Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

nutellacreppe · 03/11/2023 11:56

vivainsomnia · 03/11/2023 11:50

If I can get treatment in this situation, then someone in a same sex couple in this situation should also get treatment
We are back to saying it is not medically the same. Your OH has a medical condition which means you can't get pregnant from him. The reason why same sex couples can't get pregnant is not medical.

That's all what it comes down to. The NHS doesn't get involved with non medical ethical matters.

You are missing the point.

It's not a medical intervention.

I am the one having the treatment and I am fertile and healthy.

My husband has nothing to do with the procedure, doesn't even have to be present, and his medical condition is not being treated. The treatment and outcomes are absolutely no different than if he was female.

You have a couple who cannot conceive because one partner cannot produce sperm. You are treating a fertile, healthy woman by using donor sperm. It is simply because he is male that we are allowed this treatment on the NHS, and that is unequal. If we are allowed this treatment then a lesbian couple should also be allowed it.

Kestor654 · 03/11/2023 11:54

Right. But the article could be wrong and I'm talking about what is being worked on. As a female in a same sex relationship currently going through the process to try and get pregnant, I am following this process very carefully. I have written to my MP, written to the ICBs. The movement is for single women as well.

They reached a decision last week that they were moving towards fertility equality but it will take some time (perhaps a year).

FrangipaniBlue · 03/11/2023 11:53

If you are single, want a baby and don’t fancy paying for fertility treatment, the answer is to find a man who wants to conceive a child with you.

I agree, but the same should also apply to a same sex couple - find a donor and pay for the treatment.

NOBODY should receive IVF on the NHS unless there is a medical reason they cannot conceive naturally.

Absence of a male is not a medical reason.

Guesswho88 · 03/11/2023 11:53

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 03/11/2023 08:01

I'm not sure. I don't think it's reasonable to discriminate against women just because they're single, but I wonder if it's ultimately about the rights of the child rather than the prospective parents(s)?

Does a child have a right to two parents? (Obviously, some kids will lose a parent due to bereavement, abandonment etc, but in most cases, the starting point is two parents, even if they aren't both listed on the birth certificate.)

I'd need to see more detail regarding the arguments on both sides before I could come down firmly on one side or another.

Just to play devil's advocate here the starting point in most cases is also male and female parents and there could be an argument that a child has right to that.

Webex · 03/11/2023 11:53

Your OH has a medical condition which means you can't get pregnant from him. The reason why same sex couples can't get pregnant is not medical

But in either case the woman having IVF treatment doesn't have a medical condition - their issue is choice of partner.

MrsSkylerWhite · 03/11/2023 11:53

TheBirdintheCave

We built up some savings in advance of starting our family, it just felt like the sensible thing to do. Had we not been successful, we would 100% have spent them on treatment. Could you not do the same?

vivainsomnia · 03/11/2023 11:50

If I can get treatment in this situation, then someone in a same sex couple in this situation should also get treatment
We are back to saying it is not medically the same. Your OH has a medical condition which means you can't get pregnant from him. The reason why same sex couples can't get pregnant is not medical.

That's all what it comes down to. The NHS doesn't get involved with non medical ethical matters.

Bumpitybumper · 03/11/2023 11:48

Porridgeislife · 03/11/2023 11:40

When you have to fund your own IVF to the tune of £10-12k a round, come back and chat.

For some women having a baby is a literal matter of life and death in terms of their mental health. If you haven’t walked in their shoes, it’s difficult to comment.

(All of our IVF was paid for privately as it wasn’t available during Covid).

This is a slippery slope argument though as of course wanting something desperately and be unable to have it can impact your mental health but the NHS can't afford to fund every desire that we have just in case we decide we can't carry on without it. This is especially true in the context of an NHS that is struggling to fund genuinely life saving treatment and to support people who are struggling to cope with severe mental health disorders.

Bluelightbaby · 03/11/2023 11:48

but that’s the point, as heart breaking as I’m finding TTC I truly believe that not everyone is meant to have children and that’s life, as distressing as that is. There’s plenty of other ways like adoption/fostering.

the NHS is on its knees and can barely cope with medical emergencies let alone IVF which I stand by my statement is a luxury and not a necessity.

Gillypie23 · 03/11/2023 11:48

You could argue its unfair on single men or same sex couples.

nutellacreppe · 03/11/2023 11:48

@vivainsomnia I am getting treatment on the NHS because my partner has no sperm. We are using a donor and have had various interventions, IUI and IVF.

To me, it seems simply irrelevant whether the reason for my partner's lack of sperm is a medical issue, or whether it's because they are female.

Either way, the fact is that my partner has no sperm and we need a donor to conceive.

Why should someone get treatment in the former situation, in a heterosexual relationship, but not the latter, in a same sex relationship?

It's the same situation and the same treatment - it should be both or neither.

TheBirdintheCave · 03/11/2023 11:47

@MrsSkylerWhite Because I wasn't asked to immediately fork over £6k when I gave birth to my son. I can afford to have him because I pay for the things he needs over time, like everyone does. Private IVF is an upfront cost most of the time.

