Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to not want my partner on the mortgage

117 replies

Pizfufffff · 03/11/2023 09:59

Me and my partner have a baby. We are not married. Ever since we found out I was pregnant we decided to save up to get a home. The thing is she's now a year old and he hasnt saved barely anything whereas I have saved almost 40k. My entire pregnancy we were arguing about saving up every month. He would always come up with an excuse as to why he wasn't saving. He would send money and then take it back claiming he had this or that to pay. A few months ago he got really moody and said he was sick of feeling like he doesn't have any money when he works so hard and in anger I said " fine I don't want a penny towards the deposit anymore I will do it myself and we will just move out without you". He hasn't contributed since. However from recent comments I can see he is obviously expecting to move into the new home with us and obviously I would want him there as I do love him he is just useless with money and clearly irresponsible as he knows whatever happens I will deal with it in the end.

I've told him that I don't want him on the mortgage and my dad has agreed to go on as co-owner. So he can come and live with us as a tenant I don't think it's fair that while I haven't had a penny to myself for 2, years scrimping and saving he essentially spends all his money as he wishes and there will be no consequences.

He says I'm being unfair as I earn more than him. But after he pays for all his share of outgoings he still has 1.5k a month to himself and could have helped me with the deposit a bit?

He has saved 2.3k in 2 years.

As this has been such a big point of contention I'm unable to look at it without bias. Am I being unreasonable.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Hibiscrubbed · 04/11/2023 19:51

Well, I wouldn’t let the useless twat anywhere near my new home, but that’s me. If you do, get your home and deposit legally bound up tighter than a tight thing. His entitlement is showing…

snackatack · 04/11/2023 19:25

If you decide not to put him on the mortgage that is fine.. but if he moves in and lives with you .. he may have a claim to half the house when you spilt.

HamBone · 04/11/2023 18:49

I can completely see your point, OP, but is he going to contribute to the mortgage payments? If he pays rent to you without a lease, he’ll be a lodger with no rights, which legally seems illogical from his perspective as you could make him homeless any time(not emotionally, of course, I’m sure he wants to be with and your baby).

If he’s going to be contributing to your mortgage repayments, I personally think he should be on the deeds, despite not saving up for the deposit.

For context, I put down the entire deposit on our house, but my DH has made the majority of the mortgage payments(we’re both on the mortgage and the deeds).
My salary mainly covers other bills. Yes, it was a risk doing this, but he’s more than repaid my deposit at this point.

Again, I can completely see your logic to co-own with your Dad instead, but I can also see why your DP may decide to rent elsewhere as he’ll have zero security being your lodger.

Friendfoe1 · 04/11/2023 18:35

I’d give him his 2.3k back and do it alone.

theduchessofspork · 04/11/2023 18:34

Do not put him on the mortgage

Go and see a solicitor to make sure that by paying you rent he doesn’t have a claim on the house

Personally I wouldn’t have him move in, because when you get fed up with him (and you will) he may be hard to evict.

Whatonearth07957 · 04/11/2023 18:31

Cohabitation agreement. House solely in yours and your dad's names. Rent and a third of bills. Done. If he doesn't like it he can rent himself and pay CM.

Pizfufffff · 04/11/2023 16:32

Soontobe60 · 04/11/2023 16:25

So with a £300k mortgage on 5% interest the repayments are almost half her income.
With an income of £60k, and childcare to pay for, she would struggle to be able to borrow more than £250k.

Ah, this is all very disheartening :( 300k is the lowest you can find a house in or around our area. Maybe I will have to put my house dream on hold for now, hopefully one day the interest rates will fall and I will be able to buy a home.

OP posts:
Soontobe60 · 04/11/2023 16:25

Ineedaholidaynowplease · 04/11/2023 15:30

@Soontobe60 you clearly haven't been on any online mortgage calculators recently if you think someone on 4k NET (approx 70k ish ) can only borrow so little. OP would need very high outgoings to only borrow 120k....someone on 30k would be able to borrow that.

OP, you have done really well to save so much in such a short time. You would be right to protect it. If you do buy with your DP, I would definitely make sure you are tenants in common and that your deposit is just yours, as a % of the value rather than the 40k to protect you In the event the house value increases.

So with a £300k mortgage on 5% interest the repayments are almost half her income.
With an income of £60k, and childcare to pay for, she would struggle to be able to borrow more than £250k.

Soontobe60 · 04/11/2023 16:19

Ineedaholidaynowplease · 04/11/2023 15:30

@Soontobe60 you clearly haven't been on any online mortgage calculators recently if you think someone on 4k NET (approx 70k ish ) can only borrow so little. OP would need very high outgoings to only borrow 120k....someone on 30k would be able to borrow that.

OP, you have done really well to save so much in such a short time. You would be right to protect it. If you do buy with your DP, I would definitely make sure you are tenants in common and that your deposit is just yours, as a % of the value rather than the 40k to protect you In the event the house value increases.

I assumed that the OP earned 4K gross a month.

Zanatdy · 04/11/2023 16:05

Have you checked you can afford the repayments? 300k mortgage with the rates right now is a lot per month, be well over half your salary.

uncomfortablydumb53 · 04/11/2023 15:57

YANBU. Your DP is irresponsible and his actions show that
Do not put him on the mortgage or marry him, as he might not show commitment and shared values with you going forward
Your Dad probably has the measure of him
Protect yourself and do not let him take advantage

Ineedaholidaynowplease · 04/11/2023 15:30

@Soontobe60 you clearly haven't been on any online mortgage calculators recently if you think someone on 4k NET (approx 70k ish ) can only borrow so little. OP would need very high outgoings to only borrow 120k....someone on 30k would be able to borrow that.

