Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Simonjt · 04/11/2023 06:41

Where we live fertility treatment has been funded for gay women since 2005 and single women since 2016. Some people still choose to go elsewhere and pay (where it is cheaper than paying here) to reduce wait times. It should be funded or not, you either think women should be able to access funded IVF or they shouldn’t, we wouldn’t treat women of different religions or ethnicities differently, so we shouldn’t treat or not treat women according to their sexuality.

CurlewKate · 04/11/2023 05:50

I actually think it's a "I wouldn't start from here" issue. I'm not convinced that fertility treatment should be available on the NHS at all. But since it is, it should,of course, be available to everyone.

ginandtonicwithlimes · 04/11/2023 05:40

Papyrophile · 03/11/2023 21:19

I really don't care how you get pregnant whatever your sexual prefences. As a tax payer, I do care, a lot, about how you plan to fund and support the child you have to being a competent adult.

My husband lost his job three months after I got pregnant. It doesn't always go to plan!

Sayitaintso33 · 04/11/2023 05:23

I think single women should have the same access to IVF as women in relationships.

ginandtonicwithlimes · 04/11/2023 05:11

Cattenberg · 03/11/2023 20:32

Yes. Donor sperm from a licensed clinic can easily cost over £1,000 for one tiny “straw”, and you can’t use one straw for more than one treatment cycle.

I do think IUI has fewer health risks for mums and babies than IVF, but due to the greed of private fertility clinics, many women can’t afford to try IUI first.

What is the health risk for babies with IVF? Personally I wouldn't bother with IUI and go straight to IVF. Better success rates.

Moreempatheticmyarse · 03/11/2023 22:31

Euridicefortuna · 03/11/2023 21:32

Same sex couples do get IVF on the NHS when there are no fertility issues.My friends have 2 children via this method. They wouldn't know of any issues as they haven't had sex with a man so have never tried to conceive naturally.

They wouldn't know of any issues as they haven't had sex with a man so have never tried to conceive naturally.

That's a pretty large assumption. I knew I would have issues since I was about 16. My friend with endo knew she would have issues since she was mid 20s. Another friend knows she cant have children due to childhood cancer. Having sex with a man isn't a prerequisite to knowing you have a condition that causes fertility issues.

Euridicefortuna · 03/11/2023 21:32

KimberleyClark · 03/11/2023 08:32

Same sex couples don’t get IVF on the NHS just because they are same sex. One of them has to have a fertility problem, just like with mixed sex couples.

Edited

Same sex couples do get IVF on the NHS when there are no fertility issues.My friends have 2 children via this method. They wouldn't know of any issues as they haven't had sex with a man so have never tried to conceive naturally.

Orae · 03/11/2023 21:31

as a same sex couple, we don’t qualify for any NHS funded treatments. If that makes you feel better. It’s a postcode lottery.

It should be either entirely funded or not at all - for everybody. single, same sex or hetro shouldn’t make a difference.

TempestTost · 03/11/2023 21:28

I think if the NHS will fund treatment for lesbian women who are actually having fertility issues (as opposed to just failing to conceive because two women can't do so) then it would also be reasonable to do the same for a single women who had actual fertility issues.

My understanding is that would require paying privately to try and get pregnant first.

As it happens, I don't think the NHS should provide these treatments for anyone. I don't think that socialized medical models are going to be able to continue to offer that kind of unnecessary service if they are going to remain viable.

Papyrophile · 03/11/2023 21:19

I really don't care how you get pregnant whatever your sexual prefences. As a tax payer, I do care, a lot, about how you plan to fund and support the child you have to being a competent adult.

Horriblewoman · 03/11/2023 21:19

Nopenopenopenopenopenope · 03/11/2023 12:23

Offering "treatment" for infertility as if it's an illness is bizarre to me. It's not an illness it's just tough luck.

Do you have children?

Cattenberg · 03/11/2023 20:32

limefrog · 03/11/2023 16:59

Chances of IUI (artificial insemination) working are about 8-10% each go, even for fertile women. Not very widely known until you are going through it.
IVF is much more successful.
Many women will try a few rounds of IUI and then go onto IVF. Some go straight to IVF and it can ultimately be cheaper to have one or two rounds of IVF than 8-10 rounds of IUI.

