Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

The world has tried men in charge and look what they have done

140 replies

Eaglemom · 02/11/2023 23:06

AIBU... if the world was run by women it would not be in this fucking mess. Children’s and women’s lives would be worth more than land or grievances. Young men would not be groomed for war and aggression. What the hell are men doing to this earth?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Troubador10 · 04/11/2023 22:15

AdamRyan · 04/11/2023 22:14

excluding some persons of particular sex in favour of a less qualified person of the opposite sex?
This is what would happen, except noone would be "excluded" because of their sex. The males results and the females would be decoupled and irrelevant to each other.
Universities could set a minimum standard and run a smaller course if there were not enough applicants of one sex to meet it.

Interesting. Thanks.

AdamRyan · 04/11/2023 22:14

excluding some persons of particular sex in favour of a less qualified person of the opposite sex?
This is what would happen, except noone would be "excluded" because of their sex. The males results and the females would be decoupled and irrelevant to each other.
Universities could set a minimum standard and run a smaller course if there were not enough applicants of one sex to meet it.

Troubador10 · 04/11/2023 22:10

AdamRyan · 04/11/2023 21:28

I'd like to see senior women listened to and taken as seriously as men, instead of what we heard at the covid enquiry this week.

A 50% quota for some things would be good. For example university places. 50% male, 50% female places on every course, intra-sex competition for places. Rather than a "meritocracy" where men inevitably come out on top. Employers could do similar for apprenticeships and grad schemes. This would mean a better gender split coming out and hopefully that would feed through into more women in positions of power.

I'd like to see equal parental leave rights for both sexes with mandatory leave for men. That would hopefully help even out the burden of children across both sexes and give more women the time to pursue avenues to power.

I think politically we (in the west) should move to consensus based politics - less presidential, more PR. That would give less opportunity for power crazed megalomaniac men to get in power and do stupid things (Trump!) I don't think its coincidence that one of the most successful female politicians ever seen came from a country with a PR based system that required forming coalitions (Merkel).

On the university places point, how would that work on courses where there are significantly more applicants of a particular sex for a particular course, so 50/50 can’t be achieved without either reducing the number of places massively, or excluding some persons of particular sex in favour of a less qualified person of the opposite sex?

AdamRyan · 04/11/2023 21:28

I'd like to see senior women listened to and taken as seriously as men, instead of what we heard at the covid enquiry this week.

A 50% quota for some things would be good. For example university places. 50% male, 50% female places on every course, intra-sex competition for places. Rather than a "meritocracy" where men inevitably come out on top. Employers could do similar for apprenticeships and grad schemes. This would mean a better gender split coming out and hopefully that would feed through into more women in positions of power.

I'd like to see equal parental leave rights for both sexes with mandatory leave for men. That would hopefully help even out the burden of children across both sexes and give more women the time to pursue avenues to power.

I think politically we (in the west) should move to consensus based politics - less presidential, more PR. That would give less opportunity for power crazed megalomaniac men to get in power and do stupid things (Trump!) I don't think its coincidence that one of the most successful female politicians ever seen came from a country with a PR based system that required forming coalitions (Merkel).

Fishcycles · 04/11/2023 20:46

I don’t think it’s fair to look at a few individual women as examples, when they’re operating within a patriarchal system. A female Prime Minister doesn’t mean we’ve lived in a matriarchal society.

The question for I’d like answered is - for the people who have voted YANBU what would you like to see in an ideal world? Minimum 60/80/100% of female MPs? Similar for other key roles like judges etc?

Esmeralda94 · 04/11/2023 20:22

Comparing the few women who made it into prominent positions to the pasty white dick swinging mediocre men who have ruined the planet is absurd.

I agree. Sharia Law would be much better.

Esmeralda94 · 04/11/2023 20:17

DysonSphere · 02/11/2023 23:27

No basis for this belief. As for more respect for women and children, I don't believe that either, I've had female bosses be incredibly prejudicial and inflexible as regards my maternity rights. I've never had the same problems under a man. We've seen Nicola Sturgeon supporting male rapists in female prisons. We've seen Teresa May assert she'd happily push a nuclear button if she had to. We've seen the introduction of super brothels with an associated increase in under-age sex trafficking in Germany whilst Angela Merkel was PM.

