Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Caused a major fallout with inlaws

387 replies

WomanManChildDogCat · 03/11/2023 23:59

Buckle up, it’s a long one…
Every year DH and I host his parents for Christmas Day. We have done for 10+ yrs. Sometimes BIL has also come but not since he got with his partner 4yrs ago (SIL). This year BIL and SIL offered to host PIL for Christmas. Great, no problem. In fact I wanted to go to my parents in another country so works out perfectly.
They are also hosting their adult daughter and her partner and SIL’s parents.
BIL and SIL usually come to us for a weekend in November or December. We all live hours apart so don’t see much of each other through the year.
So this year, we were invited to go to theirs for a weekend, last weekend.
We went and had a lovely weekend. Mostly.
On arrival I noted that they had changed their bathroom since we were last there a few months ago. They explained that they had had drainage problems so had moved the toilet and outlet pipe. I asked had that sorted the problem and SIL said “Yes we hope so. The smell was dreadful so unless we’ve just gotten used to it, we think the problem is sorted”.
They have one bathroom and a separate toilet downstairs. Our room was next to the bathroom upstairs and on the first night we noticed an awful smell. The bathroom stank, like really public urinals stank. When I went to the toilet I held my breath, it was disgusting. There was no air freshener and no mention from BIL or SIL about the smell.
I said to DH that we should say something, let them know as they must be noseblind to it. He said absolutely not, do not mention it.
Anyway the smell remained and it was so gross that even having a shower in the same room did not dispel it.
On the second night, we were all a bit tipsy and while DH and BIL were in the garden with the dog I said to SIL, really kindly, that I thought maybe their pipes still needed looking at as there was a bit of a whiff in the bathroom. I thought if it was me I’d want to know, especially if I was hosting guests soon. She took it well, seemed a bit surprised and said they would get the plumbers back. She thanked me for mentioning it. We enjoyed the rest of the evening and the next morning went out for a lovely breakfast all together and then we left with lovely goodbyes and see you soons.
We had not even got home when SIL posted on the family Christmas WhatsApp chat “Well, we’re no longer hosting Christmas as apparently our house stinks of piss. Perhaps Womanman will host in their perfect house”.
I was gobsmacked. DH was livid “ I asked you not to say anything”. Before I could respond I was removed from the group chat and SIL not answering my calls. I have messaged to apologise for any offence caused etc but no response.
DH family are furious. They love a bit of drama but I honestly did not think SIL was like that.
Now there is a whole WhatsApp drama going on and I can’t believe I am the cause - I am so not confrontational, I hate it.
I don’t really know what to do.
DH wants nothing to do with it and just keeps saying “I told you not to mention it”.

OP posts:
willWillSmithsmith · 04/11/2023 07:50

Mikimoto · 04/11/2023 07:36

I think it's a combo:
-maybe tipsy OP wasn't SO subtle (even in jest)
-it's a mega-sensitive soft-spot for SIL anyway
-SIL didn't really want to host Xmas.

The whole Xmas thing is between them anyway, so have a fab time in Ireland!

Why does it have to be subtle? She’s not telling them she doesn’t like their decor or their dress sense or their cooking. A problem with bathroom plumbing is not a ‘needs to be treated sensitively’ situation in my eyes.

5YearsLeft · 04/11/2023 07:49

Also OP, I’m sorry. I posted to help sort out the issue of people complaining about paragraphs, but didn’t actually say anything about your dilemma, which is quite rude of me.

One poster said, “I hope the plane tickets are booked for Ireland!” And I agree with them completely. Once someone deleted you from the WhatsApp (and how childish is that), it was no longer your problem. They decided that the answer to the entire “problem” of being upset at you was: throw a conversational bomb in the middle of the WhatsApp trying to make you look awful, and then block/remove you before you could defend or explain or communicate or apologize.

They have shown they care more about drama than they care about you.

Which I imagine hurts a bit, BUT they’ve made their choice. I hope you make the absolute best choice for yourself (Ireland! Family!) without regards to them.

willWillSmithsmith · 04/11/2023 07:48

Too much sensitivity going on in that family.

The bathroom had a pre existing issue so mentioning the fact the fix hadn’t worked is perfectly ok. Why does it have to be done so sensitively and politely anyway, it’s not a personal attack it’s an observation that the bathroom still smells. If my sil told me the fix hadn’t worked (even if she’d said bluntly your bathroom still stinks) I can imagine I might be annoyed at the plumber but not my sil. All very strange dynamics going on there.

Mikimoto · 04/11/2023 07:36

I think it's a combo:
-maybe tipsy OP wasn't SO subtle (even in jest)
-it's a mega-sensitive soft-spot for SIL anyway
-SIL didn't really want to host Xmas.

