Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To tell him to stick his budget up his jacksie

233 replies

Wearegoingtoneedabiggerboat · 03/11/2023 19:26

I will start off to say I am aware that I am in a fortunate position financially so don’t wish to offend anyone.
DP and I are on the same pay scale within the NHS, however he earns about £300 a month more than me due to overtime. The trust I work for discourages payment for extra hrs so I tend to take time back for extra hours worked. I am happy with this.
we have separate bank accounts but share finances. Previous to this year DP paid the mortgage and I paid most of the bills. Food, petrol and living expenses went on my credit card which was paid off every month. The bill was divided into 2, with DP transferring his half to me. Now the mortgage has finished we looked at finances again. When I say we, basically DP came up with a plan and decided it was a done deal.
i will say that we would like to retire early 60’s. (We both have around 30 years NHS pension. ) Me hopefully at 60, DP a bit older as he hasn’t enough years for full state pension till 62. I have worked since I was 16, DP qualified at 26. Once DP gets something into his head that’s it he won’t listen to alternative views. Despite having NHS Pension and I also have a small private pension we need to, in DP’s head to save a good portion of our wages a month. I agree that we do need to save and I do need raining in a bit as I’m a bit of a spender, however DP is going completely over the top.
Basically what he has decided is, I will continue to pay bills and all of the food shopping petrol spends for the month which according to his budget spreadsheet should be around £3200 per month. As that is £400 more than I will earn he will transfer that to me, plus £1100 to pay for house renovations (our house is falling down around our ears since we prioritised paying off the mortgage) and money for holidays. So basically I have no money left for myself while he has approx £1700 left. He transfers that straight into our pension fund. If I overspend on our food and spends budget then DP says I just need to use the money he transfers for house and holiday fund.
Also both of our children are in university but at home. The youngest wants to go into student accommodation next year as it’s a bit of a trash for her to travel to university every day. DP has decided she’s a fool and has told her she can’t expect any money from us. At the back of my mind I am thinking he’s not concerned about her leaving home but more concerned that it may cost us money. The oldest he is also refusing to help out and has set up a spreadsheet for any money she owes us.
This is all doing my head in. I have told him there is times when you can’t help going over budget. I am aware however that I need to rain my spending in. He has become totally fixated on saving money but I have told him he’s coming across as a Scrooge, especially surrounding helping the DC’s financially through university. Or is he and I am the one being unreasonable.

OP posts:
determinedtomakethiswork · 04/11/2023 06:21

I'm sorry but you just can't trust somebody you're not married to in that way. You need to be very very careful about having things in your name as well.

NorthernLights5 · 04/11/2023 05:31

You need to prioritise transferring half of all savings in joint names into your sole name. He should do the same as either one of you could screw the other one over.

Also whilst it's important to plan for the future, you also have to live now too. I work in care and the amount of people I care for who scrimped and saved and lived miserable lives for a retirement with their partner, only for their partner to die, or one of them get dementia or havea life-changing stroke etc is huge.

LivingDeadGirlUK · 04/11/2023 04:02

Wearegoingtoneedabiggerboat · 03/11/2023 19:58

We are not married. I do trust him, we have been together 25 years and I have access to and can see how much is in our pension savings account.

Absolutely do not pay all the bills and leave him to 'save' for you. You are being set up to get screwed. If your not married you need your own seperate savings account.

UpaladderwatchingTV · 04/11/2023 03:53

The one thing that everyone seems to be ignoring is your question as to whether he is being unreasonable or whether you are OP, as you openly admit that you are 'a bit of a spender'. Only you and he know just how much of a spender you are, and if you both want to retire early, then it does make sense to save rather than constantly splurge your money on stuff that you probably don't actually need. Having said that, I wouldn't want anyone dictating to me how our joint money is to be spent/saved either. I suggest that you sit down TOGETHER, discuss what your aims are, which should include helping the kids through uni, and then making a joint plan as to how to make retirement as comfortable as possible. Oh, and of course it's never too late to get married, so after all these years together, if you want the security of being safer financially as you get older OP, it might be worth discussing tying the knot too!

