Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

School dinners v packed lunch

259 replies

F05ters1 · 02/11/2023 23:30

Reception age daughter begging to go on packed lunches already after 6 weeks of full time school.

Every day without fail when I ask her what was for lunch I get... fishfingers chips and beans, I didn't like the chips and I'm off beans so I ate the fish fingers. Please can I take a packed lunch?

pasta and cheese, I didn't like the cheese and the pasta was soggy so I just had the biscuit for pudding. when can I go on packed lunch?

mince and dumplings today, mince was too salty and the dumpling was soggy, please can I go on packed lunches?

blah blah takes a packed lunch. (dd has even approached said mum who said her dd was a picky eater 🙄)

why can't you just say I'm a picky eater mum!

For context she'll eat a salmon fillet at home but won't eat a fishfinger.
She'll eat fillet steak but not a burger.
She eats all veg and salad but isn't keen on meat. I make soup packed with lentils and do lots of eggy things for protein

I'm torn. school meals are free and I work shifts, it's been a godsend not having to worry about lunch for the four year old restaurant critic! but she is so adamant, should I relent?

OP posts:
SkinnyMalinkyLankyLegs · 06/11/2023 10:36

Could you maybe do a packed lunch on a Sunday night for the Monday and then she'll just have to deal with school dinners Tue - Fri?

Conkersinautumn · 06/11/2023 10:31

I'm a midday supervisor I wouldn't eat the school.meals, most of the kids eat two bites and bin the rest.

HoppingPavlova · 06/11/2023 10:23

The problem with packed lunches these days is the concept of quantity, nutrition and making it Insta worthy. Take away most of that and they are not a drama.

Mine all had a piece of fruit for recess, and then either a vegemite, or vegemite with cheese sandwich, according to personal preference for lunch. Plus a water bottle filled from the tap. That was from first year at primary school through to last year of senior high school. Hardly onerous lunchboxes to put together each morning when they are little and something they can well do themselves when older. None of mine were ever hungry or faded away at school or were nutrient deficient. The bread was a good quality, low GI bread though. If they have a filling, nutritious breakfast and dinner, that’s fine for lunch.

Some people feel the need to send enough food for a week, covering all food groups, in trendy lunchboxes with a thousand compartments made out of unicorn dust so they can photo them. That leads to others thinking this is normal and that they need to follow suit.

C152 · 06/11/2023 10:09

YABU, although I understand the relief the time saving element of not having to think about and prepare a packed lunch brings. My DS sounds the same as your DD. If you want her to actually eat at school, send a packed lunch. The lunches she describe sound awful - would you eat them?

Notcontent · 06/11/2023 10:06

School meals may tick all the right boxes in terms of the nutritional rules they have to comply with but that does not mean they are actually healthy or nice.

Also, there are some schools that do have good food, but of course that does not mean they are representative of all school meals.

I listened to a radio programme recently about a school in Glasgow that introduced freshly cooked, healthy and appetising meals and it sounded like an amazing success story. On the other hand, I have some friends who recently moved to an area near Glasgow from a different country and their kids were shocked at how disgusting and unhealthy the food is - pretty much all revolting beige food with a few overcooked greens in the side to pass the nutritional test…

lilyandrosa · 06/11/2023 10:06

I bet you any money that after a while
of packed lunches she will want to go back to school dinners - kids are fickle and always think the grass is greener i’ve had it for years lol
Like others have said i’d definitely stick with school dinners, they really aren’t as bad as some are making out and there are usually multiple options.
Compromise on 1-2 packed lunches a week maybe as a sweetener

Kathryn1983 · 06/11/2023 09:51

curtaintwitchersannonymous · 03/11/2023 06:53

school dinners should be abolished in my opinion, the amount of money wasted on them is insane. The tax payer is paying the wages of all those people who make and serve them, plus the energy costs, and the schools have sacrificed all that space for out of bounds kitchens, and the food itself is worth about 80p, if that. You could increase child benefit by 10x the value of the food they are getting and still make a profit by abolishing them

