Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Husband got Prosecution Notice for 5 and 7 yr old No Seat Belts

213 replies

PoppyMK · 03/11/2023 13:49

My husband received a Notice of Prosecution from the Police because he has apparently been caught driving on the M25 with our two children in the back of the car without seats belts (unclear which child it is, or whether it's both, from the notice).

I am concerned because we are in the process of separating and I want to know exactly what happened so i can make a judgement about whether my children are safe with him. AIBU or overreacting?

I have tried asking him about this - first he claimed he didn't know they had no seat belt on, then he claimed they wouldn't listen to him to stop trying to climb over the back of the seats.

I have no idea how to go about obtaining whatever evidence the Police have - but it would seem to be important that I have access to it as the co-parent of both children?

As an aside, I'm pretty certain he hasn't even responded to the notice by the deadline as I've seen what look like at least two further letters arrive for him, but as that is a problem for him and the consequences of which he will face, which will presumably be automatic points on his licence in addition to those he'll already get for the actual offence.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Yalta · 07/11/2023 11:16

There are a lot of people who aren’t that familiar with M25

Hard shoulder, did you mean the inside lane. Because that is what counts as the hard shoulder in a lot of sections

Services 🤣🤣🤣 The next services could be 30 miles away. There are only 4 service stations on the whole of the M25

emmalou I am guessing you either have no children or one child who is a girl. You remind me of a group of mums who had only one girl child each who would stand in the playground before and after school and congratulate themselves on their brilliant parenting as they had taught their dds to not jump in puddles or roll in the mud or run around shouting or take their seatbelts off when they were driving.
Add to the fact that their dds were in the highest reading group and they really thought they were much better parents.
Then one of the group had a little boy and suddenly it dawned on her that it wasn’t her parenting ability that meant her dd didnt runaround But the fact it was just her dds personality

All the parenting tricks she had used to turn her dd into this well behaved child top group child didn’t work on her ds.
He would laugh at her when she told him not to roll in the mud, jump in puddles run off in the supermarket car park and take his seatbelt off in the car and there was nothing she could do to get him to stop.

Q2C4 · 07/11/2023 11:03

@LoneFemaleTraveller they are now...! if you read my follow up you'll see that we frantically consulted the manual to find out how to put them on! (Car was newish to us at least).

enchantedsquirrelwood · 07/11/2023 09:05

Elpaso42 · 05/11/2023 23:58

I honestly can't believe how judgemental people are being here, with minimal information. It's more than likely that the kids unstrapped themselves and he obviously wasn't sure what to do. I agree with others that stopping on the hard shoulder is dangerous in itself.
The main point is that he is being dealt with legally, the idea that she should try to take his children away over this is just cruel.

Children misbehave and seems you both need to get on the same page regarding discipline, as they are only going to get worse during a divorce so you both need to have a united front regarding their behaviour.

I totally agree, and I just don't buy that all the parents posting here have perfectly behaved kids all the time. My ds never tried to undo a seatbelt but that was just because he didn't, not because of my superior "parenting".

enchantedsquirrelwood · 07/11/2023 09:03

Edamfan · 05/11/2023 07:29

Does anyone have any stats for the safety of old-style hard shoulders?
we have pulled over on the hard shoulder in the rare event our sn child has undone their seatbelt.
But may not in future if what we are doing is statistically less safe than pulling off at the next junction.

I can't remember the stats now but the casualty rate on the hard shoulders is very high. Hence why I couldn't quite understand all the complaining about smart motorways, as no motorway is safe if you break down or need to stop for another reason.

Blueink · 07/11/2023 08:27

Soontobe60 · 07/11/2023 06:57

‘We don't know that he didn't take decisive action at the time’

From his behaviour afterwards and what OP has said so far, he didn’t and doesn’t take decisive action with the DC..

If the police saw him stopping to deal with the situation there would’ve been more likely to follow and speak to him or not issued this.

If he pulled over at the next services to deal with the DC it will form part of his defence.

Andistarr · 07/11/2023 07:39

This comment has to be one of the most self-righteous I've read.

Soontobe60 · 07/11/2023 06:57

Blueink · 05/11/2023 09:40

Hi soontobe did you mean to quote me?

Idkwym by “we don’t know that he didn’t”

My post doesn’t mention whether he knew or didn’t know, but in the OPs he admitted he did know.

‘We don't know that he didn't take decisive action at the time’

melj1213 · 06/11/2023 22:14

PeachyPeachTrees · 06/11/2023 19:51

Children not in seatbelts on motorway is serious. He then blamed the kids when he is the responsible adult. Then he ignores the letters. I personally wouldn't trust him to drive them anywhere again. What a prick, I can see why he is going to be an ex.

He's the responsible adult but if the children take their seatbelts off on the motorway then the children are to blame as they are both more than old enough to know that seatbelts in the car are non-negotiable and taking them off is very dangerous.

