Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think it’s not fair that we cut public services so that older adults pay less for care?

159 replies

Bristol2021 · 03/11/2023 13:58

I work in a local authority which is facing an unprecedented budget deficit, like most councils across the country. Most of the deficit is due to the government demanding that councils pay the ‘fair cost of care’ - demanding they negotiate with local care providers so that the same rate is charged to councils as to people paying out of pocket (who are not eligible for free care). This brings the cost to private payers down a bit, but raises the cost to most councils by £tens of millions. As a result all councils are having to cut hundreds or thousands of jobs, and cut back any services (things like arts and leisure, homelessness prevention, remaining children’s centres) to what is required by law, and lower standards of what’s left. This is all so that relatively affluent older adults pay less out of pocket for care. Those people still get the lifetime cap on care costs regardless of what they pay per week of care. This is the main reason so many councils are facing bankruptcy (with a few exceptions where there’s been serious financial mismanagement). It seems to me that most tax payers are going to see far worse public services, all so that some older adults can pass on more inheritance at the end of their lives. They’re not going to spend much on themselves once they’re dependant in care, so I find it unbelievable that the ‘injustice’ of paying more than a local authority (who are a bulk purchaser) for a care package is being used to justify driving councils to bankruptcy and decimating services for everyone else. Do people not realise this is happening, or do people just care more about their inheritance than they do about schools, rubbish collection, roads, child protection, public health..?

OP posts:
Nothanksthanksanyway · 03/11/2023 18:54

hmmm. I’m not sure you’re right. The budget for children / children in care , working age adults with LD / Autism / sensory etc is much more significant. Older population has increased, but they aren’t to blame for the disastrous state of local authorities budgets ( blame the government and they’re misguided view that money to the nhs is the answer to everything!) ! I’ve known of packages of almost a million a year for young people.

WrongSwanson · 03/11/2023 18:53

My understanding is that people funding their own care effectively pay a premium to subsidise those being funded by councils. Why do you think that is fair

Exactly, I spoke to someone who runs a carehome business and he quite freely told me this is what happens. They have to keep certain level of private residents in order to be able to accept any local authority referrals, because they private payers subsidise the local authority ones.

It's disgusting.

I have no issue with more taxation if needed, but the current set up where particular individuals (those that need care) take a huge hit for the state is completely unfair.

Sisterpita · 03/11/2023 18:48

@Bristol2021 wht do you think it is fair for those who can pay for their own care to pay more than a council funded person for the same level of care?

My understanding is that people funding their own care effectively pay a premium to subsidise those being funded by councils. Why do you think that is fair?

I believe those who can afford to should contribute or fully pay for care. I don’t subscribe to the why should they sell their home - they no longer need it, why should our inheritance be used - it’s not an inheritance until they have died and they deserve to be in a place they are looked after.

WRT care costs, a basic calculation I do is NMW £10.42 x 24 hours in a day x 365 days in a year = £91,279.20. That doesn’t include employer NI & pension contributions plus cover for annual leave etc. Effectively if you had carers in your home 24/7 it is £100k a year plus all the standard utility bills, council tax, insurance etc. Residential and nursing homes achieve economies of scale but no way should self funders subsidise council funded places.

The reality is if we want services we all need to be prepared to pay more tax to fund councils etc.

VerityUnreasonble · 03/11/2023 18:47

fetchacloth · 03/11/2023 17:49

Yes, I've often wondered that too.🤔
I totally get it for someone that might need a high level of supervision, for example a dementia patient, but otherwise why on earth does it cost so much?
I can only surmise that it's a combination of shortfall of funding from councils and profit taking from the proprietor.
I really do think the whole market needs a shake up.

To be in a care home (certainly of funded by the LA) you would expect someone to have a level of need which means they need support available all the time, or close to. If you can manage at home with 4 visits a day from carers that's all the LA will fund.

There are 168 hours in a week, so at 1kish that's under £6 per hour for care / food / laundry / accommodation / heating / cleaning.

A room in a house share near me costs around £100 - 175, including bills. So that takes it down to about £5 per hour for care.

Take off say £10 a day for food, another say £20 a week for cleaning, £5 for laundry. That's £4.50 per hour for care.

Also need to pay a proportion of the cost for care home manager, deputy, kitchen staff, care taker etc. let's say a total of 2k per week? So for a home with 40 residents that's another £50.

So we are now down to £4.20 per hour for the actual carers. Carer's probably actually get £9-12 per hour but will cost the company a bit more than that for training, pensions, payroll etc.

There are other costs I've not included I'm sure.

So one person's 1k actually probably pays for maybe 1/3rd of a carer per hour? If that?

I don't know if that's good value but if you pay for care at home you are probably paying around £30 an hour for the care you receive, so would get maybe 24 hours, 3.5 hours a day for the same care costs.

PhoebesHusband · 03/11/2023 18:43

So far, so Mumsnet, so predictable. The usual errors.
Lets Blame the Tories.
Trust Funds to avoid taxation. My understanding is that over recent years many of the old loopholes have been closed. So that has gone.
Many tax levels have increased over the last 10 years.
Where is the pool of untaxed income that Labour can drain?
Or shall we completely revolutionise the tax system and levy a tax on existing assets. A Wealth Tax? Shall we Confiscate Orphan Assets in banks?
To us these look simple but they would be revolutionary. Fierce debate at home and there would be huge disquiet around the world. It would be about trust in the UK..

WrongSwanson · 03/11/2023 18:40

anniegun · 03/11/2023 17:19

I think you have this completley wrong. Its just a ruling that stops private care providers exploiting either LA's or paying customers . Neither should subsidise the other, the same rates for the same care should apply

Agree with this

WrongSwanson · 03/11/2023 18:37

I think what the govt is doing to local government is dire.

But isnt ok to ask private individuals to subsidise social care of others

WrongSwanson · 03/11/2023 18:37

I think what the govt is doing to local government is dire.

But isnt ok to ask private individuals to subsidise social care of others

Coshofliving · 03/11/2023 18:34

It's not just care home costs. Ofc most people don't go into care homes. But loads need adaptations, little bit of help with cleaning, frames, scooters, home visits etc. None of that is cheap.

nonumbersinthisname · 03/11/2023 18:33

Care isn’t just care homes. Even more elderly people are supported at home with carers, because that’s cheaper than a care home. My DM has carers visit 4x a day and pays £1.3k a month for the privilege. It’s rapidly using up her savings, and she still has to pay for all the overheads of owning a house.

Because the services are contracted out and the carers aren’t employed by the council, we all pay more to ensure the caring company make a profit while the hard working careers get minimum wage. “The market will find a solution” has been the mantra for 40+ years and is bollocks.

HelpNeededBeforeIHaveABreakdown · 03/11/2023 18:28

Care for older adults IS a public service.

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 03/11/2023 18:26

Yanbu, anyone with an ounce of sense could see the elderly care timebomb ticking down for decades. Yet, as they've done with pretty much everything else, the generations in power have buried their heads in the sand and are now trying to pass the responsibility on, to the detriment of younger generations generations.

The level of mismanagement, greed, ineptitude, corruption, and selfishness displayed over the last 60 years, and especially the last 40, is rage inducing.

Theeyeballsinthesky · 03/11/2023 18:25

It’s the current picture - out of 11 million older people over 65, currently aprox 500,000 currently reside in a care home. Regarding future care home needs, that’s predicted to rise over the next 10/20 years but equally the vast majority of people who need to go into a care home will be home owners

however its also likely that we won’t be able to meet the demand

https://www.caremanagementmatters.co.uk/feature/darting-through-the-decades-future-demand-for-older-peoples-care-homes/

Darting through the decades: Future demand for older people’s care homes

Recent research from Knight Frank shows care home operators could face cost increases of up to 30% over the coming year, what does the future for the sector look like?

https://www.caremanagementmatters.co.uk/feature/darting-through-the-decades-future-demand-for-older-peoples-care-homes/

Theunamedcat · 03/11/2023 18:23

The quicker the pensioner burns through there money the quicker they have to foot the entire bill

sittinginacafe · 03/11/2023 18:19

@Theeyeballsinthesky is this really true: ‘The vast majority of older people never go near a care home. Out of 11 million people over 65 only aprox 500,000 go into a care home. ‘???

or is that the current care home population (a v different thing)

Coshofliving · 03/11/2023 18:08

It's all a bit of a gamble at mid income levels isn't it? Are you going to make it to the finish line without getting stung for all sorts to keep you alive? If so you'll be better off "buying" your house [even though the house will go on long after you do and cost each successive purchaser more to occupy the same space so essentially the concept is bullshit] and saving. That means you'll still die but you'll die with a cash balance in credit. On the other hand if you're not going to be left with anything anyway you might as well spend as you go and have as nice a life as you can. One way or other you'll be paying tax regardless and you'll have spent 40+ years working. The only variation is people who've amassed enough to leave a substantial inheritance, and even then they themselves won't see the benefits of that. Takes a good four generations all doing the same with no mishaps/wars/catastrophic life events to feel the benefit to point of not having to worry.

BIossomtoes · 03/11/2023 18:04

Fifteenth · 03/11/2023 18:00

It’s because Govt pays. If it didn’t then markets would have forced mechanisation and other means of cost cutting.

It’s not because the government pays - in most cases it doesn’t. It’s because the ratio of staff is very high and is required 24/7. It’s perfectly obvious to anyone who’s ever stepped inside a decent care home why the fees are so high.

Fifteenth · 03/11/2023 18:00

fetchacloth · 03/11/2023 17:49

Yes, I've often wondered that too.🤔
I totally get it for someone that might need a high level of supervision, for example a dementia patient, but otherwise why on earth does it cost so much?
I can only surmise that it's a combination of shortfall of funding from councils and profit taking from the proprietor.
I really do think the whole market needs a shake up.

It’s because Govt pays. If it didn’t then markets would have forced mechanisation and other means of cost cutting.

fetchacloth · 03/11/2023 17:55

grottyb · 03/11/2023 16:53

Why should those who have been frugal pay the cost for the feckless who never saved a penny?

This is such a redundant argument. Why should I pay high tax because someone hasn’t saved enough for pension, or abuses their body & drains the NHS? Why should I pay high tax whilst others get child benefit etc. Brandishing everyone feckless is stupid & we either have a safety net or we don’t.

Quite - and that safety net is basically the Social Contract we sign up to when we accept our National Insurance numbers.

fetchacloth · 03/11/2023 17:49

OhmygodDont · 03/11/2023 16:37

The thing is aswell is why is care so expensive. I get different needs need different things but I just can’t work out how it can cost 1k or more a week for a care home place. I’d want a constant 1-1 and gourmet meals tbh and people in care homes certainly any getting that level of care.

Yes, I've often wondered that too.🤔
I totally get it for someone that might need a high level of supervision, for example a dementia patient, but otherwise why on earth does it cost so much?
I can only surmise that it's a combination of shortfall of funding from councils and profit taking from the proprietor.
I really do think the whole market needs a shake up.

VerityUnreasonble · 03/11/2023 17:34

People should spend their money, rather than just pile it up like a dragons gold.

Spending is good for the economy, it creates jobs, puts money in through VAT / PAYE etc.

I'd strongly encourage people to spend their money on living a good life and doing things they enjoy. Especially at pension age where you tend to be more secure in your finances. Keeping a small emergency fund is important, but blow the rest on whatever brings you joy. Having 100ks sitting in savings + 100ks more locked away in property isn't doing much for anyone.

If you eventually need care and have spent up and need subsidising that seems fair for putting that cash back into spending. You do need to get the spending done before you can reasonably predict you need care though.

BrimfulOfMash · 03/11/2023 17:33

Things cost what they cost: the gvt and councils need to be honest about the budgets they need.

How was it ever acceptable to raise the fees of self funders to subsidise LA funded?

I know plenty of people who used all their house sale proceeds on care, it ran out and they had to transfer to LA funded places. Why should they have to do that earlier to privately subsidise others?

cptartapp · 03/11/2023 17:22

Lots of things don't make sense or seem fair.
PIL who have hundreds of thousands in the bank and have been told repeatedly by their IFA to get rid of some money, have just been awarded over £400 a month non means tested attendance allowance which they won't spend so end up on the floor and in and out of A&E like a revolving door.
They 'means tested' my child benefit and removed it a few years ago easily enough.
We all know the funding rules for care. If we don't want to risk subsidising the next person we can spend it or drip feed it away to family over the years. And if we choose not to, that's the gamble.

anniegun · 03/11/2023 17:22

The biggest issue is that the Tories have failed to deliver their promised to fix social care, in fact they even bothered trying. The government would prefer to hand more money to the wealthy by scrapping IHT than invest in decent social care

anniegun · 03/11/2023 17:19

I think you have this completley wrong. Its just a ruling that stops private care providers exploiting either LA's or paying customers . Neither should subsidise the other, the same rates for the same care should apply