Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

sollenwir · 03/11/2023 08:49

YABVU.
IVF is a wonderful technology, but it is expensive and stressful and the NHS has to limit who they are willing to provide it to.
In an ideal world I would like to see free IVF being completely abolished, but it being offered at a subsidised rate to more people (couples, regardless of gender, and single people who could love and care for a child as well as any couple).
I accept that many won't agree with this, and also accept that free IVF has allowed some couples to have a child they wouldn't otherwise have had.

GoBackRewind · 03/11/2023 08:49

I think IVF should be for couples who can use their own eggs and sperm. I don’t agree with egg/sperm donation, it’s not in the interests of the child.

However, we allow egg and sperm donation, then it makes no sense to me why single women can’t get treatment.

Overthebow · 03/11/2023 08:45

It is a bit unfair, but the NHS is very stretched and this really isn’t a priority. I’d rather the money was spent on life threatening problems. Maybe once it is in a better state with better funding things like this can be revisited.

RoomOfRequirement · 03/11/2023 08:43

Why would it possibly be funded? They're not saying you can't have IVF, just that the HEALTH service won't give it to you for free because it's in no way a health problem?

babybirdsmomma · 03/11/2023 08:42

CalistoNoSolo · 03/11/2023 08:12

I don't think the nhs should be funding any ivf treatments for anyone.

Bit of a sweeping statement ! Why's that then ?

JustAMinutePleass · 03/11/2023 08:39

Bobsleigh334 · 03/11/2023 08:34

The NHS funds lots of things that aren’t life threatening. Not treating them can cause more cost further down the line.

Yes. NHS was interested in my periods being painful and heavy as a 10 year old - GP used to even cancel my appointments last minute as ‘not urgent’ but that was the time when my being put on the pill and thyroxine might have prevented damage to my ovaries and womb. PCOS and Hashimotos has destroyed my ovaries, my womb (lining is too thick) and my entire hormone profile to the point where thyroxine isn’t enough. I need steroids and aspirin and heparine just to conceive.

HoHoHoliday · 03/11/2023 08:37

I agree with you OP, it is very unfair.
I have fertility problems, I would be unable to conceive without medical intervention. But because I am single I do not qualify for any NHS treatment. If I picked up a random stranger man off the street I would qualify. It's ridiculously unfair.

Shelaydownunderthetable · 03/11/2023 08:36

Sadly the NHS is rife with inequality when it comes to IVF and fertility treatment - not just for heterosexual couples/same-sex couples/single people but in terms of location and the postcode lottery.

Seeing some comments here about who should and shouldn’t be entitled... Why should heterosexual couples with fertility problems be entitled to it on the NHS, but not same-sex couples? What’s the difference? Ultimately it’s two people wanting to have children with bodies who can’t achieve it.

I say this as someone with skin in the game when it comes to fertility treatment - I feel like the NHS has bigger fish to fry at the moment, unfortunately… but I’ve read that as a population, we need more people, not less, to care for an aging population so funding fertility treatment might be one way to help towards that.

CateB78 · 03/11/2023 08:36

KimberleyClark · 03/11/2023 08:32

Same sex couples don’t get IVF on the NHS just because they are same sex. One of them has to have a fertility problem, just like with mixed sex couples.

Edited

Yeah but the article says the government has committed to fund the treatment they need to prove infertility. But single women still have to pay.

OP posts:
ginandtonicwithlimes · 03/11/2023 08:35

Heyhoherewegoagain · 03/11/2023 08:32

I agree with this. Whilst it’s very distressing if you’re affected by infertility, amd I’m not minimising the psychological effects, it’s not life threatening. The nhs was never really meant for things like this, but when it was set up no one could foresee the advances which were to come in fertility issues.

I don’t care if you’re heterosexual, homosexual, pansexual, bisexual (with genuine apologies if I haven’t covered anything), having a child is not a right

Edited

It is a medical issue. Common issues for women who struggle to conceive are PCOS which can increase your risk of diabetes and endometriosis which can make everyday life horrible. NHS treats medical issues and I don't see why IVF shouldn't be offered in order to overcome those issues. Yes I am aware it isn't life threatening but the resulting mental health issues could be with suicidal thoughts etc maybe even suicide.

Giveuprobot · 03/11/2023 08:35

AgnesX · 03/11/2023 08:08

No. Have you read some of the threads here on how difficult it is to be a single parent. It's not something that should be offered by the NHS.

Have you read some of the threads on here on how difficult it is to be a married parent?

CuriousGeorge80 · 03/11/2023 08:35

If it makes you feel better OP, many lesbian couples can’t get it on the NHS either. We live in Hertfordshire and I have many lesbian friends with children - not a single one via NHS because either (a) the policy of the local NHS trust doesn’t actually allow it; or (b) the doctors insist that the women must have been actively trying for two years even though they can’t, so again they can’t get it. In my experience, based on where we live, it’s a myth that lesbian couples can get NHS funded IVF.

