Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

TheBirdintheCave · 03/11/2023 14:49

@Kendodd I imagine that's cumulative. We had one failed round which cost £6k.

Surely2023IsTheYearForMyRainbowBaby · 03/11/2023 14:45

@BIossomtoes I likely never will have one, given my body has already rejected 5 pregnancies after years and years of trying to fall Pregnant.

Kendodd · 03/11/2023 14:43

Porridgeislife · 03/11/2023 10:20

Oh give over.

We spent a shade over £60k creating our IVF child. Given that the vast majority of people in the UK with a child wouldn’t have a spare £60k lying around, it’s a completely incorrect line trotted out by people who have never had to consider the reality of infertility.

Is that a normal about? So the NHS spends about £60k per women for her chance to become a mother?

nutellacreppe · 03/11/2023 14:25

The treatment is not offered to the woman who would carry the child but the other person's medical condition.

@vivainsomnia This is untrue. I am the main registered patient at my clinic, not my husband. I receive all communications in my name and they often forget to even copy him in, I have to remind them or forward things to him. They don't even see him or really seem to care if he's involved at all.

ginandtonicwithlimes · 03/11/2023 14:22

Ebtsaqt · 03/11/2023 13:59

I cant see why there would be more miscarriage from iui.?
yes ivf is more successful but it is because it removes male factor. But same sex and single people dont have that issue, and wha t i just read showed they are both pretty success ful with iui. Although surprisingly the same sex were more successful. (Wonder if th at is std in single women? Or maybe issues from previous pregnancies or abortions or the pill etc?)
Same sex women a re likely to be younger looking to conceive.
possibly 3-4 iui then moving onto ivf.

if ivf is so much more successful we need to tackle male.weight and health factors.a

i hadnt factored in the cost of the sperm donation.

.
A hetero couple.can go along reasonably thinking they with take maybe 6 months to conceive at 30 or a year at 35 etc. Have no prior knowledge of fertility issues.
A same sex female in a couple knows that it will cost and maybe unsuccessful involving ivf and iui. So may save up or try earlier. Time to save up.
A single woman knows fertility declines by 35. Should know clinics take time etc. Has had time to save.

i guess i see the same sex and single a bit like a woman leaving it to late 30s.

unintended consequences: if single women could go straight to paid for nhs ivf certainly a woman in a couple where the man is subfertile might choose to leave him and be more successful with donor ivf. Or those who are around 35 because it would avoid the 2years ttc....

i would probably consider lowering the age for nhs ivf. But ensure wait lists/time ttc was less ..

but long term we want to reduce the numbers of babies born this way (ivf).
ive had 3 general anasthetics. And 4 ovarian stimulations. Turned my ovaries off using the meds that delay puberty - which were shown not to be good for you.

Guess it is by day 5 clinics can tell what is a good looking embryo. Obviously it doesn't guarantee not having a miscarriage but might decrease the chance.

Chris002 · 03/11/2023 14:20

mugboat · 03/11/2023 13:55

I know 2 couples who went through the process very recently and they were told if they adopted siblings they would move up the list quicker... and it would take much longer for a single child.

1 couple chose to do just that for the very reason.

I also knew someone who did fostering and was accepted for adoption as a single woman in her 40's. This was about 15 years ago. So I don't know if this has changed recently or maybe it is dependant on where you live

OhmygodDont · 03/11/2023 14:16

I don’t think it should be on the nhs at all.

Sure get testing and a diagnosis but then it should be private paid if you require ivf, a blocked tube or such things should be treated to be fixed but ivf should be fully personally funded.

Tandora · 03/11/2023 14:15

vivainsomnia · 03/11/2023 14:12

It is absolutely 100% semantic, if you have two women with exactly the same factual problem
The treatment is not offered to the woman who would carry the child but the other person's medical condition.

The reason they are the main or only one getting the treatment is only because men can't currently bare a child. If they could, it would be the infertile man who would be eligible to receive the treatment, not his medically fit partner.

The treatment is not offered to the woman who would carry the child but the other person's medical condition.

that’s not true at all.
Are you following the conversation? We are discussing fertility treatments for couples where the man has azoospermia . It’s true Some forms of azoospermia can be treated with surgery, others can’t. Fertility treatment is still funded by nhs to enable the partner to get pregnant.

Voteva · 03/11/2023 14:14

The only people being given IVF on the NHS should be people with a significant medical problem with causes infertility. Not healthy lesbians, and not healthy single women. Doctors exist to treat medical problems.

I’m infertile and have serious damage to my ovaries (caused incidentally by incompetent NHS care) but the NHS won’t give me free IVF because I have a child. So it fucks me off to see women with no medical problems demanding free medical treatment.

kikisparks · 03/11/2023 14:13

FoodCentre · 03/11/2023 13:16

I think with IVF, how much of it is:

Infertility, in terms of a medical condition, something not working right...

