Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

VanityDiesHard · 03/11/2023 10:14

No, because single parent families are a bad thing, broadly speaking. I'm not knocking those who are in that situation through no fault of their own, but it absolutely shouldn't be something to aspire to. If you can't afford IVF, you can't afford a child (I actually don't think IVF should be funded by the NHS at all, so there's that)

nutellacreppe · 03/11/2023 10:13

FrustatedAgain · 03/11/2023 10:12

I believe IVF should only be available on the NHS to those who have a medical issue preventing them getting pregnant. Not having a partner, or not having a partner equipped to get you pregnant is not an medical issue in my opinion. It is just not how people get pregnant, pregnancy requires a man and sperm, choosing not to have that present is not a medical issue regardless of your sexuality or relationship status.

If someone without a medical need chooses to acquire some sperm and pay for their IVF that is their choice and absolutely fine. I just don't believe the NHS should fund it.

Edited

'Not having a partner equipped to get you pregnant'

... So if a man has a medical issue that prevents him getting a woman pregnant, should he and his wife be entitled to fertility treatment?

Halllooo · 03/11/2023 10:13

But okay for the straights?
For what it’s worth I don’t know ANY same-sex couples who got IVF on the NHS apart from one couple who were able to prove that there were fertility issues with the woman who would be carrying the child because of cancer treatment she’d had.

FrustatedAgain · 03/11/2023 10:12

I believe IVF should only be available on the NHS to those who have a medical issue preventing them getting pregnant. Not having a partner, or not having a partner equipped to get you pregnant is not an medical issue in my opinion. It is just not how people get pregnant, pregnancy requires a man and sperm, choosing not to have that present is not a medical issue regardless of your sexuality or relationship status.

If someone without a medical need chooses to acquire some sperm and pay for their IVF that is their choice and absolutely fine. I just don't believe the NHS should fund it.

Chris002 · 03/11/2023 10:11

Fernsfernsferns · 03/11/2023 08:16

@CateB78

yes. At least for fertility treatment (doesn’t have to be IVF).

The original NHS approach was treatment for couples with a medical difficulty conceiving.

that was extended to same sex couples who may well be able to conceive naturally but of course don’t want to have heterosexual sex to do so.

so the same should be offered to single women on the same basis. Want a child, don’t want to have sex with someone you are not in a sexual relationship with to do so.

disagree on the single parents are bad point.

Many men are awful parents. Read about their neglect and abuse on here constantly.

better a baby by choice and no rubbish man in the background messing up the mother and her kids with his behaviour.

though if I was going down this road I’d consider finding a parenting partner to do it with (eg I have some close gay friends, though the one I’d have willingly parented with didn’t want kids).

" no rubbish man in the background messing up the mother and her kids with his behaviour"
You might go through ivf at the expense of the tax payers on the NHS and give birth to a little boy ! Would you be disappointed then ?

NugatoryMatters · 03/11/2023 10:11

All this whataboutery is infuriating.

This isn’t abortion or immunisation or knee replacements or whatever.

It’s ’should the state fund fertility treatment for people who simply just don’t want to have sex?’

It is not discrimination to decide that the state simply should not.

It doesn’t matter whether the NHS funds completely different stuff or whether it’s life threatening or whatever. That’s all a distraction.

Scalottia · 03/11/2023 10:10

@Londonscallingme I would say a hip replacement is more of a medical need than having a child!

Having kids is a want, not a need.

LiquoriceAllsorts2 · 03/11/2023 10:09

SunnieShine · 03/11/2023 07:55

Do you also think it's unfair that mixed sex couples can get IVF but single women can't? Why just say same sex couples?

I think there is a difference to be fair. With a mixed sex couple they need ivf due to fertility issues with a single woman or same sex couple they don’t necessarily need ivf due to fertility issues but because they are lacking the sperm and need a donation.

kikisparks · 03/11/2023 10:08

unofpr · 03/11/2023 09:53

@CateB78 it is offered where there is a medical problem. Being blunt, a single woman could, with no medical issues, get pregnant by a one night stand if she was happy to be a single parent. And really, that’s not much different to IVF, is it, but it’s free?

