Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Husband got Prosecution Notice for 5 and 7 yr old No Seat Belts

213 replies

PoppyMK · 03/11/2023 13:49

My husband received a Notice of Prosecution from the Police because he has apparently been caught driving on the M25 with our two children in the back of the car without seats belts (unclear which child it is, or whether it's both, from the notice).

I am concerned because we are in the process of separating and I want to know exactly what happened so i can make a judgement about whether my children are safe with him. AIBU or overreacting?

I have tried asking him about this - first he claimed he didn't know they had no seat belt on, then he claimed they wouldn't listen to him to stop trying to climb over the back of the seats.

I have no idea how to go about obtaining whatever evidence the Police have - but it would seem to be important that I have access to it as the co-parent of both children?

As an aside, I'm pretty certain he hasn't even responded to the notice by the deadline as I've seen what look like at least two further letters arrive for him, but as that is a problem for him and the consequences of which he will face, which will presumably be automatic points on his licence in addition to those he'll already get for the actual offence.

OP posts:
RandomButtons · 03/11/2023 14:49

PoppyMK · 03/11/2023 14:45

@saffronsoup no, they've never done it with me, I think because they absolutely know I won't tolerate it.

Then it’s 100% on your ex.

No way would I let him have my kids in his car.

DistrictAndCircle · 03/11/2023 14:49

Not much to add on what you should do, OP, but just to clarify what will happen to him if he ignores the Notice of Intended Prosecution...

If he responds to it and admits it, he will get points and a fine.

If he ignores it or denies it, it will end up being dealt with by Magistrates. He will have the opportunity to come to court. If convicted (either after a trial or in his absence) he won't get any more points. But he will potentially get a much higher fine, and will have to pay court costs and a surcharge equal to 40% of the fine. After a trial, the costs alone will be approaching £1000.

CormorantStrikesBack · 03/11/2023 14:48

What does the 7yo say what happened? I’d be trying to get info out of them, telling them they’re not in trouble but asking if daddy “forgot “ to do the seatbelts or did they undo their own

Itsnotchristmasyet · 03/11/2023 14:47

Sorry just seen their ages are in the title.

I would chat to the kids and ask them what happened.

I always wait until everyone is buckled before driving off but if they undid their belts, then there’s not a lot he could have done apart from pull over. And it sounds like the police got to him first.

The fact that they were climbing over the seats suggests that they were being really naughty and most likely took off their belts.

PoppyMK · 03/11/2023 14:45

@saffronsoup no, they've never done it with me, I think because they absolutely know I won't tolerate it.

OP posts:
PoppyMK · 03/11/2023 14:45

@LNY1986 they are reasonably well disciplined with me, as they know I will not tolerate that and that I would notice immediately. In my view, they aren't as well disciplined with him because he often isn't aware (a bit on the spectrum) and then when he is aware, he won't consistently and firmly follow up.

So whilst I sympathise with many of the points you make, I think this is down to his parenting style rather than an inherently poor discipline in the children (but of course they are well aware that what they did was wrong after his outburst).

OP posts:
saffronsoup · 03/11/2023 14:44

PoppyMK · 03/11/2023 14:42

@sandyhappypeople yes they have car seats, clearly they have taken off the seatbelts at some point and clambered out of the car seats.

Have they ever done that while in the car with you?

At 5 and 7, they shouldn't be taking off their seatbelts or getting out of car sears in a moving car. I can't even imagine how they thought that was appropriate. When it happened, was there a consequence at home for that unsafe and bad behaviour?

Itsnotchristmasyet · 03/11/2023 14:43

How old are the kids?

Are they old enough to take their seatbelts off?
Would they actually do it?

I’m sorry I don’t have any legal advice but this is basic parenting and extremely dangerous if he was responsible for not putting their belts on.

If he was angry at them for climbing around and not wanting them to do it, then it does sound like he was telling them to stop if and put their belts on though.

PoppyMK · 03/11/2023 14:42

@sandyhappypeople yes they have car seats, clearly they have taken off the seatbelts at some point and clambered out of the car seats.

OP posts:
LNY1986 · 03/11/2023 14:41

It sounds like your children need a bit more discipline.
They aren't little kids, they are well and truly old enough to sit like civilised human beings in a vehicle.

