Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To end a friendship over this comment about CM?

191 replies

Jupp1 · 04/11/2023 08:20

My partner left me and ds when he was 2 weeks old. I immediately put in a claim for CM as I was on maternity leave and desperate. At the time ex had to pay me 970 a month (three years ago). This paid my mortgage and effectively allowed me to take the full year of maternity leave as I had some savings myself too.

Anyway it’s three years later, he has sod all to do with us and his payments have gone down to 580. I know this is a chunk of money but please don’t comment that I should be grateful (I see that comment a lot on here!)… I do absolutely everything for ds so he’s effectively paying me a tiny amount towards what he should be doing practically. But this isn’t about that…

I made a throwaway comment that I was going to find it more difficult now the payments have reduced and I might have to re assess what ds can do activity wise etc. My friend jumped in almost before I had finished speaking and said at least I had the first early years effectively paid for in full as I never had to worry about nursery cost like she had to do it was a luxury, (she’s married!) and now what I’m getting ‘surely covers’ all the basics ds needs.

I keep going over it and wondering if it was meant to be supportive but the way she said it and the comment about her having to worry about nursery but not me? I struggled massively in those first three years and it didn’t feel like a luxury…!! I am so disappointed she has said this and feel really uncomfortable seeing her again. AIBU?

OP posts:
BoohooWoohoo · 04/11/2023 09:42

It is strange that some people think that high earning NRP shouldn't pay higher levels of CM. These people never say that high earners shouldn't pay more tax.

Never discuss specific amounts of CM. It makes some people strangely judgy and they forget that you don't benefit from the practical side of having a partner. It's ok to complain that you are not getting CM or it's being reduced nearly 50% but there's a surprising number who thinks that CM should be capped a lot lower because they receive pathetic amounts of £7pw or know people getting nothing.

Naunet · 04/11/2023 09:41

Cheeky cow. I’d ask her why she doesn’t think your child deserves any support from their own father. I can’t stand these stupid women who seem to resent men having to support their own kids, puppets to the patriarchy.

saraclara · 04/11/2023 09:37

Goodornot · 04/11/2023 09:28

It's clear the OP works. The maintenance allowed her to take a year of mat leave. She doesn't say anywhere that she didn't go back to work and it doesn't sound like she could afford to stay off work. The maintenance paid her mortgage but not bills etc.

So why don't nursery fees apply to her too?

saraclara · 04/11/2023 09:36

She could be struggling for money and hearing your woes about having to stop some activities, which are a luxury especially right now, probably smarted a bit.

Yep. plus maybe she'd have liked to be at home with her child or afford more activities. I dare say that if she thought it through, she'd realise the benefits (assuming her DH is decent) of having a partner to share the parenting. But I can imagine that the amount of money and you being focused on it only affecting activities could smart for a few seconds and lead to that comment.

But for goodness' sake, as a stand-alone incident, it absolutely is not a friendship ending thing.

Goodornot · 04/11/2023 09:31

Totaly · 04/11/2023 09:30

But the friend is living with her DH with 2 incomes and sharing half the rent and bills.

But they would have to pay all the nursery fees.

I think the comment was more about free nursery than CM.

And others are right, a SAHP isn’t offered extra money from their husbands, they don’t get the rent paid for by government etc

You might be doing everything, but then so might she and have an extra person to run round after.

It's depressingly common for the man to do sod all for the children and add to the load.

Totaly · 04/11/2023 09:30

But the friend is living with her DH with 2 incomes and sharing half the rent and bills.

But they would have to pay all the nursery fees.

I think the comment was more about free nursery than CM.

And others are right, a SAHP isn’t offered extra money from their husbands, they don’t get the rent paid for by government etc

You might be doing everything, but then so might she and have an extra person to run round after.

Goodornot · 04/11/2023 09:28

It's clear the OP works. The maintenance allowed her to take a year of mat leave. She doesn't say anywhere that she didn't go back to work and it doesn't sound like she could afford to stay off work. The maintenance paid her mortgage but not bills etc.

windypumpkin · 04/11/2023 09:26

Sexlivesofthepotatomen · 04/11/2023 08:54

Well OP says she's going to struggle now the payments have been cut so I was wondering whether she worked. Not an unreasonable question I don't think

It will also affect how friend feels. So I agree it is relevant

Goodornot · 04/11/2023 09:20

One other thing to consider is to keep discussions over finances to a minimum.

I don't tell my friends what I earn or my outgoings are. Perhaps limit what you tell people it's honestly nobody's business.

theduchessofspork · 04/11/2023 09:20

Jupp1 · 04/11/2023 08:24

@Snowdayplease I don’t think that at all. But having money and no supportive partner is not comparable to being married is it? The money wasn’t a luxury!!

Married people can still be skint. By your own admission the money allowed you to take a years mat leave, so presumably you weren’t struggling with bills.

Having money and no partner can easily be a far better option than being married - a partner can add to life’s difficulties in lots of ways.

You are playing a one upmanship here, which might explain why she is.

Stop it.

Of course your ex should contribute, but being a single parent doesn’t make you automatically in a worse position than anyone else.

Unexpectedlysinglemum · 04/11/2023 09:19

If she's a good friend I would try talking to her first about how she upset you and giving her a chance to apologize before cutting her off

donquixotedelamancha · 04/11/2023 09:17

Universalsnail · 04/11/2023 08:22

If you are going to end a friendship over a silly comment like this then I would suggest the friendship doesn't mean much to you in the first place. It was an insensitive comment but not friendship ending imo.