Yes. Donor sperm from a licensed clinic can easily cost over £1,000 for one tiny “straw”, and you can’t use one straw for more than one treatment cycle.

I do think IUI has fewer health risks for mums and babies than IVF, but due to the greed of private fertility clinics, many women can’t afford to try IUI first.

ginandtonicwithlimes · 03/11/2023 20:11

People do realise that the NHS doesn't just give funding for IVF willy nilly? I was entitled to a third cycle but only if the panel decided the chances of success were good enough. Funny how IVF is always mooted as the one to cut funding for.

Valeriekat · 03/11/2023 18:35

IVF shouldn't be available on the NHS at all when people are unable to access life saving tratments.

mugboat · 03/11/2023 17:03

OhmygodDont · 03/11/2023 14:16

I don’t think it should be on the nhs at all.

Sure get testing and a diagnosis but then it should be private paid if you require ivf, a blocked tube or such things should be treated to be fixed but ivf should be fully personally funded.

you can't fix a blocked/broken fallopian tube... and you can't replace removed fallopian tubes.

I had a fallopian tube removed following an ectopic pregnancy. The ectopic pregnancy was my first pregnancy.

Porridgeislife · 03/11/2023 17:03

Saz12 · 03/11/2023 16:53

Im going to ask a very crass question - revealing my ignorance. BUT - why would a member of a lesbian couple without medical issues not be able to be impregnated with doner sperm directly - ie not ivf, just a medical turkey-baster type scenario?
There cant be THAT many lesbian couples where both women have fertility issues significant enough to need ivf, so would it not be a better use of money just to get on with it rather than employ committes to discuss it...?

One reason is that same sex couples want to mix their genetics by having one woman supply and egg and the other carry the pregnancy so her epigenetics influences the embryo. Hence the relative attraction of IVF.

IUI also has a fairly low success rate compared to IVF.

limefrog · 03/11/2023 16:59

Saz12 · 03/11/2023 16:53

Im going to ask a very crass question - revealing my ignorance. BUT - why would a member of a lesbian couple without medical issues not be able to be impregnated with doner sperm directly - ie not ivf, just a medical turkey-baster type scenario?
There cant be THAT many lesbian couples where both women have fertility issues significant enough to need ivf, so would it not be a better use of money just to get on with it rather than employ committes to discuss it...?

Chances of IUI (artificial insemination) working are about 8-10% each go, even for fertile women. Not very widely known until you are going through it.
IVF is much more successful.
Many women will try a few rounds of IUI and then go onto IVF. Some go straight to IVF and it can ultimately be cheaper to have one or two rounds of IVF than 8-10 rounds of IUI.

Saz12 · 03/11/2023 16:53

Im going to ask a very crass question - revealing my ignorance. BUT - why would a member of a lesbian couple without medical issues not be able to be impregnated with doner sperm directly - ie not ivf, just a medical turkey-baster type scenario?
There cant be THAT many lesbian couples where both women have fertility issues significant enough to need ivf, so would it not be a better use of money just to get on with it rather than employ committes to discuss it...?

rocknrollaa · 03/11/2023 16:35

If anything, the NHS might decide to stop funding couples who fall in that category.

@vivainsomnia There's no indication that the NHS are considering stopping funding couples who falling to that category.

On the contrary, the article linked says that the NHS are increasing funding for same sex couples because they agree with the position you are arguing against - because not to do so is discriminatory against same sex couples.

MargotBamborough · 03/11/2023 15:29

Moreempatheticmyarse · 03/11/2023 15:21

I was basing that on the fact that some pharmacies were about to sell them at a significantly lower price, meaning they were available at a lower price than the price the private clinics charges the patient

I would be very suprised if the NHS was buying them in at the cost point the private clinic was selling them out at

That said my IVF was quite some years ago now and looking at clinic costs they appear to be suggesting average medication costs a lot lower than they were at the time so the price point may be more similar whether private or NHS nowadays

I used to do government procurement, but not in the health sector, and sometimes they really do not get good prices despite their purchasing power.