It just doesn't work that way. You don't necessarily get better government if the person in charge is a woman, anymore than you do if the person is a different ethnicity etc. People are people.

I fact, my personal view is most women in power tend to bend over backwards trying to be manly i and are liable to overplay their hands in order to prove themselves.

Queen Elizabeth the 1st might be an exception.

It's interesting what you say about maternity support and I've noticed the same. There was a big thread on it a year or so back and lots of posters mentioned that female bosses won't support women unless they make the same sacrifices they did, which hinders progression of women's rights. I suspect part of it may be bitterness - "why should she get it all without making the sacrifices I did?"

Esmeralda94 · 04/11/2023 20:12

Despite the wars/fighting I think men's natural competitiveness has likely been the foundation of many of our great medical/technological innovations, which have saved countless lives.

Men fight but they also collaborate much better than women, which is proven by lots of studies. Collaboration is key to progress. Given the squabbling/nastiness on here compared to men's forums I'm not sure we'd be any better.

ThinWomansBrain · 04/11/2023 20:03

Great idea, let's get Liz Truss back - that went so well.

Badbadbunny · 04/11/2023 19:55

Coffeerum · 04/11/2023 13:55

Well the female leaders in recent memory have hardly been a shining example have they.
Margaret Thatcher?
Theresa May?
Arlene Foster??
Liz Truss?

I raise you....

Diane Abbott
Suella Braverman

Not looking good for female politicians really is it?

User135644 · 04/11/2023 19:47

Wellhellooooodear · 04/11/2023 10:59

Are we glossing over Liz Truss? Not to mention the likes of Priti Patel and Suella Braverman. We need real people in charge, those who didn't attend an elite public school and actually understand and give a shit about people. It won't happen though.

Theresa May, Nicola Sturgeon. Margaret Thatcher.

Like them or not, there's a lot of bad legacies left behind there. Although May was treated harshly she ran a truly dreadful election campaign in 2017 which lost the Tories their majority when Corbyn was the opponent. May and Amber Rudd also leave questionable legacies behind as Home Sec (Windrush for example).

DysonSphere · 04/11/2023 17:30

Abhannmor · 04/11/2023 14:45

I'm afraid Queen Elizabeth I is not an exception @DysonSphere . She had her childhood teacher tortured on the rack . Twice. Once might be some administrative error......

😧

Oh no! Well that's me shot down in 🔥 🔥

I always thought she was though only when necessary.

Abhannmor · 04/11/2023 14:45

I'm afraid Queen Elizabeth I is not an exception @DysonSphere . She had her childhood teacher tortured on the rack . Twice. Once might be some administrative error......

Coffeerum · 04/11/2023 13:55

Well the female leaders in recent memory have hardly been a shining example have they.
Margaret Thatcher?
Theresa May?
Arlene Foster??
Liz Truss?

Goodornot · 04/11/2023 13:52

Memememestillme · 04/11/2023 11:07

Or Queen Victoria. Empire anyone?

Mary I aka Bloody Mary. Henry VIIIs first daughter. She was a tyrant. She wanted to restore Catholicism and her regime's persecution of Protestant dissenters led to hundreds of executions for heresy.

It simply isn't true that females are always more benevolent rulers.

Memememestillme · 04/11/2023 11:07

Or Queen Victoria. Empire anyone?

KimberleyClark · 04/11/2023 10:59

There’s a very interesting short story by John Wyndham called “Consider her Ways” about a world consisting entirely of women because men have died out because of a disease only affecting them.

Wellhellooooodear · 04/11/2023 10:59

Are we glossing over Liz Truss? Not to mention the likes of Priti Patel and Suella Braverman. We need real people in charge, those who didn't attend an elite public school and actually understand and give a shit about people. It won't happen though.

Willyoujustbequiet · 04/11/2023 10:55

Definitely.

Let's face it we couldn't do any worse.

AdamRyan · 04/11/2023 10:53

JaxiiTaxii · 03/11/2023 14:30

I haven't RTFT...
But it's frustrating when people leap in to use current 'powerful females' to say women are as shit at power as men. No, these examples are women who have risen in a male world and emulated masculine traits to gain power.

These women are still operating in a completely male sphere but with a female body. That's not what a female world would look like.

Zoom out & try to imagine a world run by women, formed around women - just like our world now is formed around men. Childbirth would be factored into working lives - maybe recognised as paid labour. Would we even work 9-5 or use money, would it be more socialist/ communist? Women's health issues would be more widely researched and better understood, working lives would maybe be more about making sure everyone's fed than endlessly making money. Men would definitely not be pandered to like children - but would women?
Buildings would be made for shorter people, I suspect women would not be self-curfewed after dark or travel & dress curtailed by fear of rape, if women were the dominant sex.
But absolutely no doubt there would be bad stuff too. Would it be the spiteful bullies that ruled the school through humiliation & isolation be in charge? Would those be our punishments and what would female crime look like?

Nobody knows because it's so hard to imagine there could be a true alternative to the patriarchal world men created over millennia.
It's almost impossible not to just overlay women into the roles men created now.

YES
I can imagine in a female dominated world, men could be belittled for their lack of emotional range, meaning they are less able to empathise and lead effectively. Rather than women being told they are "too emotional"
Women could bring babies to work and breastfeed tiny babies at work. There would be more breaks. Possibly an entirely different working schedule to account for menstrual cycles and childcare.
I think there would be less focus on technology and being "clever", intellectual pursuits. And more on cooperation and environmental benefits. Because women are less able to individually "win" than men by asserting their strength, and gain more power through cooperating and influencing. That would filter into what strategies society was pursuing.

DarkForces · 04/11/2023 05:04

boredfuckinsenseless · 03/11/2023 18:35

It's the personality type that likes power or being in charge. Many years ago, I was told that certain men gravitate towards either law enforcement or law breaking, and the personality is the same. this has certainly been born out in recent years.
The worst management I have had have been predominantly women groups. It was run on being 'besties', and if you weren't in the clique, you were managed out. I work in an all male team as the only woman, and it is far more pleasant!

Yes. I'm sold. We should definitely let men get on with running the world. They're much better at it than nasty women with their 'friends'.

Crime statistics about male violence are clearly because women run the justice system and let their mates off.

ntmdino · 03/11/2023 23:15

Naunet · 03/11/2023 12:15

Nothing to do with gender? Well no, it’s to do with sex, and if you look to our closest cousins in chimps, sex does make a huge difference. Chimps are led by a male, they’re violent and dramatic societies, compared to bonobos which are female dominated and much calmer. Seeing as we have never had a world run by women, you can’t possibly know what it would look like.

Comparing human behaviour to that of bonobos - specifically, running a country of 66 million people and immeasurably complex social and logistical systems versus a bonobo tribe of 30-100 individuals - is so choc-full of hilarious logical, sociological and evolutionary fallacies I'm at least 50% sure you have to be trolling here.

5128gap · 03/11/2023 18:49

Its less about the sex of the individual in charge and the traits that may or may not mean they could bring to the power role, and more about the culture of placing men and their values, interests and wishes front and centre and building everything around meeting their needs. A world where this no longer happens and the needs of women and children were centred would be a vast improvement. There's no guarantee women leaders would do this. But we can guarantee male leaders won't.

boredfuckinsenseless · 03/11/2023 18:35

It's the personality type that likes power or being in charge. Many years ago, I was told that certain men gravitate towards either law enforcement or law breaking, and the personality is the same. this has certainly been born out in recent years.
The worst management I have had have been predominantly women groups. It was run on being 'besties', and if you weren't in the clique, you were managed out. I work in an all male team as the only woman, and it is far more pleasant!

Iamnotthe1 · 03/11/2023 18:24

Boomboom22 · 03/11/2023 18:03

Except it appears that interpretation of evolution is actually the patriarchy at work again not archaeological evidence supported.
https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/the-theory-that-men-evolved-to-hunt-and-women-evolved-to-gather-is-wrong1/

I didn't suggest they'd evolved for specific roles, nor am I talking about the ideas of hunter/gatherer. I said they took on specific roles. It's a societal construct, not a biological one. Men were providers and protectors which is what led to them being in charge. They are the ones who fought against others to claim their land, their resources, their access to food, etc. They are also the ones who defended. It's what led to a society where men were the ones working, leading, fighting, etc. and women were viewed as requiring protection and direction.

I'm also not saying that there wouldn't be improvements if women (as we know them) were in charge now. I'm saying that if women had been in charge since the word go, they wouldn't be what we recognise as women now.

Swipe left for the next trending thread