Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Are We BU for not "supporting" our friend?

264 replies

algreaves1987 · 03/11/2023 22:44

This is a scenario that myself and my husband were both witness to and it's now causing a huge problem! FYI we have all known each other since our teenage years so a long time.

A(she)+B(he)= married couple (together 17 years married 10)
C(She)+D(he)= Long-term partners (15 years!)
Us! (Married 12 years together for 15)

We are all in our late 30s if that helps.

We were out at a nice restaurant. Since COVID we haven't seen that much of each other so we all agreed to get a nice hotel overnight and go out for dinner and drinks at the halfway point (the furthest between us is about 3 hours). So we meet at the hotel have a chat then go and get ready. Everything is fine at this point. We meet in the lobby and A seems a little icy with B but not that awful, in my opinion. Please note that in my opinion, B can quite often be very rude (lacks social skills - not from any issues - just doesn't care how other people feel at times).

We get a cab and go to the restaurant. We get seated and B's phone goes off and he goes outside to talk to his parents. A is instantly pissed off. She makes comments like "Here we go again" "Why can't they leave him alone for 5 minutes" etc. It's awkward but my husband does an amazing job of turning it around and we are all laughing within a few minutes.

B comes back and A literally just ignores him. He tries to talk to her, but she won't engage. At this point this is more than just the phone call I think, something is clearly going on but I really don't want to get involved and my husband and I have been looking forward to this for a few weeks. We get drinks and order food. B started talking to me and my husband asking about work. A is currently working part-time (she was a full-time social worker and just couldn't hack it - we all agree personally that she's been much happier since she dropped her hours in half and her caseload). If it's relevant here both my husband and I work full time and have the most income - significantly. If you add the rest of their incomes together it doesn't come to half what we make and for some reason, this seems to really interest B - in fact, we discuss it nearly every time we see him!

He asks us about how we divide chores etc in the house - we have a cleaner so that helps but previously we just split things between us depending on who wanted to do what. He then asks me directly whether I help my husband's parents. I haven't spoken to my MIL for nearly 3 years due to the issues I have with her behavior. I don't air our private issues in public - I know my husband is upset that there is no relationship between myself and his family but he also knows that his family caused this so doesn't blame me. I don't want to talk about it as I don't want to rub it in his face. He then hypothetically asked me "If my MIL had, had surgery and couldn't get around and needed help and was very elderly would I consider helping her in the evenings?" Again to not rub things in my husband's face I said "That would depend on my availability - work and family considering". He asked me if I would be open to it and I said sure. At this point, the dinner arrives. We are chomping away and commenting on how delicious the dinner is when suddenly A just gets up and walks out. We are all dumbfounded except B. He carries on eating his dinner telling us to do the same because she is just doing it for "attention". At this point, I feel like all the questioning me about my in-laws has something to do with it.

I tried to call A multiple times. I called the hotel (about 20 minutes after she left) to ask if she had arrived etc but they wouldn't advise me. We finished our meal, had another drink and I said to my husband that I wanted to go back to the hotel because I was no longer comfortable. He agreed. B was fuming, telling us that "she does this all the time to spoil things" and "she'll be back in about an hour completely fine and pretend that she had some emergency". I wasn't buying it. A had gotten upset over the years with comments made (and she had made quite a few herself to others) but she hadn't just walked out and disappeared.

When we got back to the hotel we called other friends and people we knew who knew her to see if anyone had heard from her because B said she wasn't in the hotel room and she'd taken her bag. Their car was still in the car park though. B just went to bed. He wasn't interested in looking. At this point, we felt like there wasn't much we could do but wait so we stayed up watched a crappy movie, and called a couple more times but ultimately went to sleep. The following morning still nothing. B went back home. We got a frantic call from him just over 3 hours later to tell us that she'd been home and most of her things were gone. At this point, my husband just asks him plainly what's going on. He explains that his mother became ill about 10 weeks ago and needed help. His father was very old-fashioned and not coping that well. In their house B is the higher earner but works 12-hour shifts so helping wasn't an option (in his eyes at least). A had put up with a lot from MIL - she'd been rude, deliberately excluded her from Christmas, and took away special moments from her (they have a daughter). To be honest I am really lucky with my husband, he fully supports me but I don't think B supported A at all whilst this was happening. A told us that he kept pushing and telling her that she wasn't making the effort. In the last 4 years, he stopped forcing the relationship - or so we thought.

