Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

School dinners v packed lunch

259 replies

F05ters1 · 02/11/2023 23:30

Reception age daughter begging to go on packed lunches already after 6 weeks of full time school.

Every day without fail when I ask her what was for lunch I get... fishfingers chips and beans, I didn't like the chips and I'm off beans so I ate the fish fingers. Please can I take a packed lunch?

pasta and cheese, I didn't like the cheese and the pasta was soggy so I just had the biscuit for pudding. when can I go on packed lunch?

mince and dumplings today, mince was too salty and the dumpling was soggy, please can I go on packed lunches?

blah blah takes a packed lunch. (dd has even approached said mum who said her dd was a picky eater 🙄)

why can't you just say I'm a picky eater mum!

For context she'll eat a salmon fillet at home but won't eat a fishfinger.
She'll eat fillet steak but not a burger.
She eats all veg and salad but isn't keen on meat. I make soup packed with lentils and do lots of eggy things for protein

I'm torn. school meals are free and I work shifts, it's been a godsend not having to worry about lunch for the four year old restaurant critic! but she is so adamant, should I relent?

OP posts:
CarInsuranceIssue · 03/11/2023 13:46

We have a menu and have to order at least one week in advance. The choices are very limited and portions small. It’s a bit of a pain getting it ready each morning but if you get the snack stuff ready the night before, it takes 2 mins to whip up a ham sandwich etc. he takes blueberries, bear paws, a small jelly, baby bel, crisps, cocktail sausages etc so all easy to bulk buy and get ready each evening. I also make sure the uniforms are ready the night before so I can focus on breakfast.

My son likes spaghetti bolognaise I can I can make that on a Sunday and just heat it up each morning before putting in a small thermos. He loves it and it’s much more nutritious than what he would get. I did say no to his request for a smoked salmon and cream cheese bagel! That is pushing his luck too far.

ginandtonicwithlimes · 03/11/2023 13:32

Mine will only eat ham wraps or sandwiches. She is desperate for packed lunches but she will have to wait until next year. Probably will have to put some money on for hot dinners just in case. 🙄

PTAProblems · 03/11/2023 13:27

Don't force her to stay on school dinners. Packed lunches take 5 minutes to make and are so much healthier.

nickaldis · 03/11/2023 13:22

Anyone else has experience of the staff/dinner ladies policing what could be eaten in packed lunches? Nothing with nuts (fine). But no sweets or any desserts, biscuits unless it was Friday.

But the school dinners always had desserts every day of the week

Honeychickpea · 03/11/2023 13:21

NeverDropYourMooncup · 03/11/2023 07:12

She'd tell you that they were serving toasted gerbils and unicorn chips if she thought it would get her closer to having half a cream cheese sandwich, mini cheddars, two frubes, a sugary drink and a Penguin (or whatever particularly salty, sweet or low nutrition stuff she sees the packed lunch kids having that she likes).

Make your decision on that basis - she's telling you what she thinks will get her what she wants.

How dare you! I am sure the OP'S 4 year old is the most reliable narrator in the UK!🤣

FreestyleInTrance · 03/11/2023 13:17

I'd check if there are any alternatives. Our school have a salad bar and a jacket potato option, but from what I could tell they didn't offer those to reception kids right away (or they just didn't know they were an option!).

Once they did, my daughter switched to salad bar every day except Friday (chips, beans, nuggets and ice cream day!). She has a wrap with egg and/or cheese, and some cucumber / tomato / peppers on the side... which is not a million miles away from what a packed lunch would look like, except she gets dessert too.

She would sort of like a packed lunch, but once I explained that I wouldn't be allowed to send any dessert in a packed lunch but she gets one with a school lunch she agreed to stick with it for now :)

(I too hate making packed lunches!)

maddiemookins16mum · 03/11/2023 13:13

It’s not the food, she wants to be with her wee pal.

Schlurp · 03/11/2023 12:50

Last time we went out for afternoon tea the sandwiches were still frozen in the middle... for £25 per head!

You just have to be a bit selective with fillings. Pate or ham works well, especially in a roll. We don't have the freezer space now but I used to in student days.

Reugny · 03/11/2023 12:44

confusedlots · 03/11/2023 11:40

Can't you do a mixture of school dinners and packed lunches? Our school dinners aren't free, but I'd much rather pay for school dinners than make 2 packed lunches every day. Mine look at the menu at the weekend and pick which days they're having school dinners and I do packed lunches on the other days.

We tried that and were discouraged from doing so. I suspect it is because they are "free" for primary school children in London so the school needs to work out the funding.

ShitChicken · 03/11/2023 12:43

EatYourVegetables · 03/11/2023 08:09

Just want to comment on the posters saying “make 5 sandwiches on Sunday and defrost” and “cook a large chilli and feed her for a week”. That’s disgusting. I don’t care how processed or overcooked the school meals are, a frozen sandwich and a week old chilli are worse.

Behave yourself. It's fine.

Unless the food tastes awful in the first place (down to the chef) it will taste fine defrosted and heated up.

ShitChicken · 03/11/2023 12:39

GlitteryGreen · 03/11/2023 11:53

I didn't even know you could freeze sandwiches? I'd have thought the butter and filling a might go a bit weird, like if you froze a cheese sandwich would it not be crumbly when it defrosted?

No, it's fine, it's just a sandwich. Only slightly crunchy if you try and eat it too soon and it's not defrosted 😂

ShitChicken · 03/11/2023 12:38

Honeychickpea · 03/11/2023 07:07

That will soon teach her to stop complaining about school dinners!

Why? My Dad did it for me, it was fine.

Ponderingwindow · 03/11/2023 12:28

I don’t know why people are freezing sandwiches.

I make up 5 lunches on Sunday with everything except the sandwich. The sandwich takes about 30 seconds.

I freeze the drink as a cold pack. I get out the night before so it starts thawing otherwise it’s still too solid by lunch if you have a well insulated lunch bag.

tiredandolderthanithought · 03/11/2023 12:04

@GlitteryGreen honestly it's absolutely fine and really good in the summer as actually keep the bread fresh for longer.

We don't do it all the time but my daughter sometimes likes ham so a pack would be thrown out before we've used it up so this way we don't waste any.

I get some people don't like it but not sure why some posters have to look down their noses at something that works for someone else (and they've never tried before).

Of course you can't put in stuff like cucumber or lettuce etc.

GlitteryGreen · 03/11/2023 11:53

tiredandolderthanithought · 03/11/2023 11:18

Frozen sandwiches are really ok, not sure why it's so pearl clutching and eating leftovers are ok too 🙄. Some of us work long hours and don't have much money so actually need to be careful with things. Those of you who can throw out a portion of chilli then go ahead but both mine like taking leftovers in a food flask to school 🤷🏼‍♀️.

Like others have said see if there is a choice. The jacket potatoes and salad at our school is lovely!

I didn't even know you could freeze sandwiches? I'd have thought the butter and filling a might go a bit weird, like if you froze a cheese sandwich would it not be crumbly when it defrosted?

VickyEadieofThigh · 03/11/2023 11:52

JustAMinutePleass · 03/11/2023 08:01

If she’s eating breakfast and tea / dinner at home then it doesn’t matter how little she’s eating during lunch. I personally wouldn’t be rejecting a fsm if she’s eating something - it will cost you a lot more in terms of money and time to make packed lunches for her.

Indeed - and add in that in EY and KS1, they often get milk and a snack mid-morning (in some schools, free access to fruit all day, etc). Some children end up being not that hungry at lunchtime as a result and additionally, EY and KS1 children are often sent to lunch at a ridiculously early time. (I used until July this year to visit schools and can't count the number of times I've gone through the hall and seen small children sitting down for lunch at 11.30am.)

confusedlots · 03/11/2023 11:40

Can't you do a mixture of school dinners and packed lunches? Our school dinners aren't free, but I'd much rather pay for school dinners than make 2 packed lunches every day. Mine look at the menu at the weekend and pick which days they're having school dinners and I do packed lunches on the other days.

Theendoftheday · 03/11/2023 11:38

I would give her packed lunches, my DD started with school dinners but the quality was awful. She would have been happy eating their ham wraps everyday but those mass produced wraps are also full of rubbish. She mainly has left overs from dinner for lunch in a flask.

forrestgreen · 03/11/2023 11:35

Do packed lunch ch and school
Dinner ch sit apart. Is the reason that she wants to sit next to her friend?

tiredandolderthanithought · 03/11/2023 11:18

Frozen sandwiches are really ok, not sure why it's so pearl clutching and eating leftovers are ok too 🙄. Some of us work long hours and don't have much money so actually need to be careful with things. Those of you who can throw out a portion of chilli then go ahead but both mine like taking leftovers in a food flask to school 🤷🏼‍♀️.

Like others have said see if there is a choice. The jacket potatoes and salad at our school is lovely!

YourNameGoesHere · 03/11/2023 11:12

Whinge · 03/11/2023 10:56

I'm really surprised anyone pays for school dinners, especially those with children in year 5 / 6. They're really expensive considering how tiny the portions are.

Agreed, the portions for KS2 kids are definitely not enough! Not to mention in many schools a lot of the food has actually run out by the time the older kids get into the dinner hall so they have not only miniscule portions but also the least amount of choice.

Whinge · 03/11/2023 10:56

I'm really surprised anyone pays for school dinners, especially those with children in year 5 / 6. They're really expensive considering how tiny the portions are.

mindutopia · 03/11/2023 10:51

Mine will be saddled with school dinners until they are old enough to do their own shopping and make their own packed lunches, if they want to. I have enough to do and I don't need one more task every day. Mine periodically go through periods of asking for packed lunch. I think it's because they are hoping for the packed lunch of school holidays - which is heavy on crisps, biscuits, treats. Not a sandwich and fruit that I'd need to make them for a school packed lunch (no different than the sandwich and fruit they could choose for school dinner, and is probably tastier than mine, and comes with an actual pudding!).

I've told my one in Y6 that she can choose to take a packed lunch in secondary school if she wishes, on the condition she does the shopping with me and makes it herself. I suspect she'll be won over the secondary school lunch offerings instead. But realistically, I can hardly get her to remember her coat for school every day. There's no way she'd manage a packed lunch, and then I'd end up doing it, otherwise she'd have no lunch (they need to be pre-ordered a week in advance).

Iamnotthe1 · 03/11/2023 10:46

StripeyDeckchair · 03/11/2023 08:32

This poster is correct - school dinners have to meet government guidelines, which are very prescriptive; no salt, low sugar, no fried food, veg/salad with all meals etc

They are incorrect about secondary school.meals - they too have to meet the nutritional guidelines.

Secondary meals aren't served as meals. They are served as individual items of which the children can select and purchase as few or as many as they wish, including having exactly the same food every single day if they want to. As such, whilst individual items may have guidelines, the overall meals the children take at the end are not nutritionally balanced.

Imtootiredtothinkofausername · 03/11/2023 10:32

our school dinners are grim tbh. I work there and am far from a fussy eater but I wouldn't eat any of it. My DD will eat anything at home, wide range of veg and a varied diet. But school food is just so rank. It is made (like everything in education) on an absolute shoestring budget and mass produced so the quality just isn't there. Thankfully our school do jacket potatoes which are altogether more palatable so my DD tends to eat these...a lot! Even her teacher joked she would turn into a jacket potato!!