Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

We are not set up for electric vehicles in this country

391 replies

Pollyannaatemyjelly · 04/11/2023 13:31

We have an electric vehicle. We tend not to do too many long journeys but today it was inevitable. We have visit a very popular destination via major motorways but there is not one fast charger available on our route. I've just stopped on the M5 on what is supposed to be a dual charger (so more than one vehicle can charge) but it's not working. I've had to wait 20 minutes for the vehicle next to me to charge before I can even begin to charge mine. There is no chance this county can become all electric when the infrastructure is so poor.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Thread gallery
9
AuntyMabelandPippin · 16/11/2023 19:19

Estermay · 15/11/2023 15:20

A four hour drive without having to charge is not really that long. My husband drives that far every day with the commute to work and back and then driving around for visits at work.
Currently EVs seem to be ideal for office workers who can charge at work or home and at regular gym and supermarket visits. Its a certain kind of middle class lifestyle.

It is when it's not fully charged when you set off...😂

Caspianberg · 16/11/2023 17:26

@Chersfrozenface - we live rural, no public transport. 1 car, not Tesla. Do have driveway with charger though ( but also have places within 3 min drive to charge)

LadyMacB · 16/11/2023 14:57

I have one car, an EV, not a Tesla and no off-street parking.

BinturongsSmellOfPopcorn · 16/11/2023 14:47

I have 1 car, and it's not a Tesla. Off street parking I'll grant you.

Chersfrozenface · 16/11/2023 11:22

Currently EVs sre only suitable for people with two cars, Teslas and properties with off-street parking.

People with money, in other words.

wonkylegs · 16/11/2023 11:17

Estermay · 15/11/2023 15:20

A four hour drive without having to charge is not really that long. My husband drives that far every day with the commute to work and back and then driving around for visits at work.
Currently EVs seem to be ideal for office workers who can charge at work or home and at regular gym and supermarket visits. Its a certain kind of middle class lifestyle.

Our EV does a real world range of about 260 miles on a charge (advertised as more but like all cars the higher figure is a bit optimistic) and if necessary can be fast charged in the time it takes for a coffee/ wee break. We rarely charge out and about and just plug in when we get home - it's only if we are doing a big trip we'd do more and it's not meant any more stops than when we used to stop anyway. .
If you are driving that much in a day you should be taking at least a small break.
There are already EVs with better range than this ours isn't really the latest tech and has dated quite a bit.

Estermay · 15/11/2023 15:20

A four hour drive without having to charge is not really that long. My husband drives that far every day with the commute to work and back and then driving around for visits at work.
Currently EVs seem to be ideal for office workers who can charge at work or home and at regular gym and supermarket visits. Its a certain kind of middle class lifestyle.

AuntyMabelandPippin · 13/11/2023 19:18

@HolefreeGrail, we had to charge for a couple of weeks till our wall charger was fitted, we just charged our Tesla overnight so we got the cheaper electricity.

We've just upgraded to a dual motor one, and it's much better for long distance driving. We managed a four hour drive without having to charge at all, and we'd only started on 80% as that's the recommended daily charge and we forgot to up it.

wonkylegs · 13/11/2023 13:23

TheHoover · 12/11/2023 07:12

Oh if anyone is worried about privacy, don’t ever buy an electric car
https://www.forensicmag.com/594249-Vehicle-Forensics-From-Car-to-Court/

Scary stuff. But on the plus side, it’s going to be much more difficult in future for anyone to get away with hit and runs,
buglaries - in fact any crime involving a vehicle.

That's applicable to all new cars not EVs
Everything is more connected whether you like it or not. "The internet of things" encompasses so much of people's lives these days, most people are really unaware of how connected they are, from personal devices & gadgets to appliances, to cars and security etc

Kokeshi123 · 13/11/2023 10:05

For people who don't often do long trips by car and are mostly just doing short trips, EVs are already at the stage of being pretty practical... as long as they have a place to charge up, that is! I've no idea what that situ is like in rural areas....

