Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

The world has tried men in charge and look what they have done

140 replies

Eaglemom · 02/11/2023 23:06

AIBU... if the world was run by women it would not be in this fucking mess. Children’s and women’s lives would be worth more than land or grievances. Young men would not be groomed for war and aggression. What the hell are men doing to this earth?

OP posts:
IDontHateRainbows · 03/11/2023 07:49

Yeah cos Liz Truss did a sterling job of being in charge.

graciousmouse · 03/11/2023 07:46

As our culture worships men, it goes without saying that many institutions also run with a patriarchal culture even if women get the top jobs. Lots of the women who do get promoted are emulating the patriarchal behaviour of men, in order to get promoted. And this is not necessarily a great thing in terms of making society fairer to women. So until our society changes on a fundamental level, in some ways you will end up with a patriarchy anyway, even in some cases where a woman is a leader.

That said I absolutely support the idea we need more women leaders and I think they would do a better job than men in most cases!

DysonSphere · 03/11/2023 07:41

Jacinda Ardern is quite polarising.

Some people think she was a nasty, dictatorial, narcissist who conveniently quit before the consequences of her policies caught up with her and her party.

Other people think she was sweetness and light and close to being saintly.

I do think what can make women perhaps more dangerous as politicians is this ability to appear inoffensive and adopt a fake motherly persona, much like Margaret Thatcher also did in her early days of running for PM. Women are supposedly better communicators so (perhaps) have a better affinity for manipulating the media with the right gestures. Ardern was the Queen of that, she had it down to a T. She was amazingly good at it.

To me, she's a demonstration of an uncomfortable truth about women. Their greater tendency than men to adopt 'Be Kind' as a motto when the end results are anything but kind.

Iamnotthe1 · 03/11/2023 07:26

Your idea makes the assumption that men and women as entire groups are inherently different naturally and based on nothing more than their biological sex and that if society were different those traits would still be there. That's an enormous assumption to make. It's entirely plausible that certain traits have become more masculine and feminine over time because of the roles each group took in society rather than the other way round.

The suggestion, for example, that women would have created a less aggressive society if they'd been in charge from the start is deeply flawed. Do you honestly think that if we'd had women leaders in the past, they wouldn't have wanted to expand their people's terrority and make life better/possible for their people? Do you think they'd have let their people starve rather than aggressively conquering the lands belonging to those around them and taking their resources? I'd argue that aggression, decisiveness, ambition, etc. are not male traits nor female traits: they are leadership traits.

meatbaseddessert · 03/11/2023 07:12

Boomboom22 · 02/11/2023 23:20

Generally I'd agree but NZ didn't go well. Or Liz!

Um. How did NZ not go well?

HomiesAlone · 03/11/2023 07:11

You have a point about patriarchy/testosterone being problematic. It's not men per se but, the typical traits associative with toxic masculinity (power, more, efficiency, strength, no emotions, rationale, no weakness, war etc). There will he individual women with this trait but overall they're quite gendered traits.

Dowhadiddydiddydum · 03/11/2023 07:04

Yea a greater proportion of women MPs would be great, but also more MPs from ‘normal’ backgrounds who actually understand normal working/middle class life. People who grew up knowing what it’s like to be cold because you can’t afford to have the heating on all the time not cold because you’ve spent too long on the ski slopes.

Busephalus · 03/11/2023 06:57

In this country the problem is generally privately educated white middle class men. They are instilled with such great self belief from such a young age, their sense of superiority, arrogance and antipathy towards others is destructive. Not sure its as common for women to have those character traits, though obviously some do.

Cookingdoesntgettougher · 03/11/2023 06:51

Currently the women that make it in politics in the uk are sharp elbowed and similar to the men. That might change if the balance was more 50:50. I’m sceptical though it takes a certain type of person. If you have a constituency in Devon or NW England or Scotland you are accepting either your children spend time travelling to London as well or you see them quite a bit less. Your past will be scrutinised so you will have a thick skin.

We also need a different attitude from voters (I include myself) as well. If we want difficult issues to be resolved we need to accept that there will be compromises.

Conservatives will have to see that you can’t have good public services and endless austerity. I’m a Labour voter but need to accept that it won’t just be “the rich” paying extra so I might not get all the improvements I want.

everyone needs to agree that decisions on paying for care will be painful. We may lose inheritance we thought we could pass on and yes we need to pay more tax as people get older and fit adults will work longer. There needs to be cross party agreement so people can plan.

Sayitaintso33 · 03/11/2023 06:51

I don't think you can compare the public with the private - i.e., our bosses with our prime ministers and other public leaders.
Many women prefer male bosses because they find it easier to get what they want/need from a man than a woman.
My brother prefers a female boss because women are usually less confrontational with him. As he puts it: there are none of the dick measuring contests.

EspressoMacchiato · 03/11/2023 06:16

Current politicians cannot possibly give an accurate picture of what women in charge would be like.

Currently women in politics need to be aggressive asshats because the men are mediocre asshats.

