Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Jk987 · 05/11/2023 19:57

Mumeries · 04/11/2023 16:23

I think disabled autistic women who struggle to make friendships or have relationships should be entitled to free fertility treatment/sperm banks

Great start for the child. They'll have to deal with no father while Mum has no friends and can't forge relationships. So they'll be no one else who loves and cares for the child no support network whatsoever. Great.

sunnydayhereandnow · 05/11/2023 17:50

TempestTost · 04/11/2023 17:50

I think the OP's question is whether people who are totally fertile should be funded if they don't want to have potentially procreative sex.

The usual bar is that they will fund treatments if there are medical issues. Not having sex is not a medical issue, nor is not having sex with an opposite sex person. The reason is irrelevant.

Think about what you're saying. People are not in relationships for any number of reasons, and they can't just decide suddenly to be in one. Suggesting that a woman should have sex outside a relationship, with a man she is probably not attracted to just in order to get pregnant (and let's assume that for most people that would have to happen a LOT of times) is really problematic. Both for the two people involved in terms of having to put themselves through this, and also because the male partner would have parental rights.

In the country I live in, fertility treatment including IVF is available and funded for any woman who needs it to get pregnant, no matter what her relationship status (you pay for donor sperm if needed, and you co-pay for medication; IVF is only available after other treatments like multiple IUIs have failed).

I see this as a feminist issue. Having spent ten years trying to find a life partner and not succeeding, I was able to have a child on my own during my fertile years, safely, without having to have risky sex with someone I am not interested in (and I was also not tempted to pursue unsuitable relationships just because the biological clock was ticking). Yes, my kid is growing up without a father in our home. But he has many good male role models among our close friends, and also has several friends with a similar family setup. Perhaps it's not ideal, but if this forum is anything to go by there are plenty of kids with a far less positive family situation.

Moreempatheticmyarse · 05/11/2023 17:35

Euridicefortuna · 05/11/2023 17:14

You are hard work aren't you.Why are you arguing with me about my friends,they are very upfront with their issues with me as I am with them.I will reiterate, they were missing sperm which the NHS provided. I went to one of her appointments when her partner couldn't make it,everything was disclosed there;her issue was no sperm.They have another round of IVF left,she is very fertile and got pregnant with her first round of IVF and luckily the second. Why can't you understand that sometimes it is just that the sperm is missing and council's work by a case by case basis;there doesn't have to be anything wrong for the NHS to help you.It is upto the individual council.One if the questions that she was asked was if she had trouble conceiving, her response, I don't know I have not had sex with a man! I will let her know that she didn't need to have sex with a man to know if she had any issues.

Well do be sure to let the NHS know that they no longer need a range of medical knowledge to know if someone's fertile or not just a man's penis

Yes Emma, we've removed your ovaries but you might still be fertile we don't know until you've had sex with a man

Once again, I wasnt saying that your friends had fertility issues. I was challenging your statement that people couldn't know if they had fertility issues until they had sex with a man. I provided several examples where this is in fact not the case. It is one of the ways people find out they infertile, not the one and only way.

Euridicefortuna · 05/11/2023 17:14

Moreempatheticmyarse · 04/11/2023 18:57

I don't know your friends better than you do. And maybe they are upfront about their fertility. But I also know plenty of people who have fertility issues who choose not to disclose their medical details to all and sundry, sometimes not even their close friends and family, as is their right.

Besides which - the point I was responding to was you saying they couldn't know whether they had fertility issues or not because they hadn't had sex with a man. Which is ridiculous as that is clearly not medically necessary to know a fair number of fertility issues.

You are hard work aren't you.Why are you arguing with me about my friends,they are very upfront with their issues with me as I am with them.I will reiterate, they were missing sperm which the NHS provided. I went to one of her appointments when her partner couldn't make it,everything was disclosed there;her issue was no sperm.They have another round of IVF left,she is very fertile and got pregnant with her first round of IVF and luckily the second. Why can't you understand that sometimes it is just that the sperm is missing and council's work by a case by case basis;there doesn't have to be anything wrong for the NHS to help you.It is upto the individual council.One if the questions that she was asked was if she had trouble conceiving, her response, I don't know I have not had sex with a man! I will let her know that she didn't need to have sex with a man to know if she had any issues.

TempestTost · 04/11/2023 22:30

Mumeries · 04/11/2023 22:28

You put emphasis on unattractive

Not sure what your point is.

Mumeries · 04/11/2023 22:28

TempestTost · 04/11/2023 17:53

Maybe we could also fund surrogates for autistic and unattractive men who struggle to connect with women?