Well it’s hugely different. Firstly she’d need to have a number of one night stands either each month around the time of ovulation or every 2-3 days and would have to find someone willing to not use protection each time. She would be opened up to the risk of STDs (including some which may be life threatening and/ or pass on to her child) or even potential violence or sexual violence at the hands of these men she does not know. The man she conceived with would, if they found out about the child, have the possibility of asserting parental rights. Plus she’d potentially be having sex she did not want and why should any woman have to do that?

By contrast with IUI she’d be safely using a screened donor in a controlled medical setting, fully consenting to the process and at a far far lower risk to her health. Her child could, if a UK donor was used, contact them at 18 but the donor would not be able to come into her child’s life before that and try and take an active parenting role.

I’m not a single parent by choice and I’m not 100% sure how I feel about donor conception as far as the rights of the child go but I can fully understand why women don’t want to just have lots of unprotected sex with strange men.

LuluBlakey1 · 03/11/2023 10:08

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 03/11/2023 08:01

I'm not sure. I don't think it's reasonable to discriminate against women just because they're single, but I wonder if it's ultimately about the rights of the child rather than the prospective parents(s)?

Does a child have a right to two parents? (Obviously, some kids will lose a parent due to bereavement, abandonment etc, but in most cases, the starting point is two parents, even if they aren't both listed on the birth certificate.)

I'd need to see more detail regarding the arguments on both sides before I could come down firmly on one side or another.

Children conceived by IVF have two parents - how is it different to a child who never knows their father for whatever reason. A single woman choosing IVF has really wanted that child.

I have, what is no doubt, a very unpopular opinion on all of this which is IVF should not be available on the NHS. It's another example of the sense of 'entitlement' that exists across our society. Having your own child isn't a right. There are many children who need homes but remain unwanted in care.

Londonscallingme · 03/11/2023 10:07

AlmostAJillSandwich · 03/11/2023 08:52

Nobody should get IVF on the NHS. Having a child isn't a right, or a medical need, it is a want/desire, it's not life threatening physically to be infertile. If conception cannot be achieved without intervention and it's something you desperately want, you save up for the treatment.
I'm mid 30's and childless with PCOS, so i'm not unsympathetic to fertility struggles, but the NHS isn't in a state to be paying for none essential treatments when there's people dying of treatable conditions due to lack of funding.

on the flip side though - we do loads of things on the NHS which would be categorised in a similar way. Knee replacements or hip replacements, for example. Not life threatening just a preference to be able to walk further with no discomfort. I’m not arguing as I don’t have a settled view on this (more exploring your argument) but do you think your argument still stands when we consider the other things we find on the nhs?

Tandora · 03/11/2023 10:06

Tandora · 03/11/2023 10:04

Should the nhs fund abortions in cases where there is no medical justification (eg danger to health/ life of mother or foetus?)

Edited

What about contraception?

Papyrophile · 03/11/2023 10:06

Like a few other posters, I don't think the NHS should be doing IVF at all.

SunshineAfterStorms · 03/11/2023 10:06

I interpreted the post differently.
Same sex couples and single women presumably have the same issue - no male to fertilise the egg. So, if same sex couples need assistance to conceive, why shouldn't single women have that same assistance?
I’m guessing the OP didnt think through that actually hetero couples may also have exactly the same issue if the man is sterile.

Thsts how I interpreted it too I presumed OP hadn’t thought about straight couples sometimes using donors. That’s why I agreed with a pp that I only think IVF should be available to couples who can use their own eggs and sperm.

nutellacreppe · 03/11/2023 10:06

CateB78 · 03/11/2023 10:00

The article says the government has committed to funding IUI for them.

Ah I see - I've read the article now.

So previously, it was the same rule for single women and same sex couples - they had to pay for private IUI to prove infertility.

Now, the government have committed to improving funding for same sex couples to access NHS treatment, but they haven't done the same for single women.

Just to be clear that this is the problem - they have improved things for same sex couples but not for single women.

I'd say it's a step in the right direction and to be honest if funding only allows one or the other of these to have access to better funding, same sex couples should take priority because a couple is (as a general rule) going to be in a better position to raise a child than a single woman - not saying in all cases before I get jumped on - but statistically - and that is all you can go by when making these decisions.

I do hope in the future that everyone who wants/ needs fertility treatment will have access to it, but I'm assuming that this is a decision based on funding constraints.