I do feel like some rural residents would be able to swap out cars for electric bikes on at least some trips IF rural areas had networks of standalone walking-and-biking trails segregated from traffic (from village to village, and from each village to the nearest town or city). Not every person or every journey or in every weather/time of day, obviously. But it would help many rural people to reduce their miles driven, be a free way to get fitter, and provide opportunities for some much-needed indepedence for older kids and teenagers in rural areas. Without standalone trails, however, this won't happen, as rural roads are scary places to bike or even to walk - you can't see what's coming round the bend and there is often no pavement.

annahay · 13/11/2023 08:52

user1477391263 · 10/11/2023 22:35

If the UK were a normal, serious country, we’d have proper, reliable, electrified fast trains from most cities and high-speed rail between major cities, and the number of people needing to do lots of long trips via car would be a lot lower than it is now, speeding up the transition.

In the country where I live, we nearly always do big trips by our excellent train network, and only occasionally decide to hire a car for this purpose, not least because in my country we have to pay heavy motorway tolls for driving because drivers are expected to cover the costs of building and maintaining motorways themselves, rather than being subsidized by the taxpayer which is what happens in the UK (fuel duty and VED cover piss-all and do not remotely cover the costs of motorways etc.).

Sadly, the UK is reaping the consequences of 70-odd years of failure on its railway network.

The real fun and games will start in a few years when the government is finally forced to accept reality and bring in per-mile road pricing due to the collapse of VED and fuel tax. The UK has given away motorway driving (except the M6, Mersey tunnels and a couple of bits) for free for decades; it’s going to be a major culture shift and a lot of people will scream bloody murder!

I live rurally and I can do big trips by train. It's the local trips that require a car. Getting to work, doing the big shop, medical appointments etc.

DdraigGoch · 12/11/2023 12:20

TheHoover · 12/11/2023 07:12

Oh if anyone is worried about privacy, don’t ever buy an electric car
https://www.forensicmag.com/594249-Vehicle-Forensics-From-Car-to-Court/

Scary stuff. But on the plus side, it’s going to be much more difficult in future for anyone to get away with hit and runs,
buglaries - in fact any crime involving a vehicle.

Or any car at all.

Blanketpolicy · 12/11/2023 12:02

TheHoover · 12/11/2023 07:12

Oh if anyone is worried about privacy, don’t ever buy an electric car
https://www.forensicmag.com/594249-Vehicle-Forensics-From-Car-to-Court/

Scary stuff. But on the plus side, it’s going to be much more difficult in future for anyone to get away with hit and runs,
buglaries - in fact any crime involving a vehicle.

Have you linked the wrong article as it doesn't mention EVs......🤔

TheHoover · 12/11/2023 07:12

Oh if anyone is worried about privacy, don’t ever buy an electric car
https://www.forensicmag.com/594249-Vehicle-Forensics-From-Car-to-Court/

Scary stuff. But on the plus side, it’s going to be much more difficult in future for anyone to get away with hit and runs,
buglaries - in fact any crime involving a vehicle.

Vehicle Forensics: From Car to Court

From the mechanisms used to enhance the driving experience to inbuilt entertainment systems, all can assist in the detection of crime and can be admissible as evidence in court.

https://www.forensicmag.com/594249-Vehicle-Forensics-From-Car-to-Court/

RedRiverShore4 · 12/11/2023 06:11

My petrol 2016 Fiesta is no VED, there was a short time around then that some small petrol cars had no road tax, it has never been changed for my car and I doubt it will be.

user1477391263 · 12/11/2023 05:08

Re monitoring: yes, I think the idea is that the kilometers driven will be recorded by devices inside your car. The figure can then be extracted
during your MOT and used to calculate the amount of tax you should pay. So no need for monitoring on the roads themselves.

In a way, monitoring via the roads would be better as this would allow a responsive/elastic system where the amount you are charged would vary according to congestion levels and so on, which could potentially create a system where people could choose to drive at less congested times in order to be charged less (a bit like those systems where you can run your washing machine for less money if it goes on in the middle of the night or whatever).

However, UK people tend to be nervous about privacy, so systems that do not record or monitor exactly where a vehicle is located at any given time, are probably more feasible and are the way it will mostly likely be done.

