Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Archaic societal norms that need to change

290 replies

Autiebibliophile · 03/11/2023 05:34

For me it's the 6 week holidays. It worked well in a time where the majority of families were one income families. Where village communities were much more present. Grandparents typically lived close by and could help with childcare. When we had typical seasons before global warming kicked in.

I grew up in the eighties, summers were playing out all day. If my mum needed to go somewhere I went to my grandparents or a friends house. It was simple. Now it's just 6 weeks of childcare hell. Spending a fortune on childcare, expensive holidays, activities. It costs a fortune and I'm not convinced children get much out of the break anymore.

I think it needs cutting down to three weeks, And give parents two weeks they can use at their choosing (at certain time periods in the year)

What societal norms do you think are outdated?

OP posts:
CoffeeCantata · 03/11/2023 13:57

Doingmybest12
Why are we cramming children with random, often useless information for them to regurgitate when information is now at the finger tips of everyone and we need skills to research, analyse and for critical thinking.

I agree in theory, Doinmybest, but I remember in my teaching days there was a huge push in both English and history lessons (where my experience was) to teach students to analyse things critically. In English we'd look at advertising and the subliminal messages etc and in history there was lots of influence on bias, using historical sources (writing, pictures, film, photographs etc) and wartime propaganda.

Alas, I've been really disheartened in recent years to see just how little impact this seems to have had! I've been sad to see that many younger people (of the generation I taught) swallow stuff whole -especially advertising. Or, even more worrying, they seem to be hooked on conspiracy theories - indicating that they've lost all perspective in analysing news etc for authenticity. They think everyone is lying! Some of my son's very academic friends are convinced that the moon landings were faked....God help us.

I know this is a tiny sample, but you only have to look at the internet to see that there's craziness all around us. I'm sick to death of hearing from otherwise intelligent people that the McCanns killed Madeleine and Prince Philip had Diana murdered.

stormteacupandcake · 03/11/2023 13:54

One of the reasons we had the summer holiday in the first place is so kids could work at the harvest.

was it?

I would suggest you read around a bit...

TrashedSofa · 03/11/2023 13:08

stormteacupandcake · 03/11/2023 13:03

But don't confuse you not liking something with it not being reality. I say all this as someone who doesn't want to cut the school holidays either.

it has nothing to do with what I like or not, it's has everything to do with schools not designed to fit around the parents choices.

Schools try to HELP with the childcare element, offering breakfast and after-school clubs, but they are not designed to be glorified child-minders.

I do maintain that when people refuse to take responsibility for their kids out of school, during holidays etc, then they really should not have them in the first place.

It clearly does. You devoted most of the post I quoted to explaining why you thought this was a bad thing.

As for design and glorified childminders, why do you think childcare and glorified childminder mean the same thing? What do you reckon the hub places for 'essential' workers during lockdown were for, if not childcare? And why are you so sure there's no connection between the way the school year is designed and the wider labour force concerns? One of the reasons we had the summer holiday in the first place is so kids could work at the harvest.

stormteacupandcake · 03/11/2023 13:04

GrumpyOldCrone · 03/11/2023 13:03

Are you posting from your yacht? Grin

If I had enough money to be on my yacht somewhere right now, I really wouldn't be wasting my time on MN 😂

stormteacupandcake · 03/11/2023 13:03

But don't confuse you not liking something with it not being reality. I say all this as someone who doesn't want to cut the school holidays either.

it has nothing to do with what I like or not, it's has everything to do with schools not designed to fit around the parents choices.

Schools try to HELP with the childcare element, offering breakfast and after-school clubs, but they are not designed to be glorified child-minders.

I do maintain that when people refuse to take responsibility for their kids out of school, during holidays etc, then they really should not have them in the first place.

GrumpyOldCrone · 03/11/2023 13:03

stormteacupandcake · 03/11/2023 12:49

Communists countries have tried to address that, didn't seem to work out that well.

Are you posting from your yacht? Grin

Greeksummer · 03/11/2023 13:03

BlingLoving · 03/11/2023 12:41

mmm, I'm not sure about this. I mean, absolutely if there is a genuine harm to physical and mental health. But if anything, I feel as a society we're sometimes going too far the other way... "oooh, it makes me uncomfortable and stressed to work to a deadline and it's bad for my mental health".

I definitely don't see a push to make people power through no matter what, but rather lots of bending over backwards to accommodate.

I’m not talking about coddled employees who are either too lazy or incompetent to meet deadlines.

Perhaps it’s just the cultures I’ve experienced throughout my career but powering through at the expense of your health and well-being (doing more than one persons job and working crazy hours for months because needs must, etc) is seen as a strength, or just something that you should or need to do. However, admitting that you’re not coping or need to take a step back is considered a failing.