You put emphasis on unattractive

Vistada · 04/11/2023 19:30

Mumeries · 04/11/2023 16:23

I think disabled autistic women who struggle to make friendships or have relationships should be entitled to free fertility treatment/sperm banks

Having a child is not a right. No one is owed the opportunity. Thats just a fact.

It's ludicrous that the NHS funds this at all.

Moreempatheticmyarse · 04/11/2023 18:57

Euridicefortuna · 04/11/2023 18:46

I am speaking specifically about my friends, who have 2 beautiful girls via IVF.They have no fertility issues;the only issue they had was that sperm is needed from a man to create a child.No large assumptions being made here:they were missing a vital ingredient which the NHS provided. Do you know my friends better than I do,fair enough if you do........

I don't know your friends better than you do. And maybe they are upfront about their fertility. But I also know plenty of people who have fertility issues who choose not to disclose their medical details to all and sundry, sometimes not even their close friends and family, as is their right.

Besides which - the point I was responding to was you saying they couldn't know whether they had fertility issues or not because they hadn't had sex with a man. Which is ridiculous as that is clearly not medically necessary to know a fair number of fertility issues.

Euridicefortuna · 04/11/2023 18:46

Moreempatheticmyarse · 03/11/2023 22:31

They wouldn't know of any issues as they haven't had sex with a man so have never tried to conceive naturally.

That's a pretty large assumption. I knew I would have issues since I was about 16. My friend with endo knew she would have issues since she was mid 20s. Another friend knows she cant have children due to childhood cancer. Having sex with a man isn't a prerequisite to knowing you have a condition that causes fertility issues.

I am speaking specifically about my friends, who have 2 beautiful girls via IVF.They have no fertility issues;the only issue they had was that sperm is needed from a man to create a child.No large assumptions being made here:they were missing a vital ingredient which the NHS provided. Do you know my friends better than I do,fair enough if you do........

TempestTost · 04/11/2023 17:53

Mumeries · 04/11/2023 16:23

I think disabled autistic women who struggle to make friendships or have relationships should be entitled to free fertility treatment/sperm banks

Maybe we could also fund surrogates for autistic and unattractive men who struggle to connect with women?

TempestTost · 04/11/2023 17:50

Simonjt · 04/11/2023 06:41

Where we live fertility treatment has been funded for gay women since 2005 and single women since 2016. Some people still choose to go elsewhere and pay (where it is cheaper than paying here) to reduce wait times. It should be funded or not, you either think women should be able to access funded IVF or they shouldn’t, we wouldn’t treat women of different religions or ethnicities differently, so we shouldn’t treat or not treat women according to their sexuality.

I think the OP's question is whether people who are totally fertile should be funded if they don't want to have potentially procreative sex.

The usual bar is that they will fund treatments if there are medical issues. Not having sex is not a medical issue, nor is not having sex with an opposite sex person. The reason is irrelevant.

thesmartwife · 04/11/2023 16:27

Theoretically the NHS provides fertility treatment for people with fertility problems, i.e. they are doing all the right things to have a baby but aren't falling pregnant and they have either some known or unexplained fertility issue. Single women or lesbian couples are not having sex with men and may not actually have fertility issues. I suppose if lesbian couples get treatment then there is no reason why single women shouldn't be treated also, provided donor sperm can be obtained.

There are ethical considerations and already gay men want to have the option of surrogacy on the NHS. Surrogacy is in almost all cases not ethical or acceptable in anyway. So widening access to "fertility treatment" via the NHS is highly fraught https://www.thepinknews.com/2020/05/04/scotland-gay-couple-surrogacy-nhs-ross-chris-muller-edinburgh/

Scotland’s first gay couple to have a baby via NHS surrogacy want others to know there is ‘an open door’

The first gay couple in Scotland to have a baby through an NHS surrogate want others to know that there is "an open door" for others.

https://www.thepinknews.com/2020/05/04/scotland-gay-couple-surrogacy-nhs-ross-chris-muller-edinburgh

Mumeries · 04/11/2023 16:23

I think disabled autistic women who struggle to make friendships or have relationships should be entitled to free fertility treatment/sperm banks

LemonPeonies · 04/11/2023 16:12

I Don't think NHS should fund IVF for anyone either, not sure I agree with it at all tbh.

Papyrophile · 04/11/2023 16:09

ginandtonicwithlimes · 04/11/2023 05:40

My husband lost his job three months after I got pregnant. It doesn't always go to plan!

As you say, life doesn't always go to plan! I hope that he got a new and even better job before you gave birth and that all has gone well since.