And how much of it is lifestyle choices, like choosing to advance a career til 38. Choosing to travel and enjoy being a couple. Choosing to get a mortgage and have substantial savings first.

I don't really see how the latter is a medical issue, but hey. It's not really possible to discriminate against one group so it's all or nothing.

There are age limits on NHS funded IVF though. At my clinic it’s 3 rounds if you’re under 40, and one round if you’re 40-42. So if you didn’t start TTC until 38, by the time you hit the 2 years unprotected sex that the clinic required before you could go on the waiting list, you would only be entitled to one funded round.

vivainsomnia · 03/11/2023 14:12

It is absolutely 100% semantic, if you have two women with exactly the same factual problem
The treatment is not offered to the woman who would carry the child but the other person's medical condition.

The reason they are the main or only one getting the treatment is only because men can't currently bare a child. If they could, it would be the infertile man who would be eligible to receive the treatment, not his medically fit partner.

TripleDaisySummer · 03/11/2023 14:05

It already is. NHS treatments don’t provide the same medication and in many areas you get 1 cycle when most women need at least 3-4

DH cousin needed IVF - had to be IVF as his wife had no* *fallopian tubes - they got one shot on NHS after jumping though many humps and being in ideal age range late 20 both fit. Then they had to self fund - took several rounds and a lot of time to get their only child. They'd have loved another but couldn't afford the IVF fees.

IVF is already a very ration scare resource - I think wider boundaries will just mean less of it for all on NHS.

Tandora · 03/11/2023 14:03

vivainsomnia · 03/11/2023 13:27

ultimately these semantic distinctions rest on value laden assumptions about “how things were supposed to be” - the way god intended and all!
They are not semantic distinctions at all. Medical and biological IS different. It is true that sometimes, it's not totally black or white, that's why the NHS have ethical and legal bodies and processes to consider these.

There is also an economical consideration to treatment. Treatments especially of high values are considered for funding on the basis of costs vs benefits vs chance of success.

Weight list surgery is not funded because the patient wants to look slimmer but because the likely benefit (reduction in calorie intakes) means a reduction in likely need for further medical intervention in the future so meets the threshold for cost benefit.

It is absolutely 100% semantic, if you have two women with exactly the same factual problem: eg. Inability for my partner to produce sperm that gets me pregnant, for which the exact same treatment is required: eg, donor sperm + ivf, to fulfil the exact same desire/need : eg: to have a baby - and then you say, we’re funding you but not you, because yours is a “medical condition” and yours is a “biological condition”.

mugboat · 03/11/2023 13:59

Nopenopenopenopenopenope · 03/11/2023 12:23

Offering "treatment" for infertility as if it's an illness is bizarre to me. It's not an illness it's just tough luck.

endometriosis is an illness, having cancer is an illness (cancer patients have eggs removed before treatment), having blocks fallopian tubes is an illness etc etc.

Ebtsaqt · 03/11/2023 13:59

I cant see why there would be more miscarriage from iui.?
yes ivf is more successful but it is because it removes male factor. But same sex and single people dont have that issue, and wha t i just read showed they are both pretty success ful with iui. Although surprisingly the same sex were more successful. (Wonder if th at is std in single women? Or maybe issues from previous pregnancies or abortions or the pill etc?)
Same sex women a re likely to be younger looking to conceive.
possibly 3-4 iui then moving onto ivf.

if ivf is so much more successful we need to tackle male.weight and health factors.a

i hadnt factored in the cost of the sperm donation.

.
A hetero couple.can go along reasonably thinking they with take maybe 6 months to conceive at 30 or a year at 35 etc. Have no prior knowledge of fertility issues.
A same sex female in a couple knows that it will cost and maybe unsuccessful involving ivf and iui. So may save up or try earlier. Time to save up.
A single woman knows fertility declines by 35. Should know clinics take time etc. Has had time to save.

i guess i see the same sex and single a bit like a woman leaving it to late 30s.

unintended consequences: if single women could go straight to paid for nhs ivf certainly a woman in a couple where the man is subfertile might choose to leave him and be more successful with donor ivf. Or those who are around 35 because it would avoid the 2years ttc....

i would probably consider lowering the age for nhs ivf. But ensure wait lists/time ttc was less ..

but long term we want to reduce the numbers of babies born this way (ivf).
ive had 3 general anasthetics. And 4 ovarian stimulations. Turned my ovaries off using the meds that delay puberty - which were shown not to be good for you.

mugboat · 03/11/2023 13:55

theduchessofspork · 03/11/2023 11:03

You are out of date.

You do not need to adopt sibling groups. Some people do, many don’t. SS like siblings to stay together but know it’s often impossible.