A true comment likely only made by someone who got free school meals and milk throughout their school life!
so much evidence on how important it is for kids to have a school meal all together and all the same or similar and yet you ignore it all! Christ We should be fighting for the opposite- free school meals for all primary kids not just up to year 2!
if politicians can get free meals when at work why can't our kids!?

mushroom3 · 06/11/2023 09:51

I would suggest you email the school and ask for a copy of the menu. They are often on a three week rotation. Vegetarian options may work better for her. You could sit with her and make suggestions. If she is hungry she will eat. I would suggest sticking to school dinners. Ask her about whether everyone sits together. It maybe she is jealous of where the packed lunch children sit. It's hard making a variety of nutritional packed lunches, specially as you are a busy working parent. It's still early days, she has only had half a term of school dinners!

TiredParentAlways · 06/11/2023 09:45

Sounds like she's playing you. She wants packed lunch because her friend has it. The lunch will have more than one option so she could choose something different. She's deliberately trying to get packed lunches so telling you the food wasn't good. It definitely would never be too salty 😂

Stick to school dinners. You are working hard to provide for her and don't need the extra stress of making a packed lunch, the only sacrifice she needs to make is to eat the free food. Don't back down. I know I sound harsh but my 4 year tryed this for a couple of weeks and I outright told her it was never happening and suddenly she was eating all her lunch when I asked her about. Absolute miracle 🙄.

Kids know how to play their parents by the time they're in reception and try every trick to get what they want. I'd explain to DD exactly why it wasn't going to happen in a nice way to help her understand and explain again every time she asked emphasising that pack lunches are not going to happen. Some times we have to put our foot down for the sale of our own mental health. Packed lunches are more work than people think and if you're working they eat in to precious resting time (never mind the cost). I also explained that my DD could have packed lunch when she can make one herself so now she's started learning how to make her own sandwiches on the weekend 😂 Win, win.

northbacchus · 06/11/2023 09:45

Would she do better on the school's veggie option?

Magicmama92 · 06/11/2023 09:34

We do school dinners three days and packed lunch two.
Personally if she's not eating them of do packed lunches. I do it the night before and then it's not too much effort in the morning.
She will have pasta or sandwiches, crisps, fruit, carrot sticks, jelly and a marshmallow squares or a packet of biscuits.
Can you ask school for a menu and maybe sort out to just send lunch on the days it's good she really won't eat. My daughter hates pizza so takes a packed lunch on those days and the days they do Currys. So every Tuesday and Thursday for her. Means she still gets hot dinners and it's not as expensive as doing it every day xx

Moveoverdarlin · 06/11/2023 09:33

My daughter is exactly the same. But I’m not giving in and making a packed lunch. She’s just as fussy with what would be in a packed lunch and would end up eating the same thing everyday. So she might as well be fussy with school dinners which are free and avoid the faff of doing sandwiches every evening. She’s not great with general table etiquette so I want her to have proper hot dinners, using a knife and fork with all her friends.

Panama2 · 06/11/2023 09:24

Is it really about the food? My granddaughter switched to taking packed lunches as it took so long getting served it cut down her lunchtime break to socialise with friends.

Lottie4 · 06/11/2023 09:15

I work at a school, it's not all bad but I'd say only about 30% I'd find appetising. Most schools these days have a salad bar, offer jacket potato with a couple of topping choices and sometimes fruit as a dessert - would she eat these?

If not, I guess you have to weigh up what your priorities are, a free meal and a hungry child or a packed lunch. Doesn't take much time to make up a sandwich or if you're making something like tomato pasta yourself the night before, keep some aside for her lunch. Bananas take no preparation and apples/grapes doesn't take long to wash. Ideally you'd avoid packaging, but things like babybel, cereal bars, yogurt, also take very little prep.

Skyscrapers921 · 06/11/2023 09:13

Stick to school meals.

