Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To tell him to stick his budget up his jacksie

233 replies

Wearegoingtoneedabiggerboat · 03/11/2023 19:26

I will start off to say I am aware that I am in a fortunate position financially so don’t wish to offend anyone.
DP and I are on the same pay scale within the NHS, however he earns about £300 a month more than me due to overtime. The trust I work for discourages payment for extra hrs so I tend to take time back for extra hours worked. I am happy with this.
we have separate bank accounts but share finances. Previous to this year DP paid the mortgage and I paid most of the bills. Food, petrol and living expenses went on my credit card which was paid off every month. The bill was divided into 2, with DP transferring his half to me. Now the mortgage has finished we looked at finances again. When I say we, basically DP came up with a plan and decided it was a done deal.
i will say that we would like to retire early 60’s. (We both have around 30 years NHS pension. ) Me hopefully at 60, DP a bit older as he hasn’t enough years for full state pension till 62. I have worked since I was 16, DP qualified at 26. Once DP gets something into his head that’s it he won’t listen to alternative views. Despite having NHS Pension and I also have a small private pension we need to, in DP’s head to save a good portion of our wages a month. I agree that we do need to save and I do need raining in a bit as I’m a bit of a spender, however DP is going completely over the top.
Basically what he has decided is, I will continue to pay bills and all of the food shopping petrol spends for the month which according to his budget spreadsheet should be around £3200 per month. As that is £400 more than I will earn he will transfer that to me, plus £1100 to pay for house renovations (our house is falling down around our ears since we prioritised paying off the mortgage) and money for holidays. So basically I have no money left for myself while he has approx £1700 left. He transfers that straight into our pension fund. If I overspend on our food and spends budget then DP says I just need to use the money he transfers for house and holiday fund.
Also both of our children are in university but at home. The youngest wants to go into student accommodation next year as it’s a bit of a trash for her to travel to university every day. DP has decided she’s a fool and has told her she can’t expect any money from us. At the back of my mind I am thinking he’s not concerned about her leaving home but more concerned that it may cost us money. The oldest he is also refusing to help out and has set up a spreadsheet for any money she owes us.
This is all doing my head in. I have told him there is times when you can’t help going over budget. I am aware however that I need to rain my spending in. He has become totally fixated on saving money but I have told him he’s coming across as a Scrooge, especially surrounding helping the DC’s financially through university. Or is he and I am the one being unreasonable.

OP posts:
Milliemoo6 · 04/11/2023 18:47

He sounds like a joy to live with. Does he have debt that you don't know about, or could he be having an affair? Stand your ground. It's your money and they're your kids. Of course you should help them if they need it.

Doyouthinktheyknow · 04/11/2023 18:20

We take home over a grand less. We give ds1 at university £100 a week and ds2, at university but staying home £50as he commutes.

We also have to top up ds1’s rent as loan doesn’t cover it.

maltravers · 04/11/2023 17:25

I see they are his kids, nevertheless, if I’ve understood you correctly the house is owned jointly (joint tenants?) and the savings are “joint”. Would you be able to leave the kids anything in your Will or is it all co-owned by him?

maltravers · 04/11/2023 17:11

Are they his kids OP? As it stands, if you die there does not appear to be any provision for them. Will he look after them financially? I would get some professional advice tbh.

jeaux90 · 04/11/2023 15:51

Wow OP this man could organise the fun out of a wedding.

Have your morning coffee, help your kids, say no to his "arrangement"

Go 50/50 and with agreed plan for house renovations.

He has way too much control already.

bluegreygreen · 04/11/2023 15:46

I don't think poverty usually involves £350 per month for entertainment.

justasking111 · 04/11/2023 15:38

Startagainjanuary · 04/11/2023 15:13

It’s very strange it’s like DP has held her captive financially speaking with the premise of paying off the mortgage even at the detriment of their falling down house and helping his own children other than with the basics of food and shelter. Now the mortgage is paid off DP has found another financial ruse to keep her captive to his miserly ways. It’s almost like she has financial Stockholm Syndrome (if that even exists). OP works hard and has done since she was 16 and yet has to bow down to her DP’s financial demands in fear of his retribution. It’s so financially abusive and the family dynamics must be scary to live with.

Edited

The falling down house is concerning if they don't spend money to put it right while working/earning he won't spend the pension on it. Which means downsizing by selling a doer upper to someone prepared to invest in it.

@Wearegoingtoneedabiggerboat is drowning disappearing down a plughole of poverty while surrounded by money . It will get so much worse once she retires

Debtfreegoals · 04/11/2023 15:34

To answer the title of the thread… yes I would!

Blanketpolicy · 04/11/2023 15:14

Wearegoingtoneedabiggerboat · 03/11/2023 20:18

Sorry for the confusion I meant it’s just a savings account in joint names that he calls pension fund.
I totally agree with helping kids out I think it’s what parents should do. He’s just obsessed at the minute down to even saying we can only have 1 coffee out a week. I used to get a coffee in the way to work in the morning, indulgent I know but gave me a bit of a pick me up before starting work in the morning.

It would make more sense to pay AVCs into actual pension funds to get the tax benefits than have a joint savings account.

I can see how he can become very focussed on retiral saving (I can be sometimes too!) once you reach an age that you are thinking about pensions and potential target ages to retire.

Surely after 25 years together the pair of you should be pooling all your finances and agreeing what your combined goals are (including if/how much you will support your children) and maximising your joint available income together rather than working against each other in silos where one side is a spender for life now and the other is a saver for the future. Sounds like you both have to make compromises, and need a better way of financially planning together.