StacieBenson · 03/11/2023 11:47

Nopenopenopenopenopenope · 03/11/2023 11:44

Unpopular opinion but I don't think it should be offered to anyone. At all.

Do you mind me asking why?

Scalottia · 03/11/2023 11:46

BIossomtoes · 03/11/2023 11:40

In which case you didn’t read it properly. Female fertility starts to decline after 30, that’s a fact. Nobody wants women not to have a career or stay at home but it’s common sense to crack on and have a family when fertility is at its peak.

Nah...I read it properly. I stand by my point.

MrsSkylerWhite · 03/11/2023 11:45

ginandtonicwithlimes · Today 08:20

Here we go again ..
**
Having children via IVF will be just for the wealthy then”

I don’t understand this argument. If a couple can’t afford IVF, how will they afford to raise a child?

If someone can’t afford nicotine gum/vapes, etc., how can they afford cigarettes. There are probably lots of other such examples.

The NHS isn’t a bottomless pit.

Nopenopenopenopenopenope · 03/11/2023 11:44

Unpopular opinion but I don't think it should be offered to anyone. At all.

SayYesToTheWrapDress · 03/11/2023 11:44

Bluelightbaby · 03/11/2023 11:32

I work for the NHS and first hand see how much it struggles. I have also been TTC for two years so see that side of the coin BUT having a baby is a luxury NOT a necessity and I don’t think any form of IVF should be provided on the NHS. Sometimes that just nature and natures way of controlling the population, not everyone can have children

Totally agree. I'm afraid there are far more important things for the NHS to fund.

Pigsears · 03/11/2023 11:43

Lelophants · 03/11/2023 08:14

I can see why it might feel unfair, but at the end of the day, ivf is paid for by the nhs for those who have a medical problem getting pregnant. Being single is not a medical problem. You could argue being in a same sex relationship isn’t a problem either, so now I’m not sure where I stand. I guess if you’re single you still have the option of having sex with a man but can’t if you’re gay.

It would be nice if the private places did longer and better loans so more people could access it.

What about single lesbians? If they are single they don't have the option.

As single lesbians and single heterosexuals are treated the same, the value is placed on being in a couple.

Do both women in the relationship qualify for treatment? If that was the case,, that would be unfair. As a hetero couple would not be funded for treatment once there was a live birth..

Hereforthebunfights · 03/11/2023 11:42

No one should be getting fertility treatment on the NHS.

Porridgeislife · 03/11/2023 11:40

Bluelightbaby · 03/11/2023 11:32

I work for the NHS and first hand see how much it struggles. I have also been TTC for two years so see that side of the coin BUT having a baby is a luxury NOT a necessity and I don’t think any form of IVF should be provided on the NHS. Sometimes that just nature and natures way of controlling the population, not everyone can have children

When you have to fund your own IVF to the tune of £10-12k a round, come back and chat.

For some women having a baby is a literal matter of life and death in terms of their mental health. If you haven’t walked in their shoes, it’s difficult to comment.

(All of our IVF was paid for privately as it wasn’t available during Covid).

BIossomtoes · 03/11/2023 11:40

Scalottia · 03/11/2023 11:32

Shall we go back to the 50s then?

Good little wife staying at home having and caring for babies whilst the big man gets his big career? No thanks.

That's how I have interpreted your post.

In which case you didn’t read it properly. Female fertility starts to decline after 30, that’s a fact. Nobody wants women not to have a career or stay at home but it’s common sense to crack on and have a family when fertility is at its peak.

fitzwilliamdarcy · 03/11/2023 11:40

I fundamentally don’t agree that the taxpayer should be funding people choosing to have a child with only one parent. I agree that it’s awful that so many dreadful people can have baby after baby, and that it seems unfair that an unsuitable couple can get free IVF when a suitable single woman can’t.

Ultimately I’d rather the NHS provided proper mental health services than free IVF (to anyone). Mental health conditions are life-threatening and all but the luckiest have to pay privately to be treated. I myself have paid thousands to heal from my own childhood. That’s the kind of thing that the NHS should be doing, rather than helping people have their wants met.

I say this as someone who lost her womb and ovaries at 32, and understands the pain of infertility.

Planesmistakenforstars · 03/11/2023 11:39

Pushing female careers and “boss babes” has not ended well for women’s fertility rates.

What is this little nugget of shit? Are you claiming there's a link between women working and infertility??

nutellacreppe · 03/11/2023 11:38

vivainsomnia · 03/11/2023 11:37

It's irrelevant in my case because we are using donor sperm due to azoospermia, so our treatment is just the same as a same sex couple
In your case indeed, but you can't make a generalisation of your case. Most men with infertility issues can get treatment unless completely azoospermic.

I can absolutely make a generalisation based on my case. That is the whole point.

If I can get treatment in this situation, then someone in a same sex couple in this situation should also get treatment.

CaptainJackSparrow85 · 03/11/2023 11:38

No, but then I don’t think same sex couples should get IVF/ICSI on the NHS - being gay isn’t a health problem. Neither is being single.