Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

School dinners v packed lunch

259 replies

F05ters1 · 02/11/2023 23:30

Reception age daughter begging to go on packed lunches already after 6 weeks of full time school.

Every day without fail when I ask her what was for lunch I get... fishfingers chips and beans, I didn't like the chips and I'm off beans so I ate the fish fingers. Please can I take a packed lunch?

pasta and cheese, I didn't like the cheese and the pasta was soggy so I just had the biscuit for pudding. when can I go on packed lunch?

mince and dumplings today, mince was too salty and the dumpling was soggy, please can I go on packed lunches?

blah blah takes a packed lunch. (dd has even approached said mum who said her dd was a picky eater 🙄)

why can't you just say I'm a picky eater mum!

For context she'll eat a salmon fillet at home but won't eat a fishfinger.
She'll eat fillet steak but not a burger.
She eats all veg and salad but isn't keen on meat. I make soup packed with lentils and do lots of eggy things for protein

I'm torn. school meals are free and I work shifts, it's been a godsend not having to worry about lunch for the four year old restaurant critic! but she is so adamant, should I relent?

OP posts:
Manthide · 07/11/2023 11:26

Wheredidyougonow · 03/11/2023 08:18

My ds is very fussy but he would eat what's in school and not the same thing at home. He's in a school that has an excellent menu, lots of options that I would love to eat! (Independent school).
I refuse to go packed lunch because that would just be the biggest pain for me and he would not be exposed to variety. His choice is eat the school lunch or starve. Funny enough he manages to eat it. I would keep her on the school lunch if you think it's good food though . If she isn't a fussy child then I would so packed lunch.

At my ds's old school they were not allowed packed lunches and school meals were included in the fees. The meals were excellent and he definitely got his money's worth

flutterby1 · 07/11/2023 09:54

Just won't catch me taking the time to shop for, pay for and prepare lunches when I've already paid taxes and so it goes towards a balanced meal ( not always an ideal in appeal but most of the time they're fine and a lot of the time they're nice dinners ) so I spend the money and time on other things.

Pooooochi · 06/11/2023 20:06

School meals may tick all the right boxes in terms of the nutritional rules they have to comply with but that does not mean they are actually healthy or nice.

This. You can get a lot nutritionally from a slice of cheap bread with a cup of milk & a vitamin, doesn't make it a good meal.

Often a chunk of the calorie is coming from a starchy pudding because it is a cheap. They aren't sugar laden, as they aren't allowed to be, however.

My kids get flavourful, nutritionally dense, fresh food at home. It's not cheap even with careful meal planning, solar panels on my roof reducing my energy bill, and me giving my time for free to cook & serve the food.

I honestly can't blame them for being disgusted at the reheated, processed, bland crap the school caterers serve up but equally i can't see how they can do much better on the budget they get.

CowboyJoanna · 06/11/2023 19:56

I do packed lunches for all four kids.
Sandwich, a piece of fruit for the girls and fridge raiders for my son, some veg, yoghurt for my youngest two, packet of crisps and a drink. The school dinners offered at the primary school are just rubbish.

Don't know how the dinners are at eldest DD's high school, but she has made it clear she wanted to bring her own food even before starting year 7 Grin

Yummybumble · 06/11/2023 19:34

I spent years doing packed lunches for older children, they are a pain and cost a heap of money (if you want to feed them actual food). Sandwiches get old so I ended up doing Bento boxes etc. With the younger children it was never an option put to them so it was never a discussion. I will admit that the school dinner offerings aren’t what our nursery prepared or what I do at home but it’s one less thing to worry about.

However, how much is she actually eating? Maybe worth a convo with the school dinner supervisors.

Sundownmemories · 06/11/2023 18:39

Honestly if she has a healthy appetite and enjoys food I’d let her have packed lunches. School dinners are rubbish. Especially in primary. I know it’s convenient and I’d love my children to have them too for that reason but they’re just not for them. My youngest especially won’t have school dinners, free or not. Don’t get me wrong he’ll eat pizza, nuggets and the rest of the child friendly crap but we don’t eat that at home on a daily basis. His favourite meal is chorizo in a creamy tomato sauce with peppers and spring onions. He revolted at school dinners.

Luckyduc · 06/11/2023 18:17

I made my kid have school meals and theb I started working in his school and saw the school meals and was horrified. Worst dinners I've ever seen. Tiny portions and often children will pick pasta, which is just cooked pasta then if they choose they can have the sauce poured over it. Doesn't look good and personally I think this is a bad way to have pasta as I like sauces cooked with the pasta. I was happy to make my kid a packed lunch after that

Jules2369 · 06/11/2023 17:51

No it’s exactly the same in the school I work in (I’m in Scotland) Strict guidelines are followed as to what can and can’t be made, how much salt, sugar etc is in each meal, how much veg, fruit etc must be served. The largest percentage of the school meals our kiddies get are really good.

