Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not understand why Zara Aleena’s killer had his sentence reduced

68 replies

Dontfencemein · 03/11/2023 21:23

Zara Aleena’s murderer has had his sentence reduced. Why? I feel desperately sad for her and her family. And for the woman and children killed at Killamarsh. Violent sexual predators hiding in plain sight. Not sure what my AIBU is really. I don’t understand why there’s not more outrage about these men who were known to be dangerous and went on to do even more awful things to women and children.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
GirrlCrush · 05/11/2023 17:46

Lougle · 04/11/2023 07:41

He's 30 now, will be at least 63 if he's released, and his behaviour inside prison is described as 'abhorrent conduct, marked by a lack of remorse and a callous attitude toward others." https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-london-67307052.amp

He isn't getting out.

I wonder what they mean by 'abhorrent conduct' interesting phrase

Is he a traveller?

TrashedSofa · 04/11/2023 17:01

Lougle · 03/11/2023 21:42

It doesn't mean he's any less guilty and it doesn't mean he's any more likely to be granted parol at the end of the minimum sentence. If the guidelines say that there must be evidence of prolonged suffering to go beyond 30 years, and the victim was rendered unconscious very quickly, then to give extra years would be double counting - part of the 30 years is already for the fact that the victim was rendered unconscious and died. The extra years would be for the extra suffering.

No number of years is enough. But there has to be a rational system to make sure people get a sentence that reflects the crime they committed.

All of this.

AmiablePedant · 04/11/2023 16:17

I'm always surprised that people think death is actually a worse fate than decades and decades rotting in prison. Whether it be 33 years or 38 years or for the entirety of his natural days.

Iheartpizza · 04/11/2023 14:00

I've just read the judgement. It says:

It is argued that she is likely to have been unconscious very early on and during much of the attack. This is speculation and there is evidence contrary to that suggestion

So I have no idea why they have now come to the conclusion that she didn't actually suffer that much as she was unconscious when they've admitted it was speculation!

It's a disgusting turn of events and her family must be devastated. However 33 years is the minimum term so hopefully he will never see the light of day again.

Flickersy · 04/11/2023 13:17

Friedgreentomatoparty · 04/11/2023 12:37

I can’t imagine there’s any higher level of suffering than death. How ridiculous and offensive that judge is. Also it’s only speculation how much she would have been aware of they should assume the worst and sentence on that basis

The judge isn't being ridiculous or offensive. If you cause someone prolonged fear and pain before killing them it is, I'd think we'd all agree, worse than killing them quickly. Some may argue the distinction doesn't matter since in both cases the victim ends up dead, but in one case the suffering is much greater than the other and therefore the punishment would usually be different.

Angrycat2768 · 04/11/2023 13:12

Friedgreentomatoparty · 04/11/2023 12:37

I can’t imagine there’s any higher level of suffering than death. How ridiculous and offensive that judge is. Also it’s only speculation how much she would have been aware of they should assume the worst and sentence on that basis

If there is no higher suffering than death you can't punish people more for torturing someone before death. Because you would have to have the same sentence for committing a quick murder than a long, drawn out one where the victim was subjected to prolonged suffering.

Loubelle70 · 04/11/2023 13:01

clpsmum · 04/11/2023 12:35

Agreed

Agree. If white and male...the privileged class..itd be different

clpsmum · 04/11/2023 12:52

TheShellBeach · 04/11/2023 12:36

In a way it's semantics.
He won't ever be released.

We hope

clpsmum · 04/11/2023 12:52

@MrsTerryPratchett there's also a very good reason murder isn't a good thing. He knew the consequences let him rot imo

MrsTerryPratchett · 04/11/2023 12:50

Sartre · 04/11/2023 10:08

He’ll only die in prison if he dies young or is refused parole once his min tariff expires. He’s 30 so he’ll be 63 when considered for parole. Average life expectancy for men is 79 now so he could have almost 20 years when released.

The tariff shouldn’t have been reduced, I have no doubt it gave the sick cunt a kick.

I'm fairly sure life expectancy is lower for people in prison. Certainly when I worked with men leaving prison after long sentences, their health wasn't good.

It sounds as though this man is behaving poorly in prison, which means he'll stay there. There are very good reasons whole life tariffs aren't a good thing. His sentence is still life.

Friedgreentomatoparty · 04/11/2023 12:37

RunningFromInsanity · 03/11/2023 21:25

I read somewhere part of the judges reasoning was that because she fell unconscious quickly, she wasn’t subjected to a high level of suffering, and therefore the sentence shouldn’t have been that high, so she reduced it.

WTF

I can’t imagine there’s any higher level of suffering than death. How ridiculous and offensive that judge is. Also it’s only speculation how much she would have been aware of they should assume the worst and sentence on that basis

clpsmum · 04/11/2023 12:36

Lougle · 03/11/2023 21:42

It doesn't mean he's any less guilty and it doesn't mean he's any more likely to be granted parol at the end of the minimum sentence. If the guidelines say that there must be evidence of prolonged suffering to go beyond 30 years, and the victim was rendered unconscious very quickly, then to give extra years would be double counting - part of the 30 years is already for the fact that the victim was rendered unconscious and died. The extra years would be for the extra suffering.

