Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think it’s not fair that we cut public services so that older adults pay less for care?

159 replies

Bristol2021 · 03/11/2023 13:58

I work in a local authority which is facing an unprecedented budget deficit, like most councils across the country. Most of the deficit is due to the government demanding that councils pay the ‘fair cost of care’ - demanding they negotiate with local care providers so that the same rate is charged to councils as to people paying out of pocket (who are not eligible for free care). This brings the cost to private payers down a bit, but raises the cost to most councils by £tens of millions. As a result all councils are having to cut hundreds or thousands of jobs, and cut back any services (things like arts and leisure, homelessness prevention, remaining children’s centres) to what is required by law, and lower standards of what’s left. This is all so that relatively affluent older adults pay less out of pocket for care. Those people still get the lifetime cap on care costs regardless of what they pay per week of care. This is the main reason so many councils are facing bankruptcy (with a few exceptions where there’s been serious financial mismanagement). It seems to me that most tax payers are going to see far worse public services, all so that some older adults can pass on more inheritance at the end of their lives. They’re not going to spend much on themselves once they’re dependant in care, so I find it unbelievable that the ‘injustice’ of paying more than a local authority (who are a bulk purchaser) for a care package is being used to justify driving councils to bankruptcy and decimating services for everyone else. Do people not realise this is happening, or do people just care more about their inheritance than they do about schools, rubbish collection, roads, child protection, public health..?

OP posts:
Nothanksthanksanyway · 03/11/2023 22:45

grottyb · 03/11/2023 19:15

The budget for children / children in care , working age adults with LD / Autism / sensory etc is much more significant.

How do you separate the figures spent on adult social care for working age vs older people?

I work in the sector and I’m pretty sure financial reports ( spends and budgets ) that are published are also split into cohorts.

grottyb · 03/11/2023 22:41

@WrongSwanson but my understanding is funding also comes from the local authority. And tbh even if 100% of funding came from the LA I don’t think the private places would be any cheaper do you?

So Mrs Jones isn't just paying for her own care, she is directly (not through general taxation) paying for Mrs Smith's care.

And I don’t think it’s unique as I said. Childcare providers charge more for places to cover the cost of free places? Businesses build in the cost of theft, loss etc into retail prices. Wasn’t dentistry costs bought in the subsidise the cost & some groups get it free.

OMGitsnotgood · 03/11/2023 22:37

Not all people self funding care are as 'affluent' as others. I do think that care should be better means tested than it is. Someone with £50k in savings will pay the same as someone with £5million. That doesn't seem fair.

I'm also surprised that the same rate is being paid by councils as self funders- i am aware of homes where the council pays less than private payers

Diolchynfawr · 03/11/2023 22:27

MrsTerryPratchett · 03/11/2023 14:01

The fact is that cutting public services makes it more expensive, not less. Cut children's services, you'll clean up more graffiti. Cut child protection, you'll need more prisons and rehabs. Cut leisure, you'll have more expensive healthcare.

The real issue isn't pensioners fighting with children, it's underfunding everything.

this, and this again.

WrongSwanson · 03/11/2023 22:26

Nb before anyone challenges the numbers - it's arbitrary numbers to illustrate the point

WrongSwanson · 03/11/2023 22:24

grottyb · 03/11/2023 22:08

No, you can’t.

Subsidising other people through general taxation is not the same as subsidising other people through paying fees to a private service provide for something you are forced into needing through the luck of your health.

I don’t understand this point. Taxation is used to pay for other private services eg landlords, childcare settings. Or are you saying that all people in care homes who aren’t paying for the service are being subsidised by those who do pay & there’s no other funding source?

The issue isn't taxation paying for privately delivered services (that's a different, albeit interesting debate)

It's that Mrs Jones pays (say). £2000/week out of her own pocket while the LA pays £350 a week for Mrs Smith for precisely the same care from the Same provider. The providers freely admit they charge much more to Mrs Jones then the service costs, so that they can afford to accept some LA placements.

So Mrs Jones isn't just paying for her own care, she is directly (not through general taxation) paying for Mrs Smith's care.

Noone can think that is fair

grottyb · 03/11/2023 22:08

No, you can’t.

Subsidising other people through general taxation is not the same as subsidising other people through paying fees to a private service provide for something you are forced into needing through the luck of your health.

I don’t understand this point. Taxation is used to pay for other private services eg landlords, childcare settings. Or are you saying that all people in care homes who aren’t paying for the service are being subsidised by those who do pay & there’s no other funding source?

WrongSwanson · 03/11/2023 21:24

FloweryName · 03/11/2023 20:53

No, you can’t.

Subsidising other people through general taxation is not the same as subsidising other people through paying fees to a private service provide for something you are forced into needing through the luck of your health.

Exactly. It's frustrating that people can't grasp the distinction

FloweryName · 03/11/2023 20:53

grottyb · 03/11/2023 17:01

@FloweryName
OP, do you think it’s fair that people who have paid their taxes and their own housing costs throughout their lives end up subsidising the care of others who haven’t done those things when they get to needing care in their old age?

You can use this argument about everything though. What about all the people who don’t have dc but subsidise those that do?

No, you can’t.

Subsidising other people through general taxation is not the same as subsidising other people through paying fees to a private service provide for something you are forced into needing through the luck of your health.

Soontobe60 · 03/11/2023 20:51

BIossomtoes · 03/11/2023 20:11

the house would be disregarded as she still lives and joint owns it I assume

His half won’t be disregarded and her living there is irrelevant if she’s under 60.

If the house is owned as joint tenants, then it’s irrelevant how old the remaining person is.

Theeyeballsinthesky · 03/11/2023 20:24

Will my home have to be included in the means test?
In some situations, your home won't be taken into account in the means test. There are a few circumstances where this applies:
If you need short-term or temporary care in a care home, your home won't be in the means test.
If your care home is permanent, it won't be counted if it's still occupied by:

  • your partner or former partner, unless they are estranged from you
  • your estranged or divorced partner IF they are also a lone parent
  • a relative who is aged 60 or over
  • a relative who is disabled
  • a child of yours aged under 18
https://www.ageuk.org.uk/information-advice/care/paying-for-care/paying-for-a-care-home/do-i-have-to-sell-my-home-to-pay-for-care/

https://www.ageuk.org.uk/information-advice/care/paying-for-care/paying-for-a-care-home/do-i-have-to-sell-my-home-to-pay-for-care/

WrongSwanson · 03/11/2023 20:11

What taxes someone has/hasn't paid is a total red herring.

It strikes me as fraud/deception that care homes are charging private individuals substantially more than local authority placements for the same services

The whole system needs a complete shake up. It's totally exploiting some of the most ill people in society

BIossomtoes · 03/11/2023 20:11

the house would be disregarded as she still lives and joint owns it I assume

His half won’t be disregarded and her living there is irrelevant if she’s under 60.

Soontobe60 · 03/11/2023 20:05

grottyb · 03/11/2023 19:45

Why should those with more money subsidise those with less? They already paid more taxes.

How can you ascertain someone with more money as an older person paid more tax?

Someone may have more money due to an inheritance - they may have paid bugger all in income tax!

Soontobe60 · 03/11/2023 20:04

FloweryName · 03/11/2023 16:55

OP, do you think it’s fair that people who have paid their taxes and their own housing costs throughout their lives end up subsidising the care of others who haven’t done those things when they get to needing care in their old age?

Ive read people on here in similar discussions say that paying privately gives people more choice over their care homes which it does in many cases, but often they are still using exactly the same homes as council funded residents who aren’t paying anything. It is not fair that some people have to pay for the and some people don’t when they’re both living in the same place with the same facilities. I have more sympathy for those people than I do for councils.

You could have a situation where one half of a married couple has to go into care, they’ve both paid taxes all their lives and bought their own home. They both earned minimum wage so had no way to pay into a private pension or save up to possibly pay for care costs. They both receive full state pension. As one half of the couple is still at home, the house can’t be sold to pay towards care costs. So the LA has to pay, and their state pension is also taken - less £25 a week.

Soontobe60 · 03/11/2023 19:53

Many people are not eligible for free care and yet struggle to pay
for someone to not be eligible for free care, they have to have savings over £25k as a minimum.
My stepfather has to pay towards his care so that means all his state pension, less £25 a week, is taken. The LA pay the rest. He’s not ‘struggling to pay’ because he literally has nothing else to spend his money on. The care home provides for his every need.

grottyb · 03/11/2023 19:45

Why should those with more money subsidise those with less? They already paid more taxes.

How can you ascertain someone with more money as an older person paid more tax?

Balletdreamer · 03/11/2023 19:29

Why should those with more money subsidise those with less? They already paid more taxes. At 50k a year how long do you think the money will last? You don’t even need to have much money before you have to start paying. And there is no cap. Even if there was it’s for care costs not living costs which is actually the majority of the cost, most people would die long before reaching that and the government knows that. Blame poor government not people unfortunate enough to have done well financially in life.

bellac11 · 03/11/2023 19:26

Gcsunnyside23 · 03/11/2023 15:20

Are you actually joking?? Is it not basically if your partner works/owns own home then you get shafted for care costs? A family member has advanced dementia, he is in his 60s and they have tried to take the house from his wife and are crippling her with costs for a care home as she still works. She's in a bog standard job and now paying her bills alone but also has these extra bills. They have worked all their lives and ended up with no support. And to point out it's a medically deemed need for him to be in a home so he cant come home either. But if they were on benefits no payment would be mentioned.
It's not affluent people that are bearing the brunt of this. How is this fair?

Something is not right about this

Firstly the bill is his, not hers and the house would be disregarded as she still lives and joint owns it I assume

Secondly if it has been medically assessed he needs the care then that should come under continuing health care costs.

Flev · 03/11/2023 19:22

Another point worth making is that we all know what has happened to inflation over the past year or so, and how much energy prices have shot up (and please note care homes as businesses are not protected by any price caps, we're now paying about 5 times the cost we did a couple of years ago and you can hardly just decide to turn the heating down to save money). But Council fees in many cases have not increased at all over the past few years, so even the money they are able to pay is not going as far. And that's mostly because they are frequently getting less, not even the same, from central government.

grottyb · 03/11/2023 19:15

The budget for children / children in care , working age adults with LD / Autism / sensory etc is much more significant.

How do you separate the figures spent on adult social care for working age vs older people?

Ohreallynotok · 03/11/2023 19:15

Frankly the standard of assessment and basic competence in adult social care leaves a lot to be desired and I for one amsick of it being blamed just on funding.
It costs little to give staff access to adequate supervision, debrief and management support and yet the humanity seems to be sorely lacking. Social work should not it's very essence be a human endeavour and relational alongside statutory provision, there is also no reason why statutory care can't be delivered nicely but it isn't. More time and energy seems to be put into justifying poor practice and covering backs than actually utilising the art of being with people.
Really winds me up!

JennyWreny · 03/11/2023 19:14

@Bristol2021 your comment "Many people are not eligible for free care and yet struggle to pay,"

Can you explain what you mean by this? I think very few people are eligible for completely free care as their income (pension etc) is used in part. However, I understand that the amount they pay is based on a financial assessment so it doesn't make sense that anyone is struggling to pay (unless they are selecting to top up to choose a more expensive care home).

grottyb · 03/11/2023 19:12

Effectively if you had carers in your home 24/7 it is £100k a year plus all the standard utility bills, council tax, insurance etc.

One of my relative recently paid for private care in the home (the state provided service just wasn’t there), cost approx 2k a wk. Yes expensive but it meant they stayed in their home & they were happy.

Bahhhhhumbug · 03/11/2023 18:56

OhmygodDont · 03/11/2023 14:43

Maybe the old cottage type places should have never been closed for those that where in between care and hospital needs, maybe councils should run their own care homes rather than paying private companies.

Maybe we shouldn’t be so obsessed with keeping someone alive at all costs but with a shit quality of life either because we are so scared of death.

Maybe also you shouldn’t expect people paying private to be subbing the council places either.

Absolutely.Wouldnt wish my mother's last six years on my worst enemy, couldn't even shuffle into a different position in bed herself. Completely immobile and terrible contractures in both arms and legs curled up in a tight ball, ,aspirating her food and could only drink tea through a straw in a baby cup (she loved a cup of tea aswell😪). She was kept alive with a massive cocktail of drugs ,of which only a couple were pain relief.
Not to mention even with council help it cost about 60k . We fought for CHC but the system was so corrupt it was impossible so gave up and never got any inheritance to speak of that our parents had always wanted us to benefit from after working hard all their lives.

Swipe left for the next trending thread