Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not lend this?

219 replies

amayzin · 04/11/2023 13:13

I feel guilty but here goes, someone I don’t know too well has asked us for £100 to borrow until the beginning of next month. I’ve never lent anyone money before as nobody has ever asked.

We could lend them the £100 but we are trying to save as we are TTC (our first, and possibly only) and really want to have enough behind us so I can have a comfortable mat leave etc. If they don’t pay it back then that is £100 less, selfishly!

They have 4 kids and another on the way and I hate the idea of any of them going hungry but on the other hand one of them smokes and they have a relatively new car so my gut instinct says hopefully their situation isn’t that bad and they will still be able to afford food and stuff. AIBU to not lend? I feel bad but DH says it would be a slippery slope and it might put both us and them in a difficult position, doing more harm than good

OP posts:
MumblesParty · 04/11/2023 17:23

MexterDorgan · 04/11/2023 16:05

I wouldn't purely because they smoke. Might be on my moral high ground, but feed your kids before your habit.

Agree

ElleCapitaine · 04/11/2023 17:22

No way - they don’t know you well. That suggests they’ve already gone through family and close friends to get to you. You will 100% not see that money again.

squashi · 04/11/2023 17:21

Don't lend. "Sorry, I can't lend you the money." Slippery slope.

Startagainjanuary · 04/11/2023 17:16

Just tell them your money is in a non accessible savings account for your ttc. Ask them if there is any other way you can help like food etc. I have loads of tins of food in the garage ready for my DS to take back with him to Uni after Xmas. If someone I knew was hungry I would give them some. Money, probably not unless it was a close friend and even then I’m not sure as my financial priorities differ from many of my friends and this is the reason I would struggle to lend them money but always happy to feed them and share a bottle of wine.

Chromium24 · 04/11/2023 17:15

in modern times, its tricky, if you lend and they take ages to repay or you lend and then they think they can keep borrowing, part of the problem with a capitalist society.

itsalongwaybackfromsorry · 04/11/2023 17:09

Nope.

The smoker isn't going without; not your problem to sort.

MeridianB · 04/11/2023 17:07

You are their new/latest ‘sucker’.

The ‘we need to feed our four kids and pregnant mum’ emotional blackmail is all part of it.

Totally agree with others saying they are asking you as everyone else has wised up to them. You won’t see the money again. And they won’t appreciate it.

New cars, petrol, smoking and children are all very expensive things. They don’t just magically appear in your life. These guys know exactly what they’re doing!

HerMammy · 04/11/2023 17:06

Say no, but remind the, they can put it on a credit card!
The assumption on MN that everyone has a CC

SweetBirdsong · 04/11/2023 17:06

Never in a million years. Me and DH had an inheritance about 7 years ago - £35,000 between us - from an aunt. He can't keep anything to himself, and just HAD to blab to people at work about it. Suddenly two colleagues, (one male and one female,) had money problems. One wanted to borrow £1250, and the other £3,000!

He was actually considering it, and said 'well ... we have had this money given to us, so it's no hardship...' And I vetoed it. 'No WAY!' I said. Luckily we share finances and he couldn't give anything to them without my say-so. But yeah, I would never ever EVER lend anyone any money. And I would not borrow any money either. (Only from a bank!)

We have lent money in the past, (23-25 years ago - nearly £400,) and we never got it back. Would have been about £750-£800 in today's money. Once bitten and all that.

uncomfortablydumb53 · 04/11/2023 17:06

Just say " No, you don't have it"
Don't feel guilty It's your hard worked for money

EarringsandLipstick · 04/11/2023 17:05

PlipPlopChoo · 04/11/2023 16:59

You are not asked for your opinion on their lifestyle or choices. How unpleasant an attitude

You are completely missing the point. What they want to hear and what they need to hear are different things.

But as I previously said above. I would only resort to this is they pushed the loan issue. Should they accept a "no" and leave it at that, then I would not comment on their lifestyle. But in my experience people asking borderline strangers for a loan never listen to the first answer.

Edited

Ah, fair enough. You didn't make that clear - sure, if they kept pushing, I think you could say something.

However, I still don't think that should be a commentary on their lifestyle. They don't 'need' it. It will have no effect whatsoever & it is simply not your place to judge.

It's just 'no' and a firmer 'no' if needed.

And while I don't mean in this case, believe me when I say it is very possible to be unaware of the extent and reasons for someone's financial difficulties.

SkinnyMalinkyLankyLegs · 04/11/2023 17:03

They keep having kids with another on the way yet they can't afford to feed the ones they already have? And they puff away a massive amount of their money? Not a chance I'd be lending a penny. They can claim for an advance on their universal credit.

