Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to let my baby cry it out

88 replies

hotcheeto · 03/11/2023 13:22

My baby is almost 8 months old.
Since he was 2 months old I have held him for every single nap. It hurts my hips to hold him on my lap for 90 minutes twice a day, at least, and as a velcro baby, nap time is the only time of day I get a physical or mental break. I know this stage won't last forever but I'd also really like to be able to eat something and drink a glass of water sometime before 6pm daily when my partner gets home from work.

Today I decided to start cot naps. The first nap of the day was good, he cried for 5 minutes, I went in to reassure, cried for another 5 minutes, I went in again, and after 11 minutes total he was asleep. He slept for 1hr 15 mins. Amazing.

For his second nap I did the same, but there was no calming him down. Going in kept making it worse. In total he properly screamed for about 20 minutes being going to sleep. I feel awful.

Can someone reassure me I'm not a selfish failure of a mother and my baby isn't going to be forever scarred by this? It's genuinely upset me, listening to him cry hard, but I'm also feeling determined to teach him better sleeping habits. I'm going back to work very soon and I don't want him to struggle at childcare. I also don't want to sit in the dark and listen to white noise for 3 hours a day anymore. But I still feel sad and guilty...

OP posts:
SwordToFlamethrower · 03/11/2023 19:32

There is a lot of evidence that this causes trauma to the child. Makes them insecure.

Chickenkeev · 03/11/2023 19:14

Slinkyminky22 · 03/11/2023 15:16

Also you should be able to eat and drink when baby is awake. It's not easy but I try and keep a water bottle sitting around and use a thermal cup for tea/coffee. Food wise I buy more ready to eat stuff than i ever have before. Or make some lunch up the night before/morning when I have five minutes spare.

You forget sometimes though! Wish i had your tips when i was going through it. I should have organised a little table beside me. Would have been v handy!

Slinkyminky22 · 03/11/2023 15:16

Also you should be able to eat and drink when baby is awake. It's not easy but I try and keep a water bottle sitting around and use a thermal cup for tea/coffee. Food wise I buy more ready to eat stuff than i ever have before. Or make some lunch up the night before/morning when I have five minutes spare.

MammaTo · 03/11/2023 15:16

We done exactly your method at 8 months - went in every 5 minutes to settle him - when the baby showed signs of slowing down I restarted the 5 mins.
We done it for bedtime and all naps, it took about 5-6 days and now he’s an amazing sleeper. Not only that but his development came on in leaps and bounds.
So as someone on the other side of what you’re doing now NO you are not selfish! You’ll look back and think why didn’t I do this sooner 😂.

Slinkyminky22 · 03/11/2023 15:12

For your mental and physical health you need a break.

I don't do cry it out, but in your case I might try putting baby in their cot and leaving for a very short time to start with. 30 seconds/one minute later if they're crying go in and give a cuddle/lie them down and leave. Slowly lengthen the time between checks and hopefully they will calm down quicker each nap time.

Leaving them for 5/10 minutes is a very long time for a baby that size. Mine would have been an inconsolable mess.

If you were to sit quietly in the same room as their bed while they nodded off would that work?

Voteva · 03/11/2023 15:07

It’s not for us to judge you.

Parenting a velcro baby is incredibly hard.

I wish I could recommend a way to make them sleep alone but it is such an unnatural thing to do and their survival instinct is warning them at top volume that they aren’t safe to sleep unless you are there.

I tried everything, nothing worked for us. Even cry it out doesn’t work on the most stubborn babies, bear that in mind and listen to your instincts.

I wish I had better advice.

2mummies1baby · 03/11/2023 15:02

That is such a promising start, OP! It took my baby a lot longer to settle into cot naps (although she was 4 1/2 months when we started) but she steadily got better and better, especially once we started leaving her alone to go to sleep herself- she got to the point where she was clearly pissed off with us shushing and patting her and just wanted us to go away! Good luck x

howsaboutit · 03/11/2023 15:00

There’s a reason it feels awful to hear your baby crying and not comfort them. It feels wrong because instinctively you want to comfort them.
I accept that in our society, where mothers have to work, a lot of parents find some form of “sleep training” necessary. I do however think that going from all contact naps to suddenly leaving your baby screaming for 20 minutes is cruel though.

As I do with every thread regarding this subject, I’d recommend looking up Lyndsey Hookway on instagram. She has some fantastic resources for helping get babies to sleep more independently. They’re not the quick fix many seem to be looking for but theyre much gentler.

Fionaville · 03/11/2023 14:52

I couldn't do it. My second just wanted to be held all the time. I read the sleep training book and tried once or twice but I couldn't get past the first few minutes. Every instinct in my body was telling me to be there for my baby. I'm a firm believer in trusting your instincts. If its painful for you to leave your baby crying, imagine how it feels for them. They don't even know why its happening. It worked out for us in the end. Once she got past one, she always slept really well.
Some people swear by it. That's OK for them, their baby isn't mine so it's not my concern.