OP, you have done really well to save so much in such a short time. You would be right to protect it. If you do buy with your DP, I would definitely make sure you are tenants in common and that your deposit is just yours, as a % of the value rather than the 40k to protect you In the event the house value increases.

Ineedaholidaynowplease · 04/11/2023 15:30

@Soontobe60 you clearly haven't been on any online mortgage calculators recently if you think someone on 4k NET (approx 70k ish ) can only borrow so little. OP would need very high outgoings to only borrow 120k....someone on 30k would be able to borrow that.

OP, you have done really well to save so much in such a short time. You would be right to protect it. If you do buy with your DP, I would definitely make sure you are tenants in common and that your deposit is just yours, as a % of the value rather than the 40k to protect you In the event the house value increases.

Findinganewme · 04/11/2023 15:10

Take the red warning signals and act fast. I would absolutely not have him on the mortgage. Do not live with him. Do not marry him. Watch your back.

Joyonacake · 04/11/2023 10:42

How is this helpful?

Riverlee · 04/11/2023 10:17

“ I also do the majority of the food shopping and most of the babies things “

and in the original list, it says he says he has 1.5k after everything has been accounted for.

Therefore, he has 1.5k spending money, every month. Ie. £15000 + a year, £30000 + over two years, and he has saved £2.3k.

CatOnTheCludgy · 04/11/2023 08:59

Do not get married. Don't have him on the mortgage.

Widower2014 · 04/11/2023 08:25

If that 1500 was 'spare' then he could of been putting 500 minimum away each month. Sounds like he wants to have his cake and eat it.

Does he help around the house or with baby

Kennamorgan · 04/11/2023 08:23

My understanding was 1500 left after 'bills', life is expensive, especially with a child. How much of the rest is spent on food, clothing, the child.. I don't think 1500 after bills leaves you much for saving after the cost of living is taken into account on his salary. She has a far greater salary to save and enough for all the typical extras after set bills. He does not. There's also an argument to say its not appropriate for them to be contributing 50/50 to bills with such different salaries. If the man was earning more and didn't want the woman on the mortgage for this reason, I think people would be appalled!

Riverlee · 04/11/2023 02:47

@Kennamorgan Didn’t op say that dp has £1500 personable disposable income after all bills are shared etc and yet has only managed to save £100 per month. You could easily save £500+ per month.

What is he spending (wasting) his money on?

Codlingmoths · 03/11/2023 21:29

Bansheed · 03/11/2023 20:17

Quick maths: in 19 months you have saved 40k. You earn 1.7k more than him a month.
If you times that diff you had 32.3 k more. So, on your outgoings, he saved nearly 3k and you saved 8k more out of the balance.

Not that much difference

It’s a huge difference, she pays more of their costs while you’re assuming for some weird reason that they split costs evenly. Even if your numbers weren’t wildly wrong, you could also say he saved 40% of what she did if rhey had the same outgoings ie bugger all. She pays more, she also grew and had a baby in these 2 years and she saves MUCH more of the residual. She is kicking life goals all over the place here, she pays most of the things for baby, nearly 300 travel a month for work, all the food I think she said or similar. He’s useless.

Bansheed · 03/11/2023 20:17

Quick maths: in 19 months you have saved 40k. You earn 1.7k more than him a month.
If you times that diff you had 32.3 k more. So, on your outgoings, he saved nearly 3k and you saved 8k more out of the balance.

Not that much difference

NikNak321 · 03/11/2023 20:12

I think this is a difficult one. I think if you go down the route of your not having a part of this, solicitors etc, not marrying him ever like some of the advice is suggesting you may as well split now. I don't think your relationship would survive that...well not positively 😢

The reality is your incomes are significantly different. Yours is nearly double. I still think he should have saved, but in reality it would be no where near the level of yours anyway. Does he pay the rent? If he always pays his bills, you have no reason to believe he won't pay his mortgage share? I would suggest to him you share the mortgage, but write a contract up that recognises you paid the deposit and if you were to split you get that % of the property back in equity first and then split the equity 50:50 afterwards to honour this investment.

If you go in hard it will set the tone of your entire relationship going forward. It sounds as if you want things to work. Maybe this is the compromise to feel financially safe, but investing trust in your relationship going forward? Good luck ❤️

Kennamorgan · 03/11/2023 20:06

I'm surprised by all the responses. You earn significantly more. If he has managed to pay his share of bills and save a couple of thousand over and above that over the last 2 years, he is doing a lot better than most people in the current climate. It sounds like you are a great saver and perhaps he cannot match up to that but he's paying his way and not got you into debt. If you trust him then yes, I'd totally put him on the mortgage. If the trust isn't there then maybe not! Depending on the jurisdiction you are in, you should be able to protect your share of the deposit in the event of separation if you chose to regardless.

FairFuming · 03/11/2023 19:54

Just for perspective I'm a single mother with a crap job and I have managed to save more in the last 2 years then he has.
I wouldn't put him in the mortgage but if you do make sure your deposit is properly protected legally

Swipe left for the next trending thread