Not many people would intentionally allow their children to jump about in the back of the car on a motorway, so although legally yoyr husband is responsible the children are extremely ill behaved and should also be punished accordingly.
If they DID unstrap themselves and weren't listening to him then that is horrendously dangerous. He cannot exactly slam on the brakes and deal with it there and then. His first priority would have been to focus on the road ahead and keep in control, especially at motorway speeds.
It's alright others on here saying he should have pulled over and refused to move until they put the belts back on but where?
The hard shoulder is for emergencies, not unruly kids. Also would have incurred a fine in it's own right!
Also at those speeds and depending on what lane he was in/traffic conditions, you can't just pull over easily.

For the police to actually catch him then the children must have been jumping or climbing around as its almost impossible to see in the back seat if kids are sat nicely and tell whether the belts are fastened or not.

You need to have a serious word with those kids and tell them they will cause a nasty accident that could kill somebody. Or Dad needs to buy a baby harness and physically lock them into a 5 point belt.

If they were mine I would refuse to transport them in a car and drag them on buses or make them walk!

PoppyMK · 03/11/2023 14:41

@Neriah just to be clear, I'm not suggesting that this will in any way affect his access or rights to the children in isolation. But neither do I want to dismiss this out of hand as this is just one of many examples of questionable choices which, over time and taken together, mean I have to constantly consider whether the safety of my children is being compromised. I'm sure you'll appreciate that is difficult and very hard emotionally, but I have to put the safety of my children first.

OP posts:
TomatoSandwiches · 03/11/2023 14:39

I'd be furious about the no seat belts but the lying and blaming children is absolutely disgusting, how can you trust him again with their safety?

sandyhappypeople · 03/11/2023 14:39

Do they have car seats/booster seats in his car OP?

Hexandthecity · 03/11/2023 14:38

This is horrific! A 5yo girl was killed in a one-vehicle collision near us, on a 40mph road. I don't know the particulars about seats/ belts, but that gives an idea of how dangerous it is. At ages 5 and 7 they should still be in car seats (ideally rear facing for the 5yo), never mind not wearing seatbelts! Does "no seatbelts" literally mean that they were completely unrestrained (no seats or belts), or could they have been in seats, but not strapped in? It's both dangerous, but I'd be even more enraged if he knowingly took them in the car without car seats. And he's a complete twat for blaming them, what a man child! I'm sorry you're dealing with this OP!

sandyhappypeople · 03/11/2023 14:38

melj1213 · 03/11/2023 14:23

The problem is we don't know what happened. If he set off and they weren't belted in securely then yanbu to think he's irresponsible but if the child/ren took them off mid-journey then I do think it's less clear cut depending on the circumstances.

If the OPs Ex was already on the motorway and one or both of the children unclipped themselves from their seats what is he supposed to do if he's nowhere near an exit/services to get off the motorway?

Especially by age 5&7 the children are more than old enough to know they don't take their seatbelts off during the journey, so why did they not have them on? Only the OP knows if her kids are the kind who will ninja out of car seats regardless of how securely you think they're fastened in - my DD never tried to get out of car seats/seatbelts/pram straps etc but my nephew is a ninja and you fasten him in securely, get in the car, set off and next thing he's waving his arms about and/or is out of his seat, but he's only 18mo so he isn't old enough to reason with whereas by 5/7 they are old enough to know the consequences of taking off their belt.

my nephew is a ninja and you fasten him in securely, get in the car, set off and next thing he's waving his arms about and/or is out of his seat.

I'd question the quality/safety of the car seat if an 18 month old can undo the 5 point harness, those things are tight for an adult to undo. You aren't meant to add anything to a car seat that didn't come with it, but if he can escape from it, then clips that go across the straps would be a no brainer.

Ebtsaqt · 03/11/2023 14:36

Im not sure if its legal to pull over on motorway hardshoulder for this though?

Ebtsaqt · 03/11/2023 14:35

I think whilst likely his fault. You need to tell the kids off too. At that age they know to put epseat belts on. At 7 she can probably do this herself.
And they should not be removing them. Imagibe if it were a rollercoaster!
Also at 7 unless the seats that clip to the car ? The car seat isnt attsched to the car if not done up

saffronsoup · 03/11/2023 14:34

7 and 5 year olds are plenty old enough to keep their seatbelts on. If kids that age are taking them off, it is absolutely fine to pull over and give them a stern warning and insist they wear them. If you pull back on the motorway and they keep unbuckling, I guess at some point you have to drive home. At that point you both have a parenting issue if your kids wont'keep their belts on and dont' listen to being told to do so.