Papyrophile · 11/11/2023 20:29

Most of my driving miles are on C and D roads that will be virtually impossible to monitor. However, it would be straightforward to add the requirement to log miles driven between MoT intervals, and to tax annual mileage retrospectively. Newer luxury cars costing above £40k already have a higher rate of VED imposed for the first few years.

Badbadbunny · 11/11/2023 19:49

@user1477391263

The real fun and games will start in a few years when the government is finally forced to accept reality and bring in per-mile road pricing due to the collapse of VED and fuel tax.

Yep, all those saying how wonderful it is to have electric cars paying little/no VED, low tax benefits in kind, and enjoying "cheap" fuel are going to get one hell of a shock when the revenue currently raised from petrol/diesel car dries up.

The days of low tax benefits in kind will end. As will zero/low vehicle excise duty, and yes, almost certainly there'll also be taxes/charges for mileage or driving in congested places, hence why we got all the smart motorways in congested places with overhead gantries etc - ideal for monitoring and charging road use!!

Estermay · 11/11/2023 18:28

I agree there are real issues with always building on brownfield sites. Where I grew up there are lots of houses now on green area that we used to play on as kids. The official parks are still there, but the population density is far higher without the informal space there used to be.

user1477391263 · 10/11/2023 22:35

If the UK were a normal, serious country, we’d have proper, reliable, electrified fast trains from most cities and high-speed rail between major cities, and the number of people needing to do lots of long trips via car would be a lot lower than it is now, speeding up the transition.

In the country where I live, we nearly always do big trips by our excellent train network, and only occasionally decide to hire a car for this purpose, not least because in my country we have to pay heavy motorway tolls for driving because drivers are expected to cover the costs of building and maintaining motorways themselves, rather than being subsidized by the taxpayer which is what happens in the UK (fuel duty and VED cover piss-all and do not remotely cover the costs of motorways etc.).

Sadly, the UK is reaping the consequences of 70-odd years of failure on its railway network.

The real fun and games will start in a few years when the government is finally forced to accept reality and bring in per-mile road pricing due to the collapse of VED and fuel tax. The UK has given away motorway driving (except the M6, Mersey tunnels and a couple of bits) for free for decades; it’s going to be a major culture shift and a lot of people will scream bloody murder!

HolefreeGrail · 10/11/2023 15:17

I am leasing a Tesla through a salary sacrifice work scheme, it arrived a couple of weeks back. Quite an economic way to try one out, I thought. However, the home charger installation can’t be scheduled for at least 10 weeks! So the bottleneck in our case is the electricians to fit the charger, not the availability of the car. In the meantime I am going to need to charge where I can. So far, I have done one supercharger (less than 3 miles away) one charge while waiting at a hospital appointment for my mum and one at a public car park when shopping in town. I have also done one charge from a normal plug at home, which took ages, but did work. So, so far, only been inconvenienced once by having to drive to the supercharger. As I mainly work from home I think I will be mainly charging with the normal plug at home as I don’t drive every day. But will be glad to get the home charger when it finally gets installed. Will have to see how the long distance drives go, but don’t do that often and got the long range Tesla with 330 miles, so hopefully ok.

Kokeshi123 · 09/11/2023 21:52

As far "car free" high streets, plenty of vibrant town centres are car friendly and remain very popular because they have sensibly sized/priced car parks and no stupid traffic calming and one way systems causing gridlock. People can still drive to them and park easily/cheaply.

Thing is, if I am a "car person" ("I like cars, I live in the suburbs because I want space to park two cars and have a car for every adult in the family, I prefer to drive everywhere, don't want to use public transport, would never considering cycling, want to patronize places that welcome me and my car(s) and make it easy for me to drive in, drive out and park in the meantime"), why would I pick a city center -no matter how car-friendly - over an out-of-town shopping centre or out-of-town shopping park filled with great big box-like shops?

Because no city centre is ever, ever going to compete with those out-of-town retail developments on car-friendliness.

The out-of-town retail places always have far more places to park free of charge and are approached by great big spacious roads; it's so easy to drive there and back and find a parking space. And then, once you are there and parked, you have these great big indoor spaces to wander around freely with no cars fouling up the air or making you panic for your toddler's safety.