This happened 2 weeks ago. She removed herself from our WhatsApp group. She sent me and our other friend C a message stating that she was upset that none of us girls " stood up" for her when it was clear that B was referring to her not helping and that she needed some space. She blocked both of us after that.
C feels like A has a point because it was obvious that B was talking about A not helping with his mother (at the time not that obvious to me, but hey ho). C and I also know that 4 years ago A's father died (her mother died nearly 20 years ago) and she was working full-time. B told her they couldn't afford for her to go part-time so she could spend more time with her dad. B said that they had Debts to pay still (turns out very little Debt and B was just saving money for "stuff"). A worked full time and went around there most evenings but cut down because B was complaining that he was working long hours and it wasn't fair he was coming home to having to do all the child care so that A could go around there. She felt like he didn't want her to help her dad out. He died and A was distraught. B did apologise for his behaviour repeatedly but things were really rocky between them for about 8 months. Honestly, I thought she was going to leave him. Their daughter was 3 at this point.

So B's mum came out of the hospital and B wants A to go around and nurse her back to health now she is part-time. According to B A laughed in his face and told him she doesn't care if she dies - he'd finally understand then. He said he'd only brought it up a few times over the last 10 weeks - I'm guessing that isn't true because I know B. When he wants something he's like a bulldog. B knows A doesn't want to be anywhere near him and he hasn't seen his daughter for 2 weeks now. He's expecting a divorce proceedings to start.

Both me, my husband, and C feel like B is the AH here but D thinks that A had her chance to leave him 4 years ago and that she is deliberately doing this out of spite. I don't feel it's the same because MIL is apparently nowhere as ill as her dad was (although her dad didn't engage with GPs etc so none of us really knew how ill he really was until he died).

Really sorry for the long post but basically me and C are getting hateful messages on Facebook from her other friends telling us what scumbags we are and how we don't deserve to live and now I am feeling pretty low about it all. I want to talk to A but I can't.

Are we BU for not supporting her during the dinner? I have told B that until I get A's side of the story I am not taking sides at all, my husband agrees. We know A can also be a little hot-headed (but to be honest we think B is way over the line here)

OP posts:
Holidayhell22 · 04/11/2023 07:16

Intents=parents.

Holidayhell22 · 04/11/2023 07:16

Bloody hell it was obvious to me before I finished reading your post that B is a total cunt.
You so called friends did a number on A. You don’t even speak to your MIL yet you pretended that you would be Snow White. How on earth did you not know exactly what B was digging it? It’s obvious he was talking about A.
Hopefully she will be ok.
B needs to grow the fuck up. He needs to step up and sort his own intents out and what a vile man he is doing what he did to A regarding her parents.
I hope A has a good solicitor and goes on to lead a wonderful life without B in it.
All you can do is tell A you are there for her if she needs you.

Ramalangadingdong · 04/11/2023 07:06

I haven’t rtft because I don’t want to be influenced by others views. I haven’t voted because I can’t make my mind up. All I know is that I feel really sorry for A. The poor woman is still grieving the loss of her father and the fact that she wasn’t able to help nurse him in his final illness. People have no idea of the impact this can have on a sensitive human. I was lucky to be able to nurse my mum. Our relationship had not been perfect but doing so gave me closure and I had shown on myself how loving and kind I can be.

Poor A has a boorish husband and friends who are so wrapped up in themselves and their own achievements that they don’t see her suffering. No one came to her aid at the dinner. It sounds as though she does however have some friends who care about her, which is good.

Greenberg2 · 04/11/2023 06:58

GodDammitCecil · 04/11/2023 02:46

I read shit like this and think - WTF am I doing on MN, is this really a good use of anyone’s time?

Answer: no, it is not.

