Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Cattenberg · 03/11/2023 11:38

I haven’t read the whole thread, but I agree it doesn’t make sense to fund IUI/IVF for lesbian couples, but not for single women.

That said, I agree the NHS probably can’t afford to fund fertility treatment for anyone with no known fertility issues.

I wish the government would crack down on the profiteering in the private fertility industry - it’s diabolical. Many of the prices charged bear no resemblance to the actual cost of providing the treatment, but the industry knows that people who are desperate for a child will go to great lengths to find the money.

One of my friends sold her home to pay for IVF, knowing that she was unlikely to ever be able to get back on the property ladder.

I have frozen embryos in storage and whilst I first paid £500 for three years storage, now I have to pay £360 per year. And liquid nitrogen costs pennies! Also, about a year ago, the clinic realised there was an item they forgot to charge me for (which would have cost them little or nothing) and contacted me to ask for the money! Not content with taking the best part of £20,000 from me in 2018, they are still determined to extract every penny that they can. Fuck you, London Women’s Clinic!

Scalottia · 03/11/2023 11:38

I agree with you @Planesmistakenforstars - what an offensive comment. Obviously @Lelophants has never had a family member who lost a limb and had to manage this for the rest of their life.

nutellacreppe · 03/11/2023 11:37

I think the only fair way to manage something like IVF on the NHS is to offer it to everyone or no-one, otherwise it becomes an ethical issue where judgements are made about who is and isn't worthy of treatment based on family setups. It's messy and inevitably leads to all kinds of 'value' judgements with quite nasty connotations.

@Bumpitybumper Very eloquently put - I agree with this.

vivainsomnia · 03/11/2023 11:37

It's irrelevant in my case because we are using donor sperm due to azoospermia, so our treatment is just the same as a same sex couple
In your case indeed, but you can't make a generalisation of your case. Most men with infertility issues can get treatment unless completely azoospermic.

Ponoka7 · 03/11/2023 11:36

AgnesX · 03/11/2023 08:08

No. Have you read some of the threads here on how difficult it is to be a single parent. It's not something that should be offered by the NHS.

Yet we allow single people to adopt. It's either ok or not for all services.

I think that NHS fertility services should be for people who have fertility issues, not people who leave it too late, or can't conceive because they are in a same sex relationship, under the current system. However I agree that there should be the ability to top up the cost, so a reduced payment system, means tested, as suggested by a pp. Medical conditions/treatments that have caused issues should be fully funded, regardless of marital/sexual orientation etc. The whole system needs a revamp.

Scalottia · 03/11/2023 11:32

Siameasy · 03/11/2023 11:09

That’s bonkers. Average wage in UK is around 35k. Mr and Mrs average ought to be the ones having kids. It’s dangerous to perpetuate the myth that it’s expensive to have kids. Marriage and kids at a younger age ought to be incentivised. Pushing female careers and “boss babes” has not ended well for women’s fertility rates.

Shall we go back to the 50s then?

Good little wife staying at home having and caring for babies whilst the big man gets his big career? No thanks.

That's how I have interpreted your post.

kikisparks · 03/11/2023 11:32

VanityDiesHard · 03/11/2023 10:45

I would not have dreamed of having a child without considerably more than 60k in savings. People are so entitled and irresponsible it is unreal.

If you think that only people with more than £60k in savings should have a child… I don’t even know what to say to that really, you must have very little understanding of how most people live!

Bluelightbaby · 03/11/2023 11:32

I work for the NHS and first hand see how much it struggles. I have also been TTC for two years so see that side of the coin BUT having a baby is a luxury NOT a necessity and I don’t think any form of IVF should be provided on the NHS. Sometimes that just nature and natures way of controlling the population, not everyone can have children

Planesmistakenforstars · 03/11/2023 11:30

Lelophants · Today 09:36

A bit unfair. For a lot of people, never having children is the worst thing imaginable. Personally I’d rather lose my limbs than have never had kids but that’s me.