Startagainjanuary · 04/11/2023 15:13

It’s very strange it’s like DP has held her captive financially speaking with the premise of paying off the mortgage even at the detriment of their falling down house and helping his own children other than with the basics of food and shelter. Now the mortgage is paid off DP has found another financial ruse to keep her captive to his miserly ways. It’s almost like she has financial Stockholm Syndrome (if that even exists). OP works hard and has done since she was 16 and yet has to bow down to her DP’s financial demands in fear of his retribution. It’s so financially abusive and the family dynamics must be scary to live with.

FictionalCharacter · 04/11/2023 15:11

Wearegoingtoneedabiggerboat · 04/11/2023 12:47

Thanks for everyone’s advice, pleased to think I AIBU in regards to this budget. Like I said before I do need to reign (not rain as I previously wrote🥴) my spending in, as I agree realistically over 3 k for bills, food, and spends seems a lot.
So if the DC’s are at home and you had my budget what would you be giving them. Would £100 a month each be fair.
I am looking as well to see solicitors as well to write our wills. DP reckons we can do it DIY.

Of course he wants to do it DIY, it's cheap. Please don't, get it done professionally.

Please do what PPs suggest and set up your own savings account. The one your DP set up isn't a pension fund. It's a savings account in his name. I know you trust him but he could meet another woman and walk off with the money. Even if he doesn't do anything like that, he'll be in control of the cash and you won't be able to spend it. It will be entirely his.

Not sure why you're asking about how much to give the dc. They're living at home, surely you're paying their living expenses. What's really concerning is that your P seems to think they should be paying you back (the spreadsheet thing is dreadful). He wants the kids to pay back the money he spent on being a parent. I find that despicable.

Most parents save money to support their kids through university. Yours will only get the minimum student loan because of your incomes. The rest has to come from somewhere and most parents make up the difference. Look at the money saving expert website.

BTW it's rein in not reign!

Hibiscrubbed · 04/11/2023 15:07

Christ on a bike, OP. You’re in such a precarious position. He has it all.

You’re falling out over this. His behaviour is unreasonable. Are you sure you want to trust him?

justasking111 · 04/11/2023 15:03

Startagainjanuary · 04/11/2023 15:02

She’s frightened of his reaction to her spending money on their daughters that’s the uncomfortable bit she’s trying her best. Probably masks it in the food shopping.

Edited

Which is appalling. Whats he going to do lock her in the cellar or the attic

Startagainjanuary · 04/11/2023 15:02

She’s frightened of his reaction to her spending money on their daughters that’s the uncomfortable bit she’s trying her best. Probably masks it in the food shopping.

bluegreygreen · 04/11/2023 14:59

Is no-one else uncomfortable about the fact that the OP's (large) amount for monthly bills includes money that she doesn't tell her husband she gives the children?

I can clearly see reasons he can be criticised, but if he is trying to work out budgets to maximise their pensions and doesn't know where the money is going he may be finding things very stressful.

endofthelinefinally · 04/11/2023 14:58

LusciousLondoner · 04/11/2023 14:25

See OP's post at 20:46 yesterday

She says "house is in both our names". That doesn't address any of the other issues that need to be included during the process of writing the wills. Particularly in the case of partners who are not married. It is perfectly fine not to be married, but it does mean that the specifics of property ownership need to be clearly addressed.

justasking111 · 04/11/2023 14:56

When the physical passion goes out of a marriage/relationship some men weigh up financial gains and losses re the relationship. Are you worth hanging onto or would a house keeper be cheaper.

IncompleteSenten · 04/11/2023 14:46

What would he do if you refused?

You don't have to obey him.

You could say no I will not be doing that.

What would happen?

Startagainjanuary · 04/11/2023 14:46

Their daughters choices in life are stifled by their fathers controlling miserly nature. The OP is trying to counteract his financial abuse by giving them some breathing space by giving them money from just her wages however, her DP is trying to dictate how she spends her wages!

The parents bring in £5900.00 take home each month with no mortgage and the OP can’t even tell her DP that she pays for her daughters toiletries and travel because she is scared of his reaction.

Her DP refuses to give any financial aid, no help if they want to move out and live nearer Uni, no driving lessons and everything spent extra to house and food added to a spreadsheet which will have to be repaid in the future under his family REIGN! This is even considering that after bills they have £2700.00 left every month. This is not normal in family life and I hope the daughters can see this for the financial abuse that it is.

justasking111 · 04/11/2023 14:46

Wearegoingtoneedabiggerboat · 04/11/2023 14:43

I am currently paying their mobiles and oldest DC’s contact lenses. DP doesn’t know this.

Tell him, you're not blowing it on anything frivolous are you

IncompleteSenten · 04/11/2023 14:44

I'd tell him to fuck off.

Pay the bills jointly and save separately.

Him using every penny you earn while putting his wage into what you call "our" pension fund could see you getting royally screwed over

Wearegoingtoneedabiggerboat · 04/11/2023 14:43

I am currently paying their mobiles and oldest DC’s contact lenses. DP doesn’t know this.

OP posts:
justasking111 · 04/11/2023 14:42

The rent for halls two years ago was £180 per week, plus near 10k for tuition fees, it's means tested. I'm surmising that the parents income is taken into account which affects grants. You don't get a pass for subsequent children. We worked on a budget of 20k for our DS

Wearegoingtoneedabiggerboat · 04/11/2023 14:41

Rein it in . 😂.

OP posts:
cestlavielife · 04/11/2023 14:36

Are both uni kids getting student maintenance loan? They should be doing their own spends out of that.
If they move to student accoomodation may need topping up
Who pays their mobile?