Canisaysomething · 06/11/2023 09:12

Agree with the other poster - packed lunches from year 3 onwards when we have to pay. There is no way I’m going to spend money wasting time making a packed lunch when dinners are free. I value my own free time and sanity more than that. My eldest was also satisfied with that and now in year 3 has packed lunches twice a week.

Canisaysomething · 06/11/2023 09:10

Are there not meal options to choose from? Ours have 3-4 choices every day that we pre select at the start of term.

Unicorntastic · 06/11/2023 09:10

My DD is Y1 but in reception she was the same, I think it was because she was used to packed lunches at Forest nursery but she seems to have got used to school dinners now and I assume she eats them, I never really know what’s she had though as she doesn’t always know what the dish is called. The school have recently changed to parents picking the lunch choice online which I quite like as I can vary it and avoid certain things if I know I am cooking a similar meal later.
from what I can gather reception kids all mostly eat jacket potatoes at school, or at least they did at my DDs school!

OneHornedFlyingPurplePeopleEater · 06/11/2023 09:04

School dinners at our school don't sound great, but there's always a jacket potato or baguette option for those that don't want the main.

Mine wants packed lunches too. I've told her she can in year three, and that seems to have satisfied her. With the odd special day where I make packed lunch (we can pick day to day at ours).

ClairDeLaLune · 06/11/2023 08:55

Alternatively you could send her to France, she would fit right in.

⬆️ this. Shameful in this country we expect our kids to eat crap. Your daughter sounds like she has great taste in food, and it’s sad she gets fed poor food at school. I would aim for a compromise - maybe tell her she needs to eat 3 meals at school and let her choose these off the menu - there is one presumably? Then do her 2 packed lunches.

Paddleboarder · 06/11/2023 08:48

Schools generally have 3 or 4 options - hot dinner, vegetarian option, school packed lunch and sometimes a jacket potato option. I work in schools and some have better menus than others but there is quite a lot of waste as some children are just generally very picky or don't focus. I used to let my child have a packed lunch 2 days a week and we had the menu in advance so chose those days according to what he liked/didn't like.

NadiyahZ · 06/11/2023 08:25

My son is also in reception and has been on packed lunches from the beginning, partly to accommodate his dietary requirements (no pork or dairy), and partly due to him needing a lot of sensory input at meal times, and being unfamiliar with the meals on offer.

He has a little thermos pot that keeps his food piping hot till lunchtime (we tested it out), this has made a huge difference compared to his lunchbox at preschool as he can take hot leftovers from the night before, rather than preparing a whole lunch in the morning. Today he’s taking a spicy pepperpot stew with dumplings, but we also send curries, rice, pasta or homemade soups in the pot, school have been fine with this, and the teacher often jokes that she’s a little jealous of his lunches.

Occasionally he’ll take a sandwich with hummus, toum (a garlic spread- like aioli), lots of rocket, pickles and grated carrot, but that’s about as fancy as I’ll get in the morning, sometimes I’ll add grilled chicken or falafel if we’ve any in the fridge.

I’m lucky enough to be a stay at home mum, but I don’t think reheating leftovers is that much work in the grand scheme of things and it means I can monitor exactly how much he’s eating (we’re waiting to see a dietician as he struggles to gain weight).

therealcookiemonster · 06/11/2023 07:59

sounds like your dd has good taste. I would just give her a packed lunch. doesn't have to be complicated.

Spottyblobby · 06/11/2023 07:45

You say you work shifts, what sort of shifts are we talking & what is the childcare set up? If you are picking up from after school club/childminder etc at say 6, arriving home at 10 past, I think that is too late to start a 4 year olds dinner as they won’t eat until half 6/7 best case scenario, although I know lots of Europeans would disagree & they do eat later. I would expect a 4 year old to be in bath at that time not eating their hot meal. However if you are picking up at 3:30 with the rest of the day off then happy days give them packed lunch & do a hot evening meal.

Beautiful3 · 06/11/2023 07:33

We had that issue too. I switched to packed lunches, when she could have had hot dinners. It was better because I could see how much she ate, and she'd finish it off after school. Now she wants hot dinners again! So she has them every Friday.