Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Siameasy · 03/11/2023 11:09

VanityDiesHard · 03/11/2023 10:45

I would not have dreamed of having a child without considerably more than 60k in savings. People are so entitled and irresponsible it is unreal.

That’s bonkers. Average wage in UK is around 35k. Mr and Mrs average ought to be the ones having kids. It’s dangerous to perpetuate the myth that it’s expensive to have kids. Marriage and kids at a younger age ought to be incentivised. Pushing female careers and “boss babes” has not ended well for women’s fertility rates.

nutellacreppe · 03/11/2023 11:09

KimberleyClark · 03/11/2023 11:06

A female partner unable to get her female partner pregnant is not a medical issue or a fertility issue. It’s not homophobic to acknowledge that.

No, but I can't see how it's not homophobic to say that a fertile female in a heterosexual couple should be treated, whereas a fertile female in a homosexual couple shouldn't be.

It's completely irrelevant that the reason for my husband's infertility is medical.

If he was female, I also wouldn't be able to get pregnant. It would be the same situation.

Why should I get IVF in this situation because I'm in a heterosexual relationship, but not if I'm in a same sex relationship?

KimberleyClark · 03/11/2023 11:08

MumblesParty · 03/11/2023 11:06

Talk me through this “finding a man” proposal of yours.

Most single woman wanting children by IVF are likely to be heterosexual women in their 30s, who are aware that time is running out, and have been unsuccessful in finding a relationship. We see it all the time on here - women in stable relationships with men who they love, being tricked into waiting to have kids, then being abandoned by their partner and finding they’re suddenly in their late 30s. Are you saying these women should simply go out and shag the first man they see? Regardless of whether they fancy them. Or should they just get a boyfriend and use him for sperm, even if he doesn’t want kids?

But most single women wanting a baby don’t NEED IVF. They can go to a clinic and be artificially inseminated by donor.

KimberleyClark · 03/11/2023 11:06

nutellacreppe · 03/11/2023 11:01

@FrustatedAgain Your stance appears to me to be:

If I am female and have a male partner who can't get me pregnant - NHS should fund IVF.
If I am female and have a female partner who can't get me pregnant - NHS should not fund IVF.

I understand that people have varying opinions on whether the NHS should or shouldn't fund IVF and there are arguments on both sides which are interesting and valid.

But I can't understand how your position above is not an inherently homophobic stance.

A female partner unable to get her female partner pregnant is not a medical issue or a fertility issue. It’s not homophobic to acknowledge that.

MumblesParty · 03/11/2023 11:06

NugatoryMatters · 03/11/2023 08:30

This is such nonsense.

If you are single, want a baby and don’t fancy paying for fertility treatment, the answer is to find a man who wants to conceive a child with you.

’i want to stay single and have the taxpayer fund fertility treatment so i can have a baby’ is a really clear statement about the levels of selfish individualism we’ve reached.

And to start shouting about how it’s
discrimination is ridiculous.

There is nothing discriminatory about telling straight, single women that they need to try having a baby by having regular unprotected sex with a man before the NHS will consider treating an actual fertility issue.

Any provision made for women in same-sex relationships is a totally separate matter for debate.

There’s something really worrying about the current trend to try to position straight people/male people/white people as the most victimised of all.

Talk me through this “finding a man” proposal of yours.

Most single woman wanting children by IVF are likely to be heterosexual women in their 30s, who are aware that time is running out, and have been unsuccessful in finding a relationship. We see it all the time on here - women in stable relationships with men who they love, being tricked into waiting to have kids, then being abandoned by their partner and finding they’re suddenly in their late 30s. Are you saying these women should simply go out and shag the first man they see? Regardless of whether they fancy them. Or should they just get a boyfriend and use him for sperm, even if he doesn’t want kids?

JustAMinutePleass · 03/11/2023 11:06

Ebtsaqt · 03/11/2023 10:38

Iui by age

  • Age 20 to 30: 17.6%
  • Age 31 to 35: 13.3%
  • Age 36 to 38: 13.4%
  • Age 39 to 40: 10.6%
  • Over 40: 5.4%

And a single woman would be even higher as not infertile

In 2019, the percentage of IVF treatments that resulted in a live birth was:

  • 32% for women under 35
  • 25% for women aged 35 to 37
  • 19% for women aged 38 to 39
  • 11% for women aged 40 to 42
  • 5% for women aged 43 to 44
  • 4% for women aged over 44
These figures are for women using their own eggs and their partner’s sperm, using the per embryo transferred measure.