MrsSlocombesCat · 03/11/2023 13:02

I think equality has backfired on women. It used to be that you could have a career IF you wanted to, now women with children are expected to work as well as all the domestic stuff they used to do. Children don’t get that special time with their mothers before they start school that they used to. SAHM feel guilty that they don’t work, working mothers feel guilty about their children being in childcare. The only winners in this are men. The irony. I know that some men take equal responsibility but certainly not all, by a wide margin.

TrashedSofa · 03/11/2023 12:57

stormteacupandcake · 03/11/2023 12:41

If you have that attitude, you should not have children. No, school is NOT childcare. Obviously parents use that free time and organise their childcare around school hours/ school days.

Schools are not there to give parents their "me time", they are there to teach the children. 6 weeks holidays are already too short for the high majority of children. Anyone with kids will see how much they need a break. They also need opportunities to have a life out of school, the older they get, the more they will miss on these opportunities.

We keep banging on about mental health, adults having a better work/life balance but at the same time some people would like to put their kids at school full time so they don't have to deal with them? Come on, it's nonsense, it's not in the child's best interests and you know it.

Edited

We have a society where school functions as childcare. You even acknowledge as much yourself, with your sentence about how parents organise their work in practice. You just sound ridiculous telling people they shouldn't have kids if they've observed this very clear fact about the world they live in.

This has nothing to do with 'me time'. It's about the fact that we rely on the labour of millions of parents of school age children to do all sorts of essential functions, and we don't have other options to look after all of those children whilst their parents work. We have arranged things so that school is indeed childcare, amongst the other things it also gives us. For those of you who needed proof of this, lockdown provided it. So this isn't even a question now.

Now that's not to say this is a good thing. But don't confuse you not liking something with it not being reality. I say all this as someone who doesn't want to cut the school holidays either.

Comedycook · 03/11/2023 12:57

bookworm14 · 03/11/2023 12:23

Ah, the ‘school isn’t childcare’ brigade. I haven’t encountered that argument since the good old covid days.

School absolutely is, among other things, childcare.

I'm pretty sure the job centre sees school as childcare

Autiebibliophile · 03/11/2023 12:55

Permanentlyunimpressed · 03/11/2023 08:13

I thought you meant 6 weeks annual leave was archaic and needed to change. That I agree with, who decided we should work 46 weeks and only get 6 off? The kids don't need less holidays, the adults need more. It's why I went self employed as a lone parent, I work full time in term time and reduce my hours/take leave in the school holidays.

Absolutely true

OP posts:
Autiebibliophile · 03/11/2023 12:52

baroqueandblue · 03/11/2023 08:33

As a previous poster said, you're being naive. But you're also feigning helplessness, and scapegoating schools. Teachers don't make the kinds of political decisions that have resulted in there being woefully diminished provision in the education system for SEN children. Politicians do that. Take it up with them, stand up for your child's rights.

(But you won't, you'll just blame teachers instead. You represent so much of what stinks about parents' attitudes to teaching staff. And I'm not a teacher btw - I've just seen up close the brutal way they've been steadily shafted for years by governments, SLTs and feckless parents 🙄)

Quote anything I've said that holds teachers responsible for the length of school holidays. Of course teachers are not responsible, they don't chose the holidays.

OP posts:
stormteacupandcake · 03/11/2023 12:49

GrumpyOldCrone · 03/11/2023 12:41

The idea that there can be people who are super-rich while a large percentage of the population live in poverty. That’s what seems archaic to me. Or, at least, it requires reform.

Communists countries have tried to address that, didn't seem to work out that well.

GrumpyOldCrone · 03/11/2023 12:41

The idea that there can be people who are super-rich while a large percentage of the population live in poverty. That’s what seems archaic to me. Or, at least, it requires reform.

BlingLoving · 03/11/2023 12:41

Greeksummer · 03/11/2023 12:37

The notion that “powering through” at the expense of ones physical or mental health is a virtue.

mmm, I'm not sure about this. I mean, absolutely if there is a genuine harm to physical and mental health. But if anything, I feel as a society we're sometimes going too far the other way... "oooh, it makes me uncomfortable and stressed to work to a deadline and it's bad for my mental health".

I definitely don't see a push to make people power through no matter what, but rather lots of bending over backwards to accommodate.

stormteacupandcake · 03/11/2023 12:41

bookworm14 · 03/11/2023 12:23

Ah, the ‘school isn’t childcare’ brigade. I haven’t encountered that argument since the good old covid days.

School absolutely is, among other things, childcare.

If you have that attitude, you should not have children. No, school is NOT childcare. Obviously parents use that free time and organise their childcare around school hours/ school days.

Schools are not there to give parents their "me time", they are there to teach the children. 6 weeks holidays are already too short for the high majority of children. Anyone with kids will see how much they need a break. They also need opportunities to have a life out of school, the older they get, the more they will miss on these opportunities.

