Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To stop making a fuss over mat leavers

64 replies

Kiwilime · 03/11/2023 15:13

Why are we still making a huge fuss and having collections and parties in the workplace for people leaving temporararily to have a baby? Aibu to think it's inappropriate and outdated?

Someone at my work is going on mat leave and we've all been aggressively pressured by her line manager to contribute to a leaving gift. Sorry but I simply didn't want to, I'm trying to grapple with mortgage and bill increases, but I'll look like an arse if I don't.

Babies are hard work, but everyone is treating her like she's off on a 1 year jolly up, and celebrating a baby who hasn't arrived yet. This colleague has been quite ill throughout her pregnancy, has GD, baby is small, and she's facing an induction, she's not exactly stoked right now, but having to grin and be happy for everyone else?

Also it's treated with faux excitement by bosses and employers - the reality is that from the moment you have a kid they subconsciously cut you out and dismiss you from opportunities and career progression. That's not anything to celebrate.

Also for context I don't have kids myself but would like to in the future, just not at that stage of my life yet. (There's no jealousy or animosity about the having the baby part, before someone predictably suggests it!)

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Growlybear83 · 10/01/2024 16:08

I think everywhere I've ever worked has marked someone leaving, retiring, or going on maternity leave with a collection and nice present. I assumed it was the norm everywhere.

AgnesX · 10/01/2024 16:02

Isn't it all about congratulating and anticipating bringing a new life into the world.

Whichever way you look at it it it's still something special.

Goldenbear · 10/01/2024 15:59

And to add, I got bought an expensive spa voucher as well and I didn't even work there!

Goldenbear · 10/01/2024 15:55

Kiwilime · 03/11/2023 15:23

@Moreempatheticmyarse Specifically mat leave because there's so many elements to it. It's complicated. Retirement is a celebration of sorts, you're freed from the shackles of employment. Birthdays aren't going to directly affect your career progression (unless you're over 50). But equally any enforced personal celebration at work is unnecessary imo. I've never seen or heard of paternity parties. That is an interesting concept though as a guy at work recently became a dad and there was no fanfare for him.

My DH works in Architecture so fairly male dominated and back in 2011 received a load of presents for the birth of our DC!

OhwhyOY · 10/01/2024 15:50

YABU. It's an exciting time in life that many people don't do often. It's nice to celebrate. Maternity is an uncertain time and it's nice to feel your colleagues care.

LetsPlayShadowlands · 04/11/2023 17:50

My work place has 2-3 collections a month due to the number of staff in the department. I stopped contributing a number of years ago unless it's someone who means something to me, or feel like I have to (close colleague illness for example).

Jericha · 04/11/2023 14:06

I'm currently on (my second) maternity leave and have been told all staff changes and of every job opportunity I may be interested in. Before I left, my team had a whip round for both me and the baby. I had a really hard pregnancy and knew when baby would be coming and it really cheered me up. My boss travelled 50 miles with a colleague to meet my baby and catch up in person at my house. I have been invited to all social outings while off, even though they knew I probably wouldn't go. I don't feel left out or that i had force a smile.

When I went off for my first mat leave it was the same - I actually applied for a job I was told of while off and returned into my new role with a £20k pay rise.

There's no pressure at my work to go overboard, but my boss and colleagues are such lovely people even if they're not "friends". I have no problem reciprocating either, in fact a colleague is having all of my baby's stuff instead of me selling it as she's about to have her first and I'm not having any more kids.

We only do milestone birthdays and there's not many of us of "child bearing age" so we aren't all spewing tenners all the time and I don't think people are celebration fatigued. It's easy to opt out of bunging some money in the collection, no one would even care. If you don't agree don't take part.

Didimum · 04/11/2023 13:47

You sound quite miserable, OP.

No, you shouldn’t be pressured into contributing to a gift, but what does it matter whether that it for a wedding, big birthday, arrival of a new baby, or whatever?