Not anyone's time. Just your time. >>>>>there's the door....

MN has helped tons of people leave awful relationships and even this post might alert people as to how to be more supportive of people in abusive situations. But you do you.

BettyPhuckzer · 04/11/2023 06:48

I agree with PPs that the very very best thing you can do is post every miniscule detail on a public forum

Because its way too difficult to work out (privately) what to do Hmm

KTSl1964 · 04/11/2023 06:42

Hope the child is ok and the relatiinship isn’t health and she’s done the right thing leaving. He sounds like a cruel bully.
leave them all to there drama and report to police if it continues.

Greenberg2 · 04/11/2023 06:41

Pumpkinspicelattetime · 03/11/2023 23:25

A's friends are out of line sending abusive messages to you. B is a complete dickhead for how he has been treating A for years. And, given you earn so much (which you were so keen to tell us about), I wonder how you are so socially inept you didn't realise what B was doing at the meal. I clued in after your first sentence about it. I wonder how many other times you've sided with the piece of shit bullying his wife.

This.

You appear absolutely clueless about what is going on in other people's lives and really rather smug. Has nothing bad ever happened in your life that you can't read the room (not wishing that on you but, really!)? Your comments about how much more you earn than everyone else, FGS!!!! It was so obvious how manipulative the DH was but he might have started knitting some red flags at the table and I don't think you would have noticed it.

D sounds like an AH too. He obviously doesn't have any empathy to realise how difficult it might be for someone who had just been bereaved and had a very young child to just walk out of a relationship with a clearly bullying and manipulative man.

It might on the face of it seem like overkill the way A's friends have been behaving but I wonder whether B's behaviour in other ways has been obvious for a very long time and you could have been supportive in the past (the stuff about A's father sounds pretty nasty).

I imagine it took extreme strength for A to leave B despite your snidey little comment about A not being able to hack a full-time job. If it were me and I'd been so tone deaf about a situation, I'd write A a letter with fullsome apologies for not seeing what had happened and wanting to support her going forward. But TBH I wouldn't blame her for not wanting to have anything more to do with any of you.

Viviennemary · 04/11/2023 06:34

This is far too involved. These people have things going on in their lives. I didn't get to the end. Just take a step back. But you do sound a bit smug with your own life and having more money than the others.

Goodnessmexxxx · 04/11/2023 06:28

Firstly I have no idea why you carried on the discussion about MIL with B when you knew what he was like. You should of asked why he was questioning you.

Secondly I am baffled why you even decided to brag about how much you earn. As a PP has stated if you earned so much you'd of clicked on what B was doing.

And thirdly, you're all so childish. You're older than me and not even I could be dealing with this primary school drama.

I do feel for A to some extent. But getting her friends to message you isn't on. But who's to say it's A getting them to message you? She might not even know they're messaging you things.

itsgettingweird · 04/11/2023 06:09

Another who could tell from your text B was asking pointed and loaded questions and getting at a RL situation.

Most of the rest of the text is irrelevant.

But the threats etc aren't on. I'd be reporting to police as cyber harassment / hate crime and moving on.

Hayliebells · 04/11/2023 06:08

Are you all friends from school, or friends from school and partners? If the latter, who is your friend from school, A or B? Given all the history with them, B is clearly a massive dick who has been awful to his wife. I'm not quite sure why you're not taking A's side on that, unless you have more allegiance with B as he's the friend from school? If A is the friend from school, what were you playing at? B was clearly having a massive dig at her and you didn't stick up for her. It's completely wrong for her friends to abuse you online though! If B rather than A is your friend from school I wouldn't be impressed with his behaviour at all, and probably tell him so. Being neutral when someone is clearly a massive bully is a bit of a cop out.

WandaWonder · 04/11/2023 06:04

Are any of these people adults? With grown up responsibilities? If this is their lives how do they have time if it is like this a lot

JaneAustensHeroine · 04/11/2023 05:52

B sounds awful. He was clearly digging for support during dinner. You could have been honest rather than wording your response in a way that suggests you would help your MIL. I don’t blame A for walking out. She feels betrayed.