Comparing the few women who made it into prominent positions to the pasty white dick swinging mediocre men who have ruined the planet is absurd. Apples and oranges.

MooFroo · 03/11/2023 06:09

I think we need more NORMAL people in charge of more companies, organisations etc - the so called professional fuck things up way too much and don’t have any real ground level insights.

If me or you or any normal person spent a few days in the NHS for example we’d be able to quickly see and fix so many things. The same in politics - we can see the issues and have simple and clear thoughts on how to fix them that those in power just don’t have.

maybe if we take away some of the power and focus on FIXING things, we’d get somewhere

SweetFemaleAttitude · 03/11/2023 05:40

SoupDragon · 02/11/2023 23:14

I think women would have fucked it up just as thoroughly. It's naïve to think it's all down to the sex of who is in charge. Women aren't some kind of perfect angel.

Not angels, no, but the aren't the aggressive, dick waving, pissing contest, my bombs bigger than your bomb, pricks either.

I definitely think the world would be a much more compassionate place if it were run by women.

Tighginn · 03/11/2023 05:20

In would choose to work with men over women, every single time. Ding, dong...

junbean · 03/11/2023 05:09

Understatement!

WandaWonder · 03/11/2023 05:03

I presume they would be perfect as every women is, unless you are a MIL, mother, SIL, cousin, sister, a friend of your child, a female teacher, politician etc.

mjf981 · 03/11/2023 04:41

I work with mostly woman and it can be a nightmare. Back stabbing, bitchiness, sulky. The best workplaces have been about 50:50 male: female, so I'd prefer this. Imagine the drama with all women at the top!

CherryMyBrandy · 03/11/2023 01:13

divinededacende · 02/11/2023 23:17

Full disclosure; I'm a man. But I've also thought the same at times. We're getting better (slowly) but we're still the product of a world that tells us we're the masters of the universe and it'll be a few generations yet before the elite of the world aren't a bunch of dick-swinging morons.

I do think there's a part of it that goes beyond gender though. Of the comparatively fewer examples of female world leaders, there have been some terrible examples there too. I think the issue is with the with the personality types that tend to seek power. Isn't there a saying about those who desire power are usually the least suited or something similar?

What we really need is a world with much better, more representative systems and a lot more accountability but that's a whoooole other discussion.

Edited

I think you are absolutely right and this is often something we discuss at home - the issue is that the type of people who would seek to have that power are probably exactly the sort of people you don't want having it. It attracts people that are driven by/motivated by status and/or power for themselves - it's highly likely to attract narcissists and sociopaths at worst, at best the type A personalities, who are ultra competitive, egocentric and can be hostile and aggressive. Not really altruistic people who want the best thing for others/the country/the world as a whole.

The whole system is screwed basically. And don't get me started on the economy and how that is completely fixed against about 99% of the population.

Not sure there is an answer to it though. How do you make personality types that aren't driven by power and status, do a job that offers power and status, and is very very difficult and that you are likely to be constantly criticised for and told you have got it wrong. Any takers?

TempestTost · 03/11/2023 00:55

Looking at all female and female dominated institutions, I can't say I agree.

My daughter is about to change schools due to horrible bullying from other girls. The management in my workplace is toxic because of several female personalities. Not unique situations.

Women might fuck it up differently but t would still be fucked up.

MiddleagedBeachbum · 03/11/2023 00:08

1000 percent agree!!!!

GirrlCrush · 03/11/2023 00:07

SocksAndTheCity · 02/11/2023 23:34

Yeah, we definitely need the likes of Truss/Braverman/Patel in the chair. Jesus wept.

This wasn't the best thought out thread..

GirrlCrush · 03/11/2023 00:07

SoupDragon · 02/11/2023 23:14

I think women would have fucked it up just as thoroughly. It's naïve to think it's all down to the sex of who is in charge. Women aren't some kind of perfect angel.

This 100%!

ACGTHelixA · 02/11/2023 23:59

it would be intriguing to see a parallel universe where women ruled

DysonSphere · 02/11/2023 23:57

reesewithoutaspoon · 02/11/2023 23:49

What about the likes of Hancock, Rees Mogg, Johnson, Cummings, Sunak, Raab, Hunt, and Gove?
I don't see those men doing a particularly stella job either, but no one extrapolates that to men shouldn't be allowed to be leaders anymore because those few are shit.
I can name a lot more male politicians who have been involved in scandals and corruption than female ones.

The point is the women do not do a better job by default of their sex. That's based on some idea of women being nicer. Fairer, less prone to corruption.

I went to a girls school with female based hierarchies, where mean girl bullying shite drove some girls to contemplating suicide. One girl I know nearly ended up dead.

So I know this 'the world would be better with women in charge' rhetoric is a total untruth.

reesewithoutaspoon · 02/11/2023 23:55

Very few women in power truly have power though. they are operating in a mans world where they often are too busy trying to out man the men
The few times women have had absolute power have been under monarchies as queens and they usually do pretty well.