Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

calyrex · 03/11/2023 13:17

FoodCentre · 03/11/2023 13:13

Same question to you, how do you propose same-sex couples have a baby? Why is an opposite sex couple who can't concieve together more worthy than a same-sex couple?

PP said nobody should get IVF on the NHS.

Anyone who wants it pays for it themselves.

The poster I quoted said people who can't conceive for medical reasons should.

FoodCentre · 03/11/2023 13:16

I think with IVF, how much of it is:

Infertility, in terms of a medical condition, something not working right...

And how much of it is lifestyle choices, like choosing to advance a career til 38. Choosing to travel and enjoy being a couple. Choosing to get a mortgage and have substantial savings first.

I don't really see how the latter is a medical issue, but hey. It's not really possible to discriminate against one group so it's all or nothing.

Tandora · 03/11/2023 13:16

Cattenberg · 03/11/2023 13:11

I disagree. You might as well say that the inability of two men to conceive is a medical condition and that they should have the right to use a surrogate mother. But that raises a lot of ethical issues.
Instead, I think we should accept that complete “fertility equality” is impossible.

You could argue that a lesbian couple having fertility treatment are luckier than a straight couple, because they have more potential options (assuming they can afford them). For example, one partner could provide the eggs and the other could carry the baby.

I disagree. You might as well say that the inability of two men to conceive is a medical condition and that they should have the right to use a surrogate mother

no it doesn’t imply this at all, because no straight infertile couples currently have this “right” - to use a surrogate - either.

You are right of course that “complete fertility equality” is impossible (I’m not suggesting it is), but it’s perfectly possible not to discriminate against the funding made available for the exact same fertility treatments based on someone’s sex, sexuality or their relationship status.

Chris002 · 03/11/2023 13:14

CateB78 · 03/11/2023 10:29

If you read the article one of the women talks about it.

Yes she says she had an overwhelming desire to get pregnant and carry a baby.

  1. Why didn't she try a dating website then lots of men out there !! Would have saved her borrowing thousands off her family !
  2. I suspect the reason she didn't do this is that the clinic procedures involves an anonymous sperm donor, no contact with biological child until they are 18 and then only if the child initiates it.
  3. So really what she is saying is if I went out on a few dates with a man and I got pregnant this guy might get to find out about it, particularly if you live in the same area, when I post all my cute baby photos and 'my story' on my tik tok channel or my Facebook page he might recognise me and god forbid he might want to get in touch with me and want to be in my child's life.
So what she is saying is, I want a baby ! Only a baby !not someone to share my child's life with. My child will grow up with just me and I am not looking any further than achieving my aim of giving birth. No mention at all of how she will explain this to her child when it is older. Women who are that self obsessed are probably like that in other areas of their life too. Lonely life for the child ?
FoodCentre · 03/11/2023 13:13

Same question to you, how do you propose same-sex couples have a baby? Why is an opposite sex couple who can't concieve together more worthy than a same-sex couple?

PP said nobody should get IVF on the NHS.

Anyone who wants it pays for it themselves.

Cattenberg · 03/11/2023 13:11

Tandora · 03/11/2023 12:56

Agreed. It’s completely irrelevant and total semantics. One is called a “medical condition” and the other a “biological reason”. They are both simply biological realities of someone’s body.

ultimately these semantic distinctions rest on value laden assumptions about “how things were supposed to be” - the way god intended and all!

When a woman has a male partner who can’t get her pregnant, we fund fertility treatment- because after all , we think, “he’s male so he should have been able to get her pregnant, if it weren’t for his medical condition”.

When she has a female partner, however, we think “well that’s not the way things were meant to be”. So that’s just biology.

But if we are making these value laden,(heterosexist) judgements about how things should be/ were meant to be, then really we might as well go back to defining homosexuality itself as a medical condition- it’s not the way things were supposed to be / how biology/ (god!) intended after all!

And if homosexuality is a medical condition after all, then surely we should, by these very same terms, be funding treatment for same sex couples!!

Edited

I disagree. You might as well say that the inability of two men to conceive is a medical condition and that they should have the right to use a surrogate mother. But that raises a lot of ethical issues.
Instead, I think we should accept that complete “fertility equality” is impossible.

You could argue that a lesbian couple having fertility treatment are luckier than a straight couple, because they have more potential options (assuming they can afford them). For example, one partner could provide the eggs and the other could carry the baby.

kikisparks · 03/11/2023 13:10

VanityDiesHard · 03/11/2023 13:05

Having children is a privilege, not a right. If you are so traumatised that you cannot be in a relationship of any kind, then should you really be having children?

I think she meant traumatised perhaps due to SA meaning they don’t want to/ cannot have sex. Not that they can’t have a relationship.

