Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To priest or not to priest? Reception school help!!!

63 replies

Rainbowflashlight · 03/11/2023 22:51

Our DS is due to start reception in 2024.

We are orthodox Christians with strong Christian values, not originally from the Uk, we want our daughter to go to our local Church of England school.

We go to the church as and when though… and the churches we go to are all Orthodox, we are not committed to a specific one.

Would it be appropriate to go to the specific Church of England church that the school is affiliated with and ask the priest to sign the supplementary form? It will be the passport for our DS to go to this school.

We are also relatively new to the area and I haven’t seen this priest ever before in my life…. And it feels weird!

AIBU - Don’t do it, you will annoy the priest
YANBU - Go for it, the priest will understand and help

OP posts:
CurlewKate · 04/11/2023 19:48

Well, at least you're not pretending you're doing it for anything but the school place. A bit icky, but not actually dishonest.

If it's oversubscribed you may need a CofE baptism certificate. And regular attendance.

SoShallINever · 04/11/2023 19:48

Oh OP, come on, you are basically asking how you can get your child into an oversubscribed school ahead of others. You don't go to Church and you probably won't go even if your DC get a place. Just do the right thing and send them to a non faith school, you can still do the God things at home.

StarlightLime · 04/11/2023 19:44

The priest is literally confirming your attendance at his church, op.
You can't just rock up anywhere as a complete unknown who hasn't actually attended the church at all.

Gifgirl · 04/11/2023 19:42

OP, I work for the CofE. I'm afraid to say that we wouldn't be signing forms for people that we don't know.

Schools want to know that you are regular attendees of church. The forms will ask the vicar to clarify that you attend regularly as a family, and for how long. No minister is going to be able to fill that form in for you unless you have been going regularly and for quite some time.

NannyR · 04/11/2023 19:28

Rainbowflashlight · 04/11/2023 13:04

We are Christians and believers, but it’s hard to be a practicing Orthodox Christian in the Uk if you leave in a relatively remote location…

I don't know much about Orthodox Christianity, but if you consider yourselves practicing Christians, is regularly attending another, more local, denomination church a complete no-no? I think the Roman Catholic Church is more closely aligned with Orthodox than Church of England.
As a Christian myself, I'm struggling to understand the mindset of attending no church at all being a better option than attending one of a different denomination.

Callmemummynotmaaa · 04/11/2023 14:07

I hear this! I’d 2 under 2 (now 3 under 4) and work in healthcare (so in our home we shift work/work weekends. The max ever home on weekend days is one parent to 3 kids and we live an ocean/plane away from family). So church attendance even bi-weekly would never have been feasible. Sadly…our faith based options were very quick to tell us, that they understood and didn’t like the system themselves but that putting strict limits in place was their way of safeguarding it/respecting attendance. Hope they are nice(r) tomorrow for you! Seems to be very location dependent.

Friends that have met criteria, have sacrificed a lot to do so (to be fair to them). Ie. Spending 2-4 hours of their only family day together at church based activities. Missing kids party’s. Unable to travel frequently to visit family if a train away. Etc etc.

Rainbowflashlight · 04/11/2023 13:07

Tomorrow we will go to the Orthodox Church (starts at 10.30am) with the form and we will try our luck… Baby will have to have his lunch in the church during the service at 11.30am and then he will have to nap in the pram just for 30’ and ultimately miss his 2hour lunch nap.

It would have been unreasonable to do this every Sunday!

OP posts:
Rainbowflashlight · 04/11/2023 13:04

We are Christians and believers, but it’s hard to be a practicing Orthodox Christian in the Uk if you leave in a relatively remote location…

OP posts:
Rainbowflashlight · 04/11/2023 13:03

@Callmemummynotmaaa Thank you!

To be honest we used to have an amazing non-church school near us that also was outstanding. Last year the head changed and new ofsted report graded it as good.

Thats why I was not bothered with specific church attendance, although we used to go to the church both in my home country and also in the Uk when that was feasible given the new baby etc. (as the closest Orthodox Church is not local and it’s a proper logistical challenge with naps/feeds)

OP posts:
Callmemummynotmaaa · 04/11/2023 12:59

OP. I can’t answer in relation to orthodox priest preference, but, our local catholic school and CoE schools are very clear on the importance of attendance. Both are oversubscribed. Families attending church have to get specific attendance booklets signed weekly, and these have to be brought to each parish office on two particular dates to be inspected in order for the priest or pastor to sign the forms needed for school.

Some leniency would be shown if you had your previous priest documents showing weekly attendance, but only if you could document living there at the same time. If living locally, it’s local attendance that counts. Limited to no leniency is shown for expanding families (those with newborns would be told they are welcome to attend) or those with additional needs.

It causes controversy here. It seems from the threads that the only way to find out for your school, is to ask. Perhaps both the Orthadox priest of the church you are most easily recognized? And the local COE priest? (But be prepared that without frequent attendance they may say no).

Rainbowflashlight · 04/11/2023 12:59

@NeverDropYourMooncup Thank you, this gives me hope…!

We will go to our closest Orthodox Church and we will speak to the priest after the service…

Please wish us luck!

OP posts:
NeverDropYourMooncup · 04/11/2023 12:38

Rainbowflashlight · 04/11/2023 12:14

@Backtomyoldname I believe an Orthodox priest would prefer the kid to attend a non-churchy school, as there are no Orthodox Church schools, in fear that he may be tought something that is not in line with Orthodox principles.