But considering the costs..
Ivf 4k+
vs
iui 700+

Obviously most couples get multiple embryos with ivf - but these have to be frozen and they only keep the best ones. Or women have to put back 2 risking twins. So the costs of freezing are on top. And later transfers. But could have a dc2 this way.

So the biggest issue is likely single women waiting until over 35 or more where any success is less.

I did 3 ivf in 9months. But assume iui would have been quicker

Iui results are misleading. That isn’t the live birth rate it’s the pregnancy rate and you are much, much more likely to miscarry an iui embryo. I know that from bitter experience.

Georgeandzippyzoo · 03/11/2023 11:05

Hoardasurass · 03/11/2023 08:10

Ofcourse it's not discrimination. Lesbian couples have to go through a process of iui at their own cost to prove that they are infertile before they can infertile on the NHS.
A single woman who isn't having unprotected sex is not infertile and therefore doesn't need infertility treatment and as such should not be allowed to get it on the NHS

But a single woman, regardless if they're having unprotected sex could very well be infertile! Not sure what you're saying here.

My friend very early on (late teens) knew that she would most probably be infertile.

berksandbeyond · 03/11/2023 11:05

No one should getting IVF on the NHS. No one has a right to have a child.

theduchessofspork · 03/11/2023 11:03

mugboat · 03/11/2023 10:52

If you adopt you usually need to take multiple children as social services do not like to split up siblings.

You also would likely be adopting traumatised children- social services only adopt out children in extreme circumstances.

Both different prospects to birthing and raising 1 child.

You are out of date.

You do not need to adopt sibling groups. Some people do, many don’t. SS like siblings to stay together but know it’s often impossible.

There were about 60 under twos up for adoption in the North East last year.

More children are removed from their parents earlier than was the case a decade ago, mainly because children were being removed too late to be adopted and get a fresh start. Some children are removed at birth or soon after (usually because one or more siblings have already been removed).

Adopted children are always (rightly) classes as vulnerable, but children removed young would not normally be traumatised.

nutellacreppe · 03/11/2023 11:03

FrustatedAgain · 03/11/2023 11:02

If your husband is infertile then yes that's a medical issue isn't it? I said if the male has a medical issue that creates a need for IVF in my opinion it should be given.
In my opinion if there is no medical issue then IVF is not needed.

But by giving me IVF they are not treating my husband. I am fertile. It's not a medical intervention either way.

Whether my partner has a medical issue or whether they are female, it makes no difference. The end result is I can't get pregnant.

FrustatedAgain · 03/11/2023 11:02

nutellacreppe · 03/11/2023 10:51

I could get pregnant without medical intervention if I wanted to (I am a female with an infertile husband). Do I not need IVF?

If your husband is infertile then yes that's a medical issue isn't it? I said if the male has a medical issue that creates a need for IVF in my opinion it should be given.
In my opinion if there is no medical issue then IVF is not needed.

nutellacreppe · 03/11/2023 11:01

@FrustatedAgain Your stance appears to me to be:

If I am female and have a male partner who can't get me pregnant - NHS should fund IVF.
If I am female and have a female partner who can't get me pregnant - NHS should not fund IVF.

I understand that people have varying opinions on whether the NHS should or shouldn't fund IVF and there are arguments on both sides which are interesting and valid.

But I can't understand how your position above is not an inherently homophobic stance.

JustAMinutePleass · 03/11/2023 11:00

ginandtonicwithlimes · 03/11/2023 10:48

How many people would be able to able to put that much away? I don't actually think you need that much anyway. Good for you you didn't need to save for your IVF plus for raising a child.

It isn’t in one go. It cost us £60k over 10 years of ttc with ivf specifically (probably 80k if you consider the stuff we tried before). We were higher earners and so didn’t feel the strain as much - we just budgeted for it instead of upsizing our house. I think most parents spend at least 6-8k a year on their child without realising it.

Moreempatheticmyarse · 03/11/2023 10:59

mugboat · 03/11/2023 10:52

If you adopt you usually need to take multiple children as social services do not like to split up siblings.

You also would likely be adopting traumatised children- social services only adopt out children in extreme circumstances.

Both different prospects to birthing and raising 1 child.

Well yes that's rather the point isnt it, that it's not the same process/outlook/senario as having a biological child.

I was making that point to the poster who only thinks infertile people should have to tell her why they didn't consider adoption when she clearly has no expectation on anyone else to tell her this.