TheCupboardUnderTheStairsAtTheMojoDojoCasaHouse · 03/11/2023 13:09

Iliedwheniwas17 · 03/11/2023 08:14

I think ivf should only be offered to those with fertility problems on the NHS. Or those with genetic issues such as the BRCA gene. I don’t think IVF should be free for someone who is in their 40s and single and wants a baby with a sperm donor as in the article. There just isn’t the funds.

IVF with pre-implantation genetic diagnosis (PGD) is offered on the NHS, but subject to the same restrictions as infertility IVF.

In my area, that's a maximum of 3 cycles and 1 healthy child - no siblings allowed.

Of course, most people seeking PGD IVF don't have fertility issues - it's literally just preventative healthcare for the future child. The NHS is quite happy to pay for the extortionately expensive medical treatment of as many genetically disabled children as we want to pop out, so long as they're conceived naturally.

It's a complete false economy.

kikisparks · 03/11/2023 13:09

LakeTiticaca · 03/11/2023 12:12

Why don't they use sperm donation,?
Fare less invasive and much cheaper

They do, that’s what the the funding is for- IUI which is insemination with (in this case) donated sperm.

VanityDiesHard · 03/11/2023 13:05

Kestor654 · 03/11/2023 11:13

I think this is a bit oversimplified. There are many reasons women choose to remain single. Why should they be forced into having unprotected sex with a man? There may be past trauma or it just might not have happened for them.

Having children is a privilege, not a right. If you are so traumatised that you cannot be in a relationship of any kind, then should you really be having children?

friendlyflicka · 03/11/2023 13:03

NHS funding is not logical. I would think this is because a lot of historic funding has remained the same and newer treatments are subject to more stringent financial tests.

For instance, thyroid conditions lead to free prescriptions and a lot of other chronic conditions do not.

Tandora · 03/11/2023 12:56

calyrex · 03/11/2023 12:38

Why is one worthy of IVF and the other not? The result is the same, they cannot physically have a child with their partner.

Agreed. It’s completely irrelevant and total semantics. One is called a “medical condition” and the other a “biological reason”. They are both simply biological realities of someone’s body.

ultimately these semantic distinctions rest on value laden assumptions about “how things were supposed to be” - the way god intended and all!

When a woman has a male partner who can’t get her pregnant, we fund fertility treatment- because after all , we think, “he’s male so he should have been able to get her pregnant, if it weren’t for his medical condition”.

When she has a female partner, however, we think “well that’s not the way things were meant to be”. So that’s just biology.

But if we are making these value laden,(heterosexist) judgements about how things should be/ were meant to be, then really we might as well go back to defining homosexuality itself as a medical condition- it’s not the way things were supposed to be / how biology/ (god!) intended after all!

And if homosexuality is a medical condition after all, then surely we should, by these very same terms, be funding treatment for same sex couples!!

Chris002 · 03/11/2023 12:49

Yes I think that egg / sperm freezing for people who are about to under go medical treatment such as chemotherapy or have medical condition that makes them infertile should be funded by the NHS but the procedures should be carried out in the private sector ie the NHS should pay a private health care provider to do this treatment.

CesareBorgia · 03/11/2023 12:44

Cosyblankets · 03/11/2023 09:43

He has a grown up child he hardly sees?

Not due to any ill-will. She moved to the other end of the country to be with her DP and with everyone involved working full time, logistics don't allow them to meet very often.

CaptainJackSparrow85 · 03/11/2023 12:43

I’ve read the NHS guidance more closely. The point isn’t, as I understand it, that the NHS offers IVF for any same sex couple who want a baby - IVF is only available to people with fertility problems regardless of sexual orientation. But the issue is that you have to have been trying unsuccessfully to conceive for 12 months to be eligible for NHS IVF, but same sex couples/single women can’t try to conceive like straight people can, they have to spend huge amounts of cash to even demonstrate their eligibility.

calyrex · 03/11/2023 12:38

vivainsomnia · 03/11/2023 12:14

@nutellacreppe, again, one can't produce sperm because of a medical condition, the other can't for biological reason.

That's all what it comes down to.

Why is one worthy of IVF and the other not? The result is the same, they cannot physically have a child with their partner.

StacieBenson · 03/11/2023 12:36

Nopenopenopenopenopenope · 03/11/2023 12:23

Offering "treatment" for infertility as if it's an illness is bizarre to me. It's not an illness it's just tough luck.

Infertility is often the result of illness (e.g. PCOS) or treatment for a medical condition (e.g. infertility post chemo). If a heterosexual couple of reproductive age are having regular unprotected intercourse over a period of years and they have not conceived that is a sign that something is biologically wrong. Apart from normal decline associated with age, you can't draw an artificial distinction between infertility and illness as though they have nothing to do with each other.

AntonFeckoff · 03/11/2023 12:34

Nopenopenopenopenopenope · 03/11/2023 12:23

Offering "treatment" for infertility as if it's an illness is bizarre to me. It's not an illness it's just tough luck.

