Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To tell him to stick his budget up his jacksie

233 replies

Wearegoingtoneedabiggerboat · 03/11/2023 19:26

I will start off to say I am aware that I am in a fortunate position financially so don’t wish to offend anyone.
DP and I are on the same pay scale within the NHS, however he earns about £300 a month more than me due to overtime. The trust I work for discourages payment for extra hrs so I tend to take time back for extra hours worked. I am happy with this.
we have separate bank accounts but share finances. Previous to this year DP paid the mortgage and I paid most of the bills. Food, petrol and living expenses went on my credit card which was paid off every month. The bill was divided into 2, with DP transferring his half to me. Now the mortgage has finished we looked at finances again. When I say we, basically DP came up with a plan and decided it was a done deal.
i will say that we would like to retire early 60’s. (We both have around 30 years NHS pension. ) Me hopefully at 60, DP a bit older as he hasn’t enough years for full state pension till 62. I have worked since I was 16, DP qualified at 26. Once DP gets something into his head that’s it he won’t listen to alternative views. Despite having NHS Pension and I also have a small private pension we need to, in DP’s head to save a good portion of our wages a month. I agree that we do need to save and I do need raining in a bit as I’m a bit of a spender, however DP is going completely over the top.
Basically what he has decided is, I will continue to pay bills and all of the food shopping petrol spends for the month which according to his budget spreadsheet should be around £3200 per month. As that is £400 more than I will earn he will transfer that to me, plus £1100 to pay for house renovations (our house is falling down around our ears since we prioritised paying off the mortgage) and money for holidays. So basically I have no money left for myself while he has approx £1700 left. He transfers that straight into our pension fund. If I overspend on our food and spends budget then DP says I just need to use the money he transfers for house and holiday fund.
Also both of our children are in university but at home. The youngest wants to go into student accommodation next year as it’s a bit of a trash for her to travel to university every day. DP has decided she’s a fool and has told her she can’t expect any money from us. At the back of my mind I am thinking he’s not concerned about her leaving home but more concerned that it may cost us money. The oldest he is also refusing to help out and has set up a spreadsheet for any money she owes us.
This is all doing my head in. I have told him there is times when you can’t help going over budget. I am aware however that I need to rain my spending in. He has become totally fixated on saving money but I have told him he’s coming across as a Scrooge, especially surrounding helping the DC’s financially through university. Or is he and I am the one being unreasonable.

OP posts:
itsalongwaybackfromsorry · 05/11/2023 10:43

You need to get your half of the money into an account with your name on it.

You are not protected here.

and you are not hearing everyone.

You are in an incredibly precarious position with him being so mean and dictating what will and will not be allowed financially, and you trying to support your joint children out of your money on your own.

My dad screwed over my mum in this manner back in the day ... she did her best for us, then he waltzed off with the bulk of the money.

Jewel52 · 05/11/2023 10:32

LusciousLondoner · 03/11/2023 20:11

If you're not married this sounds VERY financially dangerous for you. He's getting all the bills paid for him now whilst he's stuffing his pension. Sounds like a great deal for him! You might trust him now but things can unexpectedly change.

This. Pensions are individual and you need to secure your own financial future. I’m concerned that you are paying into a form of investment that’s solely in his name? I had to fight tooth and nail to secure a reasonable proportion of my ex’s pension and we were married for 20 years and I trusted him till I found out I couldn’t. It’s really scary to be in your fifties and planning for a poor retirement. He’s being selfish towards your offspring so why do you expect open handedness towards you?

Notmetoo · 05/11/2023 10:24

I feel very sorry for your children. Our income was smaller than yours but our main priority was always to support our children.we supported then both through university with accomodation fees etc and wouldn't dream of keeping a spreadsheet of how much we gave them.
If you chose to have children then you have a responsibility to support them as much as you can to complete their education. It's very different of course if you don't have the means but you and your husband do.
I wouldn't accept his 'suggestion' it's mean, controlling and probably unnecessary.

Ginmonkeyagain · 05/11/2023 10:13

I also don't understand why you both prioritised paying off the mortgage early if it meant neglecting essential home repairs. No point owning something outright that is falling down.

It sounds like he had mental health issues that are manifesting themsleves in irrational anxiety about money.

justasking111 · 05/11/2023 09:23

We're in a small cul de sac nine properties. Two are owned by retired NHS workers. With their index linked pensions they're doing well. One couple spent £150k renovating their house and garden. The others both have new cars every three years and fly first class to Australia every two years.

It's bizarre that having paid off the mortgage he's so obsessed with income.

Totaly · 05/11/2023 09:00

Zebedee55 yes the op said

Zebedee55 · 05/11/2023 08:59

He won't get a full state pension at 62, or any part of it. State pensions aren't paid until the correct age, whatever his contributions.

Cornishgorl44 · 05/11/2023 08:29

We are in a similar position to you op. Four DC between us. Two live with their mum, the one at uni gets a huge loan 10k and we still help her out. My two live away at uni but get £4.6k a year. DH insists that they get the same as his DD! And we also save. My point is. A loan does not cover much when kids are away at uni. Even with savings and working it’s nice to help them out x

TrishyLou1111 · 05/11/2023 08:02

maddening · 05/11/2023 07:47

It is "to not" rather than "not not". You need to be correct if public forum pedantry is your thing.

😆😆

Wimin123 · 05/11/2023 07:50

Can you imagine how much fun early retirement with him will be - he will be counting every penny. You will end up going back to work….

maddening · 05/11/2023 07:47

isthewashingdryyet · 04/11/2023 13:01

Rein in, the reign with a g, is what Charles does, and rain is very wet 🙄

sorry, I think you are right not not agree with him

It is "to not" rather than "not not". You need to be correct if public forum pedantry is your thing.

GracieE17 · 05/11/2023 07:38

Unfortunately, being together this long will mean absolutely nothing if something happens to him. It has just happened to my SIL. 30 years, seriously ill in ITC overnight and died. Not married and not entitled to any of his estate. Those savings need to go into a joint account at the very minimum. You should put an equal amount into a joint account to pay all the bills etc. Also, what kind of father won’t help his daughter at university? I’d be questioning longevity with someone so mean.

Catdaddy1978 · 05/11/2023 06:11

For me, I get the impression that your partner is panicked over the cost of living crisis and has gone into survival mode. However, that does not justify his behaviour which is controlling. I would suggest like the others to put forward an alternative budget, that allows for both of you to have spending money as well as offering your children some money to support them at university. I didn’t ask for a penny off my parents when I was at university but they did come through with the money from time to time and helped me out when I was really struggling and I was glad of it. I think the joint account for the bills is a good idea and maybe he can be put in charge of making sure the weekly shop is within budget or perhaps the renovations themselves as he clearly needs something to control finance-wise. Finally, take that morning coffee, you work in the NHS and it’s a stressful job - you need it!

Dotcomma · 05/11/2023 02:53

The bit about the driving lessons & him coming out in a cold sweat made me howl 🤣 Why is he so hung up on being tight about everything - is there a reason? I could understand it if either of your jobs were at risk but you've no mortgage and that's a real good place to be in financially. The kids are grown up and at Uni, their fees are paid etc so it's basically maintenance they need, do either of them have a part time job? How come he doesn't know that you pay for their travel & toiletries - he sounds a bit controlling.

TomatoSandwiches · 05/11/2023 00:53

SassyOldBroad · 05/11/2023 00:48

I was in this situation with my husband and it destroyed our marriage, because I tried to go along with it until I couldn't anymore. Put all your money in one (metaphorical) pot, include spending money, and each pays according to the percentage that goes in. If you need 500 spending money, then it comes out of the shared pot.

Marriage is a shared venture; he is treating it like a dictatorship. Come down hard on him; this behavior is not okay.

Op is not married to this man.
She is completely vulnerable.

SassyOldBroad · 05/11/2023 00:48

I was in this situation with my husband and it destroyed our marriage, because I tried to go along with it until I couldn't anymore. Put all your money in one (metaphorical) pot, include spending money, and each pays according to the percentage that goes in. If you need 500 spending money, then it comes out of the shared pot.

Marriage is a shared venture; he is treating it like a dictatorship. Come down hard on him; this behavior is not okay.

IamMoodyBlue · 04/11/2023 23:26

Yes, work on reining in your spending if you think it's a good idea.
No, don't agree to this budget.
Sort out a fair division, arrange your own debits and be prepared for tantrums

But stick to your guns. There's a good chance that once he's established himself as your financial boss he won't shift. Ever.

Flossflower · 04/11/2023 21:58

I think your partner is being financially abusive both to you and your children. The fact that you are having to not tell him what you give the children is bad.
As a parent you should be helping your children through university. I appreciate that some people can not afford to but you both clearly can.
Early retirement with such a tightwad is not going to be fun!

croydon15 · 04/11/2023 21:28

I cannot believe that he has done a spreadsheet showing how much DC owe, most decent parents especially well off one will and should help their children; there is a balance in saving and being a scrooge as he's, not an endearing feature actual fact l would tell him to f.off

Coco1379 · 04/11/2023 21:15

Insist every bill is split in half. Then if he wants to save what is left of his wage he can. You do whatever you like with yours. If he demurs just buy your own food, the petol you use and half the household bills.
DP and I live in my house and use my car. I paid the mortgage, house insurance and car insurance, petrol etc. as he does not drive. Any other expenditure is split in two, even if it is for home improvement (he says we both have the benefit and he does not expect to have any claim on my house). After that we both spend our own money as we please.

pmama · 04/11/2023 19:55

Transfer half of the saving account money to your own account - tell him that you are also getting some financial advice. This way you can control your fair share - and there would be no future issues. Only cover the same amount as he suggested from his side, but - sorry OP - with some strict budgeting. Bills, basic food. All other stuff, those should be an extra and fairly shared. Be open with the uni children. I am sorry, but if they can live at home, that is a big saving for them. They should be aware of it. For 4 people, even for adults, 3k plus is a lot without mortgage (and extras like holidays). 2k should be even a very comfortable amount. As a start, check what you bought last month, and cut all non-basic items, that would be the starting point.

wildwestpioneer · 04/11/2023 19:54

If he won't compromise and help come up with a plan together I'd split finances and stop sharing finances. He can split the savings into diffeeent saving accounts, and you both put in % in line with your earnings, for bills and also an amount for holidays and children's expenses. He can then choose to save what he has left and you can choose to help the dc out, although he should put some money aside for his children's expenses.

Lindyloomillion1 · 04/11/2023 19:46

Do your own budget and explain to him how you want things to work financially in the future.
No reason for you to accept his take on things. You're in a partnership, you negotiate when you're not in agreement.

AllyArty · 04/11/2023 19:11

Sounds like a good deal - for him!

Zerosleep · 04/11/2023 19:04

I’m sorry OP but fuck that. I work full time and I am in a role I worked very hard to achieve. No man is telling me how to spend even if it is in the name do having a comfy retirement. Everything should be split 50:50. If DH wants to bang what is left of his into his pensions, then that’s on him. You can spend yours how you like. Alternatively you both put something in your pension to build it further and you keep some back for both of you. Also if DH is banging £1700 a month into the pension then I suggest you make sure it’s a joint pension or you split that half half between your pension and his.