Most positive milestones are celebrated in society, and as you spend a significant amount of time with your colleagues and are embarking on a new part of life where you won’t see them for some time, it stands to reason that they will make a fuss of you and wish you well with all the usual trimmings of a celebration.

If she had had such a difficult pregnancy, don’t you think it’s a nice thing that they are trying to inject some positivity and warm wishes to her time ahead? Should only women experiencing easy pregnancies be given a celebratory send off? If not, then why bring up how her difficulties shouldn’t warrant one?

Do you know she is ‘gritting her teeth and bearing it’? Has she told you that?

If this is really all about just not wanting to spare your money right now then have it just be about that, tell your manager in confidence that you cannot afford it right now, and stop being so miserable.

Findyourneutralspace · 04/11/2023 13:11

If your workplace actively discriminates against mothers as you say, I think you’ve got bigger issues than a quid in an envelope. I’d be looking for a new job.

fitzwilliamdarcy · 04/11/2023 13:05

TANBU to do collections and YANBU to not contribute.

My workplace goes all out for these things and I’ve stopped contributing now as I’ve spent so much money over the last 8 years and I’m unlikely to experience it myself (single, childless, not moving house etc). Most of my colleagues have had 3-5 big collections in the last 8 years whereas I’ve had 0.

Just life really and I never say anything negative at work, but I’m another who relates to Carrie Bradshaw on this one!

MammaTo · 04/11/2023 12:58

No one should be pressured into giving to collections etc, that’s out of order. But I found when I left on maternity before last year people were genuinely excited for me to have the baby and all the experiences that come with it.
I don’t know if it’s a bit of a shared experience by people who have also been on maternity leave too - I don’t like being that person that says “you don’t understand unless you have kids” but I think it’s more of a mutual understanding perhaps?

Chocolatelabradorsarethebest · 04/11/2023 12:51

‘Also for context I don't have kids myself’

Funnily enough I didn’t need you to confirm this! Going off on May leave is a big deal for many new mums and also a chance for colleagues to say good bye for a year. If you don’t want to get involved don’t, or just chuck a quid in and sign the card. It’s what most people do to be nice to mark a life event for a lot of people.

Scottishskifun · 04/11/2023 12:39

I don't know where you work but quite concerned that your employer potentially is breaking the law on discrimination by overlooking someone because they have a baby!

You might not be interested OP but others are, don't put in the collection if you don't want to simple as that!

windypumpkin · 04/11/2023 12:33

I just say im doing my own thing and get a card and some chocolate for mum

Soontobe60 · 04/11/2023 12:31

Kiwilime · 03/11/2023 15:23

@Moreempatheticmyarse Specifically mat leave because there's so many elements to it. It's complicated. Retirement is a celebration of sorts, you're freed from the shackles of employment. Birthdays aren't going to directly affect your career progression (unless you're over 50). But equally any enforced personal celebration at work is unnecessary imo. I've never seen or heard of paternity parties. That is an interesting concept though as a guy at work recently became a dad and there was no fanfare for him.

Ive always worked in schools where a new baby is celebrated in some way. Why wouldnt you?

TheKeatingFive · 04/11/2023 12:29

You seem to have very complicated feelings about this and I'm not sure why.

Kiwilime · 04/11/2023 12:21

Yes @Unexpectedlysinglemum there's no better way to bond with your team than to force them to sit through hours of cooing and ahhing, and baby advice nonsense, and also force them to pay for a gift!

OP posts:
Unexpectedlysinglemum · 03/11/2023 21:40

Yabu and Scrooge like (unless you have trauma like miscarriages then you can just opt out). You don't have to pay anything but don't begrudge your colleagues wanting to celebrate and encourage your colleague on this huge life transition. Becoming a mother is a massive deal. It's a nice way for the team to bond too.

Milkmani · 03/11/2023 21:05

@Kiwilime Exactly it is such a waste. I have only ever gifted gift cards or a neutral item with a gift receipt should it not be suitable or to the recipient’s taste. People think they need to go over and above but once most women’s maternity pay runs out I’m sure they wouldn’t mind a supermarket gift card where you can buy both baby clothes and groceries or a coffee shop gift card for when the new mum wants to get out the house.

