Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

School dinners v packed lunch

259 replies

F05ters1 · 02/11/2023 23:30

Reception age daughter begging to go on packed lunches already after 6 weeks of full time school.

Every day without fail when I ask her what was for lunch I get... fishfingers chips and beans, I didn't like the chips and I'm off beans so I ate the fish fingers. Please can I take a packed lunch?

pasta and cheese, I didn't like the cheese and the pasta was soggy so I just had the biscuit for pudding. when can I go on packed lunch?

mince and dumplings today, mince was too salty and the dumpling was soggy, please can I go on packed lunches?

blah blah takes a packed lunch. (dd has even approached said mum who said her dd was a picky eater 🙄)

why can't you just say I'm a picky eater mum!

For context she'll eat a salmon fillet at home but won't eat a fishfinger.
She'll eat fillet steak but not a burger.
She eats all veg and salad but isn't keen on meat. I make soup packed with lentils and do lots of eggy things for protein

I'm torn. school meals are free and I work shifts, it's been a godsend not having to worry about lunch for the four year old restaurant critic! but she is so adamant, should I relent?

OP posts:
HamstersAreMyLife · 03/11/2023 08:02

Are you sure there isn't a choice? Our school meals aren't great and sound similar but there's also the option of a jacket potato or sandwich plus the hot meat and veggie options. I don't like the school dinners but I stuck to them whilst they were free. I make pack ups now but it is a pain and time consuming even without shift work! Taking leftovers isn't an option at our school and I've tried the freezer hack as I bulk cook a lot and the sandwiches came out awful so I do them fresh every night. Roll on secondary!

JustAMinutePleass · 03/11/2023 08:01

If she’s eating breakfast and tea / dinner at home then it doesn’t matter how little she’s eating during lunch. I personally wouldn’t be rejecting a fsm if she’s eating something - it will cost you a lot more in terms of money and time to make packed lunches for her.

Rockfordpeach · 03/11/2023 08:00

School lunches are generally pretty poor. My friend is a teacher at DS's school and sends a packed lunch for her daughter. My DS had a term or two on school lunches in reception and switched to packed lunches with the occasional hot dinner of the meals he particularly liked (I think there are about 3 in rotation)

Aramist · 03/11/2023 07:56

There's really nothing wrong with fish fingers, chips and beans.
People stress far too much over what their kids eat.
You should have seen what sort of stuff we ate as kids at our house. I remember eating tinned burgers, and I actually liked them!

I work in a school and the dinners are fine. They're very heavily regulated as well, so there's some rubbish being spouted on this thread.

Fussy parents breed fussy kids.

00100001 · 03/11/2023 07:56

curtaintwitchersannonymous · 03/11/2023 06:53

school dinners should be abolished in my opinion, the amount of money wasted on them is insane. The tax payer is paying the wages of all those people who make and serve them, plus the energy costs, and the schools have sacrificed all that space for out of bounds kitchens, and the food itself is worth about 80p, if that. You could increase child benefit by 10x the value of the food they are getting and still make a profit by abolishing them

Problem is that some kids won't be fed until the evening.

Some kids will be sent in with yesterday's McDonald's or a bag of Doritos and a cola drink or cold chips from the chippy, or nothing at all.

My sister works in a primary and has seen all of these things....

Dollmeup · 03/11/2023 07:55

At my kids school they have a good system where you go on and choose their options in advance, so you can see what the menu will be each day and if they are likely to actually eat it. If not you just select the packed lunch option and this reduces waste. Food at the school is ok but not amazing.

I'm encouraging mine to choose from the menu a couple of times a week (usually they will do it on the days there is a good pudding!) and the rest I just do packed lunch. At least I know that way they actually will eat it. When the meals are no longer free I'll probably just go entirely to packed lunch as they are cheaper.

I keep packed lunches simple and not too exciting and they get a sandwich, cucumber or carrot sticks and a yogurt which doesn't take too long to make. That's pretty much what they choose at weekends anyway so they are happy with it.

sashh · 03/11/2023 07:52

Facebookflight · 03/11/2023 06:43

I don’t blame her. School dinners here are so grim you wouldn’t feed them to a dog. Why is school food so dire still?

