Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think there’s nothing wrong with this office friendship?

59 replies

AbstractLandscapes · 03/11/2023 13:28

Two months in and I’ve found myself the subject of office gossip.

I took a 6 year break to try to become a painter. Painted water colour portraits of people’s houses which did quite well for a while, but demand dwindled and it got to a point where I dreaded picking up a paintbrush so I figured it was time to stop.

Two months ago I landed my current job. I knew nothing about this industry but my boss took a chance on me because I had unique skills and I like to believe that I’m good enough at it now.

That was the first point of contention with my colleagues. For the first month, they really had to pick up the slack for me and I think they weren’t expecting having to train someone from scratch. Heard through the grapevine that people thought I was a “nepo baby” even though I don’t know anyone there.

Last month, the head of our HR department retired and they promoted someone from another branch across the country to be the new head of HR.

Sometime during that week I ran into her at the coffeeshop on my way to work and we somehow got to chatting. We quickly became friends and she’s basically my “coffee buddy” now. Apparently this is another sticking point!! Heard again through the grapevine (2 separate reliable sources) that I’m now apparently a social climber!

Are people in HR or management not supposed to have friends?

AIBU to think there’s nothing wrong with this friendship?

OP posts:
Starlia · 04/11/2023 09:34

I am in a senior/executive role and I wouldn’t have coffee with one particular person to the exclusion of others no matter how friendly I was with them.
It’s not appropriate for the HR Director to be singling you out for coffee. I honestly can’t believe that they don’t see the professional boundaries being crossed. Are they new to the role?
I think you need to cultivate friendships with your colleagues.

ShoesoftheWorld · 04/11/2023 09:28

I agree with poetryandwine that there's something a bit disingenuous about your tone - there's a bit of 'oh, look at me, always landing on my feet' (and a very slight side order of 'because I'm the sort of marvellous person that influential people can't help liking') hovering around it. If that's coming across in the workplace, it won't be helping your position with your colleagues. It's human nature for them to resent having to carry you initially, especially if they themselves were expected to hit the ground running, and I think you know that the coffee friendship with the HR director does cross the boundaries of what is sensible for her professionally, as several PPs point out.

CoolShoeshine · 04/11/2023 09:22

I wouldn’t worry about it too much op, sounds as though the person who told you was stirring. However if you can become instant besties with the HR Head then surely you can find something in common with your direct colleagues?

TheRealLilyMunster · 04/11/2023 09:21

I'm a manager, and no, I can't have work friends.

That would cause massive problems within my team. Bitching, accusations of favouritism, them wondering what we are talking about while we are having our coffee.

It sounds ridiculously childish, but unfortunately that's what would happen.

lionsleepstonight · 04/11/2023 09:09

Epidote · 04/11/2023 08:16

The friendship is not a problem.
I'm intrigued which unique skills you have to get the job?

This really.

And have you actually got better at your job or are you being carried?

AlisonDonut · 04/11/2023 09:05

A social climber and a nepo baby.

That's quite a feat!

PrincessScarlett · 04/11/2023 09:03

wideawakeinthemiddleofthenightagain · 04/11/2023 08:42

In case you need it spelling out... the issue with being seen to be friends with the HR Director is that some people will see you as having a veneer of protection as will think the HR Director will always been biased in your favour. If they ever feel that you aren't doing your job properly, are bullying them or anything else then they can't go to HR. Others will think that you are telling HR things about them - and, even if you don't think you are, you will be! Finally, they will think that you are getting information from the HR Director, either about individual members of staff (possibly including them) or just an insight into what is happening at that more senior level.
You might say "oh no, we only ever talk about food" but there are bound to be passing comments to work situations.

100% agree with this. In the corporate firms I've worked in, the HR departments remain separate and don't become best friends with random members of staff. My BIL is a HR director and has stated on many occasions that it's not professional to form close friendships with staff members as it always causes problems.

Sexlivesofthepotatomen · 04/11/2023 08:51

So where does the nepo baby come into it? Do you have famous parents?

Anetra · 04/11/2023 08:44

What do you mean you heard it through the grapevine and two separate reliable sources? Who is coming to you and telling you this shit?

Are you saying these sources have told you that the office thinks you are a nepo baby and a social climber?????

That’s what you need to worry about - people who carry stories directly to you are not reliable sources - they are being mean and gossipy straight to your face - not reliable at all.

Next time one of them tries to tell you some tittle tattle they heard about you just shut it down immediately and say you don’t want to hear. That is the problem solved.

wideawakeinthemiddleofthenightagain · 04/11/2023 08:42

In case you need it spelling out... the issue with being seen to be friends with the HR Director is that some people will see you as having a veneer of protection as will think the HR Director will always been biased in your favour. If they ever feel that you aren't doing your job properly, are bullying them or anything else then they can't go to HR. Others will think that you are telling HR things about them - and, even if you don't think you are, you will be! Finally, they will think that you are getting information from the HR Director, either about individual members of staff (possibly including them) or just an insight into what is happening at that more senior level.
You might say "oh no, we only ever talk about food" but there are bound to be passing comments to work situations.

ImCamembertTheBigCheese · 04/11/2023 08:31

How are you hearing this 'office grapevine' news?

theduchessofspork · 04/11/2023 08:30

Epidote · 04/11/2023 08:16

The friendship is not a problem.
I'm intrigued which unique skills you have to get the job?