Bobsleigh334 · 03/11/2023 08:34

The NHS funds lots of things that aren’t life threatening. Not treating them can cause more cost further down the line.

user1478172746 · 03/11/2023 08:34

Children should have a village, not just a couple as parents in ideal world. Burned out parents hedding for divorce is not better for child as a single mother with strong support network.

JustAMinutePleass · 03/11/2023 08:33

ginandtonicwithlimes · 03/11/2023 08:20

Here we go again ..

Having children via IVF will be just for the wealthy then.

It already is. NHS treatments don’t provide the same medication and in many areas you get 1 cycle when most women need at least 3-4 which means it only tends to work when it’s the male who’s the one with fertility problems (my consultant has even written to the NHS saying the current system discriminates against women with fertility problems and also women over the age of 25 who might require multiple cycles).

If the NHS stopped funding free cycles and just offered discounts to everyone like the Netherlands does or totally privitise but allow centres to provide higher doses to make treatment more likely to work (like India) it would make ivf a much more achievable prospect for everyone.

KimberleyClark · 03/11/2023 08:32

Same sex couples don’t get IVF on the NHS just because they are same sex. One of them has to have a fertility problem, just like with mixed sex couples.

Heyhoherewegoagain · 03/11/2023 08:32

CalistoNoSolo · 03/11/2023 08:12

I don't think the nhs should be funding any ivf treatments for anyone.

I agree with this. Whilst it’s very distressing if you’re affected by infertility, amd I’m not minimising the psychological effects, it’s not life threatening. The nhs was never really meant for things like this, but when it was set up no one could foresee the advances which were to come in fertility issues.

I don’t care if you’re heterosexual, homosexual, pansexual, bisexual (with genuine apologies if I haven’t covered anything), having a child is not a right

user1478172746 · 03/11/2023 08:31

Shocking. Of course it's discriminatory and single mother's bashing. Maybe portion of social problems stems from the constant message that they and their children are not "preferable". Single parent's houshold is bad by definition - very ostracizing. Government is saying what type of families citizens should have. So much for diversity.

NugatoryMatters · 03/11/2023 08:30

This is such nonsense.

If you are single, want a baby and don’t fancy paying for fertility treatment, the answer is to find a man who wants to conceive a child with you.

’i want to stay single and have the taxpayer fund fertility treatment so i can have a baby’ is a really clear statement about the levels of selfish individualism we’ve reached.

And to start shouting about how it’s
discrimination is ridiculous.

There is nothing discriminatory about telling straight, single women that they need to try having a baby by having regular unprotected sex with a man before the NHS will consider treating an actual fertility issue.

Any provision made for women in same-sex relationships is a totally separate matter for debate.

There’s something really worrying about the current trend to try to position straight people/male people/white people as the most victimised of all.

CateB78 · 03/11/2023 08:27

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 03/11/2023 08:01

I'm not sure. I don't think it's reasonable to discriminate against women just because they're single, but I wonder if it's ultimately about the rights of the child rather than the prospective parents(s)?

Does a child have a right to two parents? (Obviously, some kids will lose a parent due to bereavement, abandonment etc, but in most cases, the starting point is two parents, even if they aren't both listed on the birth certificate.)

I'd need to see more detail regarding the arguments on both sides before I could come down firmly on one side or another.

I was moved by storied of the women in the video. One spent her savings, the other went into debt...

OP posts:
Teentaxidriver · 03/11/2023 08:25

So true Orangegato.

CateB78 · 03/11/2023 08:23

Hoardasurass · 03/11/2023 08:10

Ofcourse it's not discrimination. Lesbian couples have to go through a process of iui at their own cost to prove that they are infertile before they can infertile on the NHS.
A single woman who isn't having unprotected sex is not infertile and therefore doesn't need infertility treatment and as such should not be allowed to get it on the NHS

Yeah but the article says the government will fund IUI for them and not for single women if you read it.

OP posts:
ginandtonicwithlimes · 03/11/2023 08:20

CalistoNoSolo · 03/11/2023 08:12

I don't think the nhs should be funding any ivf treatments for anyone.

Here we go again ..

Having children via IVF will be just for the wealthy then.

Toddlerteaplease · 03/11/2023 08:18

I don't think same sex couples should get it free either. It should only be for couples with fertility issues.

Fernsfernsferns · 03/11/2023 08:16

@CateB78

yes. At least for fertility treatment (doesn’t have to be IVF).

The original NHS approach was treatment for couples with a medical difficulty conceiving.

that was extended to same sex couples who may well be able to conceive naturally but of course don’t want to have heterosexual sex to do so.

so the same should be offered to single women on the same basis. Want a child, don’t want to have sex with someone you are not in a sexual relationship with to do so.

disagree on the single parents are bad point.

Many men are awful parents. Read about their neglect and abuse on here constantly.

better a baby by choice and no rubbish man in the background messing up the mother and her kids with his behaviour.

though if I was going down this road I’d consider finding a parenting partner to do it with (eg I have some close gay friends, though the one I’d have willingly parented with didn’t want kids).

Swipe left for the next trending thread