A city center or high street, even when designed around cars and trying to compete with the out-of-town shopping mall, is fighting a losing battle. It just inherently does not have a car-friendly structure due to the lack of space, narrower roads; even if you blanketed the whole bloody place with free parking slots, it still won't have as much free parking as the out-of-town shopping mall. And then there isn't a nice indoor spacious car-free, fume-free area to wander about from in safety from the cars. You're stuck there with all the cars and spend most of the time dodging them and breathing in their fumes. Fun times. Why would anyone bother with this when they could just drive to SunnyLakes Shopping Haven out there in the surrounding countryside?

As suggested above, build city centres full of housing and let urban types (who actually enjoy cities, unlike the professed "car people") have their low-car cities on their doorsteps. It does seem to work just fine in other countries?

If you are a "car person" and you feel angry about city centres/high streets that are hard to access by car, well, don't go there, then. Just stick with your suburbs and drive to out-of-town retail developments/shopping centres when you want to buy something, have a day out, eat out or go to the cinema. There are plenty of these places and they are not going anywhere.

DisquietintheRanks · 09/11/2023 12:51

I'm currently visiting family in a large European city. They, along with large numbers of others, live in (or within walking distance of) the centre. And you know what - it's great. The centre is bustling. Lots of shops, lots of Cafes and bars, small supermarkets, large indoor market for meat/fish/fresh veg, parks. It's alive in a way that the UK city I live in just isn't.

DdraigGoch · 09/11/2023 01:52

@user1477391263 it's worth noting that many of the American cities who opted for option 1 (build the cities for the benefit of cars, bulldozing poor/black neighbourhoods to accommodate highways and parking lots in the process) are now in financial difficulties. Endless widenings of freeways and stroads to satisfy an insatiable demand for more road capacity, plus the cost of maintaing highway structures that are reaching life expiry now is unaffordable. Interestingly Detroit is trying to get out of bankruptcy by densifying its urban centre.

user1477391263 · 09/11/2023 00:04

As for denying planning permission, where would you put a huge Tesco superstore on the High Street? Not only will there not be any existing buildings big enough, how would people buy "big" things like TVs or a week's shopping in several full carrier bags (along with a crate of lager), carry all that back home on a bike or a bus? It makes sense to have out of town retail parks and superstores than are good for motorists - the problem was local councils not including public transport options as a condition of PP, i.e. making the developer work with local bus firms to ensure new routes added or existing routes changed to make the out of town sites accessible for locals without cars

Basically, if the idea is that you house lots of people in the urban center (which the UK is gradually starting to do anyway, given that we need to build 4 million homes and suburbanites/villagers throw hissy fits when we try to build anything near them….) they don’t need to drag a week’s worth of shopping home on a bus. They will do what I do and walk to the shops because they will be living locally.

I live round the corner from my modest-sized urban supermarket. Most people round here just pick smaller amongs things up more frequently because it takes about 5 minutes to do so on the way home from work. I do prefer to do a weekly “big shop,” so I just load it up on my buggy and push it home, which takes a few minutes. I’ve timed it against my suburban mother’s shopping trips (I visit her every summer) and I can literally walk there, get my shopping, pay for it, and get my shopping home and put away in approximately the same time that it takes her to drive to her big suburban supermarket and find a parking space. There isn’t the need for really huge supermarkets selling absolutely everything when you live centrally with lots of local shops, because we have so many smaller specialist shops along the street and it’s nice to get bread from a bakery that sells really good bread, for example, if I want specialist products.

If my family really needs to go to an out of town big box store like an IKEA (which is only a couple of times a year, probably), we just arrange for delivery. It still works out massively cheaper than running a car all year round.

If some suburbanites don’t want to use public transport to enter the city center as driving and parking there becomes increasingly difficult, that’s OK. They can, if they like, stick to a lifestyle of staying out there in the suburbs, driving to big box places out of town, and rarely coming into the city center. I know people like this - they just want to drive places like out-of-town garden centers or stay at home and they are are not interested in the kind of things you get in walkable, bustle-y town centers, like cool little shops or interesting coffee places or people-watching or whatever. That’s OK, they can do what they like and we all like different things. The big box out-of-town places are already built, and nobody is going to tear them down.