She was an artist and is now a graphic designer, so presumably they think she brings a different kind of creativity to the gig.

Anyway OP, it appears your colleagues aren’t overly keen on you, and that could be simply that it’s a toxic environment, or a bit of that and a bit of you not making enough of an effort to be appreciative when they had to carry you, which you now being mates with the new head of HR has compounded.

I wouldn’t worry about it, if you need to make a bit more effort with them do that, but accept you are going to be a bit of a Lone Ranger at this point. Either you will find your place in this company, or you’ll take the experience and leave.

It might be worth developing your skills into motion graphics BTW - there is quite a shortage of people.

Tara336 · 04/11/2023 08:27

Unfortunately you will come across people that having nothing better to do but bitch and moan. It says everything about who they are and it isn't really about you. It's jealousy and sounds like low level bullying. I worked my backside off in my last job and got promoted to a senior level, the nastiness from other (female) employees who I had thought were my friends was quite the eye opener, instead of saying well done they said awful things about me behind my back.

InsertUsernameHere · 04/11/2023 08:27

Good advice from @MaybeDoctor At one point in my career I was promoted to quite a senior position and a friend was asking me what the difference was - she was expecting to hear about responsibility etc.. and I remember saying ‘you don’t have work pals anymore’. If you are making decisions about workload/allocation/promotions/grievances you need to be seen to be fair. I experienced the change from friends to people I was friendly with. (A slight tangent from what you were asking but no in my experience people working in HR/management don’t get to have work friends in the same way)

Kattiekat · 04/11/2023 08:24

Make a bit more effort with your colleagues. Bring in some cake as a thank you. Go out of your way to say hello when you get into the office. Invite someone who has helped train you to coffee. Join in with office chats.

it may be a sore point for your colleagues to train you for a job that management didn’t see them fit to do.

cut them some slack and get stuck in as part of the team. Let them get to know you on a more personal level.

whenever these people come to you with rumours do not say anything negative in reply. Just as they tell you I am almost positive they are doing the same with your colleagues.

kill them with kindness as the saying goes.

Ramalangadingdong · 04/11/2023 08:20

One thing that stands out is that you don’t mention becoming a coffee buddy to anyone else in your department. They can’t all hate you. There must be at least one person you can make the effort to get to know better. How come you made friends with the person from HR? I am curious to know what you have in common that you don’t share with your colleagues.

Epidote · 04/11/2023 08:16

The friendship is not a problem.
I'm intrigued which unique skills you have to get the job?

MaybeDoctor · 04/11/2023 08:10

My advice is to invest a bit more time/effort into your immediate colleagues. It will pay off and you may find friends in unexpected places.

MaybeDoctor · 04/11/2023 08:05

I think you are being a little naive. You are an intelligent person and say that you had a ‘hippie’ upbringing. But surely you know (even from reading or popular culture?) that hierarchies exist in the workplace and that being taken on into a skilled role without any experience is an unusual situation that might ruffle some feathers amongst colleagues.

Many people have an out-of-mainstream upbringing (I did, to a certain degree) so then have to consciously adapt in order to succeed in social groups and in the workplace.

Having said that I did once encounter a postgrad student who argued vigorously that schools were not hierarchical or restrictive places. It turned out that he had been to Summerhill…

Bib1234 · 04/11/2023 08:03

I’d be questioning why you ‘reliable sources’ are even telling you this and what is their gain? Friends or nice people wouldn’t be telling you this stuff

Northernladdette · 04/11/2023 08:01

I started a job and was gossiped about, they didn’t like me. Transpired the office manager’s friend had been doing the job temporarily and didn’t get the permanent position. I ignored them, kept my head down and did the work, once they got to know me it was fine.

WHALESURPRISE · 04/11/2023 07:49

Think about it from their point of view. You randomly get a job you're not qualified or experienced to do and they have to pick up the slack while you're trained.... Then you magically become bffs with a high up in HR?
I can see why they think something's a bit iffy, even though you haven't done anything "wrong". Just keep improving your work and I'm sure they'll start to value your contribution.

Aurasauras · 04/11/2023 07:48

You have a friend! Don’t break any rules and you will be good. People forget we are human beings with feelings sometimes.

amyds2104 · 04/11/2023 07:44

You are not being unreasonable by having these friendships but I voted YABU purely for giving a crap what these people think of you and your friendships. When the next new person starts I’m sure these toxic individuals will do the same to them. Just hold your head up high and keep doing you!

poetryandwine · 03/11/2023 16:00

ManateeFair · 03/11/2023 15:24

I think that, if I were so intrinsically suspicious and paranoid about people's motives as you seem to be, I would be utterly exhausted.

OP, it sounds like you're working in a pretty unpleasant environment if it's one where people gossip about each other like this. There is nothing at all wrong with being friends with someone at work and I would never interpret what you describe as 'social climbing' or trying to ingratiate yourself with management. Honestly, where I work, nobody would think this was inappropriate - and I don't work in a 'hippy dippy' environment at all!

I am not particularly cynical. I think you’ve found the key point, @ManateeFair

What kind of environment is this workplace generally? We haven’t got a clue. It could generally be bitchy and OP could truly be blameless. I am open to that idea. But that being the case, in her place I wouldn’t have asked that silly question. We surely all agree that friendships can spring up anywhere. Who would object?

OTOH my environment is pretty straightforward but sadly contains its share of women who aren’t great to our admin staff. Gossip is their secret power. It’s hard to blame them.