BarbaraofSeville · 04/11/2023 03:29

You say that he's putting money in a joint savings account that's to serve as a second pension?

Is this an ISA, preferably with a significant S&S component, or is it just cash savings? If it's the latter, then that's a mistake because you're missing out on either tax relief by putting into a personal pension, or from the interest/growth being tax free, so something to look at.

If you're likely to pay tax in retirement, there's not a huge difference between putting your money in a pension vs an ISA (pref S&S if you're saving for the longer term) although the pension can be advantageous if you're likely to pay higher rate tax, which could apply at the salaries you're on, especially due to the frozen tax bands. But you definitely don't want this money in cash savings, which if it's a joint account, it sounds like it must be, as I don't think you can get joint ISAs, the clue is in the name after all.

I agree that £3200 sounds like a lot for 'bills' if you're mortgage free but perhaps not if it includes a significant amount of non bills spending, eg eating out, generous food shopping budget, entertainment and money to support DC.

Plus I definitely question how much you really need to be saving for retirement when you have two decent NHS pensions that can be taken from 60 and you're likely to have the option of working PT to top up your income, plus you own your house and DC will be independent by then so your income needs will be lower.

OnlyOpenMouthToChangeFeet · 04/11/2023 03:18

Wearegoingtoneedabiggerboat · 03/11/2023 21:31

To be honest I am helping the kids as I think it’s the right thing to do. From the £3200 I pay for their travel and toiletries and some spends, I just don’t tell DP I do that.
He says he has taken control as I have not got a clue about finance which is strange thing to say as it’s me that has enough years worked that I will get full state pension at 67 and that I started a separate private pension when I was 17.

In response to him saying he's "taken control", personally I'd show him the definition of financial abuse, and the sentencing the for it.

I know you trust him, but he's obviously becoming pretty irrational, so I would consider consulting a solicitor to see if there is anything you can do to protect yourself financially. It's not the bloody 1950's and "his way or the highway"!!

Whatever you decide, good luck. 💐

BestZebbie · 04/11/2023 01:13

Are you married? Because otherwise he has done very nicely by being solely responsible for mortgage (building himself lots if lovely capital in the house in his sole name) whilst all your contribution has gone up in smoke as consumables....

grottyb · 04/11/2023 01:13

Is it because you both want to retire early & href’s conscious that without cutbacks that’s not possible?

Hankunamatata · 04/11/2023 01:12

Nope.
£3200 + £1100 ÷ 2 = £2150 You each pay into bills holidays etc
Leaves you with £650 left over and him with £950.
then I'd allow £400 for each of you for spending or going over leaving £800 to top pension or £400 a month into each person's pension

Reiningnotraining · 04/11/2023 00:42

I don't understand why he won't give some support to DC while they're studying. If he qualified at 26 was he entirely supporting himself through studies until then.

I think you need to find a middle way together. It sounds as if you are both being more stringent/profligate in response to the other.

Also, I think you want to REIN in your spending (control as you would a horse) not RAIN?

Dotcheck · 04/11/2023 00:01

DP has decided she’s a fool and has told her she can’t expect any money from us

God how I hate selfish parents. Their children end up completely trapped.
I’d want to dump him for that, never mind his other ridiculous financial demands.

I wonder if he does other shitty things to the people he is supposed to care about most

Startagainjanuary · 03/11/2023 23:51

ToadOnTheHill · 03/11/2023 23:39

@Startagainjanuary really? Have I missed an update after the OP?

"Previous to this year DP paid the mortgage and I paid most of the bills. Food, petrol and living expenses went on my credit card which was paid off every month. The bill was divided into 2, with DP transferring his half to me. "

The credit card bill was divided into two not all the DD bills that is how I interpreted it.