We keep banging on about mental health, adults having a better work/life balance but at the same time some people would like to put their kids at school full time so they don't have to deal with them? Come on, it's nonsense, it's not in the child's best interests and you know it.

Greeksummer · 03/11/2023 12:37

The notion that “powering through” at the expense of ones physical or mental health is a virtue.

VickyEadieofThigh · 03/11/2023 12:32

tiredandolderthanithought · 03/11/2023 07:28

@Onethingatatime23 can you share this info about the monks?

Just thinking about what we teach and a lot of it wasn't about in medieval times!

Indeed. They learnt Latin and Greek. That was it.

VickyEadieofThigh · 03/11/2023 12:27

sollenwir · 03/11/2023 07:51

Education/attainment would suffer and it would be a nightmare for teachers to have to constantly re-teach different topics to different pupils.

Correct. It's very difficult already when just a few children are taken out for holidays in term time - making it an "entitlement" would be an absolute nightmare for teachers.

NotLactoseFree · 03/11/2023 12:26

Make up needs to be less gendered. For a long time, only women could wear make up and it was largely expected. I'm pleased that increasingly, women choosing not to wear make up, or very minimal make up, is considered normal and acceptable. But I think make up should be seen as equally normal for use by men.

Lots of teenage boys are as self conscious about their looks - the ability to learn to emphasise their eyes or cover blemishes seems reasonable. ditto for men.

OBVIOUSLY, all by choice.

also, I think ties should be abolished. I honestly don't understand the point of them in the 21st century.

bookworm14 · 03/11/2023 12:23

Ah, the ‘school isn’t childcare’ brigade. I haven’t encountered that argument since the good old covid days.

School absolutely is, among other things, childcare.

AlaskaThunderfuckHiiiiiiiii · 03/11/2023 12:19

Someone clearly needs to tell the government that school isn’t free childcare then as continuing to receive benefits latches on the idea that you can start a working once your child starts school. Really grinds my gears when people say tough about not being able to work school isn’t free childcare well the government think
it is

MrsSkylerWhite · 03/11/2023 12:17

Sorry, loved the long school holidays. Yabu.

Chickenkeev · 03/11/2023 12:16

honeylulu · 03/11/2023 09:42

I don't agree about reducing school holidays. School budgets are stretched to capacity already and teachers can work 60+ hours a week in term time. The holidays are the only respite! I do think that there needs to be more and affordable holiday and wraparound care in all areas. I say that as someone who has access to an excellent and modestly priced holiday club but I and my career would have been stuffed without it.

I would like to see an end to tipping which seems to be headed the way of the US in the sense that a certain percentage is now just expected rather than a discretionary award for good service. If its expected just add it to the cost price and do away with tipping altogether. (I do tip waiting staff, taxis, hairdressers etc but I feel uneasy that it's expected and also that retail workers, carers etc are also on minimum wage but never tipped.)

Ticket booking fees really get on my tits. I don't object to paying a booking fee in principle but why why why is it per ticket not per booking??? If its per ticket then its actually part of the ticket price so just bloody say so!

Agree about archaic traditions of being given away at weddings, it being the norm to take husband's name and give the children husband's name. I didn't do any of those things but most married women I know did at least one of them. It's sexist and outdated and gives the impression that women should be proud to be married but men don't have to be because they are busy being important in their own right.

Ahhhh I feel better now.

YY re booking fees! Absolute scam. I got 'secondary rage' reading your post 😂

honeylulu · 03/11/2023 09:42

I don't agree about reducing school holidays. School budgets are stretched to capacity already and teachers can work 60+ hours a week in term time. The holidays are the only respite! I do think that there needs to be more and affordable holiday and wraparound care in all areas. I say that as someone who has access to an excellent and modestly priced holiday club but I and my career would have been stuffed without it.

I would like to see an end to tipping which seems to be headed the way of the US in the sense that a certain percentage is now just expected rather than a discretionary award for good service. If its expected just add it to the cost price and do away with tipping altogether. (I do tip waiting staff, taxis, hairdressers etc but I feel uneasy that it's expected and also that retail workers, carers etc are also on minimum wage but never tipped.)

Ticket booking fees really get on my tits. I don't object to paying a booking fee in principle but why why why is it per ticket not per booking??? If its per ticket then its actually part of the ticket price so just bloody say so!

Agree about archaic traditions of being given away at weddings, it being the norm to take husband's name and give the children husband's name. I didn't do any of those things but most married women I know did at least one of them. It's sexist and outdated and gives the impression that women should be proud to be married but men don't have to be because they are busy being important in their own right.

Ahhhh I feel better now.

Swipe left for the next trending thread