Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Husband got Prosecution Notice for 5 and 7 yr old No Seat Belts

213 replies

PoppyMK · 03/11/2023 13:49

My husband received a Notice of Prosecution from the Police because he has apparently been caught driving on the M25 with our two children in the back of the car without seats belts (unclear which child it is, or whether it's both, from the notice).

I am concerned because we are in the process of separating and I want to know exactly what happened so i can make a judgement about whether my children are safe with him. AIBU or overreacting?

I have tried asking him about this - first he claimed he didn't know they had no seat belt on, then he claimed they wouldn't listen to him to stop trying to climb over the back of the seats.

I have no idea how to go about obtaining whatever evidence the Police have - but it would seem to be important that I have access to it as the co-parent of both children?

As an aside, I'm pretty certain he hasn't even responded to the notice by the deadline as I've seen what look like at least two further letters arrive for him, but as that is a problem for him and the consequences of which he will face, which will presumably be automatic points on his licence in addition to those he'll already get for the actual offence.

OP posts:
Lindyloomillion1 · 04/11/2023 19:00

I can see why you are concerned. But don't try to stop him having his kids based on this one incident.
When I was a kid we didn't wear seatbelts. There weren't any. In fact my sister and I were driven across Europe for a holiday in the back of an A40 van where there no seats either.
Just giving a bit of context. Much better safety now which is good but your kids need a less than perfect dad more than none. You can work out the conditions.

IncreasinglyGrumpy · 04/11/2023 18:59

Phone the police that the offense took place in and ask them what the situation is. As their parent im sure they will give you information, if not I'm sure if you are separating and solicitors might get involved they will gain access.
I'd be livid if it was me. I've been involved in two recent shunts and it makes you realise just how quickly your life can change - he was lucky nothing happened.

WrongSwanson · 04/11/2023 18:48

Twentyfirstcenturymumma · 04/11/2023 18:31

This. If they were my kids they would not be allowed to travel with him driving

Unfortunately this isn't entirely within ops control and it's not fair to judge her.

She can ask, and she can express concern but she needs to approach the subject with legal advice ideally as the family courts set a very low bar for dads.

(My son disclosed his dad put his life in grave danger in a very calculated and premeditated way but cafcass met him for 20 minutes over cup of tea and concluded dad was a "lovely man")

enchantedsquirrelwood · 04/11/2023 18:47

ThePeachIsSoUnusual · 03/11/2023 20:26

I hear what you are saying about a 'smart' motorway - they are very dangerous and it's hard to know what to do for the best on them. However, more generally with a hard shoulder, this: I wouldn't stop on a hard shoulder for this reason is misguided. I've for a non-breakdown issue that really required to stop. It's the right thing to do. It's much more dangerous to continue with loose children and a distracted driver trying to monitor what they are doing and get them to behave.

I totally disagree - hard shoulders are dangerous. Paradoxically a refuge bay on a smart motorway might be safer as it is slightly protected compared with the hard shoulder. Too many lorry drivers in particular plough into the back of people on hard shoulders. And there aren't many service areas on the M25 either. But there are quite a few junctions, depending on where you are, so it might be possible to come off the motorway quickly.

I wish the police were so keen to deal with other forms of dangerous driving on the M25, or indeed on the roads in general.

Plunger · 04/11/2023 18:37

My grandchildren used to undo their seatbelts until they found out that a warning sounded in my car so were found out! I would stop when safe to do so but not sure this would be a valid reason on a motorway. Is it more dangerous carrying on to a junction/sevice station or stopping on the hard shoulder especially on so called smart motorways? The hard shoulder or refuge the most dangerous place to stop. Their parents vehicle doesn't warn nor does my partner's.

Twentyfirstcenturymumma · 04/11/2023 18:31

JaxiiTaxii · 03/11/2023 14:09

The fine is your evidence that:

  • The kids were travelling his car without seatbelts.
  • On the motorway.
  • This time he got caught.
  • the police can prove it

I'm not sure why you need anything else.

This. If they were my kids they would not be allowed to travel with him driving

Zerosleep · 04/11/2023 18:29

I think this is enough evidence they clearly aren’t safe with him. How hugely irresponsible, if they had been in an accident, they wouldn’t have survived. I have no sympathy at all for him. So dangerous it’s untrue.