Tiggerbabe2 · 06/11/2023 16:24

My daughter tried school dinners for a bit, she was starving when she came out of school (beyond the normal after school snack hunger).
One day she told me she had ice cream for lunch. That was it. Just ice cream.
She's been packed lunches ever since and prefers it that way. I didn't even bother trying with my son as he's such a fussy eater it would never have worked.

ObsidianGrape · 06/11/2023 15:59

My daughter is also fussy and has been asking to switch to packed lunches since soon after starting reception. Year 1 now. I have held firm and made her stay on school dinners. She was picky and didn't eat much as it is. So at least at school she's got options to try different food and force herself to try things. She still wants to go on packed lunch, but by having school dinners she's tried more foods and some of it she likes. So I'd rather she stayed on school dinners to try and combat her fussy eating. So far I think it's working.

NoThanksymm · 06/11/2023 15:53

Free hot meal!

maybe pack a backup sandwich that she will eat but won’t like, and that doesn’t need refrigeration so it can stay in there all week if needed ( ie fake nut butter). Then she has something for the day they make something totally unpalatable. Also she should make the backup sandwich.

The free hot meal is also getting here to try things! Which is great! She at least tried the soggy pasta and mince.

Baba197 · 06/11/2023 14:11

My son is picky but he now eats most of what the school gives him, took the 1st term but he will now try much more than used to. Ours have meat/vegi options plus jacket potato. I would persist as they’re free and maybe just needs longer to get used to them

Panama2 · 06/11/2023 14:02

Again with my grandchildren at their primary the ones having school lunches must go the the dining hall those with packed lunches may stay in their classroom and guess what a film is put on for them. Is it any wonder they opt for pack up?

Simonjt · 06/11/2023 12:55

TillyTrifle · 06/11/2023 11:03

Universal free meals for infants is a terrible
policy. Much better to means test and then spend more on making actually decent food for the ones who need it. I live in a very MC area and 95% of the school I’m sure don’t need the free meals. But because the budget is stretched so thin the food is tiny and so unhealthy. The comfortable kids go home to another hot meal, this time nutritious and filling, while the poorer kids have had their hot meal and that’s that.

Im lucky not to need the free food so have persuaded my two onto mainly packed lunches. We bought food flasks and send them in with the hot meals they like through winter - chilli and rice, pasta and bolognese etc. Although they still insist on school meals on pizza day which I can live with.

School meals also come with sugar laden cakes and desserts every day. They serve yogurt and fruit too but guess which most kids choose.

They really need to charge the parents who can afford it and lift the quality by about 300%.

So in your position OP I would make packed lunches. I know it’s one more thing but it’s what, 5-10 minutes to ensure your child has a nutritious and filling meal?

Budgets don’t have to be high, making two decent meals isn’t expensive. Where we live all school dinners are free during compulsory schooling. The average cost is £2.20 per meal (the actual cost in primary is lower due to portion sizes). At my sons school there is at least one fish, one meat and one veggie option a day, along with steamed veg, salad, fruit, the pasta, potatoes etc as appropriate. Children don’t have to order, theres enough that they can have a bit of everything if they wish.

The food is well cooked (veg are just grey slop) and actually seasoned, puddings also aren’t a mix of sweeteners and margarine either.

saffy2 · 06/11/2023 12:31

My daughter is very fussy and I am making her have school dinners. I don’t want to make a packed lunch, and the school dinners is good wholesome food, and I want her to open up to things. So far we are managing, but there is a fair amount of moaning. I’m not giving in. 😂 I understand your pain. It’s really hard.

TempsPerdu · 06/11/2023 12:27

Alternatively you could send her to France, she would fit right in

Absolutely this - and add most of the rest of Europe to that. I find so many of these responses, about children ‘eating anything’ and not wanting to raise fussy eaters really depressing. As a society, we have such low standards around food for our kids. My DM is still traumatised by being force fed revolting school dinners back in the ‘60s - she’s the ultimately fussy eater now as it really messed up her perception of healthy food and eating.

I totally understand that school food varies widely, and that a lot of people have no choice. But luckily our family does and, personally - having spent a lot of time in schools before DD was born and seen what was on offer - there was no way I was going to make her eat school dinners, free or not. Here, the menu that’s sent out each week looks perfectly fine, but bears very little resemblance to what’s actually served up, and portions are tiny. So many UPFs and meat from dubious sources (‘chicken sausage’ in a dry bun was a particular low).

