Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Nopenopenopenopenopenope · 03/11/2023 12:23

StacieBenson · 03/11/2023 11:47

Do you mind me asking why?

Offering "treatment" for infertility as if it's an illness is bizarre to me. It's not an illness it's just tough luck.

nutellacreppe · 03/11/2023 12:22

I am going to duck out of this thread now - I have said all I have to say and will be repeating myself from now on. Interesting debate and opinions.

Tinklyheadtilt · 03/11/2023 12:21

IVF should not be on the NHS for anyone. The taxpayer is on the hook enough for NHS spending and should be spent on other things.

If you want a child go private.

nutellacreppe · 03/11/2023 12:20

SoftFire · 03/11/2023 12:16

I think this is more of an argument against you getting the treatment for free, rather than in favour of same-sex couples getting it.

You're right - it doesn't make sense for massive nhs resources to be spent on someone who has no relevant health issues.

I have friends who had children via ivf due to male factor infertility (one nhs, one private) but the difference was that they were able to use his sperm, so their children are biologically both of theirs, and the ivf treatment made that possible.

In your case, the nhs is spending thousands to get a fertile woman pregnant by a fertile man. It is nonsensical.

Perhaps so, however, if you had been on the journey I have been on, you would know just how difficult it has been. Infertility is one of those things that is very hard to explain to someone who has not been through it, and very hard to understand until you have.

If your friends were not able to conceive via IVF, if the male factor issue was severe and it didn't work, they may well have decided to move onto using a donor.

Whether or not the NHS should help with funding that is certainly a debate - but it needs to be the same, regardless of whether the potential parents are in a same sex or heterosexual relationship.

vivainsomnia · 03/11/2023 12:20

Yes and my argument is that it is not right that that's what it comes down to. It is favouring heterosexual couples
No, it's favouring the couple with a medical condition, who is who the NHS should treat equally.

vivainsomnia · 03/11/2023 12:19

I'm saying that it is inequal that I can get this but a same sex couple can't
I agree that there is inequality but it is not medical inequality, it's biological inequality.

What I do find very wrong is that an infertile woman isn't entitled to treatment if her partner has a child already. THAT is medical inequality based on social circumstances and that shouldn't be for the NHS to make. If one person with a medical condition is entitled to treatment, another with the same condition should too, and yes, that should include single mums with infertility.

nutellacreppe · 03/11/2023 12:16

vivainsomnia · 03/11/2023 12:14

@nutellacreppe, again, one can't produce sperm because of a medical condition, the other can't for biological reason.

That's all what it comes down to.

Yes and my argument is that it is not right that that's what it comes down to. It is favouring heterosexual couples.

And at the end of the day, the NHS obviously agree, as they are reviewing the funding for same sex couples.

SoftFire · 03/11/2023 12:16

nutellacreppe · 03/11/2023 11:48

@vivainsomnia I am getting treatment on the NHS because my partner has no sperm. We are using a donor and have had various interventions, IUI and IVF.

To me, it seems simply irrelevant whether the reason for my partner's lack of sperm is a medical issue, or whether it's because they are female.

Either way, the fact is that my partner has no sperm and we need a donor to conceive.

Why should someone get treatment in the former situation, in a heterosexual relationship, but not the latter, in a same sex relationship?

It's the same situation and the same treatment - it should be both or neither.

I think this is more of an argument against you getting the treatment for free, rather than in favour of same-sex couples getting it.

You're right - it doesn't make sense for massive nhs resources to be spent on someone who has no relevant health issues.

I have friends who had children via ivf due to male factor infertility (one nhs, one private) but the difference was that they were able to use his sperm, so their children are biologically both of theirs, and the ivf treatment made that possible.

In your case, the nhs is spending thousands to get a fertile woman pregnant by a fertile man. It is nonsensical.

nutellacreppe · 03/11/2023 12:15

KimberleyClark · 03/11/2023 12:10

Do you think lesbian couples who are both healthy and fertile should be able to get treatment on the NHS then? You are getting it because your partner is medically infertile?

I think that it should be equal.

My partner can't produce sperm so I am getting NHS funded treatment with donor sperm.

If my partner was female, we would have the same issue.

In that scenario, it would not be my choice to be gay. I would want children just as much.

Whether you allow both or neither, it needs to be equal.

sollenwir · 03/11/2023 12:14

SquashPenguin · 03/11/2023 09:23

I tried to take my own life after repeated IVF failures.

I hope you got the support you needed. I also think that even attempting IVF can in itself be as much of an emotional burden as the struggling to conceive - so much hope, time and sometimes money, and it often doesn't work at all.

vivainsomnia · 03/11/2023 12:14

@nutellacreppe, again, one can't produce sperm because of a medical condition, the other can't for biological reason.

That's all what it comes down to.

LakeTiticaca · 03/11/2023 12:12

Why don't they use sperm donation,?
Fare less invasive and much cheaper

nutellacreppe · 03/11/2023 12:12

vivainsomnia · 03/11/2023 12:08

You are missing the point
I'm afraid you are. It's because of your OH medical condition that YOU receive the treatment. If he didn't suffer from it, you wouldn't get it either.

You can debate that considering the only solution in your case is a donor, and it is therefore not a direct treatment on your OH, you shouldn't be entitled to it which indeed, is arguable, but not the other way around: that because you (you and your OH) are entitled, same sex couples should too.

Yes I know it's because of his medical condition that I am getting treatment.

I'm saying that it is inequal that I can get this but a same sex couple can't, because the impact of a partner not being able to produce sperm is the same, whatever the reason for that - be that because of a medical issue, or because of their sex.

Whether both or neither can access it, it should be the same. Currently, there is inequality. Hence they are looking at changing this and giving more funding to same sex couples, and I agree with that. I would also agree with it in principle if they took it away from me, although I'd obviously then be out of pocket by a lot of money - because it would be equal.