If you can’t be authentic with friends then why have them? Someone needed to call B out on his behaviour.

A’s friends should not be making threats but it’s quite possible that A isn’t responsible for this.

Clearly this was the last straw for A and has just reignited her grief for her Dad. I feel sad for her.

EliflurtleAndTheInfiniteMadness · 04/11/2023 05:06

Yes YABU not to have supported her during dinner. It was crystal clear what he was doing. It's very understandable that she feels angry and hurt by you and C's behaviour. Having her friends be nasty to you on social media is not ok at all. You're all in the wrong here.

MyGooseisTotallyLoose · 04/11/2023 04:59

alchemisty · 04/11/2023 01:01

Tbh this take sounds a bit childish to me, like from back in primary school or something, when best friends weren't allowed to keep any secrets from each other.

Shit happens in every adult's life, and no one is obligated to talk about anything they don't want to. That's what makes for healthy and supportive friendships, not demanding to read your friend's diary.

I agree it was probably obvious what B was trying to do, though I think OP genuinely might not have picked up on it. She might have thought A was fuming simply because she was being friendly/normal with B. But whether or not OP picked up on it, there are ways to not feed into B's trickery, without breaching your own emotional and mental boundaries. A sounds like quite... a lot... actually, judging from all the dramatics plus her friends harassing OP so nastily, and I'm not sure I'd want to mention my own issues for her to potentially weaponise in their couple conflict or in wider group dynamics.

This, A and B are absolutely ridiculous in their different ways.
Do they often need to be the centre of attention and have the group be involved in their tumultuous relationship?
Is their a reason they'd pick am expensive weekend away for everyone to kick off?
Both are dicks, agree you shouldn't be forced to share family issues to make someone else feel better.
If she is enjoying this teenage behaviour, follow her lead and 'block her back'.
Agree to screenshot her abusive friends posts and I extremely hope they are not her colleagues working with anyone vulnerable. Although I'd be interested to see what she's actually told them.
I'm too old and tired to have to engage in this drama llama behaviour!

2catsandhappy · 04/11/2023 04:58

Alot of words to justify yourself. You absolutely knew what the guy was driving at.
Self fulfiling prophecy. You can only make a decision when you speak to A. But A won't speak to you. What hand wringing agony for you. Neat and tidy way to absolve yourself from being complicit in A's break down.

I wonder if A is on MN? Would like to hear the other side.

stayathomer · 04/11/2023 04:50

B told her they couldn't afford for her to go part-time so she could spend more time with her dad. B said that they had Debts to pay still (turns out very little Debt and B was just saving money for "stuff"). A worked full time and went around there most evenings but cut down because B was complaining that he was working long hours and it wasn't fair he was coming home to having to do all the child care so that A could go around there. She felt like he didn't want her to help her dad out. He died and A was distraught.
This made me so angry and I thought Jesus poor a, b is the asshole to end all assholes, what an absolute shit. (And I never curse on here!) but then her saying she hoped the mil died … what a horrible situation, their marriage was ovsome time ago op. I think it’s crazy you didn’t know they were talking about each other bBut it doesn’t matter. It’s good you checked up on her

I would be stepping back and letting them sort it out themselves. How do people get friends with such drama in their lives? Honestly, I just couldn't be bothered with it, and all this "you should be supporting me" in something which is clearly nothing to do with you is just childish and dramatic.
eh, life happens? This isn’t a case of ‘who should have put out the bin?’, this is a huge life event!!

Oscarlimadelta1 · 04/11/2023 04:44

B is an Arsehole, A is being unreasonable in not reining her friends in, but is justifiably cross with you. There is no way you didn't realise B was baiting A. If you wanted to stay out of it you would not have answered his questions. You would also have made an effort to properly apologise after the event. None of you come of out of this looking good.

Mummyoflittledragon · 04/11/2023 04:41

It sounds as if you’ve known for a long while that A is in an abusive relationship yet didn’t want to get involved. You chose not to support her and that will be why she shared nothing of her life with you.