Henryhover · 04/11/2023 18:10

He's blaming the kids? Just aswell you're having a divorce.
Drivers responsibility especially with children in the car!! If they took it off he should of pulled over at the neatest service station.
My car doesn't move until everyone's belts is on

Unbiased111 · 04/11/2023 17:58

Agree kids should of been belted and we don't know the circumstances. I've just read inform social services. This is a big deal, but would you be posting on here if you wasn't splitting up? Is this just another weapon to stop him seeing the kids

sandyhappypeople · 03/11/2023 21:05

ThePeachIsSoUnusual · 03/11/2023 20:26

I hear what you are saying about a 'smart' motorway - they are very dangerous and it's hard to know what to do for the best on them. However, more generally with a hard shoulder, this: I wouldn't stop on a hard shoulder for this reason is misguided. I've for a non-breakdown issue that really required to stop. It's the right thing to do. It's much more dangerous to continue with loose children and a distracted driver trying to monitor what they are doing and get them to behave.

I’d say it’s a judgement call only the driver can make at the time, I wouldn’t stop on a hard shoulder for anything unless I was breaking down or have been pulled over. and I wouldn’t blame anyone else for not pulling over either, it really isn’t safe.. there’s a reason you are advised to abandon the vehicle if you come to a stop on the hard shoulder.

I WOULD however get off at the nearest junction to deal with them.

Unexpectedlysinglemum · 03/11/2023 21:03

The thing is, whether it's naughty kids and they didn't listen, or dad forgot, the fact is the kids weren't safe and without judging him
He objectively wasn't able to keep them safe

Soontobe60 · 03/11/2023 20:36

Londonlondon4 · 03/11/2023 18:50

That is also concerning and needs to be officially documented.

If they took the seatbelts off and tried to climb over the seat, that IS their fault. Do you subscribe to gentle parenting where you’d tickle them with a furry snuggle blanket to make sure they don’t do it again? Or, like the rest of us, do you raise your voice to show just how dangerous their actions were?

Soontobe60 · 03/11/2023 20:33

PoppyMK · 03/11/2023 14:42

@sandyhappypeople yes they have car seats, clearly they have taken off the seatbelts at some point and clambered out of the car seats.

If they did this with you, what would you do?

ThePeachIsSoUnusual · 03/11/2023 20:26

I hear what you are saying about a 'smart' motorway - they are very dangerous and it's hard to know what to do for the best on them. However, more generally with a hard shoulder, this: I wouldn't stop on a hard shoulder for this reason is misguided. I've for a non-breakdown issue that really required to stop. It's the right thing to do. It's much more dangerous to continue with loose children and a distracted driver trying to monitor what they are doing and get them to behave.

WrongSwanson · 03/11/2023 20:18

I am not surprised you are furious op. I would recommend some legal advice. If he is convincted that will be something to reference. Do you have other concerns?

However, my experience of cafcass and the courts (from dealing with it for myself and supporting others) is that even if he had them tied to the roof and was necking beer as he hurtled along the motorway they would probably just say "dad has a more relaxed parenting style than mum but we have no concerns" and leave it at that . The bar is obscenely low.

(Not saying dont do everything you can to keep them safe but also please do some reading understand the topsy turvy rabbit hole world of the family courts so you are prepared )

Lunde · 03/11/2023 20:14

Noseyoldcow · 03/11/2023 16:32

Once upon a time, there was no seatbelt law. Heck, there weren't even seatbelts. And somehow or other, we got to adulthood. Of course the seatbelt laws of today make sense, kids and everybody else should be properly strapped in, and unbuckling and climbing about the car cannot ever be tolerated. I'd say the kids DO need disciplining about this, and the husband too. But if the kids are little sods, then cut him a bit of slack. He's being done for it anyway, isn't he?

Yeah - but a lot of kids got avoidable injuries and many used to die in the "good old days". Easy for people to be thrown through the windscreen in an emergency stop at 70mph

I received a head injury in such an accident in the 1970s in a car with no rear seatbelts. It was a low speed, emergency stop, less than 20mph and I was thrown from the middle rear seat and ended up in the front where I hit my head on the dashboard.

Cerealkiller4U · 03/11/2023 20:13

sandyhappypeople · 03/11/2023 14:38

my nephew is a ninja and you fasten him in securely, get in the car, set off and next thing he's waving his arms about and/or is out of his seat.

I'd question the quality/safety of the car seat if an 18 month old can undo the 5 point harness, those things are tight for an adult to undo. You aren't meant to add anything to a car seat that didn't come with it, but if he can escape from it, then clips that go across the straps would be a no brainer.

I’m pretty certain the straps that go across that you add on are a definite no no from a safety point of view

i remember it coming up at something I was at in relation to why we don’t have the but the states do. If I recall the person said because they have huge safety precautions and should never be used.