I'm got to assume that you are being ridiculously melodramatic. Or would you actually say to someone who does not have legs, and faces the lifelong discrimination, financial hardship, medical treatments, physical struggles, and pain that goes with it that you would rather be them than not have children?

nutellacreppe · 03/11/2023 11:28

vivainsomnia · 03/11/2023 11:19

It's completely irrelevant that the reason for my husband's infertility is medical
ICSI is almost always the choice of treatment in make infertility, rather than IVF. This involves picking the healthiest sperm most likely to fertilise the egg. It is an intervention specific to male infertility.

The fact that it requires the female to have her eggs removed and the embryo put back is circumstantial in this instance.

Yes I'm well aware of ICSI. It's IVF + extras, it's not that different. The only difference is that they pick an individual sperm and inject it into the egg.

It's irrelevant in my case because we are using donor sperm due to azoospermia, so our treatment is just the same as a same sex couple.

Kestor654 · 03/11/2023 11:23

The state will hopefully providing that intervention for them.

Although, if the government allowed at home insemination using fresh donor sperm from a sperm bank they may not have to.

CateB78 · 03/11/2023 11:23

Kestor654 · 03/11/2023 11:19

I was under the impression the movement was for same sex couples and single women. There's been a lot of effort in trying to get this to happen.

Currently, same sex female/afab couples need to go through 6 to 12 rounds of IUI before treatment is available on the NHS. That equates to 1-2 years of trying with a rough cost of £2k per go (incl. sperm). If all fail, then same sex couples, and single women for that matter are having to pay upwards of £24k before they are currently entitled to NHS help.

There are changes being made which should open up fertility treatment to single women and same sex couples but it might take some time.

If you read the article, it says IUI will be funded by the government for same sex couples but not for single women.

OP posts:
nutellacreppe · 03/11/2023 11:21

JustAMinutePleass · 03/11/2023 11:15

I think the expectation for gay / lesbian couples to be able to have biological children is a clear demonstration of how we’re forcing heteronormative values on people who aren’t heterosexual. But if they want to have kids and the NHS is offering it why not?

Sorry, I don't really understand this comment. What do you mean by forcing heteronormative views on people who aren't heterosexual?

Some people in same sex relationships want children just as much as people in heterosexual relationships. I don't think that is about 'heterosexual norms', it's about a strong human instinct/ desire to procreate.

I imagine that if I was gay I would want a child just as much as I currently do. I certainly know gay couples who want children every bit as much as I do.

Having had the first hand experience of years of infertility that I have had, the thought that the NHS would treat me differently because of the sex of my partner, is frankly very unpleasant. I am glad that they are reviewing their funding.

Bumpitybumper · 03/11/2023 11:21

I think the only fair way to manage something like IVF on the NHS is to offer it to everyone or no-one, otherwise it becomes an ethical issue where judgements are made about who is and isn't worthy of treatment based on family setups. It's messy and inevitably leads to all kinds of 'value' judgements with quite nasty connotations.

I also think there is an argument that can be made by gay men or single men that they should be entitled to a similar level of 'help' with having a child as everyone else. Obviously this wouldn't be in the form of IVF, but I can see why they could argue that just assisting women is inherently unfair. Men would obviously involve a surrogate and be ethically dubious in other ways, but I can see how they could feel discriminated against if two lesbians or a man and woman are funded to the tune of thousands of pounds and they get nothing. For this reason, I think IVF shouldn't be available to anyone on the NHS as this is the fairest solution.

NugatoryMatters · 03/11/2023 11:19

Kestor654 · 03/11/2023 11:13

I think this is a bit oversimplified. There are many reasons women choose to remain single. Why should they be forced into having unprotected sex with a man? There may be past trauma or it just might not have happened for them.

No one is forcing them to have sex.

