Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Husband got Prosecution Notice for 5 and 7 yr old No Seat Belts

213 replies

PoppyMK · 03/11/2023 13:49

My husband received a Notice of Prosecution from the Police because he has apparently been caught driving on the M25 with our two children in the back of the car without seats belts (unclear which child it is, or whether it's both, from the notice).

I am concerned because we are in the process of separating and I want to know exactly what happened so i can make a judgement about whether my children are safe with him. AIBU or overreacting?

I have tried asking him about this - first he claimed he didn't know they had no seat belt on, then he claimed they wouldn't listen to him to stop trying to climb over the back of the seats.

I have no idea how to go about obtaining whatever evidence the Police have - but it would seem to be important that I have access to it as the co-parent of both children?

As an aside, I'm pretty certain he hasn't even responded to the notice by the deadline as I've seen what look like at least two further letters arrive for him, but as that is a problem for him and the consequences of which he will face, which will presumably be automatic points on his licence in addition to those he'll already get for the actual offence.

OP posts:
LizzBurg · 05/11/2023 11:40

As an aside, I'm pretty certain he hasn't even responded to the notice by the deadline as I've seen what look like at least two further letters arrive for him, but as that is a problem for him and the consequences of which he will face, which will presumably be automatic points on his licence in addition to those he'll already get for the actual offence.

I’ve just noticed this. If the NIP was sent with a s172 notice to name the driver and he hasn’t responded then he could be prosecuted for failure to name the driver. That offence would replace any seatbelt case because the driver isn’t established. Failing to name carries a heftier fine and points than the sear belt one.
If he is already confirmed as the driver and the correspondence is to arrange a voluntary interview which he ignores then they can build the case without his account. If the additional letters are a summons or postal requisition and he doesn’t respond then they can prove the case in his absence.

Vitriolinsanity · 05/11/2023 11:36

It's not quite as easy to pull over on a motorway as you'd think, particularly a smart motorway.

It sounds plausible to me that the kids are out of their belts, but dad can't stop/get off to the next junction when they're spotted by a police car.

It really shouldn't be a question of which parent is driving, so much as the kids shouldn't be getting out of their seats when the car is moving at all.

PhantomUnicorn · 05/11/2023 11:06

Q2C4 · 05/11/2023 10:27

@NewFriendlyLadybird so what are you supposed to do when your 3yr old manages to open the car door on a motorway?

they shouldn't be able to. You should have the childlocks on and the windows also locked if they're clever enough to figure out you can open a window and open the door from the outside.

if you're driving with children under 8 without the childlocks on, you're courting chaos.

sandyhappypeople · 05/11/2023 10:40

Q2C4 · 05/11/2023 10:27

@NewFriendlyLadybird so what are you supposed to do when your 3yr old manages to open the car door on a motorway?

How on earth would a 3 year old manage to open a car door on a motorway?

Timeforchangeithink · 05/11/2023 10:32

Yabu, in fact since you say they wouldn't do it with you perhaps your kids need to be taught how to respect their elders- particularly ones "on the spectrum". You seem very keen to blame yous H rather than two unruly kids.

Q2C4 · 05/11/2023 10:27

@NewFriendlyLadybird so what are you supposed to do when your 3yr old manages to open the car door on a motorway?

PerspicaciaTick · 05/11/2023 10:25

I would want to know why he was pulled over. Was there some other issue with his driving that made the police notice him and they only spotted the unbuckled kids when they pulled him over? Or were the kids visibly bouncing around in the back for long enough for the police to notice and decide the driver wasn't dealing with it?
Absolutely on the dad for not dealing with them himself as soon as he realised there was a problem.

greyhairnomore · 05/11/2023 10:09

In my view, they aren't as well disciplined with him because he often isn't aware (a bit on the spectrum) and then when he is aware, he won't consistently and firmly follow up.@PoppyMK
*
So rude ( not to him )*

LizzBurg · 05/11/2023 10:00

sandyhappypeople · 05/11/2023 09:49

I’m not sure about the stats, but it’s pretty common sense that being stationery next to a busy live 70mph lane, is more dangerous then pulling off at a services or leaving at a junction and finding a safe place to pull over.

all it takes is a second of inattention by someone in the slow lane and they could easily clip your car. If someone is entering/exiting the vehicle at the time or a rear seat passenger has no seatbelt, it would almost certainly end in a fatality.

Even people sat in the car wearing seatbelts can easily be killed in those circumstances, that’s exactly why you are told to abandon the vehicle if you come to a stop on a hard shoulder. .

Exactly this, if you have to stop on the hard shoulder exit your vehicle and get the other side of the crash barrier. That is why people should have a space blanket or similar in their cars so they can stay warm.

rwalker · 05/11/2023 09:57

We had one that used to undo there seat belt
right or wrong I’d take the least worst option of carrying on rather stopping on the hard shoulder terrifies me especially when your all in The car

sandyhappypeople · 05/11/2023 09:49

Edamfan · 05/11/2023 07:29

Does anyone have any stats for the safety of old-style hard shoulders?
we have pulled over on the hard shoulder in the rare event our sn child has undone their seatbelt.
But may not in future if what we are doing is statistically less safe than pulling off at the next junction.

