Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To end a friendship over this comment about CM?

191 replies

Jupp1 · 04/11/2023 08:20

My partner left me and ds when he was 2 weeks old. I immediately put in a claim for CM as I was on maternity leave and desperate. At the time ex had to pay me 970 a month (three years ago). This paid my mortgage and effectively allowed me to take the full year of maternity leave as I had some savings myself too.

Anyway it’s three years later, he has sod all to do with us and his payments have gone down to 580. I know this is a chunk of money but please don’t comment that I should be grateful (I see that comment a lot on here!)… I do absolutely everything for ds so he’s effectively paying me a tiny amount towards what he should be doing practically. But this isn’t about that…

I made a throwaway comment that I was going to find it more difficult now the payments have reduced and I might have to re assess what ds can do activity wise etc. My friend jumped in almost before I had finished speaking and said at least I had the first early years effectively paid for in full as I never had to worry about nursery cost like she had to do it was a luxury, (she’s married!) and now what I’m getting ‘surely covers’ all the basics ds needs.

I keep going over it and wondering if it was meant to be supportive but the way she said it and the comment about her having to worry about nursery but not me? I struggled massively in those first three years and it didn’t feel like a luxury…!! I am so disappointed she has said this and feel really uncomfortable seeing her again. AIBU?

OP posts:
Beezknees · 04/11/2023 12:06

YANBU at all anyway.

Maintenance is based on the NRP income, as it well should.

If you are part of a couple you have far more flexibility regarding working and earnings than lone parents do. And if you have a partner that is useless, you still have the choice to leave.

Beezknees · 04/11/2023 12:02

Goodornot · 04/11/2023 10:34

Yes but if she didn't have a child would she not need a home or to pay bills? The biggest expenses she'd pay anyway.

You didn't say if you spend £970 or £580 a month per child?

Yes but it would cost far less.

I'm a lone parent. I have a 2 bedroom flat. If I was single with no dependents, I would live in a bedsit for £250 a month less. My heating, water and electricity costs would all drop, and my food bill would more than halve. The whole "pay for bills anyway" completely ignores the fact that you need a larger property with a whole other bedroom for a child than you do as a single person.

LividHol · 04/11/2023 11:57

The state of some people on here thinking women should be grateful to get anything from a NRP.

Like the only costs associated with raising a child are the milk and nappies.

Like being a solo parent is a walk in the park, and that living alone is somehow exactly half the cost of living in a couple.

I was SOOO much better off in a couple, financially. The house we could afford together was magnificent, and I was paying less (at 50% of all bills) by miles than I am now as a solo parent in a tiny house that’s literally falling down. I mean, he was abusive and I had to leave to keep my child safe, but carry on thinking the tiny percentage of his income he legally has to give me is a massive treat I should be grateful for.

Sometimeswinning · 04/11/2023 11:45

Goodornot · 04/11/2023 10:34

Yes but if she didn't have a child would she not need a home or to pay bills? The biggest expenses she'd pay anyway.

You didn't say if you spend £970 or £580 a month per child?

Strange comparison. If she didn’t have a child she would have zero responsibility to anyone and only herself. Therefore could live however she chose. As it is she has a child with this “man” and they should both ensure there is a safe and stable home for their child. That’s what the money is for.

CaramelShortcakes · 04/11/2023 11:16

I feel people just try to make you see the positives of CM even when there aren’t any, I get £7 a month for my children even though I also do everything for them (he’s not involved) I posted on here and got told at least I could buy them an ice cream once a week or a packet of crisps 😂 maybe she was just trying to get you to see the positives?

LizzBurg · 04/11/2023 11:12

Sometimeswinning · 04/11/2023 09:03

So?? It’s hardly a second wage coming in is it? No woman should be grateful for a man paying for his child.

You’re adding your own incorrect context to my comment. My observation is not a criticism of the OP.

Goodornot · 04/11/2023 10:34

Mylovelygreendress · 04/11/2023 10:08

The OP has to provide a suitable home , heating , food , clothes etc for the child - it soon mounts up .

Yes but if she didn't have a child would she not need a home or to pay bills? The biggest expenses she'd pay anyway.

You didn't say if you spend £970 or £580 a month per child?

Gillypie23 · 04/11/2023 10:24

Firstly nobody should be grateful for getting maintenance. Its a legal right from the other parent.

I think your friend was being supportive in a clumsy way.

Velvian · 04/11/2023 10:20

Yanbu, @Jupp1 . We'd struggle in the house if either DH or my wage went down to £570, as I'm sure your friend would too.

She must realise that she is in a better situation with pooled income and resources than being single, even with a relatively high CM payment.

You should never be grateful for a parent grudgingly fulfilling their legal minimum of responsibility.

KitKatrunchie · 04/11/2023 10:11

You don’t really sound like the sort of person that anyone couldn’t say their honest view with. You’re wanting to end the friendship over this comment and have said in your post that people commenting shouldn’t say certain things.

donquixotedelamancha · 04/11/2023 10:11

Naunet · 04/11/2023 09:54

Yeah, I have more friends than you and my dads bigger than yours too…🙄 grow up.
I’m assuming ignorance and stupidity, not malice.

