Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to let my baby cry it out

88 replies

hotcheeto · 03/11/2023 13:22

My baby is almost 8 months old.
Since he was 2 months old I have held him for every single nap. It hurts my hips to hold him on my lap for 90 minutes twice a day, at least, and as a velcro baby, nap time is the only time of day I get a physical or mental break. I know this stage won't last forever but I'd also really like to be able to eat something and drink a glass of water sometime before 6pm daily when my partner gets home from work.

Today I decided to start cot naps. The first nap of the day was good, he cried for 5 minutes, I went in to reassure, cried for another 5 minutes, I went in again, and after 11 minutes total he was asleep. He slept for 1hr 15 mins. Amazing.

For his second nap I did the same, but there was no calming him down. Going in kept making it worse. In total he properly screamed for about 20 minutes being going to sleep. I feel awful.

Can someone reassure me I'm not a selfish failure of a mother and my baby isn't going to be forever scarred by this? It's genuinely upset me, listening to him cry hard, but I'm also feeling determined to teach him better sleeping habits. I'm going back to work very soon and I don't want him to struggle at childcare. I also don't want to sit in the dark and listen to white noise for 3 hours a day anymore. But I still feel sad and guilty...

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
TheShellBeach · 04/11/2023 13:21

Don't feel ashamed.
You've helped your child learn to fall asleep.
That's a good thing.

hotcheeto · 04/11/2023 10:19

I am so sorry I haven't replied until now - life, I'm sure you understand.
Will try and reply to individual comments when I can but just wanted to update.
After yesterday I felt upset and ashamed and felt like I'd hurt my baby.
However today he has settled in his cot with no crying whatsoever. None. I'm not sure if it's 'worked' or if it's just coincidence, but I feel miles happier for having an hour to myself to eat breakfast and drink coffee.
As I say will reply to more when possible but for now I'm enjoying a bit of alone time. Can't say I'm in a hurry to let him cry again though, I didn't like it (obviously) and I don't think it's for us long term.

OP posts:
MaryShelley1818 · 04/11/2023 08:45

There is nothing that would make me leave my babies to cry and scream for me. I can't imagine the distress and fear they feel crying for their mammy and no one comes. Absolutely awful.
I had 2 high needs babies, both would only contact nap, both coslept, both had no issues sleeping independently when they were developmentally ready. Yes it was difficult but they are babies for a very short time.

DarkForces · 04/11/2023 04:55

I did controlled crying at 10 months. It took her 3 nights and around an hour total of crying to learn to sleep and settle herself. It certainly didn't teach her not to cry as no one is coming. She cried if she needed me - if she felt ill, had a dirty nappy etc - but she now has the gift of being able to sleep.

A decade on she loves her bed and is one of the happiest people I know. A good nights sleep is good for the brain and wellbeing. Just wish I could sleep as well as her!

ChiefWiggumsBoy · 04/11/2023 02:50

PabloandGustheGreySquirrels · 04/11/2023 01:09

Darcia Narvaez is Professor of Psychology Emerita at the University of Notre Dame, says: "Because of this “cry-it-out” sleep training can be damaging to a rapidly growing brain – and to a growing psyche. Researchers have documented how, with sleep training, infants’ fight and flight instincts activate in the face of extensive distress, such as being left without comforting physical touch. When the distress of separation and lack of response goes on too long, the infant may quiet down but it is to reserve limited energy. This withdrawal into numbness can manifest as an impairment in social trust that can be carried into adulthood. These patterns can continue in adulthood when things become too stressful, shutting down thinking and feeling in situations where the individual is triggered into panic or anger".

You've picked and chosen from your rat study very carefully there.

Stress during infancy that is severe enough to create insecure attachment has a dissociative effect, disrupting right hemispheric emotional functioning and species preservative behavior, and a permanent bias towards self preservation can become an adult trait.

I can't see the full article, but what constitutes severe enough? Pretty certain ten minutes of crying isn't it. There are some horrible examples from the Romanian orphanage scandals of the 90s where babies were literally left alone till they didn't make a sound as they knew no one would come. This is severe. Ten minutes of crying and mum coming in and comforting isn't. Stop trying to make mother's feel terrible.

VashtaNerada · 04/11/2023 02:46

I can only speak from personal experience but I did ‘cry it out’ with DD because the alternative was getting angry and frustrated with her (suspect I probably had PND looking back now). She’s now a very intelligent, lovely teen and we have a great relationship.

ChiefWiggumsBoy · 04/11/2023 02:45

I'm really interested in those studies that say that adults could carry these 'issues' of abandonment into adulthood, because I'm fairly certain it hasn't always been the norm to put baby first to the massive detriment of maternal mental wellbeing. Because that's what it is. What people are advocating for. I'm an 80s baby and I definitely wasn't rocked to sleep, and had a proper schedule by 6 weeks (or so my mum says!).

Allowing something to happen with your baby that you don't like, but won't hurt them, is not the same as hurting them.

PS - as a mother of twins, sometimes I had to leave one to cry because it wasn't physically possible by the age of 8 months, same as OP's baby, to comfort/change/feed/whatever both at the same time. Neither of them seem to have any effects from that. Neither does their little brother who was sleep trained similarly to OP's baby at 14 months. I'm sure to some this makes me a terrible mum, but I was doing my best.

