Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Husband got Prosecution Notice for 5 and 7 yr old No Seat Belts

213 replies

PoppyMK · 03/11/2023 13:49

My husband received a Notice of Prosecution from the Police because he has apparently been caught driving on the M25 with our two children in the back of the car without seats belts (unclear which child it is, or whether it's both, from the notice).

I am concerned because we are in the process of separating and I want to know exactly what happened so i can make a judgement about whether my children are safe with him. AIBU or overreacting?

I have tried asking him about this - first he claimed he didn't know they had no seat belt on, then he claimed they wouldn't listen to him to stop trying to climb over the back of the seats.

I have no idea how to go about obtaining whatever evidence the Police have - but it would seem to be important that I have access to it as the co-parent of both children?

As an aside, I'm pretty certain he hasn't even responded to the notice by the deadline as I've seen what look like at least two further letters arrive for him, but as that is a problem for him and the consequences of which he will face, which will presumably be automatic points on his licence in addition to those he'll already get for the actual offence.

OP posts:
MariaLuna · 03/11/2023 19:11

Social services are overwhelmed with cases of abuse and neglect.

How sad.

Yalta · 03/11/2023 19:06

*Kinneddar · Today 15:25

If the OPs Ex was already on the motorway and one or both of the children unclipped themselves from their seats what is he supposed to do if he's nowhere near an exit/services to get off the motorway*

He should have pulled into the hard shoulder

What if he was on a Smart Motorway

There are sections of the M25 where there is no hard shoulder

HundredMilesAnHour · 03/11/2023 19:02

Totally agree with @PhantomUnicorn - the OP's comment that the kids are "reasonably behaved" (for her) gives the game away. Sounds like they were misbehaving big time yet the OP is blaming the Dad (who was trying to navigate the racetrack of the M25). Which probably explains why he didn't tell the OP immediately after it happened.

PhantomUnicorn · 03/11/2023 18:56

If i knew my kids had
a) taken their seatbelts off in the back of my ExH's car
and
b) refused to put them back on when he told them to, and proceeded to piss about on the backseat of the car on the Motorway, while HIS responsibility was to drive the car and not crash it.

I'd be joining him in absolutely bollocking them. He might be an ineffectual parent, but what do you expect him to do in that situation, stop the car? Shout at them? What if he did and they still didn't listen, thats a distraction that is a car crash waiting to happen.

You absolutely 100% need to back him up in making it clear to the kids, that REGARDLESS of who's car they're in THEY DO NOT REMOVE THEIR SEATBELTS UNDER ANY CIRCUMSTANCES

Never mind taking notes on proving he is a shit parent... back him up, ffs.

Deal with your damn children instead of patting yourself on the back with 'well they behave when they're with me' like it's some smug point scoring contest.

Londonlondon4 · 03/11/2023 18:50

PoppyMK · 03/11/2023 14:05

@GirrlCrush no, I didn't open his mail - I arrived home after he'd just opened the first notice and the house was in uproar because he'd been yelling at the children about how it was their fault.

Since then we haven't discussed it.

That is also concerning and needs to be officially documented.

Kinneddar · 03/11/2023 18:50

The hard shoulder is an extremely dangerous place. It should be used for emergencies only. It is NOT a substitute for the naughty step

No but the OP said the kids were climbing over the seats - while the car was on the motorway. That's incredibly dangerous for both the OPs family and other drivers if her ex gets distracted. It's slightly more than the kids just needing told off

Fingeronthebutton · 03/11/2023 18:46

How can you even ask AIBU. Words fail me.

LNY1986 · 03/11/2023 18:44

Kinneddar · 03/11/2023 15:25

If the OPs Ex was already on the motorway and one or both of the children unclipped themselves from their seats what is he supposed to do if he's nowhere near an exit/services to get off the motorway

He should have pulled into the hard shoulder

The hard shoulder is for emergencies, not unruly kids. Also would have incurred a fine in it's own right!

No it wouldn't. Fines don't get sent out to people who stop on the hard shoulder. If his car had been seen stopped the police may have stopped to check everything was OK but would be more likely to give the kids a serious talking to than their Dad.

The hard shoulder is an extremely dangerous place. It should be used for emergencies only. It is NOT a substitute for the naughty step.

PrincessScarlett · 03/11/2023 18:30

Do the kids know you and DH are separating? Could they have been playing up because of this?