Moreempatheticmyarse · 03/11/2023 10:58

I am infertile, I did have IVF, I paid for it.

I personally believe that egg retrieval/sperm retrieval/embryo creation should be funded by the NHS for someone who is about to go through a medical process that has the side effect of sterilisation such as certain chemotherapy treatments.

I don't think someone should have to choose between life saving treatment and the possibility of future children when they are in that position. And from a pragmatic view if someone put off chemotherapy to have children they could end up needing much more extensive and expensive treatment on the NHS at a later date.

However I don't necessarily think IVF can be offered to everyone free of charge unfortunately and as others have said having a baby is not a right or a need.

Of course others may disagree with my senario where it should be funded or have alternative ones that they think are more important which is probably how we ended up with a postcode lottery for IVF in the first place.

theduchessofspork · 03/11/2023 10:56

I don’t think anyone should have IVF on the NHS at present - resources are simply too stretched, it’s too expensive and the failure rate is too high. It’s not part of the NHS’s core purpose.

user1471447924 · 03/11/2023 10:53

IVF shouldn’t be free to anyone, and, as unpopular a view as it might be, ideally children should have a mother AND a father.

MargotBamborough · 03/11/2023 10:53

VanityDiesHard · 03/11/2023 10:47

Why would people without savings have children?

Well there is a lot of clear water between having no savings and having over 60k in savings, but given that according to the ONS the average person has £17,365 in savings and this is already skewed towards the higher end by people above childbearing age who tend to have more, I think it is reasonable to assume that most people who are capable of having children have a lot less than 60k in savings.

Where do you think the next generation should come from?

UK Savings Statistics 2023 - Saving Facts and Stats Report | money.co.uk

We’ve pulled together the latest UK savings statistics for 2023, covering market trends, types of savings accounts, factors affecting saving, and many more.

https://www.money.co.uk/savings-accounts/savings-statistics

mugboat · 03/11/2023 10:52

Moreempatheticmyarse · 03/11/2023 10:50

I often wonder why parents who haven't used IVF don't consider adoption?
The lose thousands of £ in income - put themselves through the mental and physical torment of pregnancy.
They never mention why the haven't considered adoption?

If you adopt you usually need to take multiple children as social services do not like to split up siblings.

You also would likely be adopting traumatised children- social services only adopt out children in extreme circumstances.

Both different prospects to birthing and raising 1 child.

Porridgeislife · 03/11/2023 10:52

VanityDiesHard · 03/11/2023 10:45

I would not have dreamed of having a child without considerably more than 60k in savings. People are so entitled and irresponsible it is unreal.

Give over. The average wage in the UK is around £35k per year. Very very few parents in the UK have £60k socked away before their child arrives given the cost of housing.

We were extraordinarily privileged to be able to afford so much private treatment.

nutellacreppe · 03/11/2023 10:51

FrustatedAgain · 03/11/2023 10:45

He is male, he has a medical issue preventing it working.

No people cannot help being gay, but there is nothing medically wrong with them. The NHS is there to help with medical issues.
Gay or not they could get pregnant without medical intervention if they chose to do so and therefore do not need IVF.

I could get pregnant without medical intervention if I wanted to (I am a female with an infertile husband). Do I not need IVF?

ginandtonicwithlimes · 03/11/2023 10:51

Infertility bingo going on here.

mugboat · 03/11/2023 10:50

VanityDiesHard · 03/11/2023 10:45

I would not have dreamed of having a child without considerably more than 60k in savings. People are so entitled and irresponsible it is unreal.

Most people wouldn't have kids then 😅

Most people would struggle to save £60k. I know I would and I have an above average wage.

Moreempatheticmyarse · 03/11/2023 10:50

Chris002 · 03/11/2023 10:26

I often wonder why people never seem to consider adoption ?
They spend thousands of £ - put themselves through mental and physical torment of ivf. They never mention why they haven't considered adoption ?

I often wonder why parents who haven't used IVF don't consider adoption?
The lose thousands of £ in income - put themselves through the mental and physical torment of pregnancy.
They never mention why the haven't considered adoption?

ginandtonicwithlimes · 03/11/2023 10:48

VanityDiesHard · 03/11/2023 10:45

I would not have dreamed of having a child without considerably more than 60k in savings. People are so entitled and irresponsible it is unreal.

How many people would be able to able to put that much away? I don't actually think you need that much anyway. Good for you you didn't need to save for your IVF plus for raising a child.