No number of years is enough. But there has to be a rational system to make sure people get a sentence that reflects the crime they committed.

He ended her life. His sentence doesn't reflect the crime he committed

TheShellBeach · 04/11/2023 12:36

In a way it's semantics.
He won't ever be released.

clpsmum · 04/11/2023 12:35

NorthernLights5 · 03/11/2023 21:36

It's disgusting. I also strongly believe the sentence would have been harsher had Zara Aleena been white.

Agreed

clpsmum · 04/11/2023 12:35

GirrlCrush · 03/11/2023 21:26

They are entitled to an appeal

Where will 'more outrage' get you? They are dealt with in the parameters of the law

Doesn't make it right does it. Law and justice system is a joke

clpsmum · 04/11/2023 12:34

RunningFromInsanity · 03/11/2023 21:25

I read somewhere part of the judges reasoning was that because she fell unconscious quickly, she wasn’t subjected to a high level of suffering, and therefore the sentence shouldn’t have been that high, so she reduced it.

WTF

Saw this too. Fucking idiots tbh she is dead he deserves a full life tariff

Merrymouse · 04/11/2023 12:33

Given the circumstances of the crime it seems unlikely that a parole board would want to be responsible for letting him out on licence again.

Angrycat2768 · 04/11/2023 12:28

JMSA · 04/11/2023 09:35

Oh, well that's alright then.

Fuck me, the bar is set low, isn't it?

The usual tariff is 30 years. The initial 8 years was added for aggravating factors. The appeal judges found there weren't aggravating factors so the aggravated part has to be reduced. That is different from ' oh it's not so bad because she didn't suffer' You have to have additions for aggravating factors. If they aren't there you can't add them. He wont get out anyway because he has a minimum sentence not a maximum sentence.

HermioneWeasley · 04/11/2023 12:15

He should be executed

Viewfrommyhouse · 04/11/2023 12:13

Misogyny. HTH.

TheShellBeach · 04/11/2023 12:12

LemonLimeDivine · 04/11/2023 07:14

It’s utterly appalling. That poor girl, and her family.

People like him deserve the death sentence.

This country hasn't got capital punishment though.

Allthatwegotisthispalebluedot · 04/11/2023 12:09

I don’t see how a 38 year minimum tariff was treating him unfairly though. I don’t see how the fact she was unconscious makes it any less abhorrent (in fact I think there’s an argument that it could be more abhorrent).

I feel so uncomfortable with this judgement and I’m usually not a ‘throw away the key’ kind of person but it was horribly pre-meditated, had a violent sexual motive, he had been in prison before and was clearly a waste of oxygen. I hope he dies in prison (as in, I hope he actually serves his life sentence) and is never released.

RIP Zara. You and your loved ones deserved so much better. 💐

Flickersy · 04/11/2023 11:05

Dontfencemein · 04/11/2023 10:04

I can see the legal arguments but it’s still perverse. Her last moments were filled with fear and pain. And he’s used how much taxpayers’ money proving a point? The family is right, we should forget him and honour her. But as PPs have said, it’s sends out a dreadful message to men who would harm women.

It's not just point-scoring. No-one, even the vilest most evil creature on earth, should be unjustly treated by the justice system. It is vital that the law is applied correctly and fairly.

It is never a waste of taxpayers money to ensure that happens.

It's only easy to agree with the above when you're dealing with someone likeable. Even if someone is a fucking awful person though, the above MUST still apply otherwise we may as well do away with the justice system entirely.

Riverlee · 04/11/2023 10:23

Nagado · 04/11/2023 07:04

There was another thread about this that linked to the judgement. If you decide to read it, be warned that it contains a very graphic description of what Zara was subjected to, which could be very triggering.

I’m massively over simplifying it but part of it was that the original judge found that him taking her mobile phone from her was in order to prevent her from calling for help and that he had caused Zara to suffer fear before her murder (there’s a legal term for it, but it’s gone out of my head). So the original judge gave him extra time for that, before knocking off the five years credit that he got for pleading guilty.

The grounds of appeal were that the phone was just one of several items that he’d taken from her, so it was wrong to say he’d taken it for that reason, and in order to give extra time for causing her fear, it had to be that the level of fear went above and beyond the fear that any victim would experience while they were being raped and murdered and that, because she’d been unconscious for some time, it couldn’t be said that she had suffered as much as she would’ve if she’d been conscious during the attack. They accepted that 30+ years was reasonable but 38 years was too much. And the Appeal Court agreed.

Thank you for explaining to this.

Sartre · 04/11/2023 10:08

He’ll only die in prison if he dies young or is refused parole once his min tariff expires. He’s 30 so he’ll be 63 when considered for parole. Average life expectancy for men is 79 now so he could have almost 20 years when released.

The tariff shouldn’t have been reduced, I have no doubt it gave the sick cunt a kick.

Swipe left for the next trending thread