Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

We are not set up for electric vehicles in this country

391 replies

Pollyannaatemyjelly · 04/11/2023 13:31

We have an electric vehicle. We tend not to do too many long journeys but today it was inevitable. We have visit a very popular destination via major motorways but there is not one fast charger available on our route. I've just stopped on the M5 on what is supposed to be a dual charger (so more than one vehicle can charge) but it's not working. I've had to wait 20 minutes for the vehicle next to me to charge before I can even begin to charge mine. There is no chance this county can become all electric when the infrastructure is so poor.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
9
SlightlyJaded · 04/11/2023 19:19

A couple of people have questioned my comment about the weight of electric cars and multi-story car parks. If you Google, there is loads of info as well as reports of car park collapses.

Here are a couple of credible source articles for starters.

www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2023/06/05/electric-cars-too-heavy-old-multi-storey-car-parks/

www.thisismoney.co.uk/money/electriccars/article-11956197/Ageing-multi-storey-car-parks-collapse-weight-heavier-electric-vehicles.html

www.topgear.com/car-news/suvs/uk-car-parks-are-apparently-danger-collapsing-because-new-cars-are-so-heavy

margotrose · 04/11/2023 19:16

Caspianberg · 04/11/2023 18:39

Well yes i live in mainland Europe. There’s a €6k ev discount, so a €17k costs €11k. You can pay in 5 year monthly instalments which is around €185 a month. The cost of insurance/ aa equivalent is included in purchase for those 5 years. For a more expensive ev it’s the same, and you can opt to pay a deposit to reduce monthly repayment. As a company our old 17 year old car could only be third party insured here and the insurance alone was around €150 a month.

We don't have those discounts available for normal family electric cars in the UK. They were discontinued last year.

So, a 26k car (the cheapest family electric vehicle on the market) is still 26k.

Of course you can get them on finance if you can afford the deposit, and the monthly payments, and you have a sufficient income/credit score to get approved for finance in the first place.

Or you could get a cheap second hand car for a couple of k outright and run it into the ground. Insurance is cheap and all you need to pay is fuel, MOT and put some aside for things like new tyres.

It's a no-brainer for most people, because they just cannot afford to even think about an electric car.

FairyMaclary · 04/11/2023 19:15

Does anyone know how much is it to replace a battery when they fail? Parts and Labour?

This will be important on the second hand market for people buying 10 year old plus cars. I think Kia have a ten year battery warranty. Will battery’s fail at the 12 year mark? If so will more cars end up being scrapped earlier as uneconomical to repair?

Caspianberg · 04/11/2023 19:12

@Badbadbunny - no I will own it. I paid a deposit, and it’s a lease to own scheme here. In 3.5 years I will own. I can then decided to keep or choose to sell in secondhand market.

RedRiverShore4 · 04/11/2023 19:07

Badbadbunny · 04/11/2023 19:00

So how much are you and other taxpayers willing to pay in extra tax to subsidise the massive improvement in public transport that's going to be needed?

No, thought not!

There wont be an improvement, it will be tough, government won't care as long as they meet their targets, only recently they were going to jail people for not fitting heat pumps. They have their targets and if life gets worse then tough.

Badbadbunny · 04/11/2023 19:03

Caspianberg · 04/11/2023 17:48

This thread is electric car classic

All current electric car owners - we love it, no problems. Had several for years

Everyone who doesn’t own one - it won’t work, charging problems, cost, mileage etc

Well, that's to be expected. Those for whom electric cars can work, i.e. charge at home, can afford one, etc., will buy them. Those for whom it won't work, i.e. not charging at home, too expensive to buy, etc., won't buy them.

Why would you think it would be any other way?

It's exactly what the government want. "Nudge" all the people for whom they're feasible to buy one. Get as many EV's on the road as possible. Then let everyone else carry on using ICE cars for another couple of decades, by which time, no doubt a more convenient form of fuel will be available to replace petrol/diesel, i.e. hydrogen or some other chemical.

Badbadbunny · 04/11/2023 19:00

RedRiverShore4 · 04/11/2023 17:37

It's to get cars off the road, of course everyone isn't going to be able to have an electric car as they will have to use the bus, cycle or walk, if you haven't got two pence to rub together it's not for you.

So how much are you and other taxpayers willing to pay in extra tax to subsidise the massive improvement in public transport that's going to be needed?

No, thought not!

Badbadbunny · 04/11/2023 18:57

Caspianberg · 04/11/2023 17:30

@RedToothBrush - ok. You believe that. Our 2022 new electric costs us less per month than our 17 year old corsa did.

