Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To end a friendship over this comment about CM?

191 replies

Jupp1 · 04/11/2023 08:20

My partner left me and ds when he was 2 weeks old. I immediately put in a claim for CM as I was on maternity leave and desperate. At the time ex had to pay me 970 a month (three years ago). This paid my mortgage and effectively allowed me to take the full year of maternity leave as I had some savings myself too.

Anyway it’s three years later, he has sod all to do with us and his payments have gone down to 580. I know this is a chunk of money but please don’t comment that I should be grateful (I see that comment a lot on here!)… I do absolutely everything for ds so he’s effectively paying me a tiny amount towards what he should be doing practically. But this isn’t about that…

I made a throwaway comment that I was going to find it more difficult now the payments have reduced and I might have to re assess what ds can do activity wise etc. My friend jumped in almost before I had finished speaking and said at least I had the first early years effectively paid for in full as I never had to worry about nursery cost like she had to do it was a luxury, (she’s married!) and now what I’m getting ‘surely covers’ all the basics ds needs.

I keep going over it and wondering if it was meant to be supportive but the way she said it and the comment about her having to worry about nursery but not me? I struggled massively in those first three years and it didn’t feel like a luxury…!! I am so disappointed she has said this and feel really uncomfortable seeing her again. AIBU?

OP posts:
cansu · 04/11/2023 20:48

You may not live together but presumably if you were living together, you may or may not do more or earn more or less than each other. In any event, whether what he pays is fair or not is irrelevant. You have mixed friendship with money. Is it important that your friend agrees with you? Why? She probably should not have commented. She made an error here too. Keep your financial affairs private.

Chichimcgee · 04/11/2023 20:48

I’d feel damn lucky if my ex paid any of the child maintenance he owes, currently over 15k and hasn’t been forced to pay. So yes those who have ex’s who contribute financially are lucky.

Jupp1 · 04/11/2023 20:47

saffronsoup · 04/11/2023 20:45

So how much would that be? What amount could cover all those costs and what would you be left with from your salary after covering that cost?

@saffronsoup this is exactly the problem though isn’t it? Women (usually) are forced into debt or a lower standard of living because CM is insufficient. I earn a high salary so I could in theory pay half of nursery and then an amount to cover some childcare outside of that to support a RP. It would be in the region of 1,500 a month. That would be the right thing to do if I was going to abandon all responsibility on a daily, 24 hour basis.

OP posts:
Secondguess · 04/11/2023 20:46

You could say to your friend something like "when you said... I was upset because it felt like... Can you talk me through what you meant by...?" then decide your next steps depending on how she responds.

RMNofTikTok · 04/11/2023 20:45

Chichimcgee · 04/11/2023 20:45

Unfortunately many, many people don’t get child maintenance so yes it’s a privilege

It's not a race to the bottom!

Jupp1 · 04/11/2023 20:45

RMNofTikTok · 04/11/2023 20:41

It's not a privilege! Paying 12% - 20% of your income towards your children IS THE BARE MINIMUM.

@Chichimcgee do you understand that you are effectively saying that women should feel lucky when men are forced to contribute financially to the upbringing of their child?

Are you stupid or just a man?

OP posts:
Chichimcgee · 04/11/2023 20:45

Unfortunately many, many people don’t get child maintenance so yes it’s a privilege

saffronsoup · 04/11/2023 20:45

Jupp1 · 04/11/2023 20:42

@saffronsoup it would never happen because I’m not a lowlife. But I would expect half of nursery fees to be paid for and then whatever childcare the person I had forced to care for my child in my absence, needed, to ensure they could maintain their own life too.

So how much would that be? What amount could cover all those costs and what would you be left with from your salary after covering that cost?

UndercoverCop · 04/11/2023 20:43

@Chichimcgee if you think the other parent contributing financially to raising their own child is a privilege, you have a very low bar

Jupp1 · 04/11/2023 20:43

cansu · 04/11/2023 20:41

The issue of what a nanny would cost is really rather bogus. Many couples have children and one partner does much more than the other or contributes more than the other. Your ex may be paying more, less or about right but that is irrelevant really. Keep your financial affairs to yourself if you value your friendship. I have friends with more and less than me. I try and separate this from how I feel about them as a person. If they are kind and fun to spend time with, arguing or feeling slighted about money or politics or whatever is pointless.

@cansu its not bogus, though. He and I are not family. It’s not the same as a wife or husband doing more or less than the other.

OP posts:
UndercoverCop · 04/11/2023 20:42

Well unless her husband earns less than £970 a month he's bringing in more to the household than your feckless ex. CM shouldn't be a race to the bottom, if that's what he was assessed as needing to pay he was on a bloody good salary. OP shouldn't feel bad about that because some men think £7 a week is adequate

supersonicginandtonic · 04/11/2023 20:42

I receive a significant amount of money per month, from the father of my children. I have never told anybody how much. Not even my partner knows as it is for my kids. I wouldn't tell people, personally but then again I was raised in a family where we didn't talk about how much money people had or how much they earned, as it was seen as private.

