Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

The world has tried men in charge and look what they have done

140 replies

Eaglemom · 02/11/2023 23:06

AIBU... if the world was run by women it would not be in this fucking mess. Children’s and women’s lives would be worth more than land or grievances. Young men would not be groomed for war and aggression. What the hell are men doing to this earth?

OP posts:
Cornettoninja · 03/11/2023 13:08

Naunet · 03/11/2023 12:15

Nothing to do with gender? Well no, it’s to do with sex, and if you look to our closest cousins in chimps, sex does make a huge difference. Chimps are led by a male, they’re violent and dramatic societies, compared to bonobos which are female dominated and much calmer. Seeing as we have never had a world run by women, you can’t possibly know what it would look like.

Chimps and bonobos aren’t even the same species for a start. There are loads of species of animals that don’t display violent territorial behaviours it doesn’t mean that those traits are automatically relevant or comparable.

BlueEyedPeanut · 03/11/2023 12:48

Surely it depends on the woman/women. Women aren't all one homogenous group of kindness and kittens. There isn't anything fundamentally "better" about women. Women are just as capable of cruelty and stupidity as men. What we need is better individuals in charge. Their genitals don't matter.

ruby1957 · 03/11/2023 12:26

DysonSphere · 02/11/2023 23:27

No basis for this belief. As for more respect for women and children, I don't believe that either, I've had female bosses be incredibly prejudicial and inflexible as regards my maternity rights. I've never had the same problems under a man. We've seen Nicola Sturgeon supporting male rapists in female prisons. We've seen Teresa May assert she'd happily push a nuclear button if she had to. We've seen the introduction of super brothels with an associated increase in under-age sex trafficking in Germany whilst Angela Merkel was PM.

It just doesn't work that way. You don't necessarily get better government if the person in charge is a woman, anymore than you do if the person is a different ethnicity etc. People are people.

I fact, my personal view is most women in power tend to bend over backwards trying to be manly i and are liable to overplay their hands in order to prove themselves.

Queen Elizabeth the 1st might be an exception.

Absolutely this. Anyone male or female can be a person with power and get it wrong.

MrsSkylerWhite · 03/11/2023 12:26

Thatcher, Palin, Braverman, Truss, Dorries, Patel, Keeghan. Could go on and on.

It’s not men that are the issue, it’s politicians. Anyone who believes they should be in charge of a nation shouldn’t be allowed anywhere near the top jobs.

CHIRIBAYA · 03/11/2023 12:24

I would rather have functional, emotionally and psychologically mature, well-rounded individuals with morals and integrity as leaders; these attributes are not determined by gender.

ToWhitToWhoo · 03/11/2023 12:24

RonObvious · 03/11/2023 11:32

Some of the most bloodthirsty and violent rulers in history were female - I don't think it's the sex of the people in power that are the problem. I tend to agree with Douglas Adams: "It is a well-known fact that those people who must want to rule people are, ipso facto, those least suited to do it... anyone who is capable of getting themselves made President should on no account be allowed to do the job."

I agree!

User135644 · 03/11/2023 12:23

aswarmofmidges · 03/11/2023 12:07

But is truss representative of all women or is she a women living up to being as manly as the men ?

If the only women chosen to be admitted to those top roles are ones chosen by men as nice and safe and just like them then of course she won't make any better choices

It's predominantly certain personality traits that seek and get great power and wealth.

Being nice, all for equality and a pacifist only gets you so far. Ask Corbyn.

Plenty of women voted Boris. A majority of white women voted Trump over Hilary Clinton.

ToWhitToWhoo · 03/11/2023 12:23

I think that in general people who WANT to be in charge should be automatically disqualified. At present, these are more likely to be men.

But no, women are not automatically more reasonable. Have people so soon forgotten Liz Truss? And Suella Braverman would be worse.

There is a significant chance that a woman will be the next president of France- and we'd better just hope that this particular woman, LePen, won't be!