Presumably you owned the corsa at the end of the HP contract. With a lease, you're just "renting" it so you have nothing to show for it at the end of the lease term. You're basically just financing it's depreciation over the 3 year lease term.

xyz111 · 04/11/2023 18:50

SlightlyJaded · 04/11/2023 13:50

Not to mention car parks...

They are talking of banning electric cars from multi-story car parks (which would be every shopping centre/airport in the uK) because they weigh too much for a standard multi story to support a floor full of them.

There have already been entire floor collapses and it's widely reported that older carparks in particular are very vulnerable - and that is before every car parked in a bay is electric.

As ever - not thought through properly. Just lots of utopian style blanket policies being made with no connection to reality.

And probably because when they catch fire, they REALLY catch fire!!

Caspianberg · 04/11/2023 18:39

Well yes i live in mainland Europe. There’s a €6k ev discount, so a €17k costs €11k. You can pay in 5 year monthly instalments which is around €185 a month. The cost of insurance/ aa equivalent is included in purchase for those 5 years. For a more expensive ev it’s the same, and you can opt to pay a deposit to reduce monthly repayment. As a company our old 17 year old car could only be third party insured here and the insurance alone was around €150 a month.

RedToothBrush · 04/11/2023 18:32

margotrose · 04/11/2023 18:23

He has a Dacia at the moment, and the new electrics look really promising. But that will still be more than twice what he paid for his current car. That's a big deal.

And that's key, isn't it? It all comes down to money.

If you have your own driveway/land, somewhere to install a charger and enough money to be able to afford an electric vehicle that suits your lifestyle, I'm sure they're fantastic.

But there are still millions of people who aren't in that position and won't be for quite some time to come.

EXACTLY my point.

I think that a 17k model will start to suck people in and create a nearly new band around the 12 to 15k mark. At which point it starts to change the market overall somewhat. Start to...

But even then it will take time as I suspect the wait time on those will be a good six months minimum for the first couple of years. We got a first wave Dacia - we were on the ball and got one early. A few months later you couldnt get one for love nor money due to the waiting list as they just couldn't match demand. My suspicion is we will see something similar.

The Dacia will also force other companies to start to drop the bottom end of the market price in time too. Particularly on the nearly new market.

You have to remember what the median wage is in this country. That gives a lot of reflection on that 17k price tag.

The infrastructure will follow cos it's all about demand.

What's interesting in the rest of Europe is how governments have offered incentives to buyers to bring the initial outlay costs down (and to build the market structure on that nearly new and second hand market...)

RedToothBrush · 04/11/2023 18:24

margotrose · 04/11/2023 17:36

Ignoring the tiny Citroen Ami (because they're pointless for anyone with a family), the cheapest petrol car on the market right now is the Kia Picanto at 13k.

https://www.autoexpress.co.uk/best-cars-vans/351901/top-10-cheapest-cars-buy-2023

The cheapest electric car (that isn't the Citroen Ami) is a Smart Car which costs 22k, and the next cheapest is 26k - so, double the cost of the similarly sized petrol equivalent.

https://heycar.com/uk/guides/cheapest-electric-cars

So yes, price is going to be a huge factor. People looking for a cheap, new family car are not going to go electric.

We have a KIA and a Dacia. They cost just over £21k together...

margotrose · 04/11/2023 18:23

He has a Dacia at the moment, and the new electrics look really promising. But that will still be more than twice what he paid for his current car. That's a big deal.

And that's key, isn't it? It all comes down to money.

If you have your own driveway/land, somewhere to install a charger and enough money to be able to afford an electric vehicle that suits your lifestyle, I'm sure they're fantastic.

But there are still millions of people who aren't in that position and won't be for quite some time to come.

RedToothBrush · 04/11/2023 18:20

margotrose · 04/11/2023 17:56

Except that there are electric car owners on this thread who have said they've had issues with finding charging points and doing long journeys.

I'm not against electric cars, I think they're a good idea, but I am realistic about what most of the population can afford and where they live. If you don't have access to your own guaranteed charger then it's not going to be easy to own one.

Where I live, there are four public charging points within a 20 mile radius. That's it.

And petrol drivers who say they want to do electric but the market isn't yet reflecting their needs but think it will in a year or too.

We took a very long look at it.

The efficiency we are getting with my petrol is really really good and I try and walk as much as possible anyway.

We are still weighing up what to do with DHs car which will need replacing in a year or two. We are closely following what's about to be launched. He has a Dacia at the moment, and the new electrics look really promising. But that will still be more than twice what he paid for his current car. That's a big deal.

In the meantime we've got the solar panels. So it IS part of our longer term plan to go electric but the timing, price point and models available need to be right before we are prepared to make that investment.

