Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To tell him to stick his budget up his jacksie

233 replies

Wearegoingtoneedabiggerboat · 03/11/2023 19:26

I will start off to say I am aware that I am in a fortunate position financially so don’t wish to offend anyone.
DP and I are on the same pay scale within the NHS, however he earns about £300 a month more than me due to overtime. The trust I work for discourages payment for extra hrs so I tend to take time back for extra hours worked. I am happy with this.
we have separate bank accounts but share finances. Previous to this year DP paid the mortgage and I paid most of the bills. Food, petrol and living expenses went on my credit card which was paid off every month. The bill was divided into 2, with DP transferring his half to me. Now the mortgage has finished we looked at finances again. When I say we, basically DP came up with a plan and decided it was a done deal.
i will say that we would like to retire early 60’s. (We both have around 30 years NHS pension. ) Me hopefully at 60, DP a bit older as he hasn’t enough years for full state pension till 62. I have worked since I was 16, DP qualified at 26. Once DP gets something into his head that’s it he won’t listen to alternative views. Despite having NHS Pension and I also have a small private pension we need to, in DP’s head to save a good portion of our wages a month. I agree that we do need to save and I do need raining in a bit as I’m a bit of a spender, however DP is going completely over the top.
Basically what he has decided is, I will continue to pay bills and all of the food shopping petrol spends for the month which according to his budget spreadsheet should be around £3200 per month. As that is £400 more than I will earn he will transfer that to me, plus £1100 to pay for house renovations (our house is falling down around our ears since we prioritised paying off the mortgage) and money for holidays. So basically I have no money left for myself while he has approx £1700 left. He transfers that straight into our pension fund. If I overspend on our food and spends budget then DP says I just need to use the money he transfers for house and holiday fund.
Also both of our children are in university but at home. The youngest wants to go into student accommodation next year as it’s a bit of a trash for her to travel to university every day. DP has decided she’s a fool and has told her she can’t expect any money from us. At the back of my mind I am thinking he’s not concerned about her leaving home but more concerned that it may cost us money. The oldest he is also refusing to help out and has set up a spreadsheet for any money she owes us.
This is all doing my head in. I have told him there is times when you can’t help going over budget. I am aware however that I need to rain my spending in. He has become totally fixated on saving money but I have told him he’s coming across as a Scrooge, especially surrounding helping the DC’s financially through university. Or is he and I am the one being unreasonable.

OP posts:
Maelil01 · 04/11/2023 14:32

It’s neither rain or reign (what a monarch does) it’s rein!

As in reins for a horse, to hold them back, which is what he wants to do with all spending 😬

LusciousLondoner · 04/11/2023 14:25

endofthelinefinally · 04/11/2023 14:21

OP I can't see if you have answered the question about ownership of the property. Who is on the deeds? Are you joint tenants or tenants in common? What is the inheritance plan for the property? Do you own the property 50:50?
You must get legal advice on this and get your wills written correctly. Also, consider what happens if one of you dies and the other subsequently gets married! Even the most unlikely things can happen. You need to make provision for the children that can't be undone by a new partner coming on the scene.

See OP's post at 20:46 yesterday

endofthelinefinally · 04/11/2023 14:21

OP I can't see if you have answered the question about ownership of the property. Who is on the deeds? Are you joint tenants or tenants in common? What is the inheritance plan for the property? Do you own the property 50:50?
You must get legal advice on this and get your wills written correctly. Also, consider what happens if one of you dies and the other subsequently gets married! Even the most unlikely things can happen. You need to make provision for the children that can't be undone by a new partner coming on the scene.

Startagainjanuary · 04/11/2023 14:20

Are you intending to support your children all on your own out of your own money only or have you actually confronted your DP?

If it is you alone footing the bill and they are living at home £100.00 a month seems fine that’s what I paid my DS every month for emptying the dishwasher since he was 12.

However, your youngest wants to live in Uni accommodation and if she was my daughter I would make it clear her not being able to do this is down to her Dad not fulfilling his duties as a parent and what is expected of parents if you earn over 70k and you have a teenager at Uni.

This post has really made me sad for you and your daughters I would be unable to live with a person so controlling and miserly as you’re DP.

Have you discussed driving lessons with your daughters? Teaching them yourself? It just seems you are all trapped in hell to me.

WrongSwanson · 04/11/2023 13:35

Soontobe60 · 04/11/2023 13:29

I hope you’ve nominated your Dc to receive your lump sum then - as clearly if he gets his hands on it they won’t see any of it!

