Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

The world has tried men in charge and look what they have done

140 replies

Eaglemom · 02/11/2023 23:06

AIBU... if the world was run by women it would not be in this fucking mess. Children’s and women’s lives would be worth more than land or grievances. Young men would not be groomed for war and aggression. What the hell are men doing to this earth?

OP posts:
Goodornot · 03/11/2023 18:20

SoupDragon · 02/11/2023 23:14

I think women would have fucked it up just as thoroughly. It's naïve to think it's all down to the sex of who is in charge. Women aren't some kind of perfect angel.

The vitriol and spite I see on this site daily from women and mothers lead me to believe it would be a different kind of poisonous world.

IvorTheEngineDriver · 03/11/2023 18:18

Human beings screwed the world. Changing their chromosone make-up wouldn't have made any difference. Sorry, but if you think otherwise you are deluding yourself.

Boomboom22 · 03/11/2023 18:03

Iamnotthe1 · 03/11/2023 17:38

There are a lot of posts on this thread simply ignoring that, had women been in charge from day one, what it means to be a woman or have "feminine traits" would be different.

It goes all the way back to tribal living. Men were in charge because they were the ones that could secure the resources that the society needed in order to survive. They could also protect the society's resources and prevent them being claimed by others. We have the society we have because men had the protector/provider role. If woman had been in charge, they would have had to have taken the protector/provider role and that would have fundamentally changed what it means to be a woman (and a man).

Except it appears that interpretation of evolution is actually the patriarchy at work again not archaeological evidence supported.
https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/the-theory-that-men-evolved-to-hunt-and-women-evolved-to-gather-is-wrong1/

The Theory That Men Evolved to Hunt and Women Evolved to Gather Is Wrong

The influential idea that in the past men were hunters and women were not isn’t supported by the available evidence

https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/the-theory-that-men-evolved-to-hunt-and-women-evolved-to-gather-is-wrong1

AllProperTeaIsTheft · 03/11/2023 18:00

There are a lot of posts on this thread simply ignoring that, had women been in charge from day one, what it means to be a woman or have "feminine traits" would be different.

Exactly. That's what I was getting at, but you put it much better!

Iamnotthe1 · 03/11/2023 17:38

There are a lot of posts on this thread simply ignoring that, had women been in charge from day one, what it means to be a woman or have "feminine traits" would be different.

It goes all the way back to tribal living. Men were in charge because they were the ones that could secure the resources that the society needed in order to survive. They could also protect the society's resources and prevent them being claimed by others. We have the society we have because men had the protector/provider role. If woman had been in charge, they would have had to have taken the protector/provider role and that would have fundamentally changed what it means to be a woman (and a man).

stormteacupandcake · 03/11/2023 16:44

I don't think women as a group are any less aggressive, power hungry or friendlier and inclusive than men. We might be less physical, but we are not different from men.

We are fighting so hard for equality, it does us no favour whatsoever to pretend there are so many differences.

countrygirl99 · 03/11/2023 16:35

tellmewhenthespaceshiplandscoz · 03/11/2023 16:16

SocksAndTheCity
Yeah, we definitely need the likes of Truss/Braverman/Patel in the chair. Jesus wept.

What about the likes of Hancock, Rees Mogg, Johnson, Cummings, Sunak, Raab, Hunt, and Gove?
I don't see those men doing a particularly stella job either, but no one extrapolates that to men shouldn't be allowed to be leaders anymore because those few are shit.
I can name a lot more male politicians who have been involved in scandals and corruption than female ones.

///

This completely

I don't think anyone is saying women shouldn't be leaders because some are shit. Just that the people who become leaders tend to be shit whether they are male or female.

Vitriolinsanity · 03/11/2023 16:34

I have no issue with the sex of whomever is in power provided that they are qualified, capable, empathetic, aspire to equality and open minded.

What I take issue with is is career politicians that live for the soundbite, have no concept of their constituents needs, have spent minimal time as a back bencher or in a minor cabinet position and fuelled by interest groups.

User135644 · 03/11/2023 16:21

tellmewhenthespaceshiplandscoz · 03/11/2023 16:16

SocksAndTheCity
Yeah, we definitely need the likes of Truss/Braverman/Patel in the chair. Jesus wept.

What about the likes of Hancock, Rees Mogg, Johnson, Cummings, Sunak, Raab, Hunt, and Gove?
I don't see those men doing a particularly stella job either, but no one extrapolates that to men shouldn't be allowed to be leaders anymore because those few are shit.
I can name a lot more male politicians who have been involved in scandals and corruption than female ones.

///

This completely

They'll catch up the more women reach the top of professions. Scandals like Michelle Mone or Dido Harding just in the last couple of years. Truss literally crashed the economy in the month she was PM only last year.

I don't care for politicians regardless of gender, or people in powerful positions in general. Women don't behave any better than men and are not inherently better or nicer.

tellmewhenthespaceshiplandscoz · 03/11/2023 16:16

SocksAndTheCity
Yeah, we definitely need the likes of Truss/Braverman/Patel in the chair. Jesus wept.

What about the likes of Hancock, Rees Mogg, Johnson, Cummings, Sunak, Raab, Hunt, and Gove?
I don't see those men doing a particularly stella job either, but no one extrapolates that to men shouldn't be allowed to be leaders anymore because those few are shit.
I can name a lot more male politicians who have been involved in scandals and corruption than female ones.

///

This completely

AllProperTeaIsTheft · 03/11/2023 16:15

I think it's having power that makes people in charge fuck up the world. Men have had the power, so they have behaved how powerful people behave. If women had had the power, they would have behaved similarly. Imo most of the different characteristics you can ascribe to male behaviour and female behaviour are down to social structure and socialisation, not inherent.

User135644 · 03/11/2023 16:14

JaxiiTaxii · 03/11/2023 14:30

I haven't RTFT...
But it's frustrating when people leap in to use current 'powerful females' to say women are as shit at power as men. No, these examples are women who have risen in a male world and emulated masculine traits to gain power.

These women are still operating in a completely male sphere but with a female body. That's not what a female world would look like.

Zoom out & try to imagine a world run by women, formed around women - just like our world now is formed around men. Childbirth would be factored into working lives - maybe recognised as paid labour. Would we even work 9-5 or use money, would it be more socialist/ communist? Women's health issues would be more widely researched and better understood, working lives would maybe be more about making sure everyone's fed than endlessly making money. Men would definitely not be pandered to like children - but would women?
Buildings would be made for shorter people, I suspect women would not be self-curfewed after dark or travel & dress curtailed by fear of rape, if women were the dominant sex.
But absolutely no doubt there would be bad stuff too. Would it be the spiteful bullies that ruled the school through humiliation & isolation be in charge? Would those be our punishments and what would female crime look like?

Nobody knows because it's so hard to imagine there could be a true alternative to the patriarchal world men created over millennia.
It's almost impossible not to just overlay women into the roles men created now.

But we get the leaders we deserve. We live in a democracy. Nobody forces people to vote for narcissists and sociopaths like Boris Johnson. There's also more women than men, so women have the advantage numerically in the voting booth. Women have huge power in democracy.

CaroleSinger · 03/11/2023 16:10

0rly? You're not getting away with Liz Truss that easily cup cake!

ExpressCheckout · 03/11/2023 16:08

The real problem here is not gender, it is the TYPE of person that these powerful positions attract. Self serving and greedy.

^^This

missmollygreen · 03/11/2023 15:34

Can you name some specific things that you think would and would not have happened if women had been in charge?

We have had female PMs and CEOs and guess what, they are never particularly better or worse that their male counterparts.
The real problem here is not gender, it is the TYPE of person that these powerful positions attract. Self serving and greedy.

Cornettoninja · 03/11/2023 15:24

Men only run the world because they bully women away from power

undeniable. But those bullying, aggressive traits would still exist in men if women ran the show.

Unless we’re talking about a scenario where men don’t exist at all which has its own, very obvious failings, those traits would still need to be subdued or managed. There would still be an impact on civilisation.

stormteacupandcake · 03/11/2023 15:19

Imagine the world being transformed into one of the satyrical sorority seen in various movies or series 😂

Begsthequestion · 03/11/2023 14:42

I've often wondered about this. Men are the dominant sex because they have had the monopoly on violence - unless women are armed. So it seems like patriarchy was inevitable in a world that developed by distributing power according to brute strength.

Women's physical strengths are different - higher pain tolerance, less prone to infections from birth, the ability to grow and deliver the next generation etc.

If hypothetically women did end up in charge, I don't think we'd be resolving issues using violence in the same way men do. Winning a war would not be the way we decide how to distribute resources, like we do now.

People who point to Maggie Thatcher/other individual politicians as an example of how a matriarchy might function or fail are not really going deep enough into the issue, imo, perhaps deliberately.

Because in fact it's a pretty useless example, because by hypothesising about women in charge we are envisioning an entirely different society altogether - not just looking at how one individual might behave in the society we already have, and judging the alternative based on that one person.

Acornsoup · 03/11/2023 14:42

SocksAndTheCity · 02/11/2023 23:34

Yeah, we definitely need the likes of Truss/Braverman/Patel in the chair. Jesus wept.

I give you Boris, Trump, Sadam Hussain, Idi Amin, Vlad the impaler, Kim Jong, Pol Pot, Mao Zedong, Osama Bin Laden, Stalin and Hitler to name a few. Your list is not really compatible, but your misogyny is in full show.

JaxiiTaxii · 03/11/2023 14:30

I haven't RTFT...
But it's frustrating when people leap in to use current 'powerful females' to say women are as shit at power as men. No, these examples are women who have risen in a male world and emulated masculine traits to gain power.

These women are still operating in a completely male sphere but with a female body. That's not what a female world would look like.

Zoom out & try to imagine a world run by women, formed around women - just like our world now is formed around men. Childbirth would be factored into working lives - maybe recognised as paid labour. Would we even work 9-5 or use money, would it be more socialist/ communist? Women's health issues would be more widely researched and better understood, working lives would maybe be more about making sure everyone's fed than endlessly making money. Men would definitely not be pandered to like children - but would women?
Buildings would be made for shorter people, I suspect women would not be self-curfewed after dark or travel & dress curtailed by fear of rape, if women were the dominant sex.
But absolutely no doubt there would be bad stuff too. Would it be the spiteful bullies that ruled the school through humiliation & isolation be in charge? Would those be our punishments and what would female crime look like?

Nobody knows because it's so hard to imagine there could be a true alternative to the patriarchal world men created over millennia.
It's almost impossible not to just overlay women into the roles men created now.

notatthisage · 03/11/2023 14:26

User135644 · 03/11/2023 11:38

Truss destroyed the economy in a month on a power trip.

I don’t think it was a power trip. It was the delusional arrogance of a personality type who refuses to listen to opposing views. She had always been like that, apparently.

When you have poor candidates for political leadership, someone like that can get to the top.

And we perhaps have poor candidates, in part, due to the toxic narrative we have created around politicians and the abuse heaped on them. We are pretty much self selecting for ideologues, fanatics and rich boys who view politics as a hobby to fill time.

coxesorangepippin · 03/11/2023 14:22

Men will never step back

Why would they

They have all the power

No one willing gives up power

stormteacupandcake · 03/11/2023 14:19

Would the world be very different if women had been in charge?
Certainly.

Would it be BETTER?
Doubt it.

Maybe we should keep raising your daughters teaching them that their sex/ gender don't matter and the West at least is not a "man's world"?

obje · 03/11/2023 14:11

Yeah.....cos Nicola sturgeon was a great example 🙄

Voteva · 03/11/2023 14:10

Males are far more violent than females. Look at the crime statistics, look at any species, look at human history in every country on earth. Go to any primary school and look at the playground behaviour differences between boys and girls.

Yes girls can be unkind, but they very rarely beat each other up or stab each other (and on the rare occasions they do, the aggressive girl has always been the victim of male violence, ask anyone involved with the social services).

Men only run the world because they bully women away from power.

And look at the state it’s in. 🔥 🔥 🔥