This. I don't really understand this MN thing about NC with people who are supposedly close over one comment you don't like.

I think you will be happier, in general, if you assume the best possible interpretation of things that are said to you- particularly by friends. However if you already don't like this woman there is no need keep seeing her.

Do things that make you happy.

Mylovelygreendress · 04/11/2023 09:17

OP , on MN you are told to consider yourself lucky to receive any CM at all . It’s an attitude I don’t understand .
One of my DDs has had a few snide comments about the CM she is - finally - receiving from her high earning exh . She pointed out that all he has to do is pay some money , she does everything else . He sees the DC for 3 hours a week .

theduchessofspork · 04/11/2023 09:14

Universalsnail · 04/11/2023 08:22

If you are going to end a friendship over a silly comment like this then I would suggest the friendship doesn't mean much to you in the first place. It was an insensitive comment but not friendship ending imo.

This! Who ends a friendship over one daft remark?!

Perhaps she is much skinter than you, married or not. Perhaps she is a bit self obsessed.

With money just avoid taking specific figures with friends.

If she’s a proper friend get over yourself. If she’s just an acquaintance then it’s not worth worrying about anyway.

Goodornot · 04/11/2023 09:12

CornishGem1975 · 04/11/2023 09:10

This. She could be struggling for money and hearing your woes about having to stop some activities, which are a luxury especially right now, probably smarted a bit.

Also, as you've discovered CM can go down, nobody should ever rely on it for anything. Your ex could lose his job tomorrow (or die) and you'd get sweet FA.

Or of he starts building a relationship with the child and begins to stay at dad's it will be cut. You can't rely on it.

CornishGem1975 · 04/11/2023 09:11

The friend will still be way better off than OP and it was very rude and insensitive to act like OP’s had it easier than her, when she obviously hadn’t.

How do you know that the friend will be better off? You don't know that friend's personal circumstance.

CornishGem1975 · 04/11/2023 09:10

EvaBlue · 04/11/2023 08:36

£970 may be not far off what her husband brings home, once you take off his living expenses. If that £400 was just going on DS’s extracurricular activities maybe she’s tired of hearing about your financial position, when hers is worse.

This. She could be struggling for money and hearing your woes about having to stop some activities, which are a luxury especially right now, probably smarted a bit.

Also, as you've discovered CM can go down, nobody should ever rely on it for anything. Your ex could lose his job tomorrow (or die) and you'd get sweet FA.

Goodornot · 04/11/2023 09:06

You see all the time on here that financial abuse starts when the children arrive.

Once on mat leave the man becomes a tight arse and keeps money to himself leaving nothing but SMP and child benefit if they qualify for it and whatever savings the OP has to live on.

OP got nearly £1000 a month for a newborn that only needed milk and nappies, a pram and a bed and some clothes for the first few months. You also had savings that allowed you take a full year off because of the maintenance.

In married couples, how often does the man hand the woman a grand a month for what they need?

You did pretty well OP and some women would prefer the money without the man around.

Sometimeswinning · 04/11/2023 09:03

LizzBurg · 04/11/2023 08:54

I’d let it go and move on. Compared to people I know receiving CM for one child £970 and even £580 is considerably more.

So?? It’s hardly a second wage coming in is it? No woman should be grateful for a man paying for his child.

Itsnotchristmasyet · 04/11/2023 09:02

LizzBurg · 04/11/2023 08:54

I’d let it go and move on. Compared to people I know receiving CM for one child £970 and even £580 is considerably more.

Yes it’s loads more than most people get.

But the friend is living with her DH with 2 incomes and sharing half the rent and bills.

The friend will still be way better off than OP and it was very rude and insensitive to act like OP’s had it easier than her, when she obviously hadn’t.

Itsnotchristmasyet · 04/11/2023 08:59

YANBU to find it upsetting and offensive but I would be careful about throwing a friendship away over it.

I would back off and if she asks to meet up, explain how much it upset you and how she can’t possibly know what it’s like being left a single parent and doing everything and not sharing the costs 50/50.

Her reaction to you will decide whether this is a friendship that you want to continue or not.

I got milk vouchers when I had my DD which I believe were £1.50 a week and they were to only be used on milk (and I think fruit).
I was a teenage single parent and no physical or financial help from anyone.
My sister was married and her and her DH was on a good income and she went mad at me when she found out I was getting these £1.50 vouchers every week as it wasn’t fair.

Some people honestly have no idea.

Sexlivesofthepotatomen · 04/11/2023 08:54

Well OP says she's going to struggle now the payments have been cut so I was wondering whether she worked. Not an unreasonable question I don't think

LizzBurg · 04/11/2023 08:54

I’d let it go and move on. Compared to people I know receiving CM for one child £970 and even £580 is considerably more.

Loubelle70 · 04/11/2023 08:54

Tell her you found it offensive (if she meant it that way). If shes a friend, you know.
Tbh my DD sperm donor contributed 5p a week, 20p a month yep. He was on benefits. I was very young and naive. I was a single mum. Working.
I struggled on one wage but managed. I am in better very well paid job Now ...but that amount is not a bad amount to cope with. I was limited at activities i could afford, but theres free near free activities... park...walk... picnic

Milkybarsareonmeeeee · 04/11/2023 08:51

Sexlivesofthepotatomen · 04/11/2023 08:43

Do you work?

Why do you as OP this. ??