NugatoryMatters · 03/11/2023 10:06

Soontobe60 · 03/11/2023 10:00

I wouldnt be at all surprised if it becomes a race to the bottom - if any unfairness is proven between different groups, then the funding for all groups will just be removed.
Once upon a time it used to be possible to have lots of minor procedures carried out under the NHS such as removal of warts / verruccas, removal of visible non cancerous moles, and other such things. Whilst not life threatening in any way, they can be debilitating. Now none of this is available on the NHS. For many people, they cant even get basic NHS dental treatment any more!
So, equal treatment may well be the withdrawal of ALL NHS funded IVF treatment for anyone.

It’s all a bit ‘and this is why we can’t have nice things’, isn’t it?

Or we could just be absolutely open in rejecting claims that(otherwise) heterosexual people who just don’t want to have sex are an oppressed group subject to awful discrimination

Tandora · 03/11/2023 10:04

OnlyFoolsnMothers · 03/11/2023 09:53

Because there isn’t a medical issue related- it’s a biological fact you can’t reproduce a male and male/ female and female - and a child isn’t a right

Should the nhs fund abortions in cases where there is no medical justification (eg danger to health/ life of mother or foetus?)

Soontobe60 · 03/11/2023 10:00

kikisparks · 03/11/2023 09:49

YANBU. However women in same sex couples have had to campaign for a long time win this right to funded IUI so unfortunately probably a similar campaign for single women will need to be pursued to get equal treatment for them.

I wouldnt be at all surprised if it becomes a race to the bottom - if any unfairness is proven between different groups, then the funding for all groups will just be removed.
Once upon a time it used to be possible to have lots of minor procedures carried out under the NHS such as removal of warts / verruccas, removal of visible non cancerous moles, and other such things. Whilst not life threatening in any way, they can be debilitating. Now none of this is available on the NHS. For many people, they cant even get basic NHS dental treatment any more!
So, equal treatment may well be the withdrawal of ALL NHS funded IVF treatment for anyone.

CateB78 · 03/11/2023 10:00

nutellacreppe · 03/11/2023 09:59

Same sex couples can only get IVF on the NHS if they are infertile and have been through 12 privately funded rounds of IUI (in most areas - it is a bit of a postcode lottery). They have to have fertility problems, just like same sex couples. They don't just automatically get it.

The article says the government has committed to funding IUI for them.

OP posts:
Topofthemountain · 03/11/2023 10:00

This is the second report in days about access to IVF, yesterday it was a Stonewall report on asexual couples wanting funded IVF and it was discriminatory to not do so. Today it is single people.

A mere coincidence maybe.

nutellacreppe · 03/11/2023 09:59

Same sex couples can only get IVF on the NHS if they are infertile and have been through 12 privately funded rounds of IUI (in most areas - it is a bit of a postcode lottery). They have to have fertility problems, just like same sex couples. They don't just automatically get it.

NugatoryMatters · 03/11/2023 09:56

There is a big difference between couples and single people.

It’s not discrimination to decide that single people aren’t eligible for NHS IVF.

I am a single person. I recognise that, should I fancy trying to get pregnant, continuing to be single will impact upon my ability to conceive and I should have to pay for any treatment I require to compensate for that choice. Even if IUI fails repeatedly and I decide I want IVF, I should just have to pay for it.

There are loads of things I might like -
even desperately want - but I can’t afford them. That, unfortunately, is life.

PoisonJuicy · 03/11/2023 09:55

YANBU.

Soontobe60 · 03/11/2023 09:54

Vistada · 03/11/2023 09:49

this is the crux of it.

Oh dear OP, its shit when you inadvertently let your homophobia show isnt it.

I interpreted the post differently.
Same sex couples and single women presumably have the same issue - no male to fertilise the egg. So, if same sex couples need assistance to conceive, why shouldn't single women have that same assistance?
I’m guessing the OP didnt think through that actually hetero couples may also have exactly the same issue if the man is sterile.

OnlyFoolsnMothers · 03/11/2023 09:53

Tandora · 03/11/2023 09:43

Why?

Because there isn’t a medical issue related- it’s a biological fact you can’t reproduce a male and male/ female and female - and a child isn’t a right

Swipe left for the next trending thread