatemyjelly · 04/11/2023 13:31

We have an electric vehicle. We tend not to do too many long journeys but today it was inevitable. We have visit a very popular destination via major motorways but there is not one fast charger available on our route. I've just stopped on the M5 on what is supposed to be a dual charger (so more than one vehicle can charge) but it's not working. I've had to wait 20 minutes for the vehicle next to me to charge before I can even begin to charge mine. There is no chance this county can become all electric when the infrastructure is so poor.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
9
enchantedsquirrelwood · 04/11/2023 17:40

Caspianberg · 04/11/2023 16:12

@enchantedsquirrelwood - it’s not at all a problem. On a long drive when you need to top up you should be stopping for 20-30 mins min anyway. Our 550km range gets us easily a 4-5hr drive. So after 4hrs most people happily stop for toilet, eating (even if that’s flask in car), and leg stretch.

Yes, but that's it. We stop for 30 minutes or so, go to the loo and get a drink and a snack. We may also get petrol on the longer journeys.

We don't want to spend x minutes (or hours) waiting to get onto a charging point and then wait another 45 minutes for the actual charging to happen.

That's why I think a plug-in hybrid is the answer - you can charge at home, and then if you can't charge easily en route, you just use petrol until you can.

It also assumes you are doing your travelling on motorways with service areas. If you are using A roads and stop at a pub, there (probably) won't be charging points.

BitofaStramash · 04/11/2023 17:40

At the moment EVs are really only for city living people with larger car budgets.

Until the price point changes (a lot) and until charging points have decent geographical coverage outwith cities (in Scotland) then I won't be switching.

PS public transport is absolutely pish outwith the cities so that's not going to get me out of my petrol car either.

RedRiverShore4 · 04/11/2023 17:37

It's to get cars off the road, of course everyone isn't going to be able to have an electric car as they will have to use the bus, cycle or walk, if you haven't got two pence to rub together it's not for you.

3Tunes · 04/11/2023 17:37

It just adds a lot more stuff to do and plan - work out where the chargers are, make sure you’ve downloaded all the apps, choose one and a back up, go and move the car once it’s charged etc. And then that for charging at home, as well as on long journeys, for those of us without driveways. I’ve got enough mental load as it is.

WithManyTot · 04/11/2023 17:36

YABU...

We have a (low) 200 miles per charge EV, and a (high) 800+ miles per tank diesel estate. Both are fine for long and short journeys but need different sorts of planning. Both are stressful if you drive them to almost empty with no options, and then start to try and make a plan. Neither is stressful if you plan ahead and make sure you have options. The EV will go for about 4 hours at a realistic UK average speed before a 20min stop and a fast charge. The diesel estate will go along way across Europe on a tank, but the softie humans still need a wee, a coffee and a driver change more frequently, often about every 4 hours....

The infrastructure for both is already here....

margotrose · 04/11/2023 17:36

Caspianberg · 04/11/2023 17:28

@margotrose - new. I’m talking new. You can’t get that many new cars for £17k now can you? So the comparison that electric is expensive’ is not correct when your comparing like for like ie new for new.

You can get secondhand electric of course and the price will vary like petrol by age, mileage etc. saying it’s £65k on Austria trader for 400mile capability is a poor comparison, you can buy a brand new Tesla model 3 for less than £65k.

Ignoring the tiny Citroen Ami (because they're pointless for anyone with a family), the cheapest petrol car on the market right now is the Kia Picanto at 13k.

https://www.autoexpress.co.uk/best-cars-vans/351901/top-10-cheapest-cars-buy-2023

The cheapest electric car (that isn't the Citroen Ami) is a Smart Car which costs 22k, and the next cheapest is 26k - so, double the cost of the similarly sized petrol equivalent.

https://heycar.com/uk/guides/cheapest-electric-cars

So yes, price is going to be a huge factor. People looking for a cheap, new family car are not going to go electric.