Agreed, I think it's really important to work on the assumption he will continue to try and hoard all money for himself

Soontobe60 · 04/11/2023 13:29

Wearegoingtoneedabiggerboat · 03/11/2023 23:28

NHS pension has death in service and pays small pension to nominated partner or children.

I hope you’ve nominated your Dc to receive your lump sum then - as clearly if he gets his hands on it they won’t see any of it!

Whydoifeelsobadallthetime · 04/11/2023 13:27

Of course your partner thinks you should DIY your wills.
I think a solicitor should peruse your joint assets.
Maybe they'll bring to light what, and where everything really is.
I don't think he's being honest with you.

Whydoifeelsobadallthetime · 04/11/2023 13:14

You read like a smart woman, however I think you are in a very precarious financial position.
Unmarried, as you are, I would be telling your partner that you would like your 50% of the savings for yourself ASAP.
And then I would rejig the finances, let him save whatever he wants, but you need to have a reasonable budget for yourselves to live on without him telling you the additional comes out of x/y/z.
Budgeting isn't particularly easy at the moment. Food shopping that cost £97 last month might cost you £101 this month. Are you just supposed to say, ah well we can do without the packet on minced beef we need for Thursdays tea then? ... or as he decides, it's coming from the savings for house repairs or holiday. Oh, no we won't worry about the roof because the food shopping has risen by x amount in the past 2 years. ....where are you going on holiday next summer? ...oh we initially thought Mexico, but cost of living has meant we're going to Skegness instead.
Don't even get me started on the not wanting to pay adequately for uni aged kids.

He sounds really, really mean OP and I'm concerned if these are thoughts he is happy to air, what is he doing behind your back with your savings? I'd almost guarantee that you will never get 50% of what's saved.

justasking111 · 04/11/2023 13:12

Frankly I get a bit tired of this me Tarzan you Jane rhetoric.

The head of a government loan agency conference that I attended said that he preferred to loan to a woman because she would work within the means of the home or company whereas if they loaned to a man he was off to land rover defender to order the latest version. While his wife was haggling over the cost of a waste paper basket

maltravers · 04/11/2023 13:09

Just tell him flat “no” this is not acceptable and give a counter-proposal eg joint account to pay all bills, house renovation etc which you both pay into. It is absolutely unacceptable that you should have no disposable income and he should be in charge of your earnings (which is what this amounts to). If your savings are in a joint account, do you have access to this? What is to stop him taking the lot to “protect it” from you in his mind.?

justasking111 · 04/11/2023 13:07

I have a friend married her husband scraped through university she has a PhD. We had lunch recently. I was so shocked that he controls both pensions. He said that she wouldn't understand finance. They're both in their seventies she has a little runabout car, he's just bought a high performance sports car two seater.

Frankly I gave her a good talking to because if he drops dead she's in the doodoo financially

isthewashingdryyet · 04/11/2023 13:01

Rein in, the reign with a g, is what Charles does, and rain is very wet 🙄

sorry, I think you are right not not agree with him

TheCatterall · 04/11/2023 12:55

If the university aged adults are at home - I’d be giving them nothing. They can learn to fend for themselves.

that’s not to say I wouldn’t help them with driving lessons, family days out etc.

id be buying enough food for the household etc. but I’d expect them to contribute if possible - or at least be able to manage their own mobile bills, bus/travel expenses etc.

But spending money - no.

Are they working or doing something to bring an income in?

Wearegoingtoneedabiggerboat · 04/11/2023 12:47

Thanks for everyone’s advice, pleased to think I AIBU in regards to this budget. Like I said before I do need to reign (not rain as I previously wrote🥴) my spending in, as I agree realistically over 3 k for bills, food, and spends seems a lot.
So if the DC’s are at home and you had my budget what would you be giving them. Would £100 a month each be fair.
I am looking as well to see solicitors as well to write our wills. DP reckons we can do it DIY.

OP posts:
itsalongwaybackfromsorry · 04/11/2023 11:10

He sounds condescending as fuck and is doing a money grab for himself.

I would not be having this. Especially as you're not protected financially if he takes his big pension pot, that you've allowed him to build up by paying for everything for all of you, and walks.

Zanatdy · 04/11/2023 11:07

Your kids will get minimum loan so you need to prioritise that right now in your life not all on pensions. Where’s your money for clothes / meeting friends for lunches / dinner out etc? I’d tell him life is for living, two of my colleagues died this year before retirement - both well under 60. He might have this plan, but you don’t agree with it it

Ginmonkeyagain · 04/11/2023 10:58

Surely you both go 50/50 on essential household bills (food, utilities, transport, house maintenance etc..) and family costs then what is left is for each of you to spend as you wish.