I’m not sure about the stats, but it’s pretty common sense that being stationery next to a busy live 70mph lane, is more dangerous then pulling off at a services or leaving at a junction and finding a safe place to pull over.

all it takes is a second of inattention by someone in the slow lane and they could easily clip your car. If someone is entering/exiting the vehicle at the time or a rear seat passenger has no seatbelt, it would almost certainly end in a fatality.

Even people sat in the car wearing seatbelts can easily be killed in those circumstances, that’s exactly why you are told to abandon the vehicle if you come to a stop on a hard shoulder. .

Blueink · 05/11/2023 09:40

Soontobe60 · 04/11/2023 22:14

We don't know that he didn't. If he were caught on camera he may not have known until the notice came through the post.

Hi soontobe did you mean to quote me?

Idkwym by “we don’t know that he didn’t”

My post doesn’t mention whether he knew or didn’t know, but in the OPs he admitted he did know.

Blueink · 05/11/2023 09:34

I would warn them very firmly they are behaving dangerously and you are going to stop the car if they don’t sit back in their car seat and put their seat belt back on.

I would meanwhile be driving to the next safe place to stop, but not stop at the hard shoulder, as wouldn’t consider that a safe place.

drivinmecrazy · 05/11/2023 09:17

DDs screech at me to stop the car if I ever start leaving our driveway and they aren't clipped in.
They are now 22 & 18!!
I did have one incident when DD1 was around two and decided to unclip herself from her car seat and try and open the door while going round a roundabout.
Since then they've known the rules 😂

WitsEnd10 · 05/11/2023 09:08

ChristmasPuddingFace · 03/11/2023 16:16

Stopping on the Hard Shoulder is an incredibly dangerous thing to do and should only be done in an absolute emergency.

@melj1213 So is driving with 2 kids not using seat belts, on a motorway.

Do you ever drive on motorways?

People stop on the hard shoulder to change a tyre, if their child is being sick, or even less than that.

It's VERY dangerous to have 2 children loose in the back of a car.
One sharp emergency stop for any reason and they could be out of the window, or brain damaged/dead from hitting their heads on the seat in front.

It's also illegal not to be strapped in.

Is that enough reason for you?

Having watched an episode of The Crash Detectives where 3 and 4 year old siblings died when their car, stopped on the hard shoulder because one of the children felt unwell, was smashed into by a van, no I absolutely wouldn’t stop on the hard shoulder for anything less than a vehicle failure. And I’d be getting out and clear of the car immediately.

BeardieWeirdie · 05/11/2023 08:44

If my children had taken off their seatbelts when old enough to know better (and yours definitely are, my three-year-old knows the rule), I’d absolutely be yelling at them. He may well be a crap dad in other areas but they need to understand that this is absolutely unacceptable and a very naughty thing to do. Report him to social services so you like but be prepared for the little brats to do it in your car too if they behave like this with him.

AnRuaRi · 05/11/2023 08:40

I drive a minibus for an adventure centre. Im also a Dad o 4 unrully kids with additional needs that affect their behaviour.
this is a clear cut case of the dad has the wrong attitude. correct response is:
Stop the car till all seat belts are on. (many cas sound an alarm if a belt is unplugged)
even if this means on the hard shoulder. unbelted kids is reasonable to stop on hard shoulder as its illegal to drive on till fixed.

LizzBurg · 05/11/2023 08:34

PrettyButterflies · 05/11/2023 07:17

Hi, I am sure it's probably been said somewhere in the thread but he wouldn't have gotten a NOIP if he hasn't been stopped. The police cannot fully see inside the vehicle when observing so they will use blue lights if they think a crime is being committed. The children may have been moving around, which is another reason they blue lighted. I say again, he would not have received this if he hadn't have been stopped - so him telling you that he has no knowledge of the incident or whatever - he is lying.

They can be sent NIP if they haven’t been stopped. Usually when stopped they are given a verbal NIP.

H007 · 05/11/2023 08:29

How old are the Dc?

Edamfan · 05/11/2023 07:29

Does anyone have any stats for the safety of old-style hard shoulders?
we have pulled over on the hard shoulder in the rare event our sn child has undone their seatbelt.
But may not in future if what we are doing is statistically less safe than pulling off at the next junction.

PrettyButterflies · 05/11/2023 07:17

Hi, I am sure it's probably been said somewhere in the thread but he wouldn't have gotten a NOIP if he hasn't been stopped. The police cannot fully see inside the vehicle when observing so they will use blue lights if they think a crime is being committed. The children may have been moving around, which is another reason they blue lighted. I say again, he would not have received this if he hadn't have been stopped - so him telling you that he has no knowledge of the incident or whatever - he is lying.

Morechocmorechoc · 05/11/2023 07:07

It's against the law because it causes death. Its not acceptable and my kids wouldn't be going with him. It's pretty basic.

LizzBurg · 05/11/2023 06:53

Emeraldsanddiamonds · 04/11/2023 21:20

I'd try calling the police. They are your children so you could say you're entitled to know what happened. Just be really polite and sound very worried.

It’s nothing to do with her, he might be prosecuted and the children are unharmed.

LizzBurg · 05/11/2023 06:48

SparklyRainbows · 05/11/2023 06:26

I'd think this is something your divorce solicitor can advise on. Perhaps they can even get hold of the evidence.

Without a court order the police would not share any evidence with the solicitor. If he is convicted the result would be public record.

SparklyRainbows · 05/11/2023 06:26

I'd think this is something your divorce solicitor can advise on. Perhaps they can even get hold of the evidence.