ChiefWiggumsBoy · 04/11/2023 02:38

@hotcheeto ask MN to change your title because as you can see, people are champing at the bit to call you cruel for allowing your baby to cry it out - and that's not what you did, at all. Even the post above mine can't seem to fathom that the baby was crying for 20 minutes and not that you left the baby for 20 minutes.

Georgeandzippyzoo · 04/11/2023 01:25

hotcheeto · 03/11/2023 13:48

I take your point, but surely there's a difference.
I would never leave my baby to cry for an hour, for instance. 20 minutes felt like forever and I went in to reassure him twice during that time. Which made him considerably more upset.
If they cry for 5 minutes then fall asleep, is that the same as 3 hours?

20 mins felt like a lifetime to you. Can you imagine what that felt like to a baby who doesn't understand permanence, that a person you can't see is still around.
Needing a parent /caregiver is a development stage for remaining safe and having needs met.
As the pp said a baby stops crying because they know noone is coming.
I do think you can build up to it as suggested from pp but to let them cry it out I've always felt seems cruel.

comfyshoes2022 · 04/11/2023 01:22

Of course it’s fine. Don’t listen to the naysayers since you’ve decided to go down this path. There is absolutely no research that it’s harmful - Google “Emily Oster sleep training” for a data-driven assessment of the evidence. If anything the research is on the side of sleep training because having enough quality sleep is so beneficial for a child’s development, not to mention for a parent’s mental and physical health.

I was apparently a horrible sleeper throughout my babyhood and childhood, and I continued to have sleep issues as a young adult. I know my parents were horrified by the idea of sleep training and I honestly wish my parents had done more to cultivate good, independent sleep.

Icopewhenihope · 04/11/2023 01:14

I did it with all mine, worked a charm. All well rounded, happy young people now with no issues.

PabloandGustheGreySquirrels · 04/11/2023 01:09

Darcia Narvaez is Professor of Psychology Emerita at the University of Notre Dame, says: "Because of this “cry-it-out” sleep training can be damaging to a rapidly growing brain – and to a growing psyche. Researchers have documented how, with sleep training, infants’ fight and flight instincts activate in the face of extensive distress, such as being left without comforting physical touch. When the distress of separation and lack of response goes on too long, the infant may quiet down but it is to reserve limited energy. This withdrawal into numbness can manifest as an impairment in social trust that can be carried into adulthood. These patterns can continue in adulthood when things become too stressful, shutting down thinking and feeling in situations where the individual is triggered into panic or anger".

PabloandGustheGreySquirrels · 04/11/2023 01:04

@WillowCraft www.psychologytoday.com/gb/blog/moral-landscapes/201112/dangers-crying-it-out

AIBU to let my baby cry it out
PabloandGustheGreySquirrels · 04/11/2023 01:00

@WillowCraft & @Sauvblanctime I remember being left to cry and being terrified, thinking they'd gone or that they didn't care. Research & studies have proven time & time again that babies who were left to cry it out, grew up with abandonment issues.

bakewellbride · 04/11/2023 00:34

I could never do it (and my youngest was similar so I know exactly how you feel - she woke hourly for 11 months and I nearly had a mental health crisis - but even then I never left her).

justanothermanicmonday1 · 04/11/2023 00:33

Sauvblanctime · 03/11/2023 13:43

Yes.

sorry but there’s so much research done that shows how detrimental it is to their development. Babies stop crying because they know no one is coming

This is a punch in the gut. Holy shit.

So glad I didn't do this. Breaks my heart.

Sauvblanctime · 04/11/2023 00:23

WillowCraft · 04/11/2023 00:07

That's an opinion piece, not a scientific study. It also doesn't claim sleep training has any detrimental effects. It only references one study on sleep training and that one says it isn't harmful.

This

Jennifer Lawrence Reaction GIF
ShineBright1209 · 04/11/2023 00:08

I haven’t read the FT but do whatever works for you and don’t feel guilty about it. I have never done contact naps with any of my 4 children and they all slept in their own crib from day 1. They were all put to bed awake at night on their own from about 3/4 weeks old and then disturbed only for night feeds for a few weeks. Daytime naps were done in the pram or once too big for that they went up to their cot. I did have to do sleep training with my eldest at around 16 months old due to him getting into a habit of coming into my room during the night (medical reasons were making him vomit in the night). Once he was no longer vomiting if he woke I did the sleep training, went about a week with broken sleep but soon went back to sleeping fine.
Yes all mine have gone through phases and been left to cry it out within reason, my oldest is now 13 and doesn’t seem to have any issues because I didn’t run to him at every noise he made and neither do any of my others.

WillowCraft · 04/11/2023 00:07

That's an opinion piece, not a scientific study. It also doesn't claim sleep training has any detrimental effects. It only references one study on sleep training and that one says it isn't harmful.