If the kids took the seatbelts off whilst DH was driving and started climbing around in the car then that is totally different to DH not putting seatbelts on in the first place and I think you need to back your DH on this. Your kids are old enough to know they don't remove seat belts and muck about in a moving car and I'd be furious with my kids if they did this to me or DH.

If however your DH set off without the kids buckled up then that is an entirely different issue and you are entitled to be annoyed with DH and consider whether your kids are safe with him or not.

User2123 · 03/11/2023 18:29

If your 5yo cannot sit sensibly and remain in their seatbelt at all times, then they should still be in a harnessed car seat (preferably rear facing) as they are not mature enough to use the adult seatbelt yet. The same could be said for the 7yo. If DH didn't bother to strap them in, or made no attempt to stop at the nearest safe location when he realised they had unbuckled themselves, then that's a different matter and he deserves the prosecution notice.

Dweetfidilove · 03/11/2023 18:12

Is he a generally ineffective parent?

Most 5 & 7 year old children know seatbelts are non-negotiable, so what inspired them to have them off?

Have you spoken to the children to see if they set off without seatbelts or if they removed them mid-travel?

Coldcaller · 03/11/2023 18:08

It was a school Coach I just used the term Bus Company. I get the impression the driver was not wearing a Seatbelt nor were a lot of the kids. I appreciate it is very difficult to get a large number of teenagers to obey. However, you would think the driver would tell the kids the coach is going nowhere until you are all wearing belts. In this case and other school coaches going forward it has to be compulsory that kids are wearing belts. The schools and Coach Companies have got to work together.

I bring this up because recently probably post Covid I am seeing a number of quite blatant disregards for safety on the roads. These notably include appallingly dangerous driving and people not wearing Seat belts in both the front and back.

Yalta · 03/11/2023 17:56

*Manadou · Today 14:11

If they were climbing about, and clearly unbelted, he should have pulled over and refused to move until they put their belts on. He should not have moved off at the start of the journey until he was sure of that*

That would have been even more dangerous. He was on the M25 and a lot of it doesn’t have a hard shoulder. Saying to stop and refuse to move on the inside lane of the M25 would have resulted in a lot more than an intended prosecution

Even the hard shoulder is a dangerous place to be

Mine took their seatbelts off regularly and scrambled about in the car.

I have been on the M25 and had ds 10months, get out of his rear facing car seat and dd deciding to join him in the front seat. They thought it was hilarious

Hard shoulder is too dangerous to stop on so you have to drive carefully and pull off at the next turning whilst screaming your head off to get back in their seats and then you have the problem of once off the motorway there is very few places you can safely and legally pull over to put them back in their seats again.

If he didn’t strap them in before he set off then by all means read him the riot act but if dc got out of their seats once then next time it could be you who finds yourself prosecuted.

enchantedsquirrelwood · 03/11/2023 17:53

Coldcaller · 03/11/2023 17:47

Its not just cars where people should be wearing Seat Belts poor, Jessica Baker from West Kirby Grammar School would still be alive if she had been wearing one. In that case it is a small miracle that no other children were killed. I have to be seriously be angry with both the bus company and the schools concerned for allowing children to travel on a Motorway without seatbelts on.

I didn't think you were allowed to go on buses without a seat belt anymore but it was a bus and not a coach wasn't it. That was such a sad story.

Coldcaller · 03/11/2023 17:47

Its not just cars where people should be wearing Seat Belts poor, Jessica Baker from West Kirby Grammar School would still be alive if she had been wearing one. In that case it is a small miracle that no other children were killed. I have to be seriously be angry with both the bus company and the schools concerned for allowing children to travel on a Motorway without seatbelts on.

Longdarkcloud · 03/11/2023 17:44

OP take a photo of the summons if it’s still laying around. This is the only documentary evidence you will probably need as evidence.
Where the safety of children is concerned it is no defence to say, well they were naughty and wouldn’t listen to me.
If he is unable to ensure they stay belted in then it would be reasonable for you to request that he not be permitted to drive the children and that contact ought to be at a contact centre until their safety can demonstrated.

aloadofbowlocks · 03/11/2023 17:17

It's all very well people berating the OP for the fact that her STBX is a poor parent - but let's imagine she and her STBX work together to ensure that their DC know that under no circumstances are they to take their seat belts off when they are in the car with their father. Fine. That's a clear rule.