As you and your husband don’t appear to have supported her at all, I’m not surprised she had such a strong reaction to your lack of support. She really needed you this time and once again, from her perspective, you didn’t come through.

The messages from her friends need to stop. But I don’t think you’ve actually been much of a friend to A.

Reading between the lines, I can totally see why she felt you have contributed to his abuse of her. She has been surrounded by people, who seem to value earning potential and their comfort over emotional intelligence.

It was pretty obvious he was using you as a stick to beat his wife. And I’m 99.9% sure he’s used how wonderful you are and your earning potential to compare her unfavourably, as part of his abuse of her. I’m therefore not surprised she now sees you as one of her abusers.

How many more sticks does she have to put up with before snapping?

I’d say the only good thing, which has come out of this is that she finally put enough value on herself to leave. And you as one of her long term friends in a strange way ‘helped’ her with that one.

My advice? Leave her alone. You didn’t help when she needed you most. She doesn’t need your help now. If you care at all about her, you will never speak to B again.

As for the messages from her friends, I would respond. ‘I realise I have been a terrible friend to A. I am very sorry. Please stop now.’ If they don’t, then you could contact the police.

But if you do contact the police, I would be very careful not to involve her. The abuse being aimed at you right now has just give you a tiny glimpse of what she has been suffering for years. She doesn’t need the police on her doorstep after everything she has been through.

Lamelie · 04/11/2023 03:54

CrapBucket · 03/11/2023 22:57

Definitely the best thing to do in this situation is post every tiny detail online…

This! 🙄

GodDammitCecil · 04/11/2023 02:46

I read shit like this and think - WTF am I doing on MN, is this really a good use of anyone’s time?

Answer: no, it is not.

NumberTheory · 04/11/2023 02:34

Yes, you dropped A in it. (And your DH is a bit of a dick for seeing A as spiteful because she didn’t leave 4 years ago when she was emotionally wrecked from her dads death, under the thumb of an uncaring husband and with a 3 year old daughter.)

The way you describe the conversation it seems like it should have been obvious. Sometimes things hit you from left field, but any conversation where a man is suggesting the women in his life should be caring for his parents or otherwise picking up the drudgery should get at least a brief education on the role of sexism in setting expectations.

But here’s the main thing - you’re old friends, good enough to drop a bunch of money on a meal out and a hotel. But you didn’t know what A was going through. You knew things had been tough before Covid and that B had been awful to her (PP is right that from your description it sounds like emotional abuse), but at your first big meet up after, when it’s clear there’s tension, you aren’t asking her if she’s okay. You didn’t support her in the conversation with B, and it seems you haven’t really supported her at all.

Still, at least A has left now and has a chance at being a lot happier. Which she may not have done if you’d not been the foil that let her see she had to save herself.

Ilovelifeverymuch · 04/11/2023 02:34

Spirallingdownwards · 03/11/2023 23:00

Yes even from your post it was bloody obvious when he was probing about whether you would help MIL that he was making pointed remarks about her. In reality you wouldn't help your MIL so why did you pretend it would depend on your availability and not just say that's a flat-out no!

No wonder A left. Good for her.

If you want a relationship for her apologise and say you were trying to avoid a confrontation and that it has backfired.

She didn't give a flat out no because she should not be airing her business in public. She doesn't have to throw it in her husband's face in front of their friends so she didn't do anything wrong.

Good for A for leaving but to tell other dumb friends who are now posting abuse on Facebook is ridiculous. A should have sorted out her relationship without involving or dragging her friends into it.

OrderOfTheKookaburra · 04/11/2023 02:22

How was it NOT obvious that he was asking about helping your MIL due to something going on with his wife??!!

And YABU to have not just said "it's totally dependent on the relationship I have with my MIL so it's not a one size fits all". Because actually, you lied. YOU would never help your MIL so yes, you threw your friend under the bus!

Womencanlift · 04/11/2023 02:15

So you earn so much more than your friends (completely irrelevant to the post but of course you had to get it in as a humble brag) but you don’t have the emotional intelligence to realise that B was talking about A at dinner?

B is out of order, you were not that great either. Don’t know enough about C and D to have an opinion about them