Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

School dinners v packed lunch

259 replies

F05ters1 · 02/11/2023 23:30

Reception age daughter begging to go on packed lunches already after 6 weeks of full time school.

Every day without fail when I ask her what was for lunch I get... fishfingers chips and beans, I didn't like the chips and I'm off beans so I ate the fish fingers. Please can I take a packed lunch?

pasta and cheese, I didn't like the cheese and the pasta was soggy so I just had the biscuit for pudding. when can I go on packed lunch?

mince and dumplings today, mince was too salty and the dumpling was soggy, please can I go on packed lunches?

blah blah takes a packed lunch. (dd has even approached said mum who said her dd was a picky eater 🙄)

why can't you just say I'm a picky eater mum!

For context she'll eat a salmon fillet at home but won't eat a fishfinger.
She'll eat fillet steak but not a burger.
She eats all veg and salad but isn't keen on meat. I make soup packed with lentils and do lots of eggy things for protein

I'm torn. school meals are free and I work shifts, it's been a godsend not having to worry about lunch for the four year old restaurant critic! but she is so adamant, should I relent?

OP posts:
DIYandEatCake · 04/11/2023 08:32

My son swapped to packed lunches in reception - his older sister had already swapped and he didn’t like the school dinner food either (and was reporting he ate ‘chips and jelly’ for lunch). We got a bento box style lunchbox, he has sandwich/cold pasta/cous cous/sausage roll in the main bit, a compartment of salad bits, a compartment of fruit, and a pudding compartment. It all gets eaten and I know he’s had a balanced meal. It is a pain making it in the morning but only takes 5 minutes.

YikYok · 04/11/2023 08:31

@Snowdropcow but she is not fed if she won’t eat it.

OP, My ds has also just started reception and refuses the food. At home he eats everything and he has a huge appetite as seems t be in an endless growth spurt.
So I have let him switch to packed lunches and he is literally happier and concentrating better at school as a result. He has 1.5 cheese or chicken sandwiches, salad and two types of fruit. It’s healthy and filling and takes no time to assemble if I am well organised. I will try school meals again in the future but for now he wants what he wants and I want him to have a meal between 8am and 6pm!

whatapalavaaa · 04/11/2023 08:29

School dinners at the school I work at are mostly beige, processed and devoid of nutrients I’m sorry to say. For convenience, I eat them a couple of times a week and they don’t taste great either. But it depends what’s going in the packed lunch and how much it’s inconveniencing/costing you.

There is likely to be a salad bar; if you stick with the school lunch option make sure she uses it, it’s usually decent. Also explore the veggie and jacket potato options which are sometimes (not always) better.

YourNameGoesHere · 04/11/2023 08:27

Whinge · 04/11/2023 08:24

but compared to a sandwhich, crisps, chocolate bar, yogurt etc that most children have in their packed lunch I’d say it’s 100% better nutritionally.

I'd much rather a child eats that packed lunch than going an entire year eating just a cracker. I really hope the school informed the parents / carers that he wasn't eating, especially as crackers aren't served every day, so most days he wasn't actually eating anything.

Agreed! How can anyone think a sandwich, packet of crisps and a yoghurt is worse than a 4 year old eating nothing but a cracker 5 days a week for a whole year!

MissTrip82 · 04/11/2023 08:25

We live somewhere where packed lunches are the norm. Both shift workers, both long hours, both regularly at work at night etc. We do a lunch box for everyone every day. Takes a few minutes if you’re organised with shopping.

There might be other reasons to do school dinners - I don’t know about costs and nutrition and so on - but being a busy shift worker isn’t one.

Whinge · 04/11/2023 08:24

but compared to a sandwhich, crisps, chocolate bar, yogurt etc that most children have in their packed lunch I’d say it’s 100% better nutritionally.

I'd much rather a child eats that packed lunch than going an entire year eating just a cracker. I really hope the school informed the parents / carers that he wasn't eating, especially as crackers aren't served every day, so most days he wasn't actually eating anything.

Luxell934 · 04/11/2023 08:16

As someone who works in a school I would stick with the dinners. We always have lots of children in reception who eat very little for months and are extremely picky, those who’s parents continue to keep them on dinners always seem to eat a lot better as the year goes on. There’s one boy who literally ate nothing but a cracker every day for the first year, now in year 1 he’s clearing his plate every day. If children are hungry enough they will eat.

Our school food isn’t that bad a typical menu will be;

Chicken dinner with roast potatoes, carrots and broccoli.
Chicken curry with rice and naan
Burger and cubed potatoes with salad
Meatballs and pasta
Salmon fish fingers, rice and salad

Every day there’s a jacket potato option and a veggie alternative for the meat/fish.

Pudding is cheese and cracker, fruit, jelly and ice cream.

The meat isn’t great quality, obviously, but compared to a sandwhich, crisps, chocolate bar, yogurt etc that most children have in their packed lunch I’d say it’s 100% better nutritionally.

MortifiedSeptember · 04/11/2023 07:13

How about a compromise of only making packlunch on your days off rest? Or only days you work? If you make your own lunch then, if possible make her a replica of what you take. So she has the option of eating what you eat, or what the school makes.
Or give her a set amount of days a week. For example, every Tuesday and Thursday.

Pipistrellus · 04/11/2023 06:59

AhBiscuits · 04/11/2023 06:54

How many peoples very young children actually eat curry/chilli/spag Bol? I'd love it if they did but that's not the reality : (

Both of mine do, they're all firm favourites.

I would consider them child friendly dinners as its easy to hide veg.

AhBiscuits · 04/11/2023 06:54

How many peoples very young children actually eat curry/chilli/spag Bol? I'd love it if they did but that's not the reality : (

Both of mine do, they're all firm favourites.

AhBiscuits · 04/11/2023 06:46

Is there no choice?
Mine can choose the main, veggie main, jacket potato with beans or tuna or tomato pasta. We get the menu in advance, which is on a 3 weekly rotation, and it seems pretty good.
My older one is year 3 now and I let her choose. She tends to have school dinners twice a week and packed lunch the rest of the time. My son is y1 and he has school dinner (mostly pasta) every day.

EcoCustard · 04/11/2023 06:46

my two DC’s currently in ks1 & reception have a mix of packed lunch & school dinners. Our schools are brought in as no adequate kitchen facility so they aren’t ‘hot’ they are ok but not great. They choose with me what they want on those days it’s often the jacket potato with sponge pudding & custard or yoghurt. They love that one of the midday supervisors gives them the leftover custard if they are still hungry 😋 (she asked if this was ok). I do notice mine are quite hungry on those days so I would either compromise or go packed lunch.

110APiccadilly · 04/11/2023 06:41

Georgeandzippyzoo · 03/11/2023 07:05

I understand iour maths but if this happened sone kids would never have food. Their school meal is a lifeline ( and for some it's not just because of cash available to parents)

Are these children best served by the papering over the cracks of giving them school dinners though? If the issue isn't money, then they're severely neglected, aren't they?

Genuine questions. I've only ever once been personally involved with a family like this (was helping with a children's club they attended) and just feeding those kids was so far from enough. Although better than nothing I suppose.

sashh · 04/11/2023 06:38

Neurodiversitydoctor · 04/11/2023 05:36

Helpful !

I wasn't being serious. I thought that was clear.

Pooooochi · 04/11/2023 06:34

Also the sausages? They list the ingredients on the menu including brand names and you can search up the products. The sausages are horrendous. They are on catering websites priced at 20p a sausage and are only 44% meat content. The rest is heavily processed filler including soy and wheat starch.

Its really poor quality food compared to what my children are served at home.

Pooooochi · 04/11/2023 06:25

There's really nothing wrong with fish fingers, chips and beans

No there isnt. Not when its the good quality ones from the fridge section in sainsburys, a thick finger of cod fillet breadcrumbed. With freshly cut potato wedges from the air fryer.

At our school the chips are weird. The children describe them as more like mash and none eat them. The fishfingers are brakes catering crap, wafer thin with processed fish filling.

Pooooochi · 04/11/2023 06:11

School dinners look great on the menu but if you see the food that the school has actually served to your child, it can be pretty disgusting and very unhealthy.

This. I know a couple of people who work in the school who've acknowledged the food is absolutely grim.

Pooooochi · 04/11/2023 06:09

@jk987 spag bol and curry (made at home with tasty fresh ingredients) are popular meals in my house. I make the curry mild - its a bit like something between a korma & a tikka masala. The spag bol i make properly, i use a gino dacampo recipe.

Pooooochi · 04/11/2023 06:07

The school dinners at our school are shite. The government does not provide enough funding to ensure decent varied food.

My kids are used to good quality home cooking so they don't like school food. Eldest is a ravenous boy of a vintage where he will put aside dislike & just eat them, youngest (reception) just won't so has a packed lunch.

Pipistrellus · 04/11/2023 05:57

Jk987 · 03/11/2023 08:46

How many peoples very young children actually eat curry/chilli/spag Bol? I'd love it if they did but that's not the reality : (

This is pretty much our weekly dinners

Newtothis2005 · 04/11/2023 05:56

I would compromise and say she can have packed lunch 2 days a week. Then it means you can ensure she eats a bit more but encourages her to stick with school dinners and try more food

Neurodiversitydoctor · 04/11/2023 05:36

sashh · 03/11/2023 05:22

Do you get the menu ahead of time?

Could you negotiate one or two days of packed lunch, or send her with snacks? So if it is fish fingers and chips and beans she could take some salad or fruit.

I'd be surprised at anything salty though, schools have rules about things like salt.

Alternatively you could send her to France, she would fit right in.

Helpful !

Reugny · 04/11/2023 05:33

nickaldis · 03/11/2023 13:22

Anyone else has experience of the staff/dinner ladies policing what could be eaten in packed lunches? Nothing with nuts (fine). But no sweets or any desserts, biscuits unless it was Friday.

But the school dinners always had desserts every day of the week

This happens at my DDs school They also police snacks.

So if the OP's DD thinks she can get away with crisps and chocolate biscuits every day of the week she will be in for a surprise.

Anyway I have asked my DD what's she eats for school dinners and have randomly got the truth out of her. They are given chips once a week which is exactly what I got at primary school.

vernatheraven · 03/11/2023 20:07

My dd takes a flask in with soup, scouse, macaroni cheese, hot dogs occasionally.
It means I know she will actually eat something hot and will like it.

Voteva · 03/11/2023 13:57

School dinners look great on the menu but if you see the food that the school has actually served to your child, it can be pretty disgusting and very unhealthy.

Just make her packed lunches ffs. Disliking school lunch isn’t being picky, it’s having good taste! Yes they are free but they are gross.

A pasta salad is way more nutritious than soggy chips and beans 🤮

In the morning before school:

  • boil 70g pasta
  • toas it in lemon juice or olive oil to keep it fresh
  • cool it in fridge
  • add a little black pepper, parmesan and chopped cucumber/tomatoes

= happy healthy kid. Why force her to eat the world’s cheapest chips when she’s asking to be healthy?