Naunet · 03/11/2023 12:15

ntmdino · 03/11/2023 11:25

Bingo.

And, on top of that, artificially drawing the line according to gender completely ignores the fact that the kind of person who wants to be in charge is usually exactly the kind of person who shouldn't be.

It's nothing to do with gender; it's the fact that having a group of people (any people) in charge automatically creates "haves" and "have nots". The "haves" always want more (which creates international conflict), and the "have nots" always resent the "haves" (which creates national conflict).

And, obviously, it's not like things were any better when we in the UK had female PMs. One created greater inequality than the country's ever seen, the next presided over Brexit (and got nowhere), and the last caused a cost of living crisis that's ruined the majority of the population.

The problem isn't gender, it's ideology and the type of person who feels they should be at the top.

Edited

Nothing to do with gender? Well no, it’s to do with sex, and if you look to our closest cousins in chimps, sex does make a huge difference. Chimps are led by a male, they’re violent and dramatic societies, compared to bonobos which are female dominated and much calmer. Seeing as we have never had a world run by women, you can’t possibly know what it would look like.

aswarmofmidges · 03/11/2023 12:07

But is truss representative of all women or is she a women living up to being as manly as the men ?

If the only women chosen to be admitted to those top roles are ones chosen by men as nice and safe and just like them then of course she won't make any better choices

Naunet · 03/11/2023 12:05

BigFatLiar · 03/11/2023 09:32

I think it's delusional to think it would be any different.
It's greed and power that run the world and women are subject to it the same as men.

I think it’s misogynistic to label women as ‘just as bad’ when they’ve never even had a chance.

User135644 · 03/11/2023 11:38

gegs73 · 02/11/2023 23:18

SoupDragon I tend to agree. Men have made a huge mess of it, but I do think if the boot was on the other foot women would end up doing much the same. Has anyone read ‘The Power’?

Truss destroyed the economy in a month on a power trip.

User135644 · 03/11/2023 11:35

Thatcher's legacy has destroyed Britain.

stormteacupandcake · 03/11/2023 11:33

HAHAHA

You only have to read threads on MN, going from the most inoffensive "shoes on/ shoes off", "answering the door/ not answering the door" to the threads about "the other woman" or "school cliques"

and see how nasty, bitter, rude, racists these posters can get and fight so strongly over absolutely nothing. (allegedly mainly women, I haven't personally checked).

Start a thread about MENZ and see how aggressive and unfair women can get too.

People are people, good or bad, the sex and gender is rather irrelevant.

The whole concept of the "sisterhood and being kind" is non-sense.

RonObvious · 03/11/2023 11:32

Some of the most bloodthirsty and violent rulers in history were female - I don't think it's the sex of the people in power that are the problem. I tend to agree with Douglas Adams: "It is a well-known fact that those people who must want to rule people are, ipso facto, those least suited to do it... anyone who is capable of getting themselves made President should on no account be allowed to do the job."

Biasquia · 03/11/2023 11:27

countrygirl99 · 03/11/2023 11:16

You only have to look at all the threads on here about manipulative relatives or CF friends to realise what sort of women would make it to the top in a female dominated society.

Yes @countrygirl99 this is a really good point because it is although not universally but more commonly a person who seeks to dominate who becomes a leader. Domineering people by definition put their own agenda and needs to the top of the pile.

I do think there is a psychology in the rest of us that puts them in power though. I think that is something we can all address as individuals. Why do we need someone we feel is a controlling/dominant type in power (if that applies to individuals). There is something about those personality traits that makes us feel safer I suspect.

ntmdino · 03/11/2023 11:25

countrygirl99 · 03/11/2023 11:16

You only have to look at all the threads on here about manipulative relatives or CF friends to realise what sort of women would make it to the top in a female dominated society.

Bingo.

And, on top of that, artificially drawing the line according to gender completely ignores the fact that the kind of person who wants to be in charge is usually exactly the kind of person who shouldn't be.