RedToothBrush · 04/11/2023 17:35

Caspianberg · 04/11/2023 17:28

@margotrose - new. I’m talking new. You can’t get that many new cars for £17k now can you? So the comparison that electric is expensive’ is not correct when your comparing like for like ie new for new.

You can get secondhand electric of course and the price will vary like petrol by age, mileage etc. saying it’s £65k on Austria trader for 400mile capability is a poor comparison, you can buy a brand new Tesla model 3 for less than £65k.

How many people buy new?

Many people buy nearly new. There isn't the number of cars in circulation for that yet. That's again part of the issue. The market is still in its infancy and not fully developed enough.

My friends have ordered an electric. It took two months to get the charge point in. The waiting list for the car is at least six months possibly longer (By contrast we walked into the showroom and had my car by the end of the week)

In that kind of market there isn't a nearly new market. That cuts a whole pile of people out.

There were SO many reasons we didn't go for an electric in the end. We very much were interested and open to it. But it just wasn't the right time.

nannynick · 04/11/2023 17:34

Around a week ago, a couple of YouTubers drove an EV and a Diesel from John O'groats to Landsend.

The EV story: Q_

DeadBugMountainClimber · 04/11/2023 17:31

The public charging infrastructure hasn’t kept pace with the purchase/registration rate of electric vehicles, that’s for sure (I have an electric car). The best thing to do re motorway charging is to actually come off the motorway a mile or so and charge at local points. They are usually less busy, cheaper and more reliable. Use an app to plan your stops.

Caspianberg · 04/11/2023 17:30

@RedToothBrush - ok. You believe that. Our 2022 new electric costs us less per month than our 17 year old corsa did.

Caspianberg · 04/11/2023 17:28

@margotrose - new. I’m talking new. You can’t get that many new cars for £17k now can you? So the comparison that electric is expensive’ is not correct when your comparing like for like ie new for new.

You can get secondhand electric of course and the price will vary like petrol by age, mileage etc. saying it’s £65k on Austria trader for 400mile capability is a poor comparison, you can buy a brand new Tesla model 3 for less than £65k.

MrsAvocet · 04/11/2023 17:28

We don't have street charging or any off-road parking so he'd be reliant on one of the two public chargers in the area, neither of which are close to our house.
I think this is a really valid point. I wouldn't currently buy an EV if I couldn't charge at home. Environmental issues aside, I think that the biggest advantage of having an EV is being able to charge at home - I have got so used to it now that I find it really annoying and inconvenient when I need to take my ICE car for fuel. But if you are fully reliant on the current commercial public chargers I can see that an EV would be neither practical nor financially viable for many people. Some joined up thinking is required, probably at national government level, to deal with that. Whether it is developments in battery technologies, charging technologies and infrastructure or the development of other alternative fuels, solutions have to be found, as whether we like it or not we can't continue to rely on fossil fuels indefinitely. I don't think we are anywhere near it being feasible for everyone to drive an EV yet, but there is definitely scope for more of us to do so.

RedToothBrush · 04/11/2023 17:28

Caspianberg · 04/11/2023 17:00

@VickyEadieofThigh - ok but it’s 15mins for a wee realistically in many motorway stations by the time you walk from parking and often there’s a que ( in women’s toilets especially). You don’t stop car on 0%, it’s like at 20-40% when you stop as there’s a convenient toilet and stop, and you just top up.
Our car is 77kw (550km). Some chargers at motorway do 350kw an hour, so 0-100% in 15 ish mins. 25% to 100 would be even quicker.

They are only going to get faster

@RedToothBrush - if you look theres a small car version of almost every car. I was
just showing you the id2 v polo comparison. Electric corsa we looked at in 2020, fiat do a tiny electric also, Dacia spring is due out next year as a small electric around £17k

Yes I am aware. I am not stupid. We looked at this.

As I have said repeatedly and you haven't grasped, £20k for a car is the big limiter. The upcoming Dacia is the one I think will start to 'break the market' because of the price point.

As I said, DH and I bought BOTH our cars for less than £22k. Price is a big deal. And I really echo this point
They are only really for fairly well off people and company car drivers not the wider public.