Leo227 · 03/11/2023 14:45

20 mins is a looong time to leave them crying. it would feel long to me never mind a baby.
if you sleep train then at least do it for the few minute intervals, being in the room with him, shushing etc that's recommended

TheGoogleMum · 03/11/2023 14:41

YANBU, I sleep trained my first and it was a huge help. We would time and go back in after 5 mins. Also there are different cries, there's a whiny not wanting to be in bed cry and a genuinely upset cry (more like the screaming you mention), for that cry I go and try and see what's wrong rather than persisting with sleep training

MargotBamborough · 03/11/2023 14:39

MoreThanEnoughSoFar · 03/11/2023 14:25

The only thing you are teaching your son by letting him cry it out is: the world is a cold and scary place and no one comes when I call for help. That's it. He is far too young to be taught anything else and the lack of someone picking him up when he is afraid will leave lasting damage. My bloody heart actually aches just thinking about any baby left to cry himself to sleep.

I'm calling bullshit on this one too.

We tried everything with my son, including cry it out. Nothing worked. He eventually figured it out in his own time. But if cry it out had worked, as it reportedly does for some people, I would no doubt be shouting from the rooftops about how great cry it out is and how it had to be done. In any case, he spent some time crying alone in his cot and whilst it didn't make him go to sleep independently, it clearly didn't do him any harm either.

I only advised the OP to not worry too much about a nap routine if it's only because of nursery, because they will figure it out. They don't need you to deliver a perfectly programmed baby in order to do their jobs.

That said, @hotcheeto, can you not eat and drink when your baby is awake? It's not a binary choice between contact naps and meeting your own basic needs.

tealweasel · 03/11/2023 14:37

I've been where you are, and I don't blame you for wanting to try something different. I remember sitting in the dark with white noise roaring, my arms and hips aching and just crying for the best part of an hour because I was so exhausted with it all, desperately trying to figure out if there was any way I could go back to work early. The next day we tried crying it out. He cried for 8 minutes and then slept for 2 hours. Within 3 days he was taking all of his naps in his cot, alone, without any tears. It's now almost 18 months later and he's a happy boy and a great independent sleeper.

Newmumma23 · 03/11/2023 14:34

Just to be really clear you are not a bad mum and you are doing an amazing job! I genuinely think you have to do what works for you and your family. Whilst cry it out might be frowned upon your mental health is important too so please don’t feel guilty. We sleep trained our little one for night time sleeps and I honestly felt that for us going in actually wound her up more. If I’m honest with myself I think me going to check in was more about me trying to comfort her rather than it being for her. She sleeps through the night now and never cries going down. I’d do some research, Emily Oster does some really good analysis of this, and decide on how you want to do the training (think of everything, how many checks/how often/ how long you leave them before you pick them up etc.) then follow that plan to the letter. It will work but it might take time. Sleep training isn’t for everyone but it can be really beneficial for families and little ones. Sending love on whatever you decide to do x

PinkRoses1245 · 03/11/2023 14:32

MoreThanEnoughSoFar · 03/11/2023 14:25

The only thing you are teaching your son by letting him cry it out is: the world is a cold and scary place and no one comes when I call for help. That's it. He is far too young to be taught anything else and the lack of someone picking him up when he is afraid will leave lasting damage. My bloody heart actually aches just thinking about any baby left to cry himself to sleep.

This is utter bulls**t. Babies need to learn to sleep alone. What’s more important is receiving love and attention when they awake. OP, so what you need to do

MoreThanEnoughSoFar · 03/11/2023 14:25

The only thing you are teaching your son by letting him cry it out is: the world is a cold and scary place and no one comes when I call for help. That's it. He is far too young to be taught anything else and the lack of someone picking him up when he is afraid will leave lasting damage. My bloody heart actually aches just thinking about any baby left to cry himself to sleep.

TwoBabas · 03/11/2023 14:19

I used to be in the 'cry it out is awful/harmful' camp. I thought badly of people who resorted to it.

Then I had my second child. A son. He would scream blue murder at nap time/ bed time wether we held him or not. It was absolutely devastating and the most stressful thing I have ever experienced. He just didn't seem comforted by us as he was trying to sleep, his own parents. Remembering it now is painful. I felt lost and hopeless. I felt like a failure.
After health checks came back clear we had to ride out the storm.
He pushed us away if we tried to cradle him. He seemed to want to be put down in his cot.
If we sang to him/shushed him/stroked his skin he would scream louder.
We soon found leaving the room and hanging around outside the door ensured the shortest amount of screaming and he would be asleep in five minutes. He like a comforter in the shape of my pyjamas bottoms cut into squares to suck on.

I remember feeling like an awful monster for 'abandoning' my child and leaving him to cry alone. I felt ashamed.

But in the end, it worked best for my son and there seemed to be no other way, no easier way.

After less than a week he didn't cry at all.

He has slept through since one year old and is a super happy chappy these days. He is also a huge mummies boy and he and I have an extremely tight close bond. He is very affectionate and I don't see any long lasting damage.
I see a content and loved child.