As the driver he had to make a decision - which was more dangerous: stopping immediately on the hard shoulder to restrain the children as quickly as possible so he's stopped for as short a period of time as possible (due to the high risk of being hit by another driver as being on the hard shoulder is the most dangerous place to be on a motorway) or getting into the left hand lane, slowing as much as possible and driving on to the nearest junction/services (while the children are not fastened into their seats they are still safer in the car on the motorway when it's moving than when stationary) where he could stop safely, take a break from driving (often a situation like this can cause the driver to need a few minutes as the adrenaline from the shock wears off), have the time to explain why their actions were so dangerous and then securely restrain the children before setting off again.

Yalta · 06/11/2023 21:06

PeachyPeachTrees Maybe the kids were to blame

PeachyPeachTrees · 06/11/2023 19:51

Children not in seatbelts on motorway is serious. He then blamed the kids when he is the responsible adult. Then he ignores the letters. I personally wouldn't trust him to drive them anywhere again. What a prick, I can see why he is going to be an ex.

LizzBurg · 06/11/2023 06:32

PollyPut · 05/11/2023 23:22

I would think that if you write in and ask for a copy of photographs giving the vehicle reg you might get it sent to you at the same address that the Notice was sent to? There must be an address on the back of the envelope?

Totally unacceptable and I wouldn't let them in his car in this situation - even if I wasn't separated.

If he drives for work then I wonder if his job is at risk if he doesn't respond

Why would the police send her any evidence? It’s nothing to do with her. And if there are photographs what difference would it make if the OP has them? He’s already told her about the NIP and if he’s prosecuted that information would be public record.
If he was stopped by the police then you would think a 5 and 7 year old would mention daddy talking to the police. He’s probably either been observed by an officer who couldn’t stop so has sent the NIP/s172 afterwards or a member of public has sent in dashcam to op snap and the letter has come from them.

Elpaso42 · 05/11/2023 23:58

I honestly can't believe how judgemental people are being here, with minimal information. It's more than likely that the kids unstrapped themselves and he obviously wasn't sure what to do. I agree with others that stopping on the hard shoulder is dangerous in itself.
The main point is that he is being dealt with legally, the idea that she should try to take his children away over this is just cruel.

Children misbehave and seems you both need to get on the same page regarding discipline, as they are only going to get worse during a divorce so you both need to have a united front regarding their behaviour.

emmaloo14 · 05/11/2023 23:47

At 5 & 7, I’d expect both children to remain seated with their seat belts on during a car ride. Both children will now be in some formal education setting and will know about rules and if you break rules there are consequences, so I can’t think of any excuse of why these children think it’s acceptable . I also wanted to add there is a lot of negative towards the dad of the children and its clear from your posts that you parent differently but sitting sensibly in a car is none negotiable for me.

PollyPut · 05/11/2023 23:22

I would think that if you write in and ask for a copy of photographs giving the vehicle reg you might get it sent to you at the same address that the Notice was sent to? There must be an address on the back of the envelope?

Totally unacceptable and I wouldn't let them in his car in this situation - even if I wasn't separated.

If he drives for work then I wonder if his job is at risk if he doesn't respond

LoneFemaleTraveller · 05/11/2023 23:15

Q2C4 · 05/11/2023 15:52

@sandyhappypeople DC did not need to get out of the car seat to open the door. The handle is reachable from the seat if you lean forward a bit. The door only opened a tiny fraction, just enough for the door alarm to sound. At 70mph you can't open a door much more than that. I leant over from the front passenger seat & held the door closed until we could stop - then I ran out, shut the door properly & frantically consulted the manual to find the child locks. Then delivered a stern lecture about not touching the door handles!

Why are your childlocks not on?

Soulou · 05/11/2023 21:16

Another thought if the children undo seat belts I would also make sure children locks were in operation on all doors. My friends always new when I had been with dgc as I would have to get out and open doors, even though new the rules and never broke them.

WilmaWonka · 05/11/2023 16:42

I assume the police pulled him over so it must have been very visible the DC didn’t have seatbelts on, as in standing up or climbing over seats? I didn’t think cameras would pick that up on a motorway, there’s only speed cameras on the M25 as far as I’m aware and zi drive on it regularly.

This is both DC not just one who suddenly decided to take their seatbelt off at the moment the police were behind and would have been at speed although the M25 is 50 in some areas but that’s still fast enough to serious injury if having to emergency stop or slow down quickly if cut up.

I’d certainly try to avoid him driving them anywhere from now on with such shit parenting.

NewFriendlyLadybird · 05/11/2023 16:21

Q2C4 · 05/11/2023 10:27

@NewFriendlyLadybird so what are you supposed to do when your 3yr old manages to open the car door on a motorway?