I thought you would appreciate the bold type as you seem to like it so much:

followmyflow · 03/11/2023 23:50

woah - big NO! he is being absolutely unreasonable. he takes it upon himself to earmark ALL of YOUR earnings for bills and expenses?? under absolutely no circumstances agree to this - what is he on? make your own budget which takes jointly from earnings to pay expenses and then the rest should be split fairly. make sure you cover YOUR OWN bases and do not trust him with a massive chunk of monthly money to put into a "joint pension". seriously!?

CandyLeBonBon · 03/11/2023 23:39

Wearegoingtoneedabiggerboat · 03/11/2023 23:28

NHS pension has death in service and pays small pension to nominated partner or children.

The minutiae aside for a second - can you see how his behaviour is disordered?

How he's behaving and reacting to what he perceives as stressors, is not proportionate.

It really, really isn't.

ToadOnTheHill · 03/11/2023 23:39

@Startagainjanuary really? Have I missed an update after the OP?

"Previous to this year DP paid the mortgage and I paid most of the bills. Food, petrol and living expenses went on my credit card which was paid off every month. The bill was divided into 2, with DP transferring his half to me. "

Littlelucas · 03/11/2023 23:31

This sounds very like financial abuse. Why does he get to dictate how many takeout coffees you buy? Why does all your money have to go on bills/living costs whilst his gets “saved”? That could end very badly for you op when you’re unmarried. I’m married and would never agree to that.

All money should be pooled, all bills/outgoings paid, decide on an amount to put in pension pot and then whatever is left over split between the two of you.

And to not help your dcs when you can easily afford it is horrible. Stop letting the tight bastard tell u what to do.

Wearegoingtoneedabiggerboat · 03/11/2023 23:28

NHS pension has death in service and pays small pension to nominated partner or children.

OP posts:
CandyLeBonBon · 03/11/2023 23:24

if you dropped dead your pension would die with you as would his.

Well that's not accurate is it? We can nominate beneficiaries etc can't we?

Caththegreat · 03/11/2023 23:23

Heythink outta the box.dont retire
Do something different

TheRealLilyMunster · 03/11/2023 23:21

I have no money left for myself while he has approx £1700 left

Aside from anything else, how does he justify that?

Scottishskifun · 03/11/2023 23:21

He doesn't get to decide that you pay all the bills and he puts some money aside for house renovations/works.

You split the bills equally (as on similar wage) plus agree to an amount for house repairs leaving you both with equal spending amounts.
It's not acceptable for 1 person to pay all bills unless a sahp situation and doing childcare or a reason one can't work.

justasking111 · 03/11/2023 23:12

He's a fool who needs real financial advice. For a start if you dropped dead your pension would die with you as would his. Does he really want to see all that money vanish.

I suggest that you both find a financial advisor who will be a lot smarter than he is. We have an annual visit from ours. We moved our pensions into a portfolio years ago which has performed very well.

The advisor may well suggest that you get a marriage certificate for financial reasons.

TheOccupier · 03/11/2023 23:07

Why aren't you married? It's not too late. You work in medicine, you must have seen cases where someone couldn't support their partner or make decisions for them because they weren't official next of kin. Can you use this as a reason to have a small (low-cost) wedding?

TravelInHope · 03/11/2023 22:49

He’s a man. Of course he is being unreasonable. Time to change the locks and dump his stuff on the drive.

CherryMyBrandy · 03/11/2023 22:49

cestlavielife · 03/11/2023 22:10

You are naive to trust him
Whose name is the house in ?
What do your wills say?
Why is pension fund in a joint savings ? Either of you could take it all out tomorrow
Why wont he support dc at uni ?

Agree completely.

And why are you putting pension savings into what sounds like a savings account? Have you maxed out your annual allowance first or you are and have been missing out on tax relief.

If there's a good reason for the use of cash savings, it should be equally going into accounts in single names to protect your investments. Otherwise as PPs have said, one of you could just take the whole lot and run.

You are very unprotected here not being married.