Which is a different issue from him not expecting them to buckle or not taking their unbuckling seriously. The kids are old enough to also give you a version of events. Does dad expect them to put their seatbelt on in the car? Does he get upset if they take it off?

rainbowstardrops · 03/11/2023 14:34

So was he actually pulled over by the police?
I'd be bloody raging!

MidnightOnceMore · 03/11/2023 14:29

melj1213 · 03/11/2023 14:23

The problem is we don't know what happened. If he set off and they weren't belted in securely then yanbu to think he's irresponsible but if the child/ren took them off mid-journey then I do think it's less clear cut depending on the circumstances.

If the OPs Ex was already on the motorway and one or both of the children unclipped themselves from their seats what is he supposed to do if he's nowhere near an exit/services to get off the motorway?

Especially by age 5&7 the children are more than old enough to know they don't take their seatbelts off during the journey, so why did they not have them on? Only the OP knows if her kids are the kind who will ninja out of car seats regardless of how securely you think they're fastened in - my DD never tried to get out of car seats/seatbelts/pram straps etc but my nephew is a ninja and you fasten him in securely, get in the car, set off and next thing he's waving his arms about and/or is out of his seat, but he's only 18mo so he isn't old enough to reason with whereas by 5/7 they are old enough to know the consequences of taking off their belt.

He lied initially.

The Police don't prosecute people who clearly have a naughty child and then deal with it.

Neriah · 03/11/2023 14:29

IncompleteSenten · 03/11/2023 14:26

Contact social services and ask for their input. Tell them you are concerned for your children's safety in light of this and would like their help.

Social services are overwhelmed with cases of abuse and neglect, and you think they have time to referee over who did or diid not put on a seatbelt? They are not a mediation service.

Neriah · 03/11/2023 14:27

I agree with the sentiment that he's an idiot. But no court in the land is going to remove his parental rights because of this single incident - and you cannot refuse to allow him to have the children based on your "judgement" or else you will also be in court.

IncompleteSenten · 03/11/2023 14:26

Contact social services and ask for their input. Tell them you are concerned for your children's safety in light of this and would like their help.

RonObvious · 03/11/2023 14:24

MidnightOnceMore · 03/11/2023 14:21

What more information do you need?

The police must have enough to demonstrate it is in the public interest to prosecute. If the kids undid their belt and he pulled over at a safe opportunity, they would not prosecute.

What more are you looking for?

Plus his reaction says everything to me. If they had been undoing their seatbelts and climbing all over the place, surely he would have told you straight away, rather than initially lying about it. The fact that his first reaction was to lie and say he didn't know they weren't wearing them, and that his second was to yell at the kids, because it was their fault. That should tell you everything you need to know. I'm so sorry you are dealing with this - it's such a difficult situation.

melj1213 · 03/11/2023 14:23

Manadou · 03/11/2023 14:11

If they were climbing about, and clearly unbelted, he should have pulled over and refused to move until they put their belts on. He should not have moved off at the start of the journey until he was sure of that.

The problem is we don't know what happened. If he set off and they weren't belted in securely then yanbu to think he's irresponsible but if the child/ren took them off mid-journey then I do think it's less clear cut depending on the circumstances.

If the OPs Ex was already on the motorway and one or both of the children unclipped themselves from their seats what is he supposed to do if he's nowhere near an exit/services to get off the motorway?

Especially by age 5&7 the children are more than old enough to know they don't take their seatbelts off during the journey, so why did they not have them on? Only the OP knows if her kids are the kind who will ninja out of car seats regardless of how securely you think they're fastened in - my DD never tried to get out of car seats/seatbelts/pram straps etc but my nephew is a ninja and you fasten him in securely, get in the car, set off and next thing he's waving his arms about and/or is out of his seat, but he's only 18mo so he isn't old enough to reason with whereas by 5/7 they are old enough to know the consequences of taking off their belt.