Then what happens in a different dangerous situation for which the children haven't been primed, and which the father is wholly unable to manage?

The children aren't the problem here, and the OP isn't the problem either. The problem is that their father is not able to parent them in a calm and consistent way which keeps them safe. Today it's seat belts. What will it be next time?

LongLostTeacher · 03/11/2023 17:17

It doesn’t matter if the children did make a stupid decision and decide to take their belts off, it is still the driver’s responsibility to ensure their passengers are safe.

Why didn’t he tell the OP about this straight away if the children did this? Surely as co-parent you would want to warn the other parent in case they did it again and so the message on their bad behaviour could be reinforced? I suspect he didn’t tell her because he knows he should have done more and the kids wouldn’t pull this shit on mum because mum parents properly.

Mariposista · 03/11/2023 17:12

PutinSmellsPassItOn · 03/11/2023 16:56

Instead of using the fact your kids were dicking about in a way which could have had serious consequences to point score against your ex you need to be supporting him on this one. It says a lot that he didn't feel he could tell you.........when realistically you need to be working together. Because next time it could be you in a dangerous situation on the motorway when they decide to pull the same stunt......maybe if they had parents who tried to put their own toxicity aside and get along for their sake they'd be a bit better behaved ? 🧐

This.

PutinSmellsPassItOn · 03/11/2023 17:04

If it wasn't thier fault for taking their belts off when he was already driving then whose was it ?

Kids aren't without responsibility, and there's little that can be done when already driving if kids choose to behave in such a stupid way.

Imperfectp3rf3ction · 03/11/2023 16:57

I wouldn't need police evidence tbf if he was yelling at them and blaming them because he failed to follow correct safety protocol and to keep the kidd in the correct safe traveling state yet he is blaming them he is abusive regardless

enchantedsquirrelwood · 03/11/2023 16:57

sandyhappypeople · 03/11/2023 15:35

In fairness, I wouldn't stop on a hard shoulder for this reason, I wouldn't stop on a hard should for ANY reason other than a breakdown, or being pulled over, I'd drop speed, get in the slow lane and carry on to the next junction. You're more likely to be killed on a hard shoulder then driving along normally. ESPECIALLY on a stupid "smart" motorway.

And if the kids weren't wearing seatbelts and you got rear ended on the hard shoulder, it doesn't bare thinking about.

I totally agree with this.

If the kids won't do it with the OP, but did it with their dad, I agree the OP needs to have very serious words with them indeed.

And her ex needs to face the consequences of his inability to keep discipline. I have sympathy to an extent (due to not being able to pull over easily) but the police caught him so he needs to deal with the letter and fast. He does not want a criminal conviction at court either - I don't know if this is the sort of thing that would appear on a DBS but if it is, even more reason to act fast.

People stop on the hard shoulder to change a tyre, if their child is being sick, or even less than that The stats for people who die on hard shoulders are shocking (which is why all the hysteria about smart motorways is a little misguided - no motorways are safe). And this was the M25 so we don't know if that section even had a hard shoulder.

margotrose · 03/11/2023 16:57

Cheesecakefiend · 03/11/2023 16:50

DC without seatbelts on and out of control in a car (if they were crawling around ) is an emergency . No traffic policeman would give a parent a fine for pulling over for this reason.

Edited

You also have to weigh that up against the risk of an accident while you're on the hard shoulder, though.

PutinSmellsPassItOn · 03/11/2023 16:56

Instead of using the fact your kids were dicking about in a way which could have had serious consequences to point score against your ex you need to be supporting him on this one. It says a lot that he didn't feel he could tell you.........when realistically you need to be working together. Because next time it could be you in a dangerous situation on the motorway when they decide to pull the same stunt......maybe if they had parents who tried to put their own toxicity aside and get along for their sake they'd be a bit better behaved ? 🧐

DonnaBanana · 03/11/2023 16:52

Manadou · 03/11/2023 14:11

If they were climbing about, and clearly unbelted, he should have pulled over and refused to move until they put their belts on. He should not have moved off at the start of the journey until he was sure of that.

If that happens while you're in the outside lane of a busy M25, that is easier said than done. Plus it's illegal to stop for that reason, so you can't win either way.

For me it would be down to what the "evidence" is. If it's one of those elevated cameras and issued by a computer, they can barely see anything. If it's a real, human police officer who's actually witnessed the situation and thought it was worth prosecuting, that's an entirely different matter.