If they don’t want to have sex - for whatever reason - then they aren’t going to get pregnant without medical intervention.

the state doesn’t have to provide that medical intervention for them.

Kestor654 · 03/11/2023 11:19

I was under the impression the movement was for same sex couples and single women. There's been a lot of effort in trying to get this to happen.

Currently, same sex female/afab couples need to go through 6 to 12 rounds of IUI before treatment is available on the NHS. That equates to 1-2 years of trying with a rough cost of £2k per go (incl. sperm). If all fail, then same sex couples, and single women for that matter are having to pay upwards of £24k before they are currently entitled to NHS help.

There are changes being made which should open up fertility treatment to single women and same sex couples but it might take some time.

vivainsomnia · 03/11/2023 11:19

It's completely irrelevant that the reason for my husband's infertility is medical
ICSI is almost always the choice of treatment in make infertility, rather than IVF. This involves picking the healthiest sperm most likely to fertilise the egg. It is an intervention specific to male infertility.

The fact that it requires the female to have her eggs removed and the embryo put back is circumstantial in this instance.

BIossomtoes · 03/11/2023 11:18

Surely2023IsTheYearForMyRainbowBaby · 03/11/2023 11:11

We can't all afford thousands to have a Baby

Then don’t have one. Having a child isn’t a right. I’d stop all NHS funded IVF when there are people dying of treatable diseases because waiting lists are so long. Anyone wanting IVF should pay for it.

NugatoryMatters · 03/11/2023 11:18

MumblesParty · 03/11/2023 11:06

Talk me through this “finding a man” proposal of yours.

Most single woman wanting children by IVF are likely to be heterosexual women in their 30s, who are aware that time is running out, and have been unsuccessful in finding a relationship. We see it all the time on here - women in stable relationships with men who they love, being tricked into waiting to have kids, then being abandoned by their partner and finding they’re suddenly in their late 30s. Are you saying these women should simply go out and shag the first man they see? Regardless of whether they fancy them. Or should they just get a boyfriend and use him for sperm, even if he doesn’t want kids?

I am saying that single women in their 30s who feel time is running out may need to simply accept that they made all sorts of choices to find themselves in this situation.

They aren’t owed a baby. Or free NHS IVF.

Not being in a sexual relationship with a man will necessarily represent a significant barrier to conceiving a child. That’s just how it is.

It’s not heartlessness. It’s basic biology.

Northernladdette · 03/11/2023 11:18

Surely donor insemination is more straightforward for female same sex couples?

Onethingatatime23 · 03/11/2023 11:15

Whatever the policy is, it should be the same countrywide, not 3 courses in one area, none in another, one in another.

JustAMinutePleass · 03/11/2023 11:15

nutellacreppe · 03/11/2023 11:01

@FrustatedAgain Your stance appears to me to be:

If I am female and have a male partner who can't get me pregnant - NHS should fund IVF.
If I am female and have a female partner who can't get me pregnant - NHS should not fund IVF.

I understand that people have varying opinions on whether the NHS should or shouldn't fund IVF and there are arguments on both sides which are interesting and valid.

But I can't understand how your position above is not an inherently homophobic stance.

I think the expectation for gay / lesbian couples to be able to have biological children is a clear demonstration of how we’re forcing heteronormative values on people who aren’t heterosexual. But if they want to have kids and the NHS is offering it why not?

Viviennemary · 03/11/2023 11:14

I think ivf on the NHS should only be available to those with a medical
problem which prevents them from conceiving.

Kestor654 · 03/11/2023 11:13

I think this is a bit oversimplified. There are many reasons women choose to remain single. Why should they be forced into having unprotected sex with a man? There may be past trauma or it just might not have happened for them.

Surely2023IsTheYearForMyRainbowBaby · 03/11/2023 11:11

CalistoNoSolo · 03/11/2023 08:12

I don't think the nhs should be funding any ivf treatments for anyone.

We can't all afford thousands to have a Baby

Swipe left for the next trending thread