I shall try to do better and follow your example of calm maturity.

Mylovelygreendress · 04/11/2023 10:08

Why do some on MN set the bar so low for absent parents’ financial contributions? Which should the RP be grateful ?

Mylovelygreendress · 04/11/2023 10:08

Goodornot · 04/11/2023 10:05

How many families spend £970 or even £580 per month for each child. But that's what the OP gets so surely the friend is right- it is enough for one child.

In any event OP should heed the fact that it has been reduced by £400 a month.
You can't rely on it. If he loses his job she gets nothing. If he has more children, it's reduced further. At 18 years old it stops.

Better to factor in not having the money at all.

Edited

The OP has to provide a suitable home , heating , food , clothes etc for the child - it soon mounts up .

Goodornot · 04/11/2023 10:05

Naunet · 04/11/2023 09:58

That’s not what the friend said though, was it?

and now what I’m getting ‘surely covers’ all the basics ds needs

How many families spend £970 or even £580 per month for each child. But that's what the OP gets so surely the friend is right- it is enough for one child.

In any event OP should heed the fact that it has been reduced by £400 a month.
You can't rely on it. If he loses his job she gets nothing. If he has more children, it's reduced further. At 18 years old it stops.

Better to factor in not having the money at all.

Daffodil18 · 04/11/2023 10:00

The thing is CM isn’t means tested against universal credit. Some people like me get nothing and just use my top up of universal credit to support my DC. I think what you get is a lot, so yes I wouldn’t want to hear you complain. However I understand it’s a drop for you and I get it will affect you, but just be more mindful that other people might not be in a good financial position.

Naunet · 04/11/2023 09:58

Goodornot · 04/11/2023 09:55

I don't think £1000 a month for a newborn is the basics. Would the OP really have wanted the father to have contact and overnight...with a newborn? Doubt it.

Edited

That’s not what the friend said though, was it?

and now what I’m getting ‘surely covers’ all the basics ds needs

Sartre · 04/11/2023 09:58

Your mistake was discussing the amount with her when it’s none of her business. I suspect she’s struggling financially and a bit envious at the amount you get from him. Obviously your ex should be paying for his child, not in the least because he does fuck all else.

Goodornot · 04/11/2023 09:55

Naunet · 04/11/2023 09:50

No you’re right, suggesting children of divorce with uninterested, unloving fathers should be ‘happy with the basics’ is totally not cheeky…

I don't think £1000 a month for a newborn is the basics. Would the OP really have wanted the father to have contact and overnight...with a newborn? Doubt it.

Naunet · 04/11/2023 09:54

donquixotedelamancha · 04/11/2023 09:48

You must have loads of mates if you react to every slightly tactless comment by assuming malice.

Yeah, I have more friends than you and my dads bigger than yours too…🙄 grow up.
I’m assuming ignorance and stupidity, not malice.

Naunet · 04/11/2023 09:50

Hercisback · 04/11/2023 09:45

She's not cheeky, you both don't fully understand the other ones life.
There's two of us but I went back to work at 7 months as we couldn't afford it. £980 was less than Hs wage.

No you’re right, suggesting children of divorce with uninterested, unloving fathers should be ‘happy with the basics’ is totally not cheeky…

Goodornot · 04/11/2023 09:49

saraclara · 04/11/2023 09:37

So why don't nursery fees apply to her too?

That I don't know.

saffronsoup · 04/11/2023 09:49

If you are each putting almost £600, that is a lot of money to be directed towards one young child and far more than many married couples can put towards each child. Few parents have £1200 to go towards their child expenses so for you to say you then can't afford extracurriculars seems very classist.

You would still have rent a mortgage and all your own expenses- utlities, food, transportation etc without a child. While many people just include their CM in their general budget, if you parse out what is child specific - nursery, child's food, child's clothing, child activiites, child use of utilitiies - most people have less than £1200 to put towards these child specific expenses. Many married people have to make choices about a cheaper nursery or staying in a flat or whatver to ensure it stays within their budget.

donquixotedelamancha · 04/11/2023 09:48

Naunet · 04/11/2023 09:41

Cheeky cow. I’d ask her why she doesn’t think your child deserves any support from their own father. I can’t stand these stupid women who seem to resent men having to support their own kids, puppets to the patriarchy.

You must have loads of mates if you react to every slightly tactless comment by assuming malice.

Milliemoos5 · 04/11/2023 09:47

i agree. It’s often a financial shock/hit hit to the resident parent if they have enough CM to live a comfy life and then the CM stops when the kid/s hit 18. Much better to work and build a career, where possible, to prepare for the fact the CM is only for a limited time.

Hercisback · 04/11/2023 09:45

She's not cheeky, you both don't fully understand the other ones life.
There's two of us but I went back to work at 7 months as we couldn't afford it. £980 was less than Hs wage.