It depends on the school.

I did a lot of supply teaching and some schools you would got a meal that could be on a pub menu, at others it was dire, very few were somewhere in between.

I started school in the 1970s where there was no choice and then at secondary only a choice of two mains and two puddings. And the mains were not that varied eg chicken supreme or chicken pie.

I think catering companies have now gone to 'kid friendly' so it is the stuff you would get on a children's menu, burgers, sausages, fish fingers rather than 'proper food'.

itsgettingweird · 03/11/2023 07:50

4yo restaurant critic Grin

I'd firstly see if they have the jacket potato or sandwich option. If they do t I'd ask the school why? Perhaps DD could be become an advocate for change?

But if not I'd just bulk make some soup (get a soup maker?) and heat it up into a thermos each day.

I take it daily and just Chuck it in the microwave when I'm in the kitchen and pour in when done. The making it takes an extra 5 minutes at the weekend and is usually done when I'm cooking anyway.

Hopingforno2in2023 · 03/11/2023 07:48

The amount of waste is insane. Sometimes the waste bin is so heavy two people have to dispose of it. This is with only 200 kids eating.

Mrsjaffacakeys · 03/11/2023 07:39

I am a school midday supervisor and it's an absolute nightmare trying to get (some) kids to eat their school dinner. I'd be happy with them eating half of it but some won't touch it at all and I worry they will be hungry as school is a long day. I totally understand why you would want her to be on school dinners though. I would maybe let her have a packed lunch sometimes, like on the days where the lunch is something she really doesn't like. Alternatively schools usually offer a sandwich or jacket potato as another option would she eat those?

Iamnotthe1 · 03/11/2023 07:32

The reason for the drop off is because parents have to start paying for them and some either can't afford or don't want to pay the £500ish per year it would be. Those who are on free school meals continue to have them and many others besides.

Schools wouldn't want to encourage kids to take up dinners if the numbers were low. Firstly, most school meals are provided by third party catering companies rather than the school itself. Beyond that, at the moment, the government funding per meal is lower than the cost of the meal so schools are having to prop up the school dinner system from their own budgets.

User56785 · 03/11/2023 07:28

*This is why I wish all parents could see what their children are being served. So many think they're eating well at school, but the menus / taster meals are very deceptive compared to what the children are actually given.

The reality is most of the food is thrown away, and I wonder how some children get through the day having eaten so little, or in some cases nothing at all.*

I agree. I won't tell a child to try and eat some more, I can't bring myself to. I just say 'are you sure you don't want to eat some pasta' or something along those lines.

On Fridays every three weeks ours have salmon gougons and I don't think a single child eats one. They seem to absolutely hate them.

User56785 · 03/11/2023 07:24

The vegetarians options are often worse unless you go to a school that has a lot of vegetarians.

I once worked in a school that was completely vegetarian and the food was excellent.

The school I am at now it is terrible.

Small schools often don't have any options at all, apart from vegetarian meals. Whereas at big schools there will be a choice of main meals and baked potatoes. Even sandwiches.

DappledThings · 03/11/2023 07:24

I don't make packed lunches. They get a decent meal at school and making packed lunches is my line in the sand.

It's the most boring of jobs and they always have the option of jacket potato if they really don't want the main option.

Whinge · 03/11/2023 07:21

Hopingforno2in2023 · 03/11/2023 07:18

DS had school dinners every day until I started as a catering assistant in a school and saw just how awful the meals are. Such poor quality meat, very processed food and little in the way of veggies. Now he has packed lunches. The puddings however are fine, homemade and tasty.

This is why I wish all parents could see what their children are being served. So many think they're eating well at school, but the menus / taster meals are very deceptive compared to what the children are actually given.

The reality is most of the food is thrown away, and I wonder how some children get through the day having eaten so little, or in some cases nothing at all. Sad

Zanatdy · 03/11/2023 07:20

They do sound rank. My kids school dinners was more nutritious and varied than they sound. But they mainly had packed lunch. God I’m glad I no longer have to make them anymore as I got so tired of doing it every morning or evening before.

OneCup · 03/11/2023 07:19

School dinners at our school are appalling. ( There was a taster session). Since then we have been doing packed lunches. No regret. I reasoned I couldn't justify letting my daughter eat what I wouldn't eat myself.

Valerianandfoxglovesoup · 03/11/2023 07:19

I think there's a difference between inedible slop like the NHS and some school meals and the snobbery about baked beans. School is a long day for children with lots of physical activity, fish fingers and chips will be the only.meal some kids get per day and is perfectly OK. The meal my mum was given, which was a lump of fish with some half cooked potatoes and tinned peaches, all slopped on the same plate is something I doubt my dog would have wanted. But loving the competitive mums "I don't know why but Crispin will only eat fresh escargot with French brandy and he wouldn't touch a fish finger" 😀

Georgeandzippyzoo · 03/11/2023 07:19

Schools I've known wouldn't allow swapping between meal/packed lunch during the week.
There should be a vegetarian option each day. Ask to see the menu which usually works on a 4 week rota and go over her choices. Making a choice in the queue can be difficult as they are rushed through.
As a PP has said speak to the teacher and ask if someone can check on what she's actually eating. She may be saying she's not eating because she wants a packed lunch like her friend.
I know lots are saying how poor dinners can be but I sometimes help out in a school I taught at and their dinners are lovely but child choices can make the plates look very unappetising . Also many schools offer additional salad /veg.

If it continues then a packed lunch may be a better option , kids cope much better at school feeling full.

savoycabbage · 03/11/2023 07:19

I see the same menu served in different schools by different cooks and the difference is enormous. At one school I go to the chicken curry (Wednesdays every third week) is boiled chicken served with a separate sauce. The broccoli is grey. They get half a slice of a sliced white loaf on their 'prison tray' . The trays are red!

At another school, the chicken curry is made from scratch and I can smell it all slow cooking when I arrive. The children get a tiny home made bread bun on their white plate.

My dc went to school where there were no packed lunches. The mostly had pasta in a Thermos funtainer.

Sartre · 03/11/2023 07:18

There’s a choice of about 6-7 different things a day at my DS’s primary. He’s also in reception and he gets to choose what he has each day which tends to either be a ham sandwich or tomato pasta tbh… I’m grateful because it’s free and, like you, I work long hours and it’s an extra stress worrying about making a packed lunch.

Hopingforno2in2023 · 03/11/2023 07:18

DS had school dinners every day until I started as a catering assistant in a school and saw just how awful the meals are. Such poor quality meat, very processed food and little in the way of veggies. Now he has packed lunches. The puddings however are fine, homemade and tasty.

TheChosenTwo · 03/11/2023 07:17

Ds wouldn’t ever contemplate a school lunch, he has taken a packed lunch every day of his school life, he’s 12!
I worked at his junior school and the lunches looked dreadful, grey meat, sloppy veg, the amount of food that got scraped into the bin at the end of lunch when I was walking through the hall back to the classroom was staggering. So many parents must think their dc are having a ‘main meal’ at lunch and so just do them something small for dinner!
Make the packed lunch, I’ve got it down to a fine art when I need to make them now (ds usually does it himself now), takes about 2 minutes to make a sandwich and throw in fruit, yoghurt and a couple of other bits. At least she’ll eat something.

Tarantella6 · 03/11/2023 07:14

DD1 used to take a thermos flask with either soup or pasta, on the rare occasions I relented and did a pack lunch (I agree with you, they are free, and I've got enough to do!). That's quite easy to do, and crucially you don't need to make sure you have all the various fresh ingredients.

LlynTegid · 03/11/2023 07:12

It depends on the quality of the cooking for the school lunches. Worth seeing if you can find out, would the school let you visit for one?