Jupp1 · 04/11/2023 20:42

saffronsoup · 04/11/2023 20:39

So OP, lets say your child goes to live with his father full time for whatever reason. What do you feel would be a reasonable amount for you to pay out of pocket out of your monthly salary to your ex for CM? And how much would that leave you to live on yourself after paying that amount?

@saffronsoup it would never happen because I’m not a lowlife. But I would expect half of nursery fees to be paid for and then whatever childcare the person I had forced to care for my child in my absence, needed, to ensure they could maintain their own life too.

OP posts:
cansu · 04/11/2023 20:41

The issue of what a nanny would cost is really rather bogus. Many couples have children and one partner does much more than the other or contributes more than the other. Your ex may be paying more, less or about right but that is irrelevant really. Keep your financial affairs to yourself if you value your friendship. I have friends with more and less than me. I try and separate this from how I feel about them as a person. If they are kind and fun to spend time with, arguing or feeling slighted about money or politics or whatever is pointless.

RMNofTikTok · 04/11/2023 20:41

Chichimcgee · 04/11/2023 20:40

It is a privilege!
thousands of people don’t get any maintenance at all or any support or help!
£580 a month is a hell of a lot regardless of where it comes from and when it’s on top of everything else as well. I can see how her friend got frustrated.

It's not a privilege! Paying 12% - 20% of your income towards your children IS THE BARE MINIMUM.

Mari9999 · 04/11/2023 20:40

@Jupp1
She was probably speaking out of her own sense of frustration. Actually being married or having a partner is only as good a thing as the spouse or partner is a good, kind, weight carrying person.

Chichimcgee · 04/11/2023 20:40

It is a privilege!
thousands of people don’t get any maintenance at all or any support or help!
£580 a month is a hell of a lot regardless of where it comes from and when it’s on top of everything else as well. I can see how her friend got frustrated.

saffronsoup · 04/11/2023 20:39

So OP, lets say your child goes to live with his father full time for whatever reason. What do you feel would be a reasonable amount for you to pay out of pocket out of your monthly salary to your ex for CM? And how much would that leave you to live on yourself after paying that amount?

ChiefWiggumsBoy · 04/11/2023 20:38

I think only you can understand the intent behind her comment, but tbh, those who've never been in the situation (from either side) really cannot fathom it. To them, they just see an amount of money coming into your household that they aren't getting, because it doesn't register that they have a two parent family and if they both work, then both salaries would be coming in. They also can't fathom that even if you're getting £££ and have it completely plain sailing from a financial perspective, parenting solo is vastly different than having a partner to lean on. It's even vastly different to amicably co-parenting to having to do it the way you are because the father is not interested.

I wouldn't cut her off, but I would try and not discuss money with her anymore. Unless you're willing to explain everything to her.

Countdowntowhat · 04/11/2023 20:37

She sounds like a rude idiot 🤷‍♀️ dotch her or forgive her, your call.

Always amazes me when people treat child maintenance like a privilege. Dimwits the lot of them.

cansu · 04/11/2023 20:37

I think you need to put the comment aside. I think disparity in money and circumstances can be tricky to negotiate. Just let it lie and steer clear of discussing this kind of thing with your friend. She may well be less well off than you. It is not worth losing a friendship over.

saffronsoup · 04/11/2023 20:34

RMNofTikTok · 04/11/2023 19:46

YANBU.

If mothers decided they suddenly couldn't afford to feed and clothe their children, we'd be charged with child neglect. It's not unreasonable to expect parents to pay a healthy amount for children they have PR for.

It's also not a race to the bottom! Just because someone receives less, or nothing, doesn't mean you should be grateful!

I'd be questioning why his income has dropped by almost half to be honest, if his income doesn't match his lifestyle I'd be asking FIU to have a look at it.

No, they wouldn't. They can collect benefits and get government support with childcare and housing and food vouchers. You are very naive if you think that all women earn the money to provide all needs for their children. There are many mothers who contributed far less than £580 of their own earned cash each month to their children.

Chichimcgee · 04/11/2023 20:31

It’s your choice to pay out for nursery and live the way you’re living though.
you seem very bitter and resentful of your friend being when at the end of the day you get the equivalent of some people’s complete take home pay on top of benefits and money from working etc

Beckafett · 04/11/2023 20:31

People do not have a clue what it's like to be a single parent with no emotional, physical or financial support.
I wouldn't end the friendship but I'd have to say why I was so annoyed.

Differentstarts · 04/11/2023 20:29

Never talk about money, do you moan about money problems a lot to your friend, one of my friends use to always moan about how hard up they where and their financial struggles to the point I would pay for drinks or food out ect it then came out they where bringing in more then triple what me and my partner where and that they where just bad with money.