What I don't agree with is the inequality and this daft idea that because it is 'medical' it makes a difference. The fact is that a lack of sperm means you can't conceive, whether you are in a same sex or heterosexual couple, and should be treated the same.

vivainsomnia · 03/11/2023 12:10

But in either case the woman having IVF treatment doesn't have a medical condition - their issue is choice of partner
Yes, one has a medical condition, the other Durant. That's the difference.

Goodluckanddontfitup · 03/11/2023 12:10

It’s such a complicated subject. All I know through personal experience is that the NHS made it possible for me to have my child and that was life changing for me and I will be forever grateful. It’s really not as simple as fertility treatment shouldn’t be funded for anyone as it’s not life threatening, the pain of the thought of never becoming parents is unbearable for some and really affects your whole life. In an ideal world where money was no object those that craved becoming parents and would make a loving family for a child would get that chance.

KimberleyClark · 03/11/2023 12:10

nutellacreppe · 03/11/2023 11:56

You are missing the point.

It's not a medical intervention.

I am the one having the treatment and I am fertile and healthy.

My husband has nothing to do with the procedure, doesn't even have to be present, and his medical condition is not being treated. The treatment and outcomes are absolutely no different than if he was female.

You have a couple who cannot conceive because one partner cannot produce sperm. You are treating a fertile, healthy woman by using donor sperm. It is simply because he is male that we are allowed this treatment on the NHS, and that is unequal. If we are allowed this treatment then a lesbian couple should also be allowed it.

Do you think lesbian couples who are both healthy and fertile should be able to get treatment on the NHS then? You are getting it because your partner is medically infertile?

TheBirdintheCave · 03/11/2023 12:09

@MrsSkylerWhite Your question was how can people afford children but not IVF which is what I was answering. You don't need savings to have and raise a child if you have a good wage coming in every month as no one ever asks you for a lump sum of thousands of pounds. Savings would be nice of course, but not necessary.

Sure I COULD have saved up money before having my son but it would have taken us years to save the amount a round of private IVF costs. I was 29 when I first met my husband so we didn't have the luxury of time to save.

calyrex · 03/11/2023 12:08

FrangipaniBlue · 03/11/2023 11:53

If you are single, want a baby and don’t fancy paying for fertility treatment, the answer is to find a man who wants to conceive a child with you.

I agree, but the same should also apply to a same sex couple - find a donor and pay for the treatment.

NOBODY should receive IVF on the NHS unless there is a medical reason they cannot conceive naturally.

Absence of a male is not a medical reason.

Same question to you, how do you propose same-sex couples have a baby? Why is an opposite sex couple who can't concieve together more worthy than a same-sex couple?

vivainsomnia · 03/11/2023 12:08

You are missing the point
I'm afraid you are. It's because of your OH medical condition that YOU receive the treatment. If he didn't suffer from it, you wouldn't get it either.

You can debate that considering the only solution in your case is a donor, and it is therefore not a direct treatment on your OH, you shouldn't be entitled to it which indeed, is arguable, but not the other way around: that because you (you and your OH) are entitled, same sex couples should too.

calyrex · 03/11/2023 12:06

vivainsomnia · 03/11/2023 11:50

If I can get treatment in this situation, then someone in a same sex couple in this situation should also get treatment
We are back to saying it is not medically the same. Your OH has a medical condition which means you can't get pregnant from him. The reason why same sex couples can't get pregnant is not medical.

That's all what it comes down to. The NHS doesn't get involved with non medical ethical matters.

So how do you propose same-sex couples have children then?

nutellacreppe · 03/11/2023 12:05

@vivainsomnia

  1. My partner should be able to produce sperm but can't = NHS funded fertility treatment.

  2. My partner can't produce sperm and was never able to = No NHS funded fertility treatment.

That seems pretty messed up to me.

People don't choose their sexual orientation. They are what they are.

Both partners can't produce sperm. Both couples can't conceive. They should both get treatment or neither.

ManchesterLu · 03/11/2023 12:05

SunnieShine · 03/11/2023 07:55

Do you also think it's unfair that mixed sex couples can get IVF but single women can't? Why just say same sex couples?

It's not the same though is it. With a M/F couple there will be some medical fertility issue, whereas with SS, singles it's just a biologically impossible situation - it's wanting something that will never be possible without intervention.

Elsiebear90 · 03/11/2023 12:04

I think the nhs is funding donor conception it should be available for all, because that’s not really a treatment for a person with a medical condition it’s a replacement.

fitzwilliamdarcy · 03/11/2023 12:03

Planesmistakenforstars · 03/11/2023 11:30

Lelophants · Today 09:36

A bit unfair. For a lot of people, never having children is the worst thing imaginable. Personally I’d rather lose my limbs than have never had kids but that’s me.

I'm got to assume that you are being ridiculously melodramatic. Or would you actually say to someone who does not have legs, and faces the lifelong discrimination, financial hardship, medical treatments, physical struggles, and pain that goes with it that you would rather be them than not have children?

I had to lose my reproductive organs to save my life. A parent at work, when I returned, blurted out that in my position she’d rather have died than not be able to have kids. People really do think and say things like this, out loud!

BeeHappy12 · 03/11/2023 12:02

CalistoNoSolo · 03/11/2023 08:12

I don't think the nhs should be funding any ivf treatments for anyone.

What? Why not?? I'm very curious as to why you would think this.

Personally I've always thought fertility issues must be so difficult mentally and physically and these families deserve all the help they can get.

What are your thoughts on ex smokers receiving donated lungs or ex alcoholics receiving livers or drug addicts new heart valves?

Swipe left for the next trending thread