The whole Xmas thing is between them anyway, so have a fab time in Ireland!

Mouse82 · 04/11/2023 07:33

GabriellaMontez · 04/11/2023 06:50

You didn't cause this. You mentioned the issue as politely as possible. Your sil caused a shit storm and pil wafted the flames.

You're not guilty here.

Enjoy your Christmas.

She was tipsy, so did she really approach it as politely as she thought, or did she actually go balls dip bravado style from the drink.

Zonder · 04/11/2023 07:33

Perhaps it appears differently on different devices. This is what I see - clear paragraphs which I've marked with a blue dot.

Caused a major fallout with inlaws
willWillSmithsmith · 04/11/2023 07:32

Your DH must be used to walking on eggshells around his family if he thought mentioning the smell was taboo. If that had been my family I’d have said “hey just so you’re aware (re possible nose blindness) your bathroom still smells pretty bad, I don’t think the plumbing fix has worked”. And my family would have said the same to me. I fail to see why anyone would be offended by a family member saying such a thing.

stormpitchchrome · 04/11/2023 07:29

I think it was a bit of an overreaction from SIL but you shouldn’t have said anything. If the smell is that bad she would know and probably feeling a bit sensitive about it. We used to have an old cat who pee’d everywhere and despite all the cleaning products in the world the house used to slightly smell of cat pee. I hated it and would have been mortified if anyone had pointed it out too. Your DH asked you not to but you went ahead anyway.

Purplecatshopaholic · 04/11/2023 07:26

Jeezo, what a bunch of drama llamas. His family are in a strop over a smelly bathroom? (That of course you should have mentioned - they need to get it sorted, it’s just a minor plumbing issue not a drama!) Not your circus…

WonderingWanda · 04/11/2023 07:23

I've not read all the comments so apologies if this has already been said but your sil comment about your perfect house smacks of jealousy / insecurity. Her ridiculous dramatic overreaction also suggests quite defensive personality which can also insecurity. I have a family member like this they always go 0 - 60 and project onto other people....I feel bad about myself so I'm going to tear someone else down to make myself feel better. Leave her to it op, it wasn't a bit deal. If someone said what you did to me I'd be a bit mortified and apologetic but that's it. She's got some 'issues' I would say!

wyse · 04/11/2023 07:15

What a beautiful thread. Lovely grammar and well set out. An English teacher's dream.

Lastchancechica · 04/11/2023 07:15

drhf · 04/11/2023 07:05

Best thread in a long time! Well done team, especially the paragraph police…

I’m going to buck the trend, because actually I sympathise with your sister in law here. A urine smell doesn’t suggest a drain problem (that would smell of sewage), it suggests a man with poor aim or (dare I say it) a peeing in the shower problem. Either is highly embarrassing, and I doubt your sister in law is personally responsible.

Of course she should be mature enough to hear your honest information without getting upset, but planning for Christmas does bring out the worst in everyone and she was probably trying very hard to give you all a lovely time, plus it is exhausting trying to run down an apparently insoluble household problem (and if the smell is caused by her husband peeing in the shower then she may be blinded to the cause).

Give her ring, tell her she was a fantastic host and say you were tipsy and that you’re really sorry. Life is much, much too short. (But if the smell is so bad then don’t work too hard to get reinvited for Christmas!)

Yes, you’re not being unreasonable, and many people would want you to speak up, but so what? Do you want to be right, or do you want your family to enjoy these precious years together while they can?

Don’t be that people pleasing doormat op.

Headsett · 04/11/2023 07:10

JudgeJ · 04/11/2023 06:43

She did everything wrong, you don't make that sort of comment in another person's home, being drunk is no excuse. There may have been some over-reaction but she started the problem.

I don't think it's outrageous, they'd mentioned they'd had plumbing done so it wasn't completely random- I'd want to know if my bathroom stank (beyond obviously normal bathroom smells) if I'd had issues with drainage; not everyone is a delicate flower who can't accept comments that aren't even personal criticisms.

OP I'd just leave it to blow over and be firm that you're still going to see your family. What a load of drama over a perfectly reasonable comment, your DH sounds a bit pathetic in this situation too- he can sort his family out if he isn't willing to stick up for you.

drhf · 04/11/2023 07:05

Best thread in a long time! Well done team, especially the paragraph police…

I’m going to buck the trend, because actually I sympathise with your sister in law here. A urine smell doesn’t suggest a drain problem (that would smell of sewage), it suggests a man with poor aim or (dare I say it) a peeing in the shower problem. Either is highly embarrassing, and I doubt your sister in law is personally responsible.

Of course she should be mature enough to hear your honest information without getting upset, but planning for Christmas does bring out the worst in everyone and she was probably trying very hard to give you all a lovely time, plus it is exhausting trying to run down an apparently insoluble household problem (and if the smell is caused by her husband peeing in the shower then she may be blinded to the cause).

Give her ring, tell her she was a fantastic host and say you were tipsy and that you’re really sorry. Life is much, much too short. (But if the smell is so bad then don’t work too hard to get reinvited for Christmas!)

Yes, you’re not being unreasonable, and many people would want you to speak up, but so what? Do you want to be right, or do you want your family to enjoy these precious years together while they can?

Vettrianofan · 04/11/2023 07:05

Enjoy Christmas with your own family 🙌

Wonderfulz · 04/11/2023 07:04

I’m just thinking how I would feel if someone close mentioned that my newly done loo smelt. I’d be concerned about sorting the smell and would take steps to investigate it. Any embarrassment would be fleeting and gone in two minutes. I certainly wouldn’t start a ridiculous family drama.

Lastchancechica · 04/11/2023 07:03

I hope the flights are booked to Ireland!

You have done absolutely nothing wrong. Your sil is using this as an excuse to get out of hosting. Just ignore her/then.

In this scenario my dh would post ‘have a great Christmas folks’ and remove himself from the WhatsApp group in solidarity. To remove you was a disgraceful overreaction on their part, but at least it saved you reading the PA posts that would have followed.

Your in laws will come round - it’s in their interests to come crawling back. Don’t apologise, don’t back down and remain completely silent on the issue. I would have done the same as you and informed her - who wouldn’t?! Your sil created this, she can fix it.

Enjoy your Christmas with your folks op.

farnworth · 04/11/2023 07:01

I hate causing offence and think I can sometimes err on the side of being overly polite, but I would have commented on the continuing smell. They needed to know as there is clearly some problem that needs fixing or investigating. (Just keep calmly telling your DH this if he continues his bleat of how he told you not to say anything.) A considerate guest would let them know this, so you did nothing wrong. Ignored plumbing problems do not go away - they can quickly become far more serious too.

The reaction of your SIL and the rest of the family is very bizarre and very OTT, and looks like they are spoiling for a fight. Just ignore them. Your husband says he wants nothing to do with it, fine. That should be your reaction too. Don’t be upset. It’s them, not you. If there is what’s app drama, so be it. If your DH mentions this, shrug and say how very oddly they are behaving and that you aren’t interested in this silly drama.
As an aside, for some reason, your DH perhaps seems to want to blank out how oddly / aggressively they are behaving. If you feel able to, ask him why.

You have been an amazing DIL hosting Christmas for ten years. If needed, remind your husband of this. He should appreciate all you have done.
Enjoy the time with YOUR family this Christmas and don’t feel any guilt. You have done more than enough. Your family should matter as much as his.
Going forward, think carefully about your own wants and needs, including at future Christmases. Don’t cave into doing what your DH or his family want - you have seen now how they don’t deserve it!

Namechange4234 · 04/11/2023 07:00

Myfabby · 04/11/2023 00:19

Your DH told you to leave it., but no, you conviently told her when he wasn't there under the guise of being slightly tipsy. If your DH didn't feel comfy telling his brother, you overstepped massively.

Yes they are overacting but you set yourself up for this.

I agree with this

For someone who doesn't like confrontation.......

Wonderfulz · 04/11/2023 06:56

Who removed you from the WhatsApp group

Wonderfulz · 04/11/2023 06:55

Your SIL and ILs are being utterly ridiculous. Let them crack on with their stupid drama. I recon SIL was looking for an excuse to get out of having ILs for Xmas. Continue with your own plans to visit Ireland, ignore all the drama lamas.

MayThe4th · 04/11/2023 06:55

It’s ironic really, the people bleating on about paragraphs, instead of looking clever, are actually coming across as rather thick.

GabriellaMontez · 04/11/2023 06:50

You didn't cause this. You mentioned the issue as politely as possible. Your sil caused a shit storm and pil wafted the flames.

You're not guilty here.

Enjoy your Christmas.

Iwantmyoldnameback · 04/11/2023 06:49

As a fellow drinker (so no judgement there)) I wonder if you were quite as tactful as you think.
On the other hand they will definitely be nose blind and should be grateful as it's hardly a healthy situation is it?

Ramalangadingdong · 04/11/2023 06:48

Your husband said not to say anything for a reason and you know it. Now you are being disingenuous. Do you have form for this kind of thing?

Swipe left for the next trending thread