He would also advice to visit ideally on a weekly basis an Orthodox Church (…even if the closest one is 45min driving and we also have a baby to look after…) in order to raise the kids with the “correct” values, principles etc.

They're generally in favour of attending a Faith School. If they weren't I wouldn't have spent years handling documentation completed by Orthodox (Easter, Oriental, Russian, Greek, Romanian, etc, etc) Priests, Baptist, Pentecostal, Seventh Day Adventist, etc, etc, Marthoma, and all other faiths and denominations for a Faith school.

Rainbowflashlight · 04/11/2023 12:14

@Backtomyoldname I believe an Orthodox priest would prefer the kid to attend a non-churchy school, as there are no Orthodox Church schools, in fear that he may be tought something that is not in line with Orthodox principles.

He would also advice to visit ideally on a weekly basis an Orthodox Church (…even if the closest one is 45min driving and we also have a baby to look after…) in order to raise the kids with the “correct” values, principles etc.

OP posts:
Backtomyoldname · 03/11/2023 23:54

You need to go to both the school and Parish Priest to ask these questions.

Generally if Church membership/attendance is required there may be a register to quantify your attendance. Not ideal or always fair but that’s how it is - often after disappointed parents have gone legal. Its hard to argue with a register.

You also need to study the entrance criteria. These kick in once the class over subscribed.

The majority of the answers here are correct - but may not apply to the school that you are asking about.

Some schools may recognise foreign denominations, some ‘Churches Together’, some just their own.

Do this sooner than later.

A question….. You wrote that Orthodox Priests are very strict and do not favour Orthodox children attending C of E schools. Orthodox schools are few and far between. What do they propose?

Schoolchoicesucks · 03/11/2023 23:37

If I start now attending the church , 2.5 months of attendance on a weekly basis, will it be enough for him to sign the “fortnight” for 2 years

No of course not. But there may be an option for the overseas priest to sign that you attended overseas regularly for 21 months and then that you've attended linked church for the 2.5 months. You would likely fall in category of other churchgoers rather than linked churchgoers though. And if you hadn't attended the overseas church for the 21 months all depends how willing your priest would be, which you seem to suggest isn't very!

cabbageking · 03/11/2023 23:34

We accept evidence of all faiths. But if you say you have attended elsewhere before moving home or for other reasons we would expect some evidence from that or those churches. We also have letters of faith along with supplementary forms where different faith leaders have put some evidence to paper.

The person you are asking to sign should sign what they know to be true and if there is no evidence of attendance elsewhere they should sign perhaps the "no evidence to support the statement" depending on the supplementary form which should be on the Council website. You need to check the criteria for each school.

Gather info from the various churches you have attended would be my advice.

Quitelikeacatslife · 03/11/2023 23:33

I work in c of e school, first (after looked after children etc) is SIF form signed by affiliated church then SIF form signed by other churches recognised by c of e. But all this only counts if in catchment and local vicar will absolutely not sign the form unless you attend every 2 weeks.
So you need to read the admissions policy for the school you want . It will be all spelled out

UsingChangeofName · 03/11/2023 23:27

If I start now attending the church , 2.5 months of attendance on a weekly basis, will it be enough for him to sign the “fortnight” for 2 years?

Well, of course (s)he can't / won't do that, but, if you are newly arrived, and were genuinely weekly Church goers in your home country, that might be taken into consideration.
You can but ask.

However, I think the fact you only attend Church on an ad hoc basis since you've been here, might go against you.

You can, of course bring your dc up in your own faith, without them going to a local CofE school.

Agadododoo · 03/11/2023 23:25

Can you contact the school and ask? How long ago did you live in Poland? Imho it seems fair enough that you attended when there was a church close to you, but don't so much now there isn't... Worth giving it a shot.

meditrina · 03/11/2023 23:25

Rainbowflashlight · 03/11/2023 23:18

Question: what if a non-British orthodox priest sign the form? What if it’s a form signed from a polish priest in a polish Orthodox Church in Poland?

would that add any value?

Check the criteria!

If they want evidence of fortnightly over 2 years, and that straddles the time when you moved to UK, then having a reference from the priest there that you had been attending at X frequency for Y number of years until (date of departure) may help.

But then you'll also need a second reference for the time since your arrival in UK

Multipleexclamationmarks · 03/11/2023 23:24

Meant to put that quote in bold not cross it out!

Multipleexclamationmarks · 03/11/2023 23:23

If I start now attending the church , 2.5 months of attendance on a weekly basis, will it be enough for him to sign the “fortnight” for 2 years? Omg…

Well that's asking him to lie so no he won't do that.
You could ask your Polish priest to do it but he can only say the church you attended there so that won't be recent if you are now in England.

Voteva · 03/11/2023 23:22

Go see the priest, explain the situation and ask his advice and if he is ok to sign the form. Be extremely clear that you have always been regular church goers but at a variety of churches over the years so are unsure who to ask. He’ll probably be happy to sign the form. If he isn’t well at least you tried.

sunflowerdaisyrose · 03/11/2023 23:21

At our church we have to sign in whenever we go to a service and they base it purely off that. Worth asking but they may well say no.

Rainbowflashlight · 03/11/2023 23:20

I am saying that because prior to our arrival in the Uk we attended on a weekly basis the church as there was a very local one around

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread