Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think it’s not fair that we cut public services so that older adults pay less for care?

159 replies

Bristol2021 · 03/11/2023 13:58

I work in a local authority which is facing an unprecedented budget deficit, like most councils across the country. Most of the deficit is due to the government demanding that councils pay the ‘fair cost of care’ - demanding they negotiate with local care providers so that the same rate is charged to councils as to people paying out of pocket (who are not eligible for free care). This brings the cost to private payers down a bit, but raises the cost to most councils by £tens of millions. As a result all councils are having to cut hundreds or thousands of jobs, and cut back any services (things like arts and leisure, homelessness prevention, remaining children’s centres) to what is required by law, and lower standards of what’s left. This is all so that relatively affluent older adults pay less out of pocket for care. Those people still get the lifetime cap on care costs regardless of what they pay per week of care. This is the main reason so many councils are facing bankruptcy (with a few exceptions where there’s been serious financial mismanagement). It seems to me that most tax payers are going to see far worse public services, all so that some older adults can pass on more inheritance at the end of their lives. They’re not going to spend much on themselves once they’re dependant in care, so I find it unbelievable that the ‘injustice’ of paying more than a local authority (who are a bulk purchaser) for a care package is being used to justify driving councils to bankruptcy and decimating services for everyone else. Do people not realise this is happening, or do people just care more about their inheritance than they do about schools, rubbish collection, roads, child protection, public health..?

OP posts:
grottyb · 04/11/2023 08:06

And I don't agree with it in dentistry/childcare either. But it's particularly unpleasant in this instance where we are talking about very ill and vulnerable individuals.

So you agree with me, it’s not unusual? That was my point….

I would argue those that qualify for funded dentistry & free childcare are often also very vulnerable tbh.

grottyb · 04/11/2023 08:03

@Quisquam can you link anything? I remember reading something a few yrs ago in the Times or FT but can’t remember the detail except it certainly said the majority of the funding came from LAs

I don’t know anything about the figures for childcare and dentistry, but are people paying £275 per week to subsidise other people?

My point was there is a subsidy, so your argument is that it’s ok if it’s a low subsidy?

I paid just under 2k a month for one childcare place. Certainly childcare providers cannot cover everything based on the rates the gov provide for the free hours.

WrongSwanson · 04/11/2023 07:59

Quisquam · 04/11/2023 07:48

In reality how much are private paying care home people paying to subsidise the LA places? My understanding is it’s not a significant figure.

I went to a talk by the Director of Adult Social Care. He talked about this. Iirc, he said the LA wouldn’t pay more than £650 a week, while self funders were paying £1,000 - £1,200. He said the real cost of the council funded places was probably in the middle. So, if the average of £650 and £1200 is £925 a week, then the self funders are imo subsidising LA places significantly.

I don’t know anything about the figures for childcare and dentistry, but are people paying £275 per week to subsidise other people? We have a private dentist; if we are lucky, we don’t pay £275 in a year for 4 checkups. Even a while filling is £120! However our dentist doesn’t do NHS, so we don’t subsidise anyone.

Yes these are broadly the numbers I have heard (from care providers themselves)

So on top of paying for their own care very people are paying approx £15k /annum over the odds.

And I don't agree with it in dentistry/childcare either. But it's particularly unpleasant in this instance where we are talking about very ill and vulnerable individuals.

Quisquam · 04/11/2023 07:48

In reality how much are private paying care home people paying to subsidise the LA places? My understanding is it’s not a significant figure.

I went to a talk by the Director of Adult Social Care. He talked about this. Iirc, he said the LA wouldn’t pay more than £650 a week, while self funders were paying £1,000 - £1,200. He said the real cost of the council funded places was probably in the middle. So, if the average of £650 and £1200 is £925 a week, then the self funders are imo subsidising LA places significantly.

I don’t know anything about the figures for childcare and dentistry, but are people paying £275 per week to subsidise other people? We have a private dentist; if we are lucky, we don’t pay £275 in a year for 4 checkups. Even a while filling is £120! However our dentist doesn’t do NHS, so we don’t subsidise anyone.

Cosyblankets · 04/11/2023 07:21

VerityUnreasonble · 03/11/2023 18:47

To be in a care home (certainly of funded by the LA) you would expect someone to have a level of need which means they need support available all the time, or close to. If you can manage at home with 4 visits a day from carers that's all the LA will fund.

There are 168 hours in a week, so at 1kish that's under £6 per hour for care / food / laundry / accommodation / heating / cleaning.

A room in a house share near me costs around £100 - 175, including bills. So that takes it down to about £5 per hour for care.

Take off say £10 a day for food, another say £20 a week for cleaning, £5 for laundry. That's £4.50 per hour for care.

Also need to pay a proportion of the cost for care home manager, deputy, kitchen staff, care taker etc. let's say a total of 2k per week? So for a home with 40 residents that's another £50.

So we are now down to £4.20 per hour for the actual carers. Carer's probably actually get £9-12 per hour but will cost the company a bit more than that for training, pensions, payroll etc.

There are other costs I've not included I'm sure.

So one person's 1k actually probably pays for maybe 1/3rd of a carer per hour? If that?

I don't know if that's good value but if you pay for care at home you are probably paying around £30 an hour for the care you receive, so would get maybe 24 hours, 3.5 hours a day for the same care costs.

I see where you're going with the figures but the care home will have a ratio of staff to residents. It's not one to one.

Cosyblankets · 04/11/2023 07:15

Flev · 03/11/2023 14:51

Right now Councils are paying way less than it actually costs to provide care. That's why providers are handing contracts back to local authorities - they simply cannot afford to deliver them and are at risk of going bust themselves. It's why salaries in care are so low, backlogs so high (hence impacting on the NHS) and standards so hard to keep high. It's not about saving private payers money, it's about making sure it is actually possible to deliver the services for council-funded individuals.

I'm currently supporting a relative who is paying upwards of £3500 a month for care in their own home. 2 carers 4 times a day. This is via their local council but self funded.

grottyb · 04/11/2023 06:43

I haven’t disputed that there is a subsidy, I just don’t think it’s anything like the council/taxpayers pay 10% of the costs & the self funders cover 90% of the council places. Tax payers do pay for care which seems to be misconstrued on this thread.

I don’t believe self funded places would be cheaper if LA increased their funding.
And I don’t understand why it’s ok to have subsidies in other areas eg childcare & dentistry but it’s unacceptable in re care homes?

grottyb · 04/11/2023 06:27

I don’t think anyone has said that they shouldn’t pay. What they have said is that they shouldn’t be expected to pay for their own care and additionally to subsidise residents who are council-funded.

In reality how much are private paying care home people paying to subsidise the LA places? My understanding is it’s not a significant figure.

And why is it any different to paying for dentistry or eye care costs or childcare costs?

And as I said I don’t believe private places would suddenly get cheaper if council-funded places were fully funded? Why do you?

StarTrek6 · 04/11/2023 05:57

grottyb · 03/11/2023 16:41

I don't think it's ethical that the taxpayer is funding privately owned facilities in this way.

It’s like paying £££ to landlords though as so much social housing has been paid off. Or for childcare.

If there was squillions to be made in care homes we'd be awash with them. Care Homes are closing whcih doesn't suggest there's much profit.

MrsFezziwig · 04/11/2023 01:33

grottyb · 04/11/2023 01:20

And why is it wrong that someone who can pay does pay? I’ve not seen a coherent argument.

I don’t think anyone has said that they shouldn’t pay. What they have said is that they shouldn’t be expected to pay for their own care and additionally to subsidise residents who are council-funded.

grottyb · 04/11/2023 01:20

And why is it wrong that someone who can pay does pay? I’ve not seen a coherent argument.

grottyb · 04/11/2023 01:19

Mrs Smith's care should be paid for by the taxpayer.

So what you meant to write was 100% of the care costs should be paid by the taxpayers… because as I said taxpayers do pay.

This has been explained multiple times, by different people, in very plain English.

The irony 😆

grottyb · 04/11/2023 01:18

Mrs Smith's care should be paid for by the taxpayer.

So what you meant to write was 100% of the care costs should be paid by the taxpayers… because as I said taxpayers do pay.

This has been explained multiple times, by different people, in very plain English.

The irony 😆

WrongSwanson · 04/11/2023 00:57

grottyb · 04/11/2023 00:52

Show me where I suggested Mrs Smith was feckless?

I thought my post was clear that I was talking about the narrative of these debates & the narrative is often the ones who pay for their care were hardworking, didn’t spend recklessly etc whereas as the ones who don’t are somehow lesser.

Mrs Smith's care should be paid for by the taxpayer.

Taxpayers do pay though?

I can't see what's hard to understand here.

clearly 😆

"tax payers do pay"... They pay a component, the rest is subsidised by Mrs Jones and the other private residents because the LAs won't pay the full amount. This has been explained multiple times, by different people, in very plain English.

grottyb · 04/11/2023 00:52

Show me where I suggested Mrs Smith was feckless?

I thought my post was clear that I was talking about the narrative of these debates & the narrative is often the ones who pay for their care were hardworking, didn’t spend recklessly etc whereas as the ones who don’t are somehow lesser.

Mrs Smith's care should be paid for by the taxpayer.

Taxpayers do pay though?

I can't see what's hard to understand here.

clearly 😆

WrongSwanson · 04/11/2023 00:35

grottyb · 04/11/2023 00:19

But it should be paid for by the tax payer, not by Mrs Jones in the room next door who is really poorly but just managed to scrape by and pay her mortgage her whole life

Why has Mrs Jones managed to scrape by? I hate the moralising on these debates. poor Mrs Jones who worked all her life to fund feckless Mrs Smith in the next room 🙄

Show me where I suggested Mrs Smith was feckless?

I didn't.

I may well be Mrs Smith in the future (work v hard in public service but facing disability that may mean i can't work soon,)

Mrs Smith's care should be paid for by the taxpayer.

Just not by Mrs Jones's own personal care bill.

I can't see what's hard to understand here.

DisquietintheRanks · 04/11/2023 00:35

OhmygodDont · 03/11/2023 16:37

The thing is aswell is why is care so expensive. I get different needs need different things but I just can’t work out how it can cost 1k or more a week for a care home place. I’d want a constant 1-1 and gourmet meals tbh and people in care homes certainly any getting that level of care.

Actually it's really not that hard when you do the maths. Cost of a purpose built care home mortgage, maintenance, energy costs (high), 24 hour staffing at the correct ratios, home cooked food, running a minibus, specialist equipment (all needs regular servicing) and so on. And then, yes, subsising those funded by the local authority and profits.

BrimfulOfMash · 04/11/2023 00:32

grottyb · 04/11/2023 00:19

But it should be paid for by the tax payer, not by Mrs Jones in the room next door who is really poorly but just managed to scrape by and pay her mortgage her whole life

Why has Mrs Jones managed to scrape by? I hate the moralising on these debates. poor Mrs Jones who worked all her life to fund feckless Mrs Smith in the next room 🙄

Er wasn’t it Mrs Smith the hard working under paid care worker who was being subsidised?

Anyway, the point is that those who cannot afford it should be supported by our state system (which has money from many sources, not just ‘the taxpayer’ ) which is democratically accountable. Not by an informal unaccountable system of private subsidy managed by privately run profit-making businesses.

Flopsythebunny · 04/11/2023 00:23

fetchacloth · 03/11/2023 16:29

I've often wondered whether local councils should have, and run, their own senior care facilities. These would be financed on a not-for-profit basis. This then means that the taxpayer isn't funding profit making private care facilities.
I don't think it's ethical that the taxpayer is funding privately owned facilities in this way.

They used to. Some still do have council run specialist dementia units

grottyb · 04/11/2023 00:19

But it should be paid for by the tax payer, not by Mrs Jones in the room next door who is really poorly but just managed to scrape by and pay her mortgage her whole life

Why has Mrs Jones managed to scrape by? I hate the moralising on these debates. poor Mrs Jones who worked all her life to fund feckless Mrs Smith in the next room 🙄

grottyb · 04/11/2023 00:12

@Nothanksthanksanyway can you link anything? When I googled council
spending it lumped all social care together.

WrongSwanson · 03/11/2023 23:09

JenniferBooth · 03/11/2023 23:04

I see there is the usual cognitive dissonance going on here, because the ones who wont be able to fund their own care are the care workers caring for todays elderly Because their wages are too low Are you really going to begrudge them care when they are older? if they all took the advice to find a better paying job tomorrow the shit would hit the fan even sooner

No one is begrudging them their care.

But it should be paid for by the tax payer, not by Mrs Jones in the room next door who is really poorly but just managed to scrape by and pay her mortgage her whole life

JenniferBooth · 03/11/2023 23:04

I see there is the usual cognitive dissonance going on here, because the ones who wont be able to fund their own care are the care workers caring for todays elderly Because their wages are too low Are you really going to begrudge them care when they are older? if they all took the advice to find a better paying job tomorrow the shit would hit the fan even sooner

OMGitsnotgood · 03/11/2023 22:56

No they won’t. That £50k will run out very quickly indeed. The person with £5 million will be paying until their last breath - and they’ll be in a much, much nicer care home, one that no publicly funded person will ever see the inside of. My parents’ care home only took self funders.

I was making a point. Obviously the person with £50k will run out of money very quickly. The person with £5m in the same care home will pay the same and that was my point. They are hardly likely to live long enough to exhaust their savings . I get that they can afford better care - i was just drawing a parallel to say it seems unfair that they all pay the same in the same care home. We have a relative in a privately funded care home, chosen partly because the state will take over payment for that home when the time comes.

BIossomtoes · 03/11/2023 22:49

OMGitsnotgood · 03/11/2023 22:37

Not all people self funding care are as 'affluent' as others. I do think that care should be better means tested than it is. Someone with £50k in savings will pay the same as someone with £5million. That doesn't seem fair.

I'm also surprised that the same rate is being paid by councils as self funders- i am aware of homes where the council pays less than private payers

No they won’t. That £50k will run out very quickly indeed. The person with £5 million will be paying until their last breath - and they’ll be in a much, much nicer care home, one that no publicly funded person will ever see the inside of. My parents’ care home only took self funders.

Swipe left for the next trending thread