Try not to let others make you feel like a monster as it is not always clear cut.

hotcheeto · 03/11/2023 14:15

See if I could rock him to sleep and put him down at that point, I would. But he's straining to get out of my arms if I rock him. Then I think he must want to be laid down.
The only thing that works is to sit still on the sofa with him facing outwards in darkness with white noise on.

I suppose I could try laying down with him in my bed and sneaking away once he's asleep, but I worry about the mattress not being breathable (he's a front sleeper now) and him falling off the bed. I have a monitor of course but he flings himself around his cot in the night.

The very last thing I want to do is cause him any lasting damage. I love him more than life obviously, but I need time for myself too.
I know not making time to eat and drink is making me feel like shit.

He won't sleep in the pram, swing, carrier. He's too big for the bouncer now but never slept in that anyway either. He will sleep in the car after 30-45 mins of driving, but wakes after I stop.

I'm not justifying cry it out at all but I do feel like I need to get him sleeping in his cot for both of our sakes to be honest 😢

OP posts:
Sauvblanctime · 03/11/2023 14:08

MargotBamborough · 03/11/2023 14:04

Totally.

When my son was small I wasted so much time and energy on trying to get him into a meal and nap routine ready to go to the childminder when I could have just been enjoying the last couple of months of my maternity leave.

With my daughter I did none of that. We rocked up on day one of nursery and I just said, "Yeah, she's not really interested in food, she only likes boobs and also she won't take a bottle, and all our naps so far have been contact naps and I couldn't really tell you how many naps she has each day or how long for, and she sleeps in our bed at night. Sorry."

And they were like, "It's fine, we'll handle it."

It has been fine.

Haha exactly! Same with my second. And he just went in to nursery without a second glance 🤣🤨

MargotBamborough · 03/11/2023 14:04

Sauvblanctime · 03/11/2023 14:00

This!!

they also eat all the food they won’t eat at home 🤨🤣

Totally.

When my son was small I wasted so much time and energy on trying to get him into a meal and nap routine ready to go to the childminder when I could have just been enjoying the last couple of months of my maternity leave.

With my daughter I did none of that. We rocked up on day one of nursery and I just said, "Yeah, she's not really interested in food, she only likes boobs and also she won't take a bottle, and all our naps so far have been contact naps and I couldn't really tell you how many naps she has each day or how long for, and she sleeps in our bed at night. Sorry."

And they were like, "It's fine, we'll handle it."

It has been fine.

Changednamesforthis22 · 03/11/2023 14:02

I used to take mine for a walk in the pram to get him to fall asleep and then come back home, park him in the hallway and enjoy some free time at home before he woke up. Could never do cry it out but I didn't have to worry about nursery as I stayed at home till he was 2. So I understand that you want your baby to be able to nap at nursery.
I was told to put mine down 'drowsy but awake' which didn't work for me but might for you.

Sauvblanctime · 03/11/2023 14:00

MargotBamborough · 03/11/2023 13:53

If you're going back to work soon I'm not sure I'd bother trying to get him to nap independently.

In my experience babies are often different in a childcare setting. Your baby won't be able to contact nap with a childminder or at nursery but these people have so much experience with babies that they will find a way to get your child to nap independently.

In your position I'd just keep doing the contact naps safe in the knowledge that once you go back to work it won't be every day.

This!!

they also eat all the food they won’t eat at home 🤨🤣

Sauvblanctime · 03/11/2023 13:59

hotcheeto · 03/11/2023 13:48

I take your point, but surely there's a difference.
I would never leave my baby to cry for an hour, for instance. 20 minutes felt like forever and I went in to reassure him twice during that time. Which made him considerably more upset.
If they cry for 5 minutes then fall asleep, is that the same as 3 hours?

Yeah there’s a difference, massive, but crying it out is literally just leaving them.

do you put any music on? Moshi is really good to help them sleep x

MargotBamborough · 03/11/2023 13:53

If you're going back to work soon I'm not sure I'd bother trying to get him to nap independently.

In my experience babies are often different in a childcare setting. Your baby won't be able to contact nap with a childminder or at nursery but these people have so much experience with babies that they will find a way to get your child to nap independently.

In your position I'd just keep doing the contact naps safe in the knowledge that once you go back to work it won't be every day.

Razorcroft · 03/11/2023 13:50

There is nothing wrong with leaving a baby for 5 minutes to have a shriek and moan when you have exhausted all avenues. I’ve done this plenty. Sometimes they fall asleep, sometimes they need a resettle and a feed/snuggle.

However it is not correct to say this ‘good sleep habits’ in an eight month old baby who rightfully will still need a bit of help in getting to sleep and settling. Because, they are an eight month old baby.

It’s not teaching them shit. They aren’t manipulating you. This is developmentally normal.

Solidarity and all, it’s shite and I remember it- but this ‘teaching sleep habits’ is not necessary nor factual.

i struggled to get to sleep last night, tossed and turned. I had a lot on my mind. Woke up twice as well, bit cold, needed the loo. I’m a thirty year old woman- why am I expecting so much of an infant??