Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

The world has tried men in charge and look what they have done

140 replies

Eaglemom · 02/11/2023 23:06

AIBU... if the world was run by women it would not be in this fucking mess. Children’s and women’s lives would be worth more than land or grievances. Young men would not be groomed for war and aggression. What the hell are men doing to this earth?

OP posts:
notatthisage · 03/11/2023 09:07

I suppose there is also the question of how far the sex makes a difference or whether certain personality types are attracted to, and achieve, leadership. So you always get the same type of person in leadership.

But then of course, leaders need their parties to support them, and I do think more women in politics mean more analysis of how women’s lives are different from men’s and more consideration of how policies affect women. Though there is still not enough consideration of this by politicians of either sex, and women’s interests are still quickly made secondary when it seen as politically expedient to do so. As events in the past ten years or so have shown.

notatthisage · 03/11/2023 08:57

AdamRyan · 03/11/2023 08:15

This thread is hilarious. Voting says one thing then all the comments are the opposite!

That’s a common phenomena! I’ve noticed it a lot. I’d love to know why!

BottleShipDown · 03/11/2023 08:57

We need people that are smart enough to govern, maintain compassion and integrity and make tough decisions when evidence suggests it’s the right thing. People that are not so driven by power and their own career progression. I really don’t think it’s a male/female thing.

I think what we need is people of any gender, with balance. What we have in the UK currently is too much ‘dick swinging’ as a PP rightly put it - even the women. It’s a race to the bottom as to who can be most outrageously crass and uncaring to keep the rabid DM readers happy.

Where are the core values (unless you class hate and greed as values)?

I think we also need higher standards of behaviour in Government in the UK. The way that our UK Government have behaved in the last few years has been appalling and if I behaved in just a small but similar way at work I’d be sacked, and rightly so. Aside from the lying, stealing, law breaking etc, if talked in meetings like they do in Parliament (shouting over each other, calling each other names etc) I’d not be taken seriously and it would be a massive issue.

What we need is more balance.

notatthisage · 03/11/2023 08:54

Toloveandtowork · 02/11/2023 23:47

I don't think we can say what it would be like if women had 'the power' because women are so dominated by the men in power that we can't tell.

This.

If women were the leaders we would be living in a world ( mostly? Totally) free from misogyny. We don’t know what that would mean for how women are.

And if women were the world leaders, it would mean it were not an equal society but one skewed towards women. And what we don’t know what that would mean for how women are.

Would we use our powers for good or evil?! Who knows!

But I’m guessing, like men, we would enjoy being the dominant sex, would enjoy looking down on men, would enjoy the power and would want to hold onto it. I’m not quite so sure if we would be starting lots of wars though.

Stillandquiet · 03/11/2023 08:25

@Sayitaintso33 alot of what you mentioned there were liberties that shouldn’t have needed to be granted because they should never have been considered privileges in the first place, the rest are technologies that have arguably facilitated a negative trajectory and perpetuated humanity destroying the planet and also living to 100 isn’t a fucking great idea on any level- painful, miserable and expensive, some fucker makes 100 grand a year out of that misery though running a ‘care’ home .
a selfless, symbiotic existence looks much more like our ape cousins who stay where they’re fucking put, and don’t bother anyone or destroy any other creatures habitat for shits and giggles.

Zuve · 03/11/2023 08:20

Come back common sense and care. The guys forget we are all one family, the Human family

meatbaseddessert · 03/11/2023 08:18

DysonSphere · 03/11/2023 07:41

Jacinda Ardern is quite polarising.

Some people think she was a nasty, dictatorial, narcissist who conveniently quit before the consequences of her policies caught up with her and her party.

Other people think she was sweetness and light and close to being saintly.

I do think what can make women perhaps more dangerous as politicians is this ability to appear inoffensive and adopt a fake motherly persona, much like Margaret Thatcher also did in her early days of running for PM. Women are supposedly better communicators so (perhaps) have a better affinity for manipulating the media with the right gestures. Ardern was the Queen of that, she had it down to a T. She was amazingly good at it.

To me, she's a demonstration of an uncomfortable truth about women. Their greater tendency than men to adopt 'Be Kind' as a motto when the end results are anything but kind.

What were the 'consequences' of the NZ Labour Party policies?

Sayitaintso33 · 03/11/2023 08:18

The wheel, the road, the internal combustion engine, concrete, steel, glass, hospitals and healthcare, schools and education for all, the Arts, the phone, the computer, democracy (the vote in UK for all men in 1918, the vote in the UK for all women 1928), a justice system that I have criticised often but it is still far preferable to the wild west, freedom of speech, freedom of assembly, freedom to protest, often relative affluence and impressive life-expectancy.

This all had to be created from chaos. I'm not so sure that men have done that badly.

AdamRyan · 03/11/2023 08:15

This thread is hilarious. Voting says one thing then all the comments are the opposite!