Imagine it like this. A pharmacy sells about 20 boxes of paracetamol per day so they need 600 boxes per month. If you're buying paracetamol wholesale but in relatively small quantities you just buy it from whichever supplier offers the best price. Whereas the NHS needs paracetamol in quantities no supplier will be able to offer without a dedicated long term contract, so they will have to go out to tender, and only suppliers who are capable of procuring such huge quantities of paracetamol will be able to bid, and they will all know more or less how much their competitors will be charging, so they can hike their prices up knowing that the NHS can't just tell them to go fuck themselves and buy paracetamol from wherever the little pharmacy is getting it.

So the little pharmacy, and potentially the consumer, might be getting paracetamol cheaper than the NHS gets it, despite the NHS having greater buying power.

Baconisdelicious · 03/11/2023 15:26

single parent families aren’t something to aim for

far better a child is brought up by a single parent who has had to give serious thought to her situation prior to even getting pregnant than the average just bumbling along in life, having children because that’s what couples do, surely?

or are you one of those who just can’t cope when single mums manage perfectly well without swinging a man on their arm?

Moreempatheticmyarse · 03/11/2023 15:21

MargotBamborough · 03/11/2023 15:17

I'm not sure it's necessarily true that the NHS gets drugs more cheaply than individual consumers.

Obviously most drugs are prescription only so there isn't much overlap. But for drugs which can be purchased privately or supplied by the NHS, the NHS will pay whatever price it has managed to negotiate in its drug procurement, which may not be the best price.

I was basing that on the fact that some pharmacies were about to sell them at a significantly lower price, meaning they were available at a lower price than the price the private clinics charges the patient

I would be very suprised if the NHS was buying them in at the cost point the private clinic was selling them out at

That said my IVF was quite some years ago now and looking at clinic costs they appear to be suggesting average medication costs a lot lower than they were at the time so the price point may be more similar whether private or NHS nowadays

MargotBamborough · 03/11/2023 15:17

Moreempatheticmyarse · 03/11/2023 15:13

No it wouldn't be 60k

The NHS doesn't fund IVF until a woman gets pregnant. They fund so many rounds, this is the postcode lottery part - it might be 1, 2 or 3 rounds depending on various factors. So they don't keep going and going

The private clinics charge an absolute fortune for the drugs. I remember at one point one of the supermarket pharmacies was offering them more or less at cost for women going through IVF and the cost was 100s rather than 1000s so the NHS will get these drugs at a significantly cheaper cost than the private clinics charge patients for them. And not every patient will need the drugs or the full range of them.

60k generally represents more rounds of IVF than the NHS is ever going to offer currently

I'm not sure it's necessarily true that the NHS gets drugs more cheaply than individual consumers.

Obviously most drugs are prescription only so there isn't much overlap. But for drugs which can be purchased privately or supplied by the NHS, the NHS will pay whatever price it has managed to negotiate in its drug procurement, which may not be the best price.

Moreempatheticmyarse · 03/11/2023 15:13

Kendodd · 03/11/2023 14:43

Is that a normal about? So the NHS spends about £60k per women for her chance to become a mother?

No it wouldn't be 60k

The NHS doesn't fund IVF until a woman gets pregnant. They fund so many rounds, this is the postcode lottery part - it might be 1, 2 or 3 rounds depending on various factors. So they don't keep going and going

The private clinics charge an absolute fortune for the drugs. I remember at one point one of the supermarket pharmacies was offering them more or less at cost for women going through IVF and the cost was 100s rather than 1000s so the NHS will get these drugs at a significantly cheaper cost than the private clinics charge patients for them. And not every patient will need the drugs or the full range of them.

60k generally represents more rounds of IVF than the NHS is ever going to offer currently

vivainsomnia · 03/11/2023 14:54

Fertility treatment is still funded by nhs to enable the partner to get pregnant
Most men with infertility are entitled to ICSI. When ICSI isn't even an option, which is now the exception rather than the norm, donor sperm is available. This is indeed questionable that it should be so. If anything, the NHS might decide to stop funding couples who fall in that category.

But again, it's not funded for the healthy person but the one with the issue. Again, it's the woman who has to go through the treatment because biologically only she can carry a child, but it's not for HER benefit.

I am the main registered patient at my clinic, not my husband
That's totally irrelevant to the reason why treatment is funded. It is funded because of your partner's condition. That's what triggers eligibility.

It's really not that hard to understand!

Swipe left for the next trending thread