DD (Year 1 now) has had packed lunches from the outset. She’s the only one in her class, and we do get the odd comment from others about it, but she’s happy and we’re assured that she’s eating a filling and nutritious lunch every day. She has a mix of sandwiches/home made flapjack/fruit/cheese and biscuits and hot food in a food flask (pesto or tomato pasta, meatballs, sausage and beans, home made soups etc).

It’s not really schools’ or parents’ fault in most cases, but as a society we should be doing better by our kids.

therealcookiemonster · 06/11/2023 11:41

flutterby1 · 06/11/2023 05:18

School dinners at this age are free, nutritious, balanced and I don't have to make or pay for packed lunches, I wouldn't dream of swapping!
She'll have to just learn to be less fussy.

nutritious and balanced? are you by any chance in another country? because that is certainly not the case in most schools in the UK... even a lot of the fee paying ones! obviously it varies by region.... but mostly its crap

Fourmagpies · 06/11/2023 11:38

We compromised and did packed lunches twice a week. We did that all the way through primary, even when we had to pay for it. They now have packed lunches every day in secondary, it's quick but not the best - a wrap, packet of crisps and a granola bar or flapjack - but better than what they choose themselves from the canteen! They do get a healthy dinner.

DeOro · 06/11/2023 11:32

Eww I'd rather eat soggy pasta

KingsleyBorder · 06/11/2023 11:29

ShitChicken · 03/11/2023 02:16

Without question. The school dinners at our place are rank, I wouldn't eat them, I wouldn't expect my child to eat them. Not that they are made without love, they are, but they're not nutritious or tasty.

My top tip is, make five sandwiches at the beginning of the week, tin foil them individually and freeze. Each morning just remove one pack from the fridge and stick it in the lunch box, it'll be defrosted by lunchtime.

Christ. Defrosted sandwich sounds ranker than the rankest school dinner.

Wetblanket78 · 06/11/2023 11:23

Get a food flask keeps food warm for 8 hours. Can use up what's leftover from the night before. I did this for DD when her respite started asking for £5 to give her a bit of tea.

TillyTrifle · 06/11/2023 11:03

Universal free meals for infants is a terrible
policy. Much better to means test and then spend more on making actually decent food for the ones who need it. I live in a very MC area and 95% of the school I’m sure don’t need the free meals. But because the budget is stretched so thin the food is tiny and so unhealthy. The comfortable kids go home to another hot meal, this time nutritious and filling, while the poorer kids have had their hot meal and that’s that.

Im lucky not to need the free food so have persuaded my two onto mainly packed lunches. We bought food flasks and send them in with the hot meals they like through winter - chilli and rice, pasta and bolognese etc. Although they still insist on school meals on pizza day which I can live with.

School meals also come with sugar laden cakes and desserts every day. They serve yogurt and fruit too but guess which most kids choose.

They really need to charge the parents who can afford it and lift the quality by about 300%.

So in your position OP I would make packed lunches. I know it’s one more thing but it’s what, 5-10 minutes to ensure your child has a nutritious and filling meal?

Planesmistakenforstars · 06/11/2023 11:00

Do her friends mostly have packed lunches? Because that's likely the reason she's gunning for them, and she might not be telling the whole truth about what the dinners involve and what she eats of them. I'd stick with the dinners under the circumstances.

GonnaGetGoingReturns · 06/11/2023 10:43

Iamnotthe1 · 03/11/2023 06:57

I have to say, as someone who works in schools, I don't recognise the way school dinners are being described here. There are strict nutritional guidelines at a primary level where specific limits, minimums, maximums, etc. have to be adhered to across the planned menu. Many of the dishes are adjusted to take account of this, including things like what is actually going into the burger meat to improve it's nutritional value before making the burgers, and there's a huge amount of veg and salad served with each meal. Secondary school lunches are a different story with no guidelines in place at all.

Perhaps my experience is the exception but the dinners served at my current school, and at other schools I've worked at/with, have always been lovely. At least 30% to 40% of the staff at my current school order dinners every day.

DNephew’s (5) school dinners are great too (I’ve seen his menus!) with strict nutritional guidelines. He loves them and his DP would do packed lunches if he stopped them though.

Leopardpj · 06/11/2023 10:37

The school lunches sound awful. But I also fully understand the desire not to surrender her having a hot, free lunch, I feel exactly the same!
Can you talk to the school about the provision? Our primary school dinners were like this until parents raised concerns, they changed their provider in the summer, and now have this amazing local provider which does proper nutritious food and my kids really love them (Menu — FUEL FOR LEARNING (fuel4learning.co.uk)
Could you raise this with the head and see what he/she says? I bet you're not the only family unhappy with the meals if they are that bad!

Menu — FUEL FOR LEARNING

https://www.fuel4learning.co.uk/menu

Swipe left for the next trending thread