But you’re 100% right that if an 18 month old can get out of the car seat that it needs a new one. One of the ones that have the sections you clip in rather than straps are meant to be safer than the 5 point harnesses to from a friend of mine who is a pead dr. He says he operates in at least 2 children a week who are in car accidents and they have a much better safety (his was a few years ago.)

Royalbloo · 03/11/2023 20:07

JaxiiTaxii · 03/11/2023 14:09

The fine is your evidence that:

  • The kids were travelling his car without seatbelts.
  • On the motorway.
  • This time he got caught.
  • the police can prove it

I'm not sure why you need anything else.

This!

Cerealkiller4U · 03/11/2023 20:06

PoppyMK · 03/11/2023 13:49

My husband received a Notice of Prosecution from the Police because he has apparently been caught driving on the M25 with our two children in the back of the car without seats belts (unclear which child it is, or whether it's both, from the notice).

I am concerned because we are in the process of separating and I want to know exactly what happened so i can make a judgement about whether my children are safe with him. AIBU or overreacting?

I have tried asking him about this - first he claimed he didn't know they had no seat belt on, then he claimed they wouldn't listen to him to stop trying to climb over the back of the seats.

I have no idea how to go about obtaining whatever evidence the Police have - but it would seem to be important that I have access to it as the co-parent of both children?

As an aside, I'm pretty certain he hasn't even responded to the notice by the deadline as I've seen what look like at least two further letters arrive for him, but as that is a problem for him and the consequences of which he will face, which will presumably be automatic points on his licence in addition to those he'll already get for the actual offence.

The police won’t tell you anything.

PhantomUnicorn · 03/11/2023 20:03

"I am concerned because we are in the process of separating and I want to know exactly what happened so i can make a judgement about whether my children are safe with him. AIBU or overreacting?"

From your OP.

"this is just one of many examples of questionable choices which, over time and taken together, mean I have to constantly consider whether the safety of my children is being compromised"

From your second post

"I think this is down to his parenting style rather than an inherently poor discipline in the children"

From your 4th post

I think i've got your tone and reasons down thanks. Its not to do with supporting your H to make sure the kids are behaving in a dangerous situation. It IS down to inherently poor discipline btw.

But carry on, next time it might be a phonecall from the police reporting a crash, but you keep on patting yourself on the back because "they've never done it with me, I think because they absolutely know I won't tolerate it."

PoppyMK · 03/11/2023 19:52

@PhantomUnicorn i think if you read both the tone and the content of my replies you’ll see this is actually the opposite of point scoring. If I was point scoring I wouldn’t feel the need to ask if I was being reasonable (and I probably wouldn’t care what other’s viewpoints were), I’d just be hassling a lawyer, social services etc., which I have no intention of doing. It’s exactly because, in theory, this could happen to any parent I asked for the views of others. As you’ll see there are a range of views expressed in the comments and so that confirms this is not a straightforward judgement to make. I wasn’t asking for views on whether I should be annoyed at the kids or back him up that what they did was wrong (I did both!). I encourage you to read all the things the OP says before commenting so you’re actually adding to the debate without looking to judge the motives of the OP somewhat unfairly.

OP posts:
ZoeCM · 03/11/2023 19:38

Once upon a time, there was no seatbelt law. Heck, there weren't even seatbelts. And somehow or other, we got to adulthood.

Well, not everyone did! The ones who were killed aren't here to tell their stories. It's not as though seatbelt laws were brought in for no reason. Plus, there were fewer cars on the road in the 70s.

Domestic violence and sexual assault used to be taken much less seriously than they are now. It doesn't mean that was a good thing. Princess Diana would probably be alive today if she'd been wearing a seatbelt.

Pooooochi · 03/11/2023 19:30

The 7 year old should know not to ever undo their seatbelt in the car, even if dad is more lax on discipline than you. Tbh the 5 year old should too.

They are pretty fucking naughty kids if they are pulling this stunt on any adult. The m25 can be quite hard to immediately pull over on, its absolutely chocker 99% of the time.

Burnoutwhat · 03/11/2023 19:25

This feels strange they seem like well disciplined kids with you then would do this with him. What is he normally like with parenting and risk? This will tell and everyone else a lot about how likely it is he did this on purpose.

LizzBurg · 03/11/2023 19:23

So if it’s a notice of intended prosecution then they will most likely call him in for a voluntary interview where they will put the evidence to him.
lf he’s received a summons or postal requisition to attend or submit a plea to court then any evidence would be sent with it.
He may get offered a fixed penalty. You aren’t entitled to be told or to see anything.

Swipe left for the next trending thread