PlipPlopChoo · 04/11/2023 16:59

You are not asked for your opinion on their lifestyle or choices. How unpleasant an attitude

You are completely missing the point. What they want to hear and what they need to hear are different things.

But as I previously said above. I would only resort to this is they pushed the loan issue. Should they accept a "no" and leave it at that, then I would not comment on their lifestyle. But in my experience people asking borderline strangers for a loan never listen to the first answer.

BebbanburgIsMine · 04/11/2023 16:58

Some years ago I loaned a friend nearly £500, I'd had a bit of a windfall, and I got all the promises to pay it back in installments, on her payday every month, I couldn't really afford to lend that money, but was taken in by the sob stories.

I would get a tenner here and there, and when I started to chase it up a bit she more or less stopped speaking to me. It's only been this year that the full amount has been paid back. I'd kind of written it off, learned my lesson about lending anyone money.

I got an envelope through my door, with just a note saying "Here, it's paid back now"!

I have nothing to do with her anymore.

EarringsandLipstick · 04/11/2023 16:57

PlipPlopChoo · 04/11/2023 16:56

Deciding to offer judgment on their lifestyle and family planning is totally out of order

As soon as they push for a loan giving them financial advice is perfectly acceptable. The added benefit is they will probably never ask for money or even speak to you again.

Edited

Of course it isn't 🙄

You can say no.

You are not asked for your opinion on their lifestyle or choices

How unpleasant an attitude.

OneMorePlant · 04/11/2023 16:56

Only lend money to people if you have no expectations or desire of ever getting it back. And you won't be annoyed or angry when they don't pay it back.

Considering you are trying to save and you don't really know these people the answer to lending them is obviously no.

PlipPlopChoo · 04/11/2023 16:56

Deciding to offer judgment on their lifestyle and family planning is totally out of order

As soon as they push for a loan giving them financial advice is perfectly acceptable. The added benefit is they will probably never ask for money or even speak to you again.

misunderstoodMilo · 04/11/2023 16:56

You say they have come to you to ask to borrow money even though you don’t know them well. I wonder if this is because closer friends have already refused because they know what they are like or because they won’t be repaid.

I think your husband is right and if you say yes you will be seen as being a soft touch. Most people do not go round asking acquaintances for cash so a definite red flag.

OhComeOnFFS · 04/11/2023 16:51

You don't even know them.

The reason they are asking you is because they have asked everyone else and nobody's lent it to them. That will probably be because they don't pay anything back.

I wouldn't lend a penny to someone who smokes, anyway - they're prioritising that over food.

DyslexicPoster · 04/11/2023 16:47

I wouldn't. I occasionally lend my best friend money and she never pays back on time, and has treated a bf to days and meals out and presents before prioritising repaying me. She does always pay me back. But once it was almost a year later! Only lend out what your happy to never get back

BananaHamster · 04/11/2023 16:47

No I wouldn't lend money to someone who keeps having more kids and can't afford the ones they have either.
It's different if it was an emergency say there house set on fire or had to get to hospital but otherwise nope.

Ponderingwindow · 04/11/2023 16:44

Do not lend money. Give money if a situation truly warrants the gift and you can afford to give.

Also think rationally for a minute. Their children should not be at risk of hunger or deprivation if you don’t lend this money.

Just looked up the average price of a pack of cigarettes is 12.61. 100 would buy you 7.93 packs, let’s call that 8 to make things easier. 8 packs x 20 cigarettes per pack = 160 cigarettes. 30 days in a month, that is 5.33 cigarettes per day.

All they have to do to come up with the money themselves is drop 5-6 cigarettes a day. Should they do that or should you be stressed about getting your money back?

TomatoSandwiches · 04/11/2023 16:44

Just say no, you don't lend out money.
If you want to offer some homemade meals that's more than generous but don't give her any wiggle room to argue her case because if she is a cheeky fucker she will try to make you feel guilty.

Lairymary · 04/11/2023 16:43

Hmm this sounds very much like a family I know. Exactly the same circumstances. The guy bleeds his mother dry and turns up at the supermarket when he knows his mum is shopping with his offspring trailing behind in the hope of a bit of a scrounge. Talks about needing to use food banks but I suspect it's just to get financial sympathy. Doesn't stop to think about child number 5 or getting a puppy. You're not in a town beginning with A are you?

Give them a swerve otherwise they will keep coming. Never lend money that you can't afford to not get back.

LeilaDarling · 04/11/2023 16:42

say we aren’t in the position to do that but they are welcome to come for a meal - trust me they won’t take you up! X