The number of people who can't grasp that a lot of others can't afford more than £10k on a car, and you need the lower end of the market as well as the second hand market to develop.

Battery technology isn’t there yet and there isn’t the capacity in the National Grid for everybody to have an electric car.

This is also a really good point. We've had an issue with electric locally. Many substations are at capacity for the number of properties they serve already (often due to a lot of new builds without additional substations being added). There was a new service added which needed a road closed for weeks whilst they built and extension to the next substation because the local one was over capacity. Adding electric charge points isn't going to help matters. Solar panels will set you back the best part of £10k. If you can even install them (can't if you rent or your house isn't suitable).

If you think about in these terms it's not necessarily just about the cost of the car. It's the cost of putting in your own charge point (if you can) and potentially the cost of solar panels...

margotrose · 04/11/2023 17:24

Electric corsa we looked at in 2020, fiat do a tiny electric also, Dacia spring is due out next year as a small electric around £17k

17k is over four times what we can afford to spend on a car.

Saying "you can get them cheaper" is irrelevant when "cheaper" still means "extortionate" and is well out of the price range of most people.

DH and I both rely on our cars for work and neither of us spend more than 4k on either of our vehicles. I genuinely can't afford 17k!

catmothertes1 · 04/11/2023 17:22

annahay · 04/11/2023 13:43

I agree. How will people without a driveway charge their cars? Or those in flats? Will renters be allowed to install the faster chargers? Will workplaces provide charge points? Can the grid even manage? Too many questions not being talked about.

I own my house but it's situated in a courtyard. So,no drive. No idea how I'd manage an electric car.

Pollyannaatemyjelly · 04/11/2023 17:15

Cyclistmumgrandma · 04/11/2023 14:11

So you stopped at a motorway service station which was bound to be crowded only and had a dual charger and were surprised to find you couldn't charge? With an electric car you need to plan in your charging stops, expecting to leave the motorway and find a charging station with multiple chargers a little way off the motorway. Unfortunately National Grid lines do not follow motorways and chargers need to to be placed where there is a good electricity supply (see how many there are in Banbury for example). You also need to stop when you have sufficient charge left to get to your backup charger. Planning is key here. Download and use apps like "Zapmap" or "ABRP".

What makes you think I hadn't done that which kind of proves my point. There were no charging points close enough to be convenient to my route except for the motorway. As I said in my OP, I was at a major tourist destination yet there was only 1 50kwh charger within a 3 mile radius. There were technically 4 charging points at the services but as two were out of order I ended up having to wait.

OP posts:
MrsMoastyToasty · 04/11/2023 17:11

Until we can get an electric car that allows us to drive from south west England and out to the Hebrides to visit family in one hit we will be staying with our petrol and diesel cars. We don't want to be making a 12 hour drive (we share driving) and 1 hour ferry (no airport on the island) crossing any longer than that. The island only has 5 public charging points.

StillWantingADog · 04/11/2023 17:09

maddening · 04/11/2023 16:14

I believe that there a lots of concerns including for example older muti story carparks which are not designed for each car to be such a huge weight

The weight issue is just as pertinent with range rovers as it is with the heavier EVs

people buy bigger and heavier cars than they did when they built early multi storeys.

bonkersAlice · 04/11/2023 17:02

Battery technology isn’t there yet and there isn’t the capacity in the National Grid for everybody to have an electric car.

Caspianberg · 04/11/2023 17:00

@VickyEadieofThigh - ok but it’s 15mins for a wee realistically in many motorway stations by the time you walk from parking and often there’s a que ( in women’s toilets especially). You don’t stop car on 0%, it’s like at 20-40% when you stop as there’s a convenient toilet and stop, and you just top up.
Our car is 77kw (550km). Some chargers at motorway do 350kw an hour, so 0-100% in 15 ish mins. 25% to 100 would be even quicker.