Caspianberg · 04/11/2023 18:12

@Bingsbongs - we live in the alps. It’s full on hard core winter driving, extreme hills. Never felt safer. Most local services like postman, buses are all electric now also

BinturongsSmellOfPopcorn · 04/11/2023 18:02

We don't want to spend x minutes (or hours) waiting to get onto a charging point and then wait another 45 minutes for the actual charging to happen.

I've never waited for a changing point at a service station (I have at a little hotel that only had 1 charger, but if I hadn't been staying there anyway I could easily have gone to another nearby one instead). Why do you think it would take hours? And chargers are getting faster all the time - 20 mins is usually as much as I need.

Bingsbongs · 04/11/2023 18:01

Caspianberg · 04/11/2023 17:48

This thread is electric car classic

All current electric car owners - we love it, no problems. Had several for years

Everyone who doesn’t own one - it won’t work, charging problems, cost, mileage etc

Might be okay if you use it a to b inside a town/city,electric bike would be fine too.

I personally would not want to go on a motorway,especially in the winter driving for long distances in a toy car.

Bingsbongs · 04/11/2023 17:57

dont forget WEF do not want us to have our own houses,the goal is we rent cars call them as we need them (claus said our cars are unused and 90percent of the time not in use so waste of resource),as for our homes aim is everyone renting no house ownership, travel super limited what is it one return flight a year is the aim?

margotrose · 04/11/2023 17:56

Caspianberg · 04/11/2023 17:48

This thread is electric car classic

All current electric car owners - we love it, no problems. Had several for years

Everyone who doesn’t own one - it won’t work, charging problems, cost, mileage etc

Except that there are electric car owners on this thread who have said they've had issues with finding charging points and doing long journeys.

I'm not against electric cars, I think they're a good idea, but I am realistic about what most of the population can afford and where they live. If you don't have access to your own guaranteed charger then it's not going to be easy to own one.

Where I live, there are four public charging points within a 20 mile radius. That's it.

Caspianberg · 04/11/2023 17:53

@bellac11 - we drove 1000km+ there and then back through several countries this summer. We never charged at motorway ( but did stop for wee and to check out charging options). We charged at accommodation, outside restaurant, in multi-storey car park in a city, and at a random parking spot on beach. Motorway services are where many people do stop though on long drives, hence why people say it’s just a 30 min charge and can do whilst there

Caerulea · 04/11/2023 17:51

@timetochangethering

Oh and it's PETROL and DIESEL that is up to 20 times more likely to catch fire than electric. That one always shocks people and it is completely true!

And you're more likely to be bitten by a Yorkshire terrier than an XL Bully. The point is the consequences are wildly different. Your other points are fair, but it doesn't help anyone to underplay the risks of lithium ion.

bellac11 · 04/11/2023 17:49

Caspianberg · 04/11/2023 16:12

@enchantedsquirrelwood - it’s not at all a problem. On a long drive when you need to top up you should be stopping for 20-30 mins min anyway. Our 550km range gets us easily a 4-5hr drive. So after 4hrs most people happily stop for toilet, eating (even if that’s flask in car), and leg stretch.

God Im sick of hearing this

For us when we're doing a long drive, the last thing I want to do is spend time hanging around a petrol station or services on the motor way,, we try to plan little stops at small cafes or pubs if we actually want to eat

But if the journey involves the inevitable stop to fill up with petrol/nip to the loo, I can easily spend 20-30 mins queuing up to come off the motor way, trailing round the car park for a space, parking up, going into the services which are miles from the only space you can find. queuing to use the loo, queuing to buy a coffee, trudging back to the car, loading up the car with scalding coffee in the drinks holder which you then snag your leg on because you're trying to rush and off I go

I am not adding on another 45 mins on top of that farce to charge up a car. No way.

Caspianberg · 04/11/2023 17:48

This thread is electric car classic

All current electric car owners - we love it, no problems. Had several for years

Everyone who doesn’t own one - it won’t work, charging problems, cost, mileage etc

bellac11 · 04/11/2023 17:43

In terms of weight, as people have mentioned the weight, surely hybrids are worse as the have an engine and the battery to cope with?

But just referencing the OP, yes I am put off EVs at the moment for two reasons, one is cost, like others on the thread, my top price for a car is 4k and I need a range of around 350 reliable miles, not fantasy miles.

Its a shame as I would like to stop paying so much for petrol but I have long and unpredictable and short notice trips to make quite a lot. My OH has a very long commute which would require a predictable range of at least 200, he wouldnt have anywhere to charge it during the day either so we have discounted it for him also (not to mention we simply cannot afford one for either of us right now)

enchantedsquirrelwood · 04/11/2023 17:42

Oh and the app thing. At the moment, I go to a petrol station and use my debit card. No having to mess about downloading apps, uploading details and having to find the right sort of charger for the right app.

It's a total nonsense.