WillowCraft · 03/11/2023 23:52

RadoxRita · 03/11/2023 22:37

Thanks for sharing this - you’ve just confirmed my point… “Experts like Hiscock say they aren't aware of any studies that look at potential long-term effects of cold-turkey cry-it-out […]. They also examined healthy babies at least six months old. So these findings aren't necessarily applicable to infants trained at younger ages, or in other ways”. Like I said earlier, studies like that would never be ethically approved because of the risk of clinical harm to infants. Rather, experts use a synthesis of the extensive available research in the areas of early brain development, attachment and developmental trauma to conclude this practice is harmful.

Anyhow, I’ve said my piece. It’s up to the OP what she chooses to do. Seeing the impact further down the line though, I couldn’t not say anything. Good luck to you all.

Did you actually read the article...it includes loads of studies....the Hiscock study is an RCT and follows children up to 6 years...looks at similar method to what OP is doing....

https://www.researchgate.net/publication/230830539_Five-Year_Follow-up_of_Harms_and_Benefits_of_Behavioral_Infant_Sleep_Intervention_Randomized_Trial

WannaLiveInABubble · 03/11/2023 23:49

We did controlled crying with all of ours, no damage done, now young adults, teens and kids.

WillowCraft · 03/11/2023 23:45

Legoroses · 03/11/2023 23:38

Convincing people who have invested in one approach that that approach might be damaging their children is basically impossible - that's what cognitive dissonance is. We can't let ourselves hold that sort of belief about our actions - so this is a pointless question for a chat forum. We're all going to say the thing we did was the right thing, but i'm afraid the actual science is with the psychologist.

The science is in the scientific literature, use google scholar and have a look for yourself.

Also, check out the pyramid of evidence. Expert opinion (e.g. from a single clinical psychologist) is the lowest form of evidence (expert opinion from an internet random would be even lower if it were listed).

WillowCraft · 03/11/2023 23:42

Sauvblanctime · 03/11/2023 23:20

There’s loads of research. Same as in orphanages, your baby doesn’t cry because they know no one is coming

Oh for goodness sake. Link one study then, I challenge you. A peer reviewed scientific study, not an opinion by Sarah Ockwell Smith

WillowCraft · 03/11/2023 23:41

RadoxRita · 03/11/2023 21:44

A baby that age absolutely does NOT recognise that you are still there. A baby’s brain at that age is not structurally or neurologically developed enough to recognise itself as separate from its primary caregiver, whom its primal (attachment) behaviours such as crying are designed to elicit care from.

A baby at that age is completely at the mercy of its physiological state. It experiences a wet nappy with the same level of distress as imminent death. Its neurological development does not make sense of patterns at that age. A baby is physically incapable of ‘self-soothing’ - babies and young children NEED attunement and comfort from a safe adult to genuinely calm. The loss of crying is owing to one of two factors - the baby has given up (an attachment wound that will continue) or they are so distressed/exhausted they collapse (babies sleep when distressed - dissociation is their only escape when other survival mechanisms (such as fight, flight or fawn) evade them. Please don’t mistake a quiet baby for a happy/calm baby after being left to ‘cry it out’ - any blood test would show you the elevation is cortisol.

A baby’s earliest, pre-verbal experiences shape what they come to believe about themselves, what they expect from others and how safe they perceive the world as the develop. This impacts on their ability to develop other fundamental skills as they develop of emotional and behavioural regulation as they grow. Don’t ever let anyone tell you that something a baby can’t remember won’t harm them. We know very well now that the inter utero environment through to the 5th birthday is the most profound time for trauma to impact long term on children’s subsequent mental and physiological health. Children that hold no explicit memory carry it in their bodies (not least because the brain structures and language capacities were not present to help it be processed at the time they experienced it).

It is not hard to find this information online. You don’t really need a clinician like me to tell you this. You just need to stop asking people on here who did it themselves so, likely have a invested interest in insisting it does no harm (what we call ‘cognitive dissonance’). These kinds of people always demand to see ‘research’ that “proves” crying it out is harmful, but obviously, no ethics committee is ever going to approve a study that could potentially cause harm to infants. Rather, just like in many areas of this nature, the (extensive) available research that supports this being a harmful practice is drawn from a synthesis of what we know about brain development, attachment and developmental trauma. I hope this helps.

I don't believe you're a clincial psychologist at all. Lots of babies can go to sleep on their own right from birth so it's not true to say they are incapable of it. Also most babies don't care about having a wet nappy.

Sleep trained babies do not "give up" crying either at night or in the day. It's just that they no longer cry because they can't get to sleep. (because they don't need to). They will still cry for other reasons such as hunger, illness etc.

There has been at least one randomised controlled trial on sleep training which I'm sure you are aware of if you are an expert, as you claim. There are also plenty of other study designs. None found any harm from sleep training

I don't think there is any evidence showing that sleep training is harmful. (if you know of any please feel free to link - I cannot find any) There is of course evidence that extreme neglect is harmful but that is not relevant.

As for the claim you made earlier that child and teenage mental health problems are due to being sleep trained as a child - it seems highly unlikely that you can pin the cause down to any one thing. Did none of these children have divorced parents, excessive screen time or social media use, parental mental health problems, neglect or abuse, bullying at school, attend nursery from a young age, etc etc etc?