They are only going to get faster

@RedToothBrush - if you look theres a small car version of almost every car. I was
just showing you the id2 v polo comparison. Electric corsa we looked at in 2020, fiat do a tiny electric also, Dacia spring is due out next year as a small electric around £17k

RedRiverShore4 · 04/11/2023 16:59

They are only really for fairly well off people and company car drivers not the wider public.

MrsAvocet · 04/11/2023 16:57

RichardMarxisinnocent · 04/11/2023 16:19

Agreed. Mcdonald's car parks are often a good bet for fast chargers too.

I also agree.
I wouldn't generally buy diesel from a motorway services and I tend not to buy electricity from them either. There are often charging points that are faster, cheaper and less busy a few minutes drive from motorway exits and we usually find somewhere fairly easily. I've noticed that Instavolt seem to have a deal with Costa as well as McDonald's. I've seen quite a lot of their charges popping up in Costa carparks. They're usually 150kW so you get a decent charge in the time it takes to drink a coffee.

VickyEadieofThigh · 04/11/2023 16:52

Caspianberg · 04/11/2023 16:12

@enchantedsquirrelwood - it’s not at all a problem. On a long drive when you need to top up you should be stopping for 20-30 mins min anyway. Our 550km range gets us easily a 4-5hr drive. So after 4hrs most people happily stop for toilet, eating (even if that’s flask in car), and leg stretch.

We share the driving on long drives, though - largely because we want to shorten the time it takes to get there. We very rarely stop for longer than it takes to go for a wee.

margotrose · 04/11/2023 16:52

Caspianberg · 04/11/2023 16:15

@RedToothBrush - ok. But that’s against all cars then? Your argument is electric new cars cost lots. No, all new cars cost lots. You can buy an identical car basically in petrol or electric new, id2 or vw golf, and it will still cost you £22k. It’s a new car thing not an electric thing.

You can of course then get cheaper electric versions second hand, same as petrol.

It’s like me arguing I can get a 3 year old car cheaper than a brand new one:. Of course you can

The cheapest electric car on Autotrader is just under 3k but it only does 124 miles per charge, which is a bit pointless for anyone who commutes a significant distance or who doesn't have access to their own charger.

I mean, DH's commute to work is about 40 miles each way. So he'd pretty much need to charge it once a day. We don't have street charging or any off-road parking so he'd be reliant on one of the two public chargers in the area, neither of which are close to our house.

He just bought a second hand diesel car a few weeks ago for 4k. He only fills it up once a week, it takes seconds to put fuel in and he can do it on his way to work without having to worry about finding a charger.

The cheapest car on Autotrader with the equivalent range (400 miles per charge) is nearly 65k!

RedToothBrush · 04/11/2023 16:40

Caspianberg · 04/11/2023 16:15

@RedToothBrush - ok. But that’s against all cars then? Your argument is electric new cars cost lots. No, all new cars cost lots. You can buy an identical car basically in petrol or electric new, id2 or vw golf, and it will still cost you £22k. It’s a new car thing not an electric thing.

You can of course then get cheaper electric versions second hand, same as petrol.

It’s like me arguing I can get a 3 year old car cheaper than a brand new one:. Of course you can

My argument is that a huge number of people are currently priced out of the electric market for various reasons and don't have a budget of £21k.

That's a big deal. That means the demand might be there but supply isn't matching the requirements of the demand.

When DH and I both bought cars for less than the electric you are making a point about you will have a problem. Until the market can hit that tipping point it's going to be a slow uptake.

More than that you are saying there's one car available. Great. So what happens when I get in it and the visibility is shocking and I don't like it? Or DH gets in it and finds that when he sits up straight he is looking at the ceiling above the window not out the window (hello Astras)? If I'm going to spend all that money on a car I want it to work for me on a very basis level and I certainly don't want to be paying more than I can afford.

Two years ago there was no a car in my budget and to my size requirements. It's still the case now. I know it is changing. Is this hard for your comprehension skills or are you just going to argue the toss that I should have bought a car I didn't want and couldn't afford?

HTH.