An NHS pension is pretty decent. If he is concerned about the amount does the scheme allow additional voluntary contributions? If not he needs to talk to an IFA about the most effective way to create an additional retirement savings pot.

As others have pointed, out a basic savings account is not a pension scheme.

It sounds as if he is just hoarding cash as an anxiety reflex. If he really wants to prepare for retirement, if you house is a mess he should be prioritising big ticket house repairs while he is still earning.

2DayP1zzaP1neapple · 04/11/2023 10:38

£3200 bills sounds very high with no mortgage

2DayP1zzaP1neapple · 04/11/2023 10:16

If mortgage is paid

You pay half the bills each
The left over money is for each of you to do what you want

He can save his if he wants

You can spend it on the children or yourself

But you need that money for yourself

Open up your own ISA or savings account in your name or premium bonds

You need to put your foot down now, not in 5 years time or 10 years time !

Legally, you are 2 single people

Take control !

Startagainjanuary · 04/11/2023 09:35

The 50 to 100 left over from direct debits and the 20 surplus goes into savings for going out money and buying wine when it is on 25% off 6.

Startagainjanuary · 04/11/2023 09:26

For perspective and maybe to show your husband how on a decreased budget you can still help your children. This is our budget. Like you we have NHS pensions all sorted so not too worried about adding into pensions. I work part time and my husband retired early. I can increase our take home by working more hours (self employed now) but we have decided to try and make it work as I am prioritising my health now. However, not at the expense of not supporting my child at all and I would work more hours if I had to. I am trying to find a balance.

My son passed his driving test at 17 and half years because we insured him on my husbands car (£300 for 1 year) and we did his driving lessons. I will give him my 2019 car when he finishes Uni maybe SORN it til then if we decide 1 car is enough now my DH has retired.

No mortgage, 2 cars (each 5 years old) owned outright and no debt. House needs 20k (new kitchen) spending on it if we were staying long term but as soon as our son has finished Uni we will downsize and at 50 I’m over house renovations. Hoping to give 50k to son for a house deposit when we downsize.

My husband and I enjoy walking in nature, and simple holidays like walking up a mountain or visiting historic buildings. We both did extensive travels in our teens and early twenties.

Take home per month 3230.00

910.00 fixed DD Bills (this is rounded up 50.00 to 100.00 goes into savings depending what the actual DD are that month)
200.00 holiday fund
100.00 house maintenance
100.00 car maintenance
250.00 fixed rate savings
150.00 savings hair/dentist/opticians
50.00 gym membership
100.00 Christmas/present fund
850.00 support son in Uni (5 or 6 year medical degree depending if he intercalates)
100.00 petrol
400.00 food for 2 adults (still bulk buy non perishables like tuna, beans, shampoo, toilet roll from Costco for son to take with him back to Uni).

TOTAL 3210.00

It’s to the bone but it is working.

Hope this helps and highlights how other families still save, enjoy their lives and also manage to help their children on much less income than you have. It’s all about priorities and your husband is being very controlling and self centred at the expense of his family.

Lastchancechica · 04/11/2023 07:23

He is completely ripping you off.

FormerlyPathologicallyHappy · 04/11/2023 07:23

At best you’re naive, at worst he’s financially abusing you. You don’t need a joint savings account.

Hes got too much power here.

TammyJones · 04/11/2023 06:57

Startagainjanuary · 03/11/2023 20:00

I don’t understand parents who can afford to help their kids at Uni who choose not to. I budget £850 a month on a lot less income than you to support my son at Uni. He also received 8k from the Gov CTF stocks and shares investment when he turned 18 to use and manage himself as his emergency fund.

Do you have any say in your families affairs?

What do you mean about the eldest keeping a spreadsheet and not helping?

You earn £2800 your DH earns £3100 so £5900 minus £3200 all bills and DD leaves £2700 and he doesn’t want to help his kids in Uni! This is so mean 😪

Edited

I used ti get a monthly food delivery when my kids were at Uni abs other bits.
My son couldn't understand how some of his friends parent could help them , but wouldn't.
And then we wonder why care homes are full of people without any visitors...

TammyJones · 04/11/2023 06:54

HerRoyalNotness · 03/11/2023 19:54

£3200 a month with no mortgage? Does that sound right to you! Interrogate the spreadsheet and each put half in for the bills. Then you can help your DC at uni, spend, save etc the rest of your wage. He can do what he likes with his

Mine are about £600 maybe more with increased fuel.
But if he was paying half the bills surely he keeps doing that.
You'll have no life ....