Stillandquiet · 03/11/2023 08:15

Difficult to say. We have no examples because the only women ever in power were just sock puppets of a patriarchal society anyway. If you dissect what’s actually wrong with humanity it boils down to greed, capitalism, lack of connection with the natural world, hubris etc. If a truly matriarchal society would have changed that then great, I can’t be sure it would. As a general rule women are slightly less aggressive, possessive and less likely to invade a neighbouring country for glory and gold I expect as those types of things seem to be attached to testosterone, but I think we’re shit because we’re human. It’s a species thing.

aswarmofmidges · 03/11/2023 08:13

Companies that have a more balanced board and senior management do better than male dominated companies

There isn't enough data to compare to female dominated companies ( may be collection , may be not enough such companies )

Aid given to the females in a society benefits the society much more than when given to the males - i recall one community buying TVs and the other buying toilets/ I bet you can guess in which community the women got the aid

The role of women in the Irish peace process has recently been admitted to have been pretty necessary

Whilst you do get bad women and women who have to be more masculine than the men to succeed, nevertheless on average it seems that a more balanced approach seems to be better for all

This is at a society level not individual anecdotes

Moc25 · 03/11/2023 08:08

I think most women are happy with the status quo

Biasquia · 03/11/2023 08:08

I think women are largely as entrenched in misogyny as men. Loads of women don’t see misogyny and participate and amplify it. I would love for women to get their chance at this stuff but equally I would love to see this misogyny tackled.

The whole trans ideology thing has shown me how turkey voting for Christmas our more commonly female need to people please is. I think our conditioning and socialisation makes women far, far easier to manipulate. The traits people most commonly vote for in leaders/politicians across the world, which are quite frankly dark triad traits, seem to be far more common in men. It would be interesting to see who women alone would vote for given the opportunity.

countrygirl99 · 03/11/2023 08:05

Having been the victim ofthe mean gang at an all girls school with mostly female teachers and an all female leadership team I doubt there would be much difference.

muchalover · 03/11/2023 08:03

Any criticism of women's performance has to be borne in mind that everything operates in a male world. The structures of power in schools , even girls schools, medical care, housing, childcare all run to a male world agenda.

What is more radical is not to complain how women perform in a male world but to consider how it might be built from the dirt with equitable female influence, meeting the needs of both sexes and all age groups.

Why are houses built without room for pushchairs?
Why do pavements run alongside roads?
Why do we educate children in systems they don't thrive in (they were created to educate boys)?
Why is childcare not available 24 hrs a day?
Why is Government filled with Etonians?

Nousernamesleftatall · 03/11/2023 08:03

I wish people would wake up. Politicians are selected, not elected. Wars are fought and won by the same people with our children as fodder. It’s a big club and we are not in it.

DarkForces · 03/11/2023 08:02

Theresa May would have done a better job than Boris Johnson during the pandemic imo and her Brexit was far more pragmatic but the men said no.

CesareBorgia · 03/11/2023 08:00

Dowhadiddydiddydum · 03/11/2023 07:04

Yea a greater proportion of women MPs would be great, but also more MPs from ‘normal’ backgrounds who actually understand normal working/middle class life. People who grew up knowing what it’s like to be cold because you can’t afford to have the heating on all the time not cold because you’ve spent too long on the ski slopes.

💯

AgnesX · 03/11/2023 07:59

Having had Margaret Thatcher, Liz Truss and the other who, shockingly, I can't remember the name of. I'm not convinced. Maggie Thatcher's housing policy being a point in hand.

I agree that more of a gender mix will change things in the future but it'll need a mix of ideologies. Sadly it'll also take a long time to have true influence.

DysonSphere · 03/11/2023 07:58

IDontHateRainbows · 03/11/2023 07:49

Yeah cos Liz Truss did a sterling job of being in charge.

I actually think Liz was done dirty and am still not comfortable with the way she was ousted. There was nothing democratic about it. There was a strong whiff of misogyny about for e.g., her being mocked for obviously having a private melt down and not making it to PM Questions. 'Dumb dizzy blonde' was the overtones. What she was trying to achieve would only have started coming to fruition after around 5 years or so. Her mistake was doing too much too early. The Conservatives left her to hang herself for reasons I'm not quite sure of.

May also encountered constant challenges.

It takes iron women to run politics in the UK. Women who over compensate and are harder than the men seems to be the prototype for women in politics here.

TheaBrandt · 03/11/2023 07:58

I agree . Men’s values dominate. Men need to step back now they have proved themselves incapable. The sex balance of power in each country needs to be switched over. So for example if all men are in charge eg Afghanistan then all women in charge if there are 30% women then there can be 30% men.

Naunet · 03/11/2023 07:55

SocksAndTheCity · 02/11/2023 23:34

Yeah, we definitely need the likes of Truss/Braverman/Patel in the chair. Jesus wept.

Throwing out random few women as examples when they worked under a patriarchy, is not the same as living in world wide matriarchal society.

TheaBrandt · 03/11/2023 07:54

Agree but also It’s the personalities that are attracted to power that are the problem. Absolute twats like putin and trump. Arthur Dent was right the person who should be running the universe is the person that doesn’t want to do it.

Naunet · 03/11/2023 07:51

SoupDragon · 02/11/2023 23:14

I think women would have fucked it up just as thoroughly. It's naïve to think it's all down to the sex of who is in charge. Women aren't some kind of perfect angel.

No one is saying all women are angels though, are they? But we are different from men, you only have to look at crime stats to see that. Why write us off as being as shit as men, when we’ve never even had the chance?

Uggquestion · 03/11/2023 07:50

I wouldn't like to see what Liz Truss, Braverman or Patel might do.