Pigsears · 04/11/2023 15:34

Tbh, I don't think the NHS should fund IVF treatment at all.

How many months of nursery fees would it take to pay for a round of private IVF?

Yes, I get it isn't fair that some people have to pay and some don't.

Flyhigher · 04/11/2023 15:22

No. It's better to have two parents if possible. If Nhs funds lots of single women to have babies that they then can't support well enough it's a burden on everyone including the mother. Also with limited resource it will always be spent on two parent families. It's a big undertaking parenting. Doing it alone is too difficult.

Cattenberg · 04/11/2023 12:45

When an acquaintance had a baby as a single woman through private IVF, she went to see her GP first. Her GP said, “why are you doing this? Go and have a one night stand or something”. My acquaintance was pretty shocked.

The options for single women aren’t that great. I remember looking at a website for women looking to connect with sperm donors, with no involvement from a clinic. It was a bit seedy. Some men wrote “natural method preferred” on their profiles.

I remember reading the profile of one man who said he was 40, then let something slip (I can’t remember what), that suggested he was actually pushing 60.

I had a vision of a group of dodgy older men looking to have unprotected sex with much younger women, and perhaps not being entirely honest about their age, sexual health or medical history. And maybe giving a false name, in case the Child Support Agency came looking for them.

Pumpkinspie · 04/11/2023 12:44

I don’t think anyone should get IVF on the NHS. Having a child is not a right.

Groundhoghcg · 04/11/2023 12:41

If a woman has gone through IUI privately and has established she has a fertility problem I can't see a reason why it wouldn't be funded, provided it was clear there aren't any concerns about the woman's ability to parent alone.

Private IVF is expensive, around £15k for three cycles. I would guess the average single IVF patient will already be mid thirties at the point of starting. Even if she's earning well saving enough for a three cycle package would take years, by which time it is far less likely to work.

Outpatient procedures like IVF are a drop in the ocean in the NHS budget compared to all of the unnecessary hospital stays due to social care and housing delays. Irrate taxpayers would be better off getting cross about that.

mugboat · 04/11/2023 12:41

with all due respect, if you have funds to pay for private treatment, it's irrelevant what you think as regards the NHS offering it for those without ££££ in the bank.

You don't know what it's like, you only know what it's like to need fertility treatment and have the means to pay for it.

mugboat · 04/11/2023 12:38

Cattenberg · 04/11/2023 12:20

I think the possible risks to the baby vary somewhat, depending on whether the cycle involved a fresh embryo transfer or a frozen embryo transfer.

However, some studies suggest a link between IVF and an increased risk of premature birth, low birth weight, birth defects, high blood pressure and childhood cancer. The absolute risk of birth defects or childhood cancer for IVF children looks to be very low, but the increase in relative risk is concerning.

More research is needed, as the results of some studies have been contradictory. Also, some of these risks may be associated with conditions causing infertility, rather than the IVF process itself.

there's no increased risk of childhood cancer linked to ivf.

Low birth weight probably does link to IVF but only because many IVF pregnancies are twin pregnancies.

Singleton IVF pregnancies are no riskier to mum or baby...

The IVF clinics do not do anything to the embryo- they basically extract eggs and add them to a petri dish with sperm and let them do their thing... then put 1 or 2 embryos back into the womb.

Raincloudsonasunnyday · 04/11/2023 12:25

Why should taxpayers assist a fertile woman in having a baby, when there are cost-free alternatives available to her?

Being homosexual isn’t a lifestyle choice. Being single, is.

Fairyliz · 04/11/2023 12:24

I don’t think anyone should be getting IVF on the NHS and I speak as someone who has gone through it privately.
If two adults working full time can’t afford to save up for it how on earth can they afford a child?
It not just the cost of food/clothing/equipment etc but the cost of childminding or loss of income if one parent says at home. That literally costs thousands a year.

Cattenberg · 04/11/2023 12:20

ginandtonicwithlimes · 04/11/2023 05:11

What is the health risk for babies with IVF? Personally I wouldn't bother with IUI and go straight to IVF. Better success rates.

I think the possible risks to the baby vary somewhat, depending on whether the cycle involved a fresh embryo transfer or a frozen embryo transfer.

However, some studies suggest a link between IVF and an increased risk of premature birth, low birth weight, birth defects, high blood pressure and childhood cancer. The absolute risk of birth defects or childhood cancer for IVF children looks to be very low, but the increase in relative risk is concerning.

More research is needed, as the results of some studies have been contradictory. Also, some of these risks may be associated with conditions causing infertility, rather than the IVF process itself.