It's nothing to do with gender; it's the fact that having a group of people (any people) in charge automatically creates "haves" and "have nots". The "haves" always want more (which creates international conflict), and the "have nots" always resent the "haves" (which creates national conflict).

And, obviously, it's not like things were any better when we in the UK had female PMs. One created greater inequality than the country's ever seen, the next presided over Brexit (and got nowhere), and the last caused a cost of living crisis that's ruined the majority of the population.

The problem isn't gender, it's ideology and the type of person who feels they should be at the top.

countrygirl99 · 03/11/2023 11:16

You only have to look at all the threads on here about manipulative relatives or CF friends to realise what sort of women would make it to the top in a female dominated society.

RainbowFlutter · 03/11/2023 11:12

No, totally incorrect. At lot of the current ideology stems from Margaret Thatcher.

I only need to point out Suella B, Priti P, Liz T

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 03/11/2023 09:36

The world has tried men in charge and look what they have done

Goes both ways though doesn't it? If you're saying look at all these bad things that happen, these are the result of men being in charge, then you'd have to say all the good things are because of them too.

For example, as a species, we've moved on from feudalism and serfdom to a more fairer form of governance (even modern day Saudi Arabia or North Korea provide a better standard of living for the average person than 13th century England or Imperial Rome).

We've also broadly increases life expectancy, reduced infant mortality, improved health outcomes, increased access to education, food, travel, work, leisure, etc, etc.

Have all those only happened because men are in charge or is it a bit more complex than that?

Cornettoninja · 03/11/2023 09:36

I think we’re shit because we’re human. It’s a species thing

In a nutshell. We have a very ingrained need for ‘stuff’, the more we have the more we want.

I think things would look different if roles had been reversed over the centuries but I’m not convinced that things would be any better. Women are just as ruthless and detached given a situation where they want something or need to defend something and that something is limited in resource.

BigFatLiar · 03/11/2023 09:32

I think it's delusional to think it would be any different.
It's greed and power that run the world and women are subject to it the same as men.

cooliebrown · 03/11/2023 09:27

have been saying for ages we should experiment with a women-only parliament.

For a trial period of, say, 200 years...

Naunet · 03/11/2023 09:19

notatthisage · 03/11/2023 08:54

This.

If women were the leaders we would be living in a world ( mostly? Totally) free from misogyny. We don’t know what that would mean for how women are.

And if women were the world leaders, it would mean it were not an equal society but one skewed towards women. And what we don’t know what that would mean for how women are.

Would we use our powers for good or evil?! Who knows!

But I’m guessing, like men, we would enjoy being the dominant sex, would enjoy looking down on men, would enjoy the power and would want to hold onto it. I’m not quite so sure if we would be starting lots of wars though.

I really can’t imagine women would treat men how they’ve treated us, both historically and still in some places today, deciding they can’t drive, must cover up, not allowed credit, not allowed job security, paid less, legally a woman’s property, huge amounts of porn showing them being choked and hurt for women’s pleasure, body shamed for hair, told their most important quality is how attractive they are, not allowed to put their names to inventions, put in huts outside at certain times of the month, sold off as young boys to older women…

I could be wrong, but I just don’t think women would spend so much time and energy on oppressing men.

notatthisage · 03/11/2023 09:12

Why are houses built without room for pushchairs?
Why do pavements run alongside roads?
Why do we educate children in systems they don't thrive in (they were created to educate boys)?
^Why is childcare not available 24 hrs a day?*
Why is Government filled with Etonians?

I agree with your general points but on education, don’t girls now outperform boys?
And my experience is early years and primary which I think is set up to suit girls developmental needs far more than boys. ( though doesn’t suit either particularly well in most settings). Early years and primary is dominated by women and I suspect they set things up thinking back to how they were as girls with boys needs being less well met.

Swipe left for the next trending thread