I can’t remember what I said that this would be in reply to but luckily I’ve always had child locks.

Q2C4 · 05/11/2023 15:52

@sandyhappypeople DC did not need to get out of the car seat to open the door. The handle is reachable from the seat if you lean forward a bit. The door only opened a tiny fraction, just enough for the door alarm to sound. At 70mph you can't open a door much more than that. I leant over from the front passenger seat & held the door closed until we could stop - then I ran out, shut the door properly & frantically consulted the manual to find the child locks. Then delivered a stern lecture about not touching the door handles!

sandyhappypeople · 05/11/2023 15:40

Q2C4 · 05/11/2023 14:36

@sandyhappypeople we couldn't believe it either!

Assuming a three year old could get out of their car seat, then be able to open the door handle (assuming you didn’t have any child locks engaged??) they wouldn’t have been able to open the door at motorway speeds, it’s just not physically possible.

I’d actually be loath to pull up on the hard shoulder for a different reason as if there was no child locks, there’d nothing to stop them opening the door when you come to a stop, and they could be straight out into motorway traffic, it would be safer to get off the motorway to deal with it.. and put the child locks on!

Q2C4 · 05/11/2023 14:37

@PhantomUnicorn you haven't actually answered the question.

Q2C4 · 05/11/2023 14:36

@sandyhappypeople we couldn't believe it either!

SuperBored · 05/11/2023 13:03

PhantomUnicorn · 03/11/2023 20:03

"I am concerned because we are in the process of separating and I want to know exactly what happened so i can make a judgement about whether my children are safe with him. AIBU or overreacting?"

From your OP.

"this is just one of many examples of questionable choices which, over time and taken together, mean I have to constantly consider whether the safety of my children is being compromised"

From your second post

"I think this is down to his parenting style rather than an inherently poor discipline in the children"

From your 4th post

I think i've got your tone and reasons down thanks. Its not to do with supporting your H to make sure the kids are behaving in a dangerous situation. It IS down to inherently poor discipline btw.

But carry on, next time it might be a phonecall from the police reporting a crash, but you keep on patting yourself on the back because "they've never done it with me, I think because they absolutely know I won't tolerate it."

Edited

As already alluded to by pp about social workers, in the courts there is a very low bar as to what is deemed to be acceptable parenting, imho you will be on a hiding to nothing if you expect this to influence how shared care will be allocated.

AnotherEmma · 05/11/2023 12:38

PoppyMK · 03/11/2023 14:41

@Neriah just to be clear, I'm not suggesting that this will in any way affect his access or rights to the children in isolation. But neither do I want to dismiss this out of hand as this is just one of many examples of questionable choices which, over time and taken together, mean I have to constantly consider whether the safety of my children is being compromised. I'm sure you'll appreciate that is difficult and very hard emotionally, but I have to put the safety of my children first.

"this is just one of many examples of questionable choices which, over time and taken together, mean I have to constantly consider whether the safety of my children is being compromised."

This is absolutely key. I'm not surprised there's a lot more behind this one incident - which is a very serious incident - and the fact that you two are separating. You absolutely need to consider the safety and well-being of your children as paramount when you are negotiating child arrangements. In the first instance you could seek advice from NSPCC. I do think it's worth talking to social services to seek their advice on protecting the children. I wonder if police have reported to them already? In which case you should be proactive and reach out to them as well.

If you and your STBXH are not able to reach an agreement between yourselves or in mediation, you will need to go to court and CAFCASS should be involved. See https://childlawadvice.org.uk/information-pages/the-role-of-cafcass/

AIBU is really not the best place for this kind of thread so I suggest you get it moved or start a new one in Relationships or Legal.

The role of Cafcass - childlawadvice.org.uk

This page explains the role of the Children and Family Court Advisory and Support Service in the court process, including the safeguarding checks that they carry out and explaining section 7 reports.

https://childlawadvice.org.uk/information-pages/the-role-of-cafcass/#:~:text=Cafcass%20work%20with%20children%20and,or%20in%20an%20adoption%20applications.

Whydoifeelsobadallthetime · 05/11/2023 11:56

I would imagine that he was caught, just like other people are with driving offences.
Years ago my (stupid) husband was eating pasta on the motorway. He said there was a vehicle next to him, next thing he sees is some sort of recording device and he's pulled over.

So if its anything like that situation, they will have a recording of what actually happened.

I wouldn't be letting him take them into a car anytime soon, however you do need legal advice, ASAP on how you can enforce this.

I think that the fact he was driving on a motorway with them without a seat belt shows quite an extreme lack of care for their safety.
Then the shouting at them when you got home, all seems a bit like the less exposure to him the better.

Devil's advocate for just a second though. What have the kids said happened? Did they undo their belts?

Swipe left for the next trending thread