Kiwilime · 03/11/2023 20:57

@Milkmani Doesn't sound ungrateful at all. Sounds like you're conscious of waste and inconvenience, which most people don't appear to care about. Love that you tried to book the baby shower day off but they changed it to another day!

OP posts:
Milkmani · 03/11/2023 20:37

@Kiwilime Yes you’re right! I had a difficult pregnancy, repeatedly told manager I didn’t want a baby shower (they just love it at my place) She ignored my wishes and I then booked the day of the BS off. Surprise surprise she then sprung it upon me another day. Giant bloody cake (which the smell of made me feel ill) and insisted I take home the cake that wasn’t finished. A nappy cake, what new parent doesn’t love unfurling hundreds of tightly rolled nappies?! Super small newborn outfits, couldn’t use them as my son I was large and it was evident as I was carrying big and kept being asked if I was having twins. Chunky 0-3 month cardigans from Jojo Maman for a baby born in early June. I think my colleagues contributed over £150 in total for gifts that I couldn’t use. Honestly wish they had kept their money, like you said COL and all that. The thought is kind but more often than not it’s usually not the mum to be that enjoys the BS. Some will say it’s ungrateful but honestly a card and some flowers would suffice.

Kiwilime · 03/11/2023 20:31

Yes exactly this. It was via transfer so they know exactly who has contributed. The line manager involved is very loose lipped when she's had a drink, very judgy and bitchy, and I can imagine her telling everyone at drinks or the Christmas party exactly who doesn't contribute to collections.

OP posts:
BeingATwatItsABingThing · 03/11/2023 20:18

Loverofoxbowlakes · 03/11/2023 19:44

I have a colleague who left for mat leave today. Not close, not on my team but in same office.

There has been a baby shower (with gift list for invitees who also had to pay for the meal/venue), office collection and card, and apparently an expectation from colleagues that when the baby arrives they'll take a gift for the baby, something for the older sibling and 'a little something so mum can spoil herself'. So, a huge expense, potentially for her closest colleagues/friends.

Since being with the company there has also been a wedding (overseas hen do expense, wedding attendance expenses and gift) and the same rigmarole for the first dc.

It's madness. I'm not a fan of baby showers or fancy hen do's anyway, the whole thing feels really grabby.

Yay, you got hitched and dropped a couple of sprogs. I need to do a Carrie Bradshaw and make my own 'I'm not getting married/reproducing gift registry...'

What madness is this?! I wouldn’t want my closest friends and family to spend this much, let alone colleagues!

LizzBurg · 03/11/2023 20:11

I bet you’re fun at a party. Lighten up, either stick a quid in and sign the card or say you don’t want to and own it. I personally choose to wish my colleagues well when they are going on maternity leave as I’m excited for them, about to start the rollercoaster ride that is having children and I never understand why people think to take pleasure in relaying childbirth or baby horror stories. And if the inequality of no collection etc for male colleagues bothers you that much, be the change and the next time someone takes paternity leave get a card and start the collection.

Loverofoxbowlakes · 03/11/2023 19:44

I have a colleague who left for mat leave today. Not close, not on my team but in same office.

There has been a baby shower (with gift list for invitees who also had to pay for the meal/venue), office collection and card, and apparently an expectation from colleagues that when the baby arrives they'll take a gift for the baby, something for the older sibling and 'a little something so mum can spoil herself'. So, a huge expense, potentially for her closest colleagues/friends.

Since being with the company there has also been a wedding (overseas hen do expense, wedding attendance expenses and gift) and the same rigmarole for the first dc.

It's madness. I'm not a fan of baby showers or fancy hen do's anyway, the whole thing feels really grabby.

Yay, you got hitched and dropped a couple of sprogs. I need to do a Carrie Bradshaw and make my own 'I'm not getting married/reproducing gift registry...'