Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Am I unreasonable?

109 replies

Floating101 · 03/11/2023 23:22

Had dinner out with a friend this evening. Partner offered to give me a lift into town and pick me up afterwards. About 25 minute drive. I left my friend and hadn’t yet messaged partner to ask to be picked up, had to walk right past the bus stop where bus was just pulling in that comes directly past the house. I got on the bus, messaged my partner to say don’t worry about picking me up, bus is right here.

Partner now in a mood, could have had a drink, could have had a bath etc etc. I didn’t know bus was going to be there! Should I really have waited in the cold for 25 minutes rather than just get on the bus? I thought they’d be happy about not having to come out in the cold!
Once again not speaking 😩

OP posts:
JustGotToKeepOnKeepingOn · 04/11/2023 12:12

You're not being unreasonable at all OP! You did the right thing. He sounds like a complete moody arse. You've saved him the best part of an hour of driving!

He couldn't have a bath? Ridiculous. He couldn't have a drink? He could have put the phone down and opened a bottle of wine so you could both have a nightcap when you got home. Instead he's sitting sending nasty texts, ruining your night. How often does he ruin your nights out?

He sounds mean and controlling. The bus is the least of your problems.

margotrose · 04/11/2023 11:59

If it’s honestly such a big deal to forego a drink and a bath then why not say so at the outset of the evening and the other person can plan to get the bus regardless? Why offer and then have a ridiculous sulk because things happened to work out differently?

Because (as has been said multiple times), I don't mind forgoing a bath or a drink to help someone out, but I do mind forgoing those things only to be told (at the last minute) that I'm not actually needed after all.

IMO if someone is kind enough to offer you a lift, the least you can do is respect their time and not mess them around by cancelling at the last minute.

margotrose · 04/11/2023 11:56

I wonder if there's a divide between people who find it easy to relax regardless, and those who feel on edge if they know they're going to have do something in an hour or so.

Personally, I hate waiting around to do something or to go to an appointment. I find it really hard to relax and would rather have the appointment first thing or straight after work, so I don't have a random amount of "dead time" where you're just waiting around.

BogHag · 04/11/2023 11:56

margotrose · 04/11/2023 11:32

I just think there's a difference between forgoing something for a reason, and forgoing something only to be told "well, I'll get a lift you didn't need to sit in and wait around for me after all".

It's just a shitty attitude, really. Like the DP can just sit around and wait for her call, but OP can change her mind last minute regardless.

But how could it possibly have helped the situation for her to insist her partner come and get her regardless? Would it have made things better for him in any way to have to come and get her when she could, as a matter of chance / coincidence have got the bus?

If it’s honestly such a big deal to forego a drink and a bath then why not say so at the outset of the evening and the other person can plan to get the bus regardless? Why offer and then have a ridiculous sulk because things happened to work out differently?

You're either happy to do the favour or you’re not. If you’re not, don’t do it and make a different plan. If you are, don’t be a dick because at the last minute something happens to change the plan in a way which makes it less of a hassle for you.

ChocolateCakeOverspill · 04/11/2023 11:53

YesThatsATurdOnTheRug · 04/11/2023 11:40

But @Ameanstreakamilewide he shouldn't have offered if he wasn't ok to do that, especially as OP could get a bus. He has a responsibility not to offer something that will make him feel angry at her, she wasn't to know he'd resent doing something he'd offered. She thought she was saving him a trip, it makes no difference to what he'd done all evening anyway. If she'd seen the bus and thought, no I'll not get on it I'll wait 30 mins in the cold for DH he still would have not had his bath etc (his own choices) and the.man would have come out and driven for 50 mins. He's being illogical.

Flipping eck! It’s not the giving the lift which is the issue, it’s the waiting all night only to be told as the last minute that your services aren’t required. It’s incredibly selfish to do that to someone unless you phone them first and say ‘looks like I can get a bus if that would be easier for you’

I’m not sure why people are conflating the two things.

ButWhatAboutTheBees · 04/11/2023 11:48

TedMullins · 04/11/2023 11:09

You can do all of those things while you wait though. Have a bath, put PJs on, get in bed, then when they call chuck a coat on over your pyjamas and nip out. It seems very inflexible to be sat fully dressed on alert all evening or be so stressed by a change of plan

Until they call when you're in the bath and you have to rush
And MN is pretty clear people in PJs shouldn't go outside
And you get in bed, get warm and comfy and then have to get out again... not what most people would do at all

You CAN'T relax properly if you are waiting for someone to call because yes, you are on alert

burnoutbabe · 04/11/2023 11:46

YesThatsATurdOnTheRug · 04/11/2023 11:40

But @Ameanstreakamilewide he shouldn't have offered if he wasn't ok to do that, especially as OP could get a bus. He has a responsibility not to offer something that will make him feel angry at her, she wasn't to know he'd resent doing something he'd offered. She thought she was saving him a trip, it makes no difference to what he'd done all evening anyway. If she'd seen the bus and thought, no I'll not get on it I'll wait 30 mins in the cold for DH he still would have not had his bath etc (his own choices) and the.man would have come out and driven for 50 mins. He's being illogical.