It can very much be part of an illness. Endometriosis can cause infertility, for example. And in some cases infertility could have been avoided had the woman been offered treatment for endometriosis sooner instead of having to jump through hoops and suffer excruciating pain for an average of seven years just to get a diagnosis.

Tandora · 03/11/2023 12:33

MrsSkylerWhite · 03/11/2023 11:45

ginandtonicwithlimes · Today 08:20

Here we go again ..
**
Having children via IVF will be just for the wealthy then”

I don’t understand this argument. If a couple can’t afford IVF, how will they afford to raise a child?

If someone can’t afford nicotine gum/vapes, etc., how can they afford cigarettes. There are probably lots of other such examples.

The NHS isn’t a bottomless pit.

Don’t be silly; there are all manner of people having babies who couldn’t afford IVF

Apollo14 · 03/11/2023 12:30

There is no doubt that facing challenges in becoming a parent can significantly impact mental health. As can many other life challenges. I tried to conceive for 13 years before adopting. I was on the waiting list for IVF and was offered it eventually but decided against it and went for the adoption route. I am also adopted which shaped my thinking.

I appreciate I am a product of my own experiences, as are we all. I have come to think that the NHS is too thinly spread and should be focusing on core issues. I don’t think any IVF should be funded by NHS. I don’t believe that anyone has a right to have a child and don’t view infertility as a medical problem that requires to be fixed.

Yes, if you want to have biological children and can’t, I accept that is life changing, but life is hard, and the state should not be responsible for trying to provide solutions to all problems. I accept that the NHS disagrees with this and does see Infertility through a medical lens. But patients who can’t have children are not unwell. It is a lifestyle choice.

I work in mental health and there are much worse things in life , than not being able to have children. I accept this is devastating for those impacted but it shouldn’t be for the state to solve.

ginandtonicwithlimes · 03/11/2023 12:30

Nopenopenopenopenopenope · 03/11/2023 12:23

Offering "treatment" for infertility as if it's an illness is bizarre to me. It's not an illness it's just tough luck.

It is a medical issue. You sound like a compassionate person. Let me guess I bet you concieved with no issues.

ginandtonicwithlimes · 03/11/2023 12:28

MrsSkylerWhite · 03/11/2023 11:45

ginandtonicwithlimes · Today 08:20

Here we go again ..
**
Having children via IVF will be just for the wealthy then”

I don’t understand this argument. If a couple can’t afford IVF, how will they afford to raise a child?

If someone can’t afford nicotine gum/vapes, etc., how can they afford cigarettes. There are probably lots of other such examples.

The NHS isn’t a bottomless pit.

Why are you even comparing nicotine and IVF? What a bizarre comparison.

Tandora · 03/11/2023 12:28

nutellacreppe · 03/11/2023 11:01

@FrustatedAgain Your stance appears to me to be:

If I am female and have a male partner who can't get me pregnant - NHS should fund IVF.
If I am female and have a female partner who can't get me pregnant - NHS should not fund IVF.

I understand that people have varying opinions on whether the NHS should or shouldn't fund IVF and there are arguments on both sides which are interesting and valid.

But I can't understand how your position above is not an inherently homophobic stance.

Absolutely. It is 100% homophobic.

SoftFire · 03/11/2023 12:27

nutellacreppe · 03/11/2023 12:20

Perhaps so, however, if you had been on the journey I have been on, you would know just how difficult it has been. Infertility is one of those things that is very hard to explain to someone who has not been through it, and very hard to understand until you have.

If your friends were not able to conceive via IVF, if the male factor issue was severe and it didn't work, they may well have decided to move onto using a donor.

Whether or not the NHS should help with funding that is certainly a debate - but it needs to be the same, regardless of whether the potential parents are in a same sex or heterosexual relationship.

I'm close enough to my friends to know they'd already decided against the donor route if ivf didn't work.

I agree 💯 that there needs to be equality between couples of same/different sexes and for exactly that reason, I don't think it should be available for anyone where it's not actually treating a person with fertility problems.

Because once it's provided free for same-sex female couples, there's an instant claim that same-sex male couples are being discriminated against, and before you know it, there will be surrogates and donor eggs provided on the NHS for male-male couples. And it will end up being vulnerable women who are exploited to provide this.

Having also been on the waiting list for eating disorder treatment for 5 years and counting, with an ED with a mortality rate of around 10 percent, I can't really get my head around the nhs paying for fertility treatment for people who don't have any fertility problems.

vivainsomnia · 03/11/2023 12:23

And at the end of the day, the NHS obviously agree, as they are reviewing the funding for same sex couples
That certainly doesn't mean they will make a change to the criteria. These criteria have been 'reviewed' every few years since IVF has-been funded over 20 tears ago. The policy has not changed much since. They will need to be legally challenged before they go based on gender discrimination.

Swipe left for the next trending thread