There were about 60 under twos up for adoption in the North East last year.

More children are removed from their parents earlier than was the case a decade ago, mainly because children were being removed too late to be adopted and get a fresh start. Some children are removed at birth or soon after (usually because one or more siblings have already been removed).

Adopted children are always (rightly) classes as vulnerable, but children removed young would not normally be traumatised.

I know 2 couples who went through the process very recently and they were told if they adopted siblings they would move up the list quicker... and it would take much longer for a single child.

1 couple chose to do just that for the very reason.

ThereIbledit · 03/11/2023 13:52

Unpopular opinion especially on a parenting forum but we are so royally fucked as a species anyway that we really do no need to be facilitating more people to have more children "unnaturally" (by which I mean in circumstances where they wouldn't normally - i.e. if they aren't a woman sleeping with a man). I know that's going to offend plenty of people who have struggled with their fertility and ached for a child, and for that I'm sorry - I feel for your pain, I really, really do.

As a species we are a parasite and a fatal liability to this earth. We should not be having as many children as we are, already.

So no, we shouldn't be using the finite resources of the struggling NHS to facilitate more babies coming into the world in general.

Saz12 · 03/11/2023 13:39

But someone /couple who doesnt regularly introduce sperm to egg (single person not having regular sex, lesbian couple not using sperm donation, a male couple, etc) isnt going to fall pregnant due to biological fact, regardless of weather rheres anything medically wrong.

vivainsomnia · 03/11/2023 13:31

Single people and male/male couples are not able to demonstrate they are suffering from infertility and so don't get NHS treatment for it
They can to an extent. Sperm tests are quite cheap as are blood tests for women as a start.

vivainsomnia · 03/11/2023 13:27

ultimately these semantic distinctions rest on value laden assumptions about “how things were supposed to be” - the way god intended and all!
They are not semantic distinctions at all. Medical and biological IS different. It is true that sometimes, it's not totally black or white, that's why the NHS have ethical and legal bodies and processes to consider these.

There is also an economical consideration to treatment. Treatments especially of high values are considered for funding on the basis of costs vs benefits vs chance of success.

Weight list surgery is not funded because the patient wants to look slimmer but because the likely benefit (reduction in calorie intakes) means a reduction in likely need for further medical intervention in the future so meets the threshold for cost benefit.

calyrex · 03/11/2023 13:24

vivainsomnia · 03/11/2023 13:18

Why is one worthy of IVF and the other not?
Both are equally worthy, IVF isn't discriminatory but NHS is only funded for medical needs.

Many worthy procedures are not available on the NHS for that same reason.

But it is available on the NHS for same sex couples though.

namechanger563 · 03/11/2023 13:21

IVF on the NHS is to treat a medical condition - infertility. Female same sex couples have to jump through hoops to prove they are also suffering infertility, by self funding rounds of IUI with donated sperm.

Single people and male/male couples are not able to demonstrate they are suffering from infertility and so don't get NHS treatment for it.

Kestor654 · 03/11/2023 13:21

In terms to the question of the thread - if they allow fertility treatment for one group of people then they should allow it for all. Straight, gay, single. Everyone should be entitled to it.

WearingTheHardHat · 03/11/2023 13:21

VanityDiesHard · 03/11/2023 13:05

Having children is a privilege, not a right. If you are so traumatised that you cannot be in a relationship of any kind, then should you really be having children?

Okay, I'm one of these people. I was assaulted when I was 16, and I have never been able to have a relationship since (now 39). I've never had consensual sex. By containing my trauma by not getting into relationships I'm a perfectly happy and normal human being - nobody knows this is behind my life choices, not even my parents. They just think I'm asexual. I'm honestly perfectly 'normal'.

For around 15 years I have absolutely desperately wanted a child. I feel bereft that I can't have one. I earn £30k, live alone in the south east (where all my family are) so there's not a lot left after housing, and not enough to raise a child on without going onto benefits.

I've accepted I can't have one by IVF. Is it fair gay couples can get help when I can't? I don't think it's fair that it's uneven, but life isn't fair, and where is the line? I say I've accepted it - to be honest, it's still fucking hard. And I really worry in a couple of years when I am literally infertile and the option is 100% gone, how I'll feel.

Any judgement about single parents I think really isn't ethical - around a third of marriages fail, more failures in unmarried couples - there's too many other factors that impact whether a family can be stable or not. And financially, plenty of people get pregnant knowing they'll need to receive benefits. What's the difference?

Really, there are no easy answers. Anyone putting a one-line opinion isn't really looking at the whole picture.

vivainsomnia · 03/11/2023 13:18

Why is one worthy of IVF and the other not?
Both are equally worthy, IVF isn't discriminatory but NHS is only funded for medical needs.

Many worthy procedures are not available on the NHS for that same reason.