Exactly

Would he have got equally angry if say friends partner offered both a lift home at last minute? Would he have expected her to say no -I shall wait here in the cold for partner and drag him out on cold night?

Bonkers he is annoyed about it!
Only "wrong thing" is not having checked busses in advance to know one would bring you home and then trying to aim to be at bus stop for that time. (Unless only 1every 2 hours)

YesThatsATurdOnTheRug · 04/11/2023 11:40

But @Ameanstreakamilewide he shouldn't have offered if he wasn't ok to do that, especially as OP could get a bus. He has a responsibility not to offer something that will make him feel angry at her, she wasn't to know he'd resent doing something he'd offered. She thought she was saving him a trip, it makes no difference to what he'd done all evening anyway. If she'd seen the bus and thought, no I'll not get on it I'll wait 30 mins in the cold for DH he still would have not had his bath etc (his own choices) and the.man would have come out and driven for 50 mins. He's being illogical.

margotrose · 04/11/2023 11:32

BogHag · 04/11/2023 11:26

I think if these things are so important to a person that foregoing them for the sake of occasionally doing a nice thing for their partner turns them into a grumpy arsehole then it’s better to simply not offer the favour at all.

I just think there's a difference between forgoing something for a reason, and forgoing something only to be told "well, I'll get a lift you didn't need to sit in and wait around for me after all".

It's just a shitty attitude, really. Like the DP can just sit around and wait for her call, but OP can change her mind last minute regardless.

BogHag · 04/11/2023 11:26

margotrose · 04/11/2023 11:17

You can do all of those things while you wait though. Have a bath, put PJs on, get in bed, then when they call chuck a coat on over your pyjamas and nip out. It seems very inflexible to be sat fully dressed on alert all evening or be so stressed by a change of plan

It's not about "sitting fully dressed on alert all evening".

It's about knowing that you're going to get a phone call at some point, so you need to stay awake and be "ready" to go out and collect them at any point in the evening.

Yes, I could (and would) just chuck a coat on over my pyjamas, but I wouldn't be able to curl up and relax in bed (and perhaps doze off), or have a nice long bath, because I'd know I'd have to go back out again at some random time.

I think if these things are so important to a person that foregoing them for the sake of occasionally doing a nice thing for their partner turns them into a grumpy arsehole then it’s better to simply not offer the favour at all.

margotrose · 04/11/2023 11:17

You can do all of those things while you wait though. Have a bath, put PJs on, get in bed, then when they call chuck a coat on over your pyjamas and nip out. It seems very inflexible to be sat fully dressed on alert all evening or be so stressed by a change of plan

It's not about "sitting fully dressed on alert all evening".

It's about knowing that you're going to get a phone call at some point, so you need to stay awake and be "ready" to go out and collect them at any point in the evening.

Yes, I could (and would) just chuck a coat on over my pyjamas, but I wouldn't be able to curl up and relax in bed (and perhaps doze off), or have a nice long bath, because I'd know I'd have to go back out again at some random time.

GrumpyOldCrone · 04/11/2023 11:15

I agree about not fully relaxing. But I get to relax almost an hour earlier if my partner unexpectedly gets the bus and I don’t need to go out after all. I’d be quite pleased about that.

Ameanstreakamilewide · 04/11/2023 11:12

YesThatsATurdOnTheRug · 04/11/2023 11:10

I honestly cannot understand half these posts. Why couldn't he have a bath?!? Why couldn't he get in his PJs watch a movie etc, just carry on as normal til you get the call!! If you're going to be aggy about wasting your evening just don't bother offering, whether or not she got the bus is totally irrelevant. If you're not doing those things with good grace just don't do them!

you have a responsibility for your own happiness, if he is choosing to be a martyr that's his choice, he could easily have enjoyed his evening while waiting, or just not offered the lift.

Probably because he wouldn't be able to truly relax.
I know I wouldn't.
I'd be clock watching too.

TattyOne · 04/11/2023 11:12

With the amount of attacks on lone women, it's better you got the bus rather than wait. He's being a dingbat with his childish behavior!

YesThatsATurdOnTheRug · 04/11/2023 11:10

I honestly cannot understand half these posts. Why couldn't he have a bath?!? Why couldn't he get in his PJs watch a movie etc, just carry on as normal til you get the call!! If you're going to be aggy about wasting your evening just don't bother offering, whether or not she got the bus is totally irrelevant. If you're not doing those things with good grace just don't do them!

you have a responsibility for your own happiness, if he is choosing to be a martyr that's his choice, he could easily have enjoyed his evening while waiting, or just not offered the lift.

TedMullins · 04/11/2023 11:09

margotrose · 04/11/2023 10:48

Why couldn’t he have chilled and got comfy at home while he waited?

Because he knew he'd have to get ready and go back out in the cold/dark/rain to collect her.

If I knew DH was going to call me at some point to collect him, I wouldn't be able to fully chill out as I'd be constantly waiting for my phone to ring. If he'd told me he was making his own way home, I'd be able to get changed, maybe have a bath or go to bed early knowing I wouldn't be disturbed and made to go back out.

You can do all of those things while you wait though. Have a bath, put PJs on, get in bed, then when they call chuck a coat on over your pyjamas and nip out. It seems very inflexible to be sat fully dressed on alert all evening or be so stressed by a change of plan

BogHag · 04/11/2023 11:03

This is an extreme level of pettiness from him. Nice, normal, good natured people simply don’t get sulky over things like this.

He had agreed to pick you up. At that point he had foregone the option of having a drink etc. That wasn’t on the table any more. If, in fact, he did still want to do those things then he shouldn’t have offered.

The bus arriving when it did was convenient and not predicted by you. Nothing you could have done at that point would have given him back the chance to have a drink. All you could do was make BOTH YOUR LIVES more convenient by getting yourself home quicker and saving him from coming out in the cold.

He’s being a grumpy arse and I’m baffled by the people criticising you for doing a sensible and practical thing that saved both you and him trouble.

GrumpyOldCrone · 04/11/2023 10:58

This wouldn’t annoy me if I were the partner. I’d be glad I didn’t have to go out after all. My partner almost never gets the bus so I wouldn’t expect it to have occurred to him in advance. I can also understand the thing about not texting from the restaurant if you knew you had a bit of a walk to the pick up point. But even if your partner was annoyed, not speaking to you is a massive overreaction.

margotrose · 04/11/2023 10:48

Why couldn’t he have chilled and got comfy at home while he waited?

Because he knew he'd have to get ready and go back out in the cold/dark/rain to collect her.

If I knew DH was going to call me at some point to collect him, I wouldn't be able to fully chill out as I'd be constantly waiting for my phone to ring. If he'd told me he was making his own way home, I'd be able to get changed, maybe have a bath or go to bed early knowing I wouldn't be disturbed and made to go back out.

Floating101 · 04/11/2023 10:41

Sirzy · 04/11/2023 10:37

But what many really don’t get is why you hadn’t sorted being picked up way before the bus being an option at all? It just doesn’t make sense

In hindsight I see that would have been the ideal. I don’t know really - chatting a lot with my friend, a couple of gins, didn’t really occur at the time. I can see that was definitely my mistake here.

OP posts:
windypumpkin · 04/11/2023 10:40

Floating101 · 04/11/2023 09:18

Thanks for all the replies.
So I wouldn’t have been picked up directly outside the restaurant - city centre so not easy to drive in. I needed to walk around 10 mins to where I was dropped off to be picked up. Said bye to friend, had phone out to text, then see the bus stop ahead of me that I have to walk right past that has lots of people waiting. Get to bus stop and bus is coming in 2 mins - text DP and say bus is about to come I might as well get on it. It arrives, I get on, then I get texts saying how irritating it is, couldn’t drink, couldn’t have a bath etc, etc. I said sorry, that I’d just been lucky with timing - they are not that frequent. But then still further texts about how annoying it is. I honestly thought it would have been a relief not to have to come out and get me.

Next time get the bus?

10HailMarys · 04/11/2023 10:40

If you are ‘once again’ not speaking over something this trivial, this relationship sounds deeply dysfunctional.

windypumpkin · 04/11/2023 10:39

ButWhatAboutTheBees · 04/11/2023 10:18

But the bus was clearly an option she was WILLING to take
So she could have said "thanks for dropping me off. I've checked bus times and there's one that I should be able to catch home."
DP might still have decided not to drunk etc in case of a change of plans but it wouldn't be the same.

Exactly! If the bus was an option she felt OK with why bother getting DH to wait up

Sirzy · 04/11/2023 10:37

But what many really don’t get is why you hadn’t sorted being picked up way before the bus being an option at all? It just doesn’t make sense

ChocolateCakeOverspill · 04/11/2023 10:35

TheOneWhereWeDontGiveAPhuck · 04/11/2023 09:36

The replies on this post are just bonkers to me. It's literally saved him